The Voice: 5 Reasons It's Completely Underrated
Last year, the BBC finally found something that they thought could rival ITVs Britains Got Talent and The X Factor after The Voice of Holland introduced the concept of blind auditions and the format proved successful in the US. Although its ratings havent remained as consistently high this year in its second series as they would have liked, with overlaps with Britains Got Talent hardly helping, there is much to enjoy in this singing show that is easily at the top of its game of performance-based TV. Here are five reasons explaining why I think The Voice is criminally underrated. 5. The Live Band
An essential feature to support the credibility and talent of the singers, there is a live band present at all times with their own spin on any song the contestant wants to sing, and these guys dont get enough recognition. Even in the blind auditions when they have to rehearse with every contestant who walks onto the stage (except the odd solo guitarist), the band always sound absolutely tight and are not even just regurgitating any published versions of the songs. There are six blind audition episodes with at least ten singers shown in each, meaning that there is a lot of material, and yet every 90 second audition is made totally gripping.
This is a huge contrast to the singers auditions on ITVs talent shows, on which there is always an awkward nod backstage when the tape is ready to be played, and some of their karaoke tracks are absolutely cringe-worthily cheesy. We should count ourselves lucky that The Voice followed Strictly Come Dancings footsteps in the world of the live band, as it adds the feeling that everyone involved is taking the process seriously, and that allows the audience to take it more seriously too.4. It Is A Feel-Good Show
Although we all love Simon Cowells biting comments and seeing contestants running off screaming, there is something healthy in enjoying such a positive programme. Holly Willoughby has repeatedly described the show as feel-good, presumably meaning that the coaches and everyone backstage are happy to be there and to help the contestants wherever possible- the horror! When everyone on stage and around the stage is having a good time, its hard not to enjoy the ride with them.
Jessie J runs up to hug anyone who cries, everyone receives extremely constructive criticism (it is useful that each judge explains why they didnt want to turn around) and no one goes away feeling that sad even when they didnt get through because they enjoyed the experience of being there so much. To those who need their Saturday night round of cattiness The Voice wont be satisfactory, but it is a nice positive way to spend an hour or so a week.
3. The Coaches Squabbles
There are never really any hard feelings, but the way the coaches annoy each other when fighting for a contestant is good fun to watch. will.i.am is often the instigator, butting in to tell the contestant who he thinks they should go with depending on their musical style or personality, and this annoys Jessie J in particular, often mimicking his voice next to him. Even when not frustrating the others, Will.i.am has the most vibrant personality, with the deep announcer voice he creates with his microphone when a contestant is being indecisive, or his almost-catchphrase Im gonna be transparent now. In season two, it is fun to watch the introduction of more tactics after rivalries grew in the wake of Tom Jones victory last year, and this means that they end up annoying each other more as they call each other out on whether they turned round at the last second or arguing over whether who turned round first is important. Danny ODonoghue also seems to get on Jessie Js nerves sometimes, whether hes starting chants in his own or someone elses favour, wearing double denim or charming all the ladies. This is easily one of the most simultaneously amicable and fiery teams of coaches weve had on a talent programme and with all four from such different backgrounds, both social and musical, there is someone there to appeal to everyone.
2. Sir Tom Jones
Deserving of a solo mention is Sir Tom Jones, seller of over 100 million records and singer in a whole array of genres. All three of the other coaches seem designed to appeal to the all-important youth demographic, and they are all hugely successful and popular in their own right, but their tender years cant compare with Tom Jones wealth of experience that he clearly knows how to depart successfully, having won the first series with Leanne Mitchell. At 72 years old, most men would be taking time out to relax by now, but Tom hasnt stopped and has proven himself up for experimenting with changing times and new TV formats. Often stoically and subtly smiling at things going on around him, he seems to have the most patience of all the coaches to sit through a 90 second performance without fidgeting or requiring validation from the others, and he is the expert at turning round at the last possible second. Happily, this doesnt seem to be a technique to make for good television, but rather to allow him to check all facets of their vocal performance before making a decision. Even in less of a performance setting, Jones is still a pleasure to watch after all this time.
1. Genuinely Good Singers
It is the basic premise of the programme, but most of its values come from the fact that the coaches cant see the performers. Even unintentionally, it is easy to subconsciously judge an act on their style choices, general appearance, age and stage presence, especially when working with a rough idea of an end result in your head, like the prize at the end of this competition. In acknowledging that this happens and taking away the possibility of it happening, the coaches literally only have the voice that they hear behind them to go on. Also, due to the producers auditions before the blind auditions in which they keep a deliberately high calibre of singer (again, unlike ITVs shows who clearly have a quota of awful acts too), every single singer has the potential to deserve a place on the coaches teams- nerves allowing, of course- so this is the show to watch if the quality of music is what matters to you. The four coaches even team up with their contestants for performances in the late stages of the competition, so when four high-profile singers like this are singing with unsigned talent, you know they must be good- and if theyre not quite good enough, they will work hard to make themselves seem worthy. Say anything you like about The Voice, and disagree with any of the other points, but the music on here is better than any other of its kind and that should be what matters. Do you agree? Make your voice heard in the comments section.