The Walking Dead: 10 Questions That Always Confused You

These questions have been EATING at the fanbase for a long time.

The Walking Dead
AMC

There's no denying that The Walking Dead is one of the most popular TV shows of the last decade-plus.

And as its mainline run soon prepares to wrap up - though the many spin-offs will keep the wheels turning - it's fair to say that there's still plenty that fans are a bit confused about.

Over the course of more than 175 episodes across 11 seasons, The Walking Dead has offered up an enticing - if uneven - journey, and left fans to ponder a number of mysteries which have been left unresolved within the show itself.

From enigmatic imagery in the very first episode, through to a certain credibility-straining moment in a more recent one, these are the questions that have compelled and even haunted fans most over the years.

In some cases there are deeply plausible fan theories that more-or-less make sense of these questions, while others have received canon-ish answers from crew members in interviews, and yet many are simply left totally up in the air.

We probably shouldn't expect all of these mysteries to get sewn up before the main show ends its run, but here's to hoping...

10. How Long Was Rick In A Coma?

The Walking Dead Rick
AMC

One of the most-discussed aspects of the show since its very first episode has been the length of time that Rick Grimes (Andrew Lincoln) spends in a coma after being shot and then reawakening in the midst of the undead apocalypse.

The timeline of Rick's recovery has never been concretely confirmed within The Walking Dead itself, with fans regularly speculating that he was probably holed up in that hospital bed for at least a month or two.

But in 2015, while promoting spin-off Fear the Walking Dead, its showrunner and executive producer Dave Erickson told Tech Insider that the comic's creator, Robert Kirkman, had given him a rough timeframe. He said:

"Robert has said for him, the coma, Rick was probably out four to five weeks."

As for how Rick was able to survive that long without food and water? It's been theorised that he was taken care of by Dr. Gale Macones (Ellen Greene), who was shown to be caring for patients in the same hospital in the webisode series "The Oath."


9. What Happened To Lori's Bones?

The Walking Dead Rick
AMC

Early in the show's third season, Lori (Sarah Wayne Callies) dies during childbirth, and in the episode "Say the Word," Rick visits the boiler room where she died.

In lieu of her corpse, though, he finds an extremely bloated walker, and making the understandable deduction that the walker has consumed Lori's body, promptly executes it.

Yet this still begs the question - what happened to Lori's bones?

It's established in the show that the walkers don't eat bones, so where exactly did Lori's skeletal remains go?

Though it's not easily indicated by the episode itself, director and make-up effects supervisor Greg Nicotero confirmed in an interview with Daily Dead that Lori's bones were very close by indeed:

"The idea is supposed to be that the walker has sort of dragged her around the corner of that boiler room. There's actually a blood trail that continues past the walker and goes around the corner."

Nicotero added that he made a conscious decision not to show Lori's feasted upon remains for fear that it would detract from the impact of her demise:

"In keeping the emotional resonance of Lori's death, there are some boundaries. You may not believe it, but there are a few boundaries here and there on The Walking Dead that we want to preserve."

8. Did Hershel Know That Sophia Was In The Barn?

The Walking Dead Sophia
AMC

One of the second season's prevailing mysteries is the disappearance of Carol's (Melissa McBride) daughter Sophia (Madison Lintz), who in the mid-season episode "Pretty Much Dead Already" is revealed to be one of the walkers in Hershel Greene's (Scott Wilson) barn, before being executed by Rick.

Once fans got the shock of Sophia's discovery and death out of their system, a question emerged - did Hershel know that Sophia was in his barn the whole damn time?

Fans often point to a scene in an earlier episode, "Cherokee Rose," where Shane (Jon Bernthal) asks what they're going to do if Sophia is already a walker.

Andrea (Laurie Holden) says that they'll tell Carol the truth, at which point Maggie (Lauren Cohan) gives her father Hershel a seemingly knowing look, before Hershel shakes his head.

In retrospect, many have interpreted this as confirming that Hershel and Maggie knew that Sophia was in the barn the whole time.

On the opposite side, though, it's also established that the walkers were placed in the barn by Otis (Pruitt Taylor Vince), and given that he was soon enough killed by Shane, it's entirely possible that he simply never told Hershel that Sophia was in the barn prior to his demise.


7. Who Was In The Helicopter In The Very First Episode?

The Walking Dead Rick
AMC

One of the most distinctive sights from the pilot episode is Rick riding through desolate Atlanta on horseback, when he suddenly spots a helicopter flying overhead. But upon following it, he ends up running into a huge horde of walkers.

Ever since this episode aired 12 years ago, fans have speculated on who might be inside the helicopter and what their story could be, but alas it's never been unambiguously confirmed. Plus, our brief glimpse of the helicopter offers no identifying insignias.

Though some believe this helicopter to be the very same one that Michonne (Danai Gurira) and Andrea witnessed crashing into the forest in season three's "Walk with Me," others believe it to be a mere hallucination on Rick's part, while there are also those who have accepted it as simply a remnant military vessel doing a sweep of the area.

We still don't know for sure, and considering that the series has gone well over a decade without providing a definitive answer, we probably never will.


6. Why Did The Governor Want The Prison?

The Walking Dead Governor
AMC

As fierce as The Governor (David Morrissey) undeniably was throughout his stint on the show, fans continue to be mystified as to why the authoritarian leader of Woodbury was so hell-bent on taking control of the prison.

After all, Woodbury is a considerably more inviting place to see out the undead invasion compared to a soulless, clinical prison. But to truly understand the Governor's motivations, you need to stop thinking like a rational person.

