The Umbrella Academy: Ranking Every Character Worst To Best

Seven gifted children, but not all as gifted as the others...

Umbrella Academy Characters
Netflix

You really have to hand it to Netflix. Almost at the exact same time that they announce the end of their Marvel programming with the cancellations of Jessica Jones and The Punisher, they've scored arguably an even bigger hit than most of those later series with a completely atypical comic book TV show.

Based on Gerard Way and Gabriel Ba's exceptional comics, The Umbrella Academy is a rivetting, dark antithesis to the usual comic book adaptations, from the moment it begins to the explosive ending. And it's a joy to watch all the way through, introducing a host of characters who range from the sublime to the ridiculous.

There are also a collection of supporting characters who recur a few times like Chuck Beaman (a pretty poor detective figure), Klaus' boyfriend Dave, Lance Biggs from the false eye lab and The Conductor (played by Peter Outerbridge, who delightfully played Josef Grool in Cool Runnings), but when ranking the show's characters, it's best to stick with the mains. But who is best?

Warning: some spoilers are within.

Worst

16. Detective Patch

Umbrella Academy Patch

NetflixUnfortunately for Detective Eudora Patch, she's neither a good police officer nor a particularly well-fleshed out character. She exists mostly as a point of contact between the Academy and the police and her past relationship with Diego gives him something interesting in his past to make him seem more human. Beyond that, she's not particularly notable.

She's mostly remarkable for her part in advancing Diego's story, which is never a good sign and for the fact that her name being Eudora means that she and Diego combine to make a possibly accidental reference to Dora The Explorer and her cousin Diego (of Go, Diego, Go! fame). When that's what you're thinking about when she appears, it's probably not the best


15. Leonard

Umbrella Academy Leonard
Netflix

Leonard is probably the most frustrating part of the entire show. Introduced to the show rather than adapted from the comics, he plays the role that the nefarious Orchestra play in the source material in leading Vanya to darkness. As such, he's a pivotal character to the plot, but he's just not all that great.

There are some interesting ideas in there - like his Buddy from The Incredibles obsession with being an Umbrella Academy kid and the murder of his father - but he's not particularly well written beyond being a narrative device designed to lead another character somewhere. Sure, preserving his secrets are pretty important for the way the show deals with the twist, but it would have been nice to have some more substance.

As it is, it's pretty much impossible to see why Vanya would have even given him a second look, even with her past issues with isolation and withheld affection well-established. The grip just isn't there.


14. The Handler

Umbrella Academy Handler
Netflix

The Handler mostly appears as your run of the mill mysterious corporate handler (hence the rather unimaginative name) who appears when we're already quire invested in the storyline to throw something of a spanner into the works.

This type of role, though mostly perfunctory in shows usually, is typically played by someone notable - a stunt casting - since they're effectively their show's answer to Q from Star Trek (not quite omnipotent but answering to an entirely different level). Here, she's played by the excellent Kate Walsh, who has more than enough charisma to sell the slight role.

She's also able to add a little more edge when she returns towards the edge (with a few more tics in tow), but ultimately she serves a purpose and doesn't do that much.


13. Agnes

The Umbrella Academy Agnes
Netflix

Aspirational donut shop proprietor and twitcher Agnes is important for what she represents to Hazel, mostly. She is the embodiment of his dream and the absolute antithesis of everything his life has been defined by until he meets her.

She's basically a constant presence in the show and a stark reminder that the coming apocalypse won't just wipe out the Academy themselves. She's pretty much the only "real person" on the character list (since anyone else not empowered is a cop or linked to some other institution) and there's a lot of heavy-lifting involved for her to represent our dog in the fight.

Luckily, she's entirely likeable and charming in a sort of country farm way and Sheila McCarthy brings a wide-eyed innocence that really works for her.


12. Allison

Umbrella Academy Allison
Netflix

The weakest of the Umbrella Academy ranks as far down because she's the most difficult prospect in terms of selling empathy. From time to time, we're reminded that she has a romantic entanglement with Luther (which is worrying, since the pair were brought up from infancy as siblings and refer to each other as such) and a daughter as the script tries to make us care more.

Unfortunately, there's just something off about her as a character. Perhaps it's that she doesn't have the edge of most of her siblings, but her impressive powers are never enough to raise interest levels in her. And the final testament to her impact comes when she is almost killed and what is supposed to be a heavily loaded moment doesn't really land that big a punch.

Maybe she's just too much of a goody-two-shoes for this universe but it's hard not to think of her as this show's answer to Halle Berry's Storm.