Because of course, who was the Governor if not a sociopathic, power-hungry madman whose actions frequently defied the logic of a grounded human being?

The notion that Rick and his group had control of the prison was an affront to the Governor's ego on a basic level, that somebody else completed a task that he was convinced couldn't be done.

And so, propelled forward by his own colossal ego, the Governor staged not one but two unsuccessful raids on the prison, resulting in his own death.

The phrase "hoist by his own petard" seems rather appropriate here - a man defeated by his own insatiable, senseless thirst for empire and control.


5. Why Were The Walkers Smarter In Season One?

The Walking Dead
AMC

One common point of confusion among fans is how much smarter the walkers appear to be in the show's earlier episodes - especially season one - where they're shown to retain memories from their pre-walker days and exhibit far more complex motor functions.

Perhaps most memorably there's the walker child (Addy Miller) in the show's pilot episode - a young girl who Rick sees picking up and carrying a teddy bear, as is most uncharacteristic behaviour for a walker.

Other walkers were shown turning doorknobs, smashing windows, and even climbing fences, which ultimately proved to be inconsistent with the presentation of the walkers in later seasons, where they were considerably "dumber."

The practical answer is that the vision for the show changed when Frank Darabont was fired as showrunner, and make-up effects supervisor/director Greg Nicotero himself admitted that they hadn't "figured out yet what the rules for the zombies were."

But the trailers for the currently-airing final season have made it clear that the series will finally circle back to the "smart" walkers, who will presumably be confirmed as another variant of walker altogether.

Considering how odd it is to watch the show's earlier episodes today and see the walkers behaving so differently, a concrete explanation will be most certainly welcome.


4. Who The Hell Is Mowing All The Lawns?

The Walking Dead Rick
AMC

Silly as it might sound, it's one of The Walking Dead's most pervasive mysteries since its very first season - who the hell is out here mowing all of these lush lawns across Georgia?

Despite a full-blown undead holocaust taking place, somebody evidently found the time to hop on their lawnmower and keep things looking nice and tidy.

It's especially ridiculous given that the invasive plant species kudzu is prominent throughout Georgia, earning the nickname "the vine that ate the South."

Even in our not-apocalyptic reality, the vine is spreading faster than it can be maintained across the Southern United States, so how the hell has it not just overgrown everything in the world of The Walking Dead?

As hilarious as it is to consider a team of committed - or very, very bored - people keeping the city's kudzu at bay in the middle of the walker invasion, there isn't really any plausible in-universe explanation for this.

In terms of the show's logistics it's clearly an aesthetic thing, not to mention that covering the entirety of Atlanta in kudzu - whether practically or digitally - would be hugely expensive.


3. How Did Lydia Attach The Rope To Save Aaron?

The Walking Dead Aaron
AMC

One of the low-key most baffling moments of the entire series happened in the recent season 11 episode "No Other Way," where Aaron (Ross Marquand) ends up trapped in a flooded basement with walkers clipping at his heels.

Aaron is left dangling off a rusty metal pipe as the walkers claw at his body, when he's suddenly rescued by Lydia (Cassady McClincy), who inexplicably uses a rope to pull him free.

The sequence is edited to never show how Lydia managed to quickly jerry-rig a rope system to pull Aaron clear.

Given that the pipe was literally collapsing moments earlier, how exactly was Lydia able to hook up any sort of knot that would support his weight from the outside? After all, Aaron wasn't exactly in any position to help her set it up, given that he most certainly had his own hands full.

Fans have suggested that the rope scene didn't come together properly in the editing room, and so the decision may have been made to just cut it entirely.

It's either that or straight-up lazy writing, because it just isn't clear how Lydia was able to conceivably help Aaron escape.


2. What Was Up With The Hermit?

The Walking Dead Hermit
AMC

Considering he only appeared in the show for all of two minutes, it's impressive that fans still keep asking questions about the unnamed hermit (Alex Van) unlucky enough to encounter Rick and company in the season three episode "When the Dead Come Knocking."

Rick, Daryl (Norman Reedus), Michonne, and Oscar (Vincent M. Ward) end up seeking shelter from the walkers in a cabin, where they encounter the hermit, who is understandably startled by their presence.

The hermit inadvertently attracts more walkers to the cabin, and when he goes to open the door, Michonne promptly runs him through with her sword, before Rick hurls his corpse outside for the walkers to feast on while they make their escape.

Again, the hermit was a most minor character, yet his tragic fate and the callous means through which he was dispatched have kept him in the minds of fans an entire decade on.

So, what exactly what his deal? His dialogue, namely threatening to call the cops, seems to imply that he's not even aware of the zombie apocalypse taking place, and he also appears far more concerned about the living, breathing humans in his house rather than the walkers surrounding it.

It's of course entirely possible that the man is either mentally ill or hopped up on drugs, but considering he was basically minding his own business until the "heroes" ruined his whole damn life, it's a shame we never got to learn more about him.


1. Why Doesn't Anyone Say "Zombie"?

The Walking Dead Walkers
AMC

It is admittedly a pretty common trope in zombie media that the characters don't say the "z-word," though given the immense popularity of zombies in pop-culture, it does seem a tad silly that The Walking Dead's characters say "walker" instead.

It's an especially odd choice given that Robert Kirkman's comic books have freely referred to the undead as zombies, yet this was changed for the TV adaptation.

As for why? In a recent edition of Cutting Room Floor with Robert Kirkman, he revealed that this was largely mandated by the series' creator and original showrunner Frank Darabont.

Darabont wanted to have the story take place in a world where zombie fiction didn't