11. Vanya

Umbrella Academy White Violin
Netflix

Vanya has some significant issues to overcome to be a truly interesting character beyond being the living husk for an interesting story twist. Firstly, the nature of her secret requires a clipped performance; she's supposed to be the product of her environment and the way she's nurtured - a sort of half-person that we aren't really supposed to notice that much.

That would have worked a lot better if Vanya wasn't played by Elliot Page. Perhaps as a result of the actor being so recognisable, Page is arguably too successful in making Vanya grey and the show simply forgets to seed anything in her for the big twist. It would have been far better to suggest that the character was prone to emotional outbursts as a child (before we do see it) or that there's something more to her than her surface. Even in her musical playing, there's no transformation at all.

The result is that while Vanya's an interesting character, the grand reveal feels like a bit of an ass-pull because Page has been working against it so much and it just needed a little more establishing work where we could look back in hindsight and realise that the clues were there.


10. Ben

Umbrella Academy Ben
Netflix

Everyone loves a ghost sidekick. Whoopie Goldberg had one, Haley Joel Osment had one and the Ghostbusters had one, when he wasn't being an outright villain. Even Harry Potter ended up having ghostly pals.

Umbrella Academy's answer to those characters is Ben, the deceased former Number 6 of the Academy's team, who was killed violently at a young age while on a mission. He effectively plays Klaus' conscience (apart from when he gets his moment to shine in the big finale), offering asides and reactions to him and he necessarily misses all manner of character development.

But he's still interesting - mostly because of the questions he leaves behind (what exactly are his powers? How did he die? Why is he fully grown as a ghost but was a child when he died?) and it'll be great to see more of him.


9. Cha-Cha

Mary J Blige Cha Cha Umbrella Academy
Netflix

Mary J Blige's casting as time travelling assassin Cha-Cha is an interesting one in that it's both slightly distracting (something the show acknowledges by playing one of her own songs under a scene she's in) and completely brilliant.

She plays the disgruntled but committed killer well, establishing easy chemistry with Hazel and offering a real threat in fights with the Academy thanks to some great choreography. She's only not really capable of competing with Hazel because she lacks any kind of relatable depth. There's a flash that she feels some sort of affection for her partner at one point but it's fleeting and beyond that she's mostly the voice of the Commission working against Hazel's increasing desire for free-will.

Still, her and Hazel's interactions are some of the most rewarding in the show and if there was a possibility of a spin-off, you know you'd watch it.


8. Sir Reginald Hargreeves

the Umbrella Academy Colm Fiore
Netflix

The revelation of what Sir Reginald actually is at the very end of the show's run is a little disappointing, in that it really isn't given enough focus, but he's still an intriguing character whose legacy hangs over the entire story.

He's effectively this show's answer to Professor X, except instead of him outwardly caring deeply for his students as individuals, he's more invested in them as deterrents to a coming apocalypse that he somehow knows is coming. He is eventually shown to have a paternal side, but he's an interesting character more because of his (literal) alienness and the slightly off way he always interacts with the children.

He's also one of the most morally complex characters - almost certainly on the Dumbledore Spectrum - whose behaviour balances what is right with what is good and that's always an interesting undercurrent.


7. Grace

Umbrella Academy Grace
Netflix

If you love the Stepford Wives (not the remake, it wasn't very good, to be honest), you'll recognise the cheery, Tim Burton-ised idealised picture of motherhood from the 1950s in Grace.

She might be a robot (and one who is retired for some of the show after she's wrongly implicated in Sir Reginald's death), but there's humour in her interactions with the kids and she's genuinely warm and loving (like a robo-Mary Poppins, which is exactly the point).

The performance behind the cyborg by Jordan Claire Robbins is both perfectly alien and hauntingly human (a little like the way Paul Bettany initially approached Vision), with a mix of naivety and a deep-lying secret that ends up being very important. If this were Star Wars, she and Pogo would basically be C-3PO and R2-D2.


6. Luther

Umbrella Academy Luther
Netflix

Despite the fact that he's literally a man's head on the body of a gorilla (though not quite as strangely designed as he is in the comics), Luther isn't nearly as interesting a character as you'd probably hope. Like Allison, he lacks an edge for the most part and he very much suffers from Cyclops Syndrome (to continue the X-Men analogies), in that he's heroic and obviously hugely-impressive, but put him next to a darker, more edgy alternative (in this case Klaus, Diego and Number 5) and he is immediately inferior.

Luther is the golden boy and ironically he gets a hell of a lot more intriguing when it turns out that he has been living a lie for the past four years on the moon. When he then goes off the rails, we get the best version of Luther and it's just a shame it takes so long to get there. Perhaps that's because he's hampered a little too much by the romantic subplot with Allison, which isn't particularly interesting either.

There's nothing at all wrong with Tom Hopper's performance, he just lacks some of the pizzazz his brothers have.


5. Pogo

The Umbrella Academy Pogo
Netflix

The Umbrella Academy's monkey butler (sort of) and long-term companion and best friend of Sir Reginald Hargreeves is something of an enigma, in that we aren't told anything about his origin but the fact that he exists being purely incidental is part of his appeal. This is a world where there's a talking, intelligent chimpanzee and a man can have a gorilla body and time travelling assassins are just a thing. Deal with it or move on.

Pogo is no Igor-type either, he's an erudite, loquacious character weighed down by the sins of his master but duty-bound to protect his legacy even when it threatens him. He is realised with some brilliant effects for the most part and mo-cap performances underneath the gloss by Ken Hall (who also plays Commission worker Herb) and vocal artist Adam Godley (best recognised as the Headmaster from Love Actually). There is more life and more humanity in him than there is in Allison, Leonard or Vanya, which is both impressive and disappointing.


4. Diego

The Umbrella Academy Diego
Netflix

David CastaƱeda's rebellious Diego is the Wolverine to Luther's Cyclops, a more interesting and darker iteration who clashes with him and is generally led by his emotions more. His powers - of super accuracy and manipulation of knives - is easily the worst of the Academy kids, but he's enough of a bad-ass that it doesn't matter even slightly. He even rocks a cute, edgy scar on the side of his head for good measure.

His sub-plot linking him to Detective Patch is a little distracting, but Diego is one of the most entertaining Academy characters when it comes to him interacting with his strangest two siblings. He's also the most fiery when it comes to that, establishing his belief that he should be number 1 through snide comments and subtle challenges.

His fighting is generally the most solidly choreographed throughout the show's run too.


3. Hazel

Umbrella Academy Hazel
Netflix

It's probably not ideal for the writers that any of the Umbrella Academy should be outside of the top 7 of rankings like this, but that's partly thanks to the strength of the supporting characters. And in a lot of cases, characters as universally and immediately adored as Hazel would usually be the top star. Or would be in line for a spin-off pretty quickly at the very least.

Even "just" in his hitman guise, Hazel is already interesting (partly because Cameron Britton is an imposing guy and while he's not exactly athletic, the way he's choreographed makes him convincingly a real threat - there's something even balletic to it), but when he gets more depth he's even better.

There's a sort of mournful reflection to him and a gentleness in contradiction to his violence and the fact that his dream is simply to find a home makes him a beautifully written character. If he's not back in season 2, it's an absolute travesty.


2. Klaus

Umbrella Academy Klaus
Netflix

In almost every other TV show, Klaus would be the stand-out character by some distance. But this is Number 5's world and we're all just living in it.

Still, Robert Sheehan's volatile, vulnerable addict is one of the most densely written characters in the show. His powers are huge but unthinkable (he's basically the Sixth Sense kid with some added bells and whistles he doesn't even know about) and his coping mechanisms - from fatalism to drug issue to flamboyant projection - all make him a wonder to watch.

He's essentially an amalgamation of Sheehan's Misfits character with some Captain Jack Sparrow and Jim Morrison thrown in from the side who goes through the biggest shift in the show (other than Vanya) thanks to his accidental time travelling and his decision to get clean. He steals just about every scene he's in, but not in a way that is uncharitable to his costars and he's just irresistibly watchable from start to finish.


Best

1. Number 5 (And Dolores)

The Umbrella Academy Aidan Gallagher
Netflix

Thanks in part to a stunning performance by relative newcomer Aidan Gallagher, Number 5 is the best character in The Umbrella Academy. He's effortlessly cool, hugely complex and layered like an onion. Or a cake. Or an ogre.

The conceit that he is a fifty-odd-year-old man trapped in a young teenager means Gallagher is forced to play an adult role, which is taxing for any young actor, but he is wholly convincing. He's basically as immediately brilliant as Finn Wolfhard was in Stranger Things and the future is absolutely bright for him.

And of course, mention has to also go to Dolores, who is essentially just a projection of another part of Number 5. Makes you wonder how close their relationsho was though. Thirty years is a long time to be lonely...

What did you think of The Umbrella Academy? Share your reactions below in the comments thread.


Contributor
Contributor

WhatCulture's former COO, veteran writer and editor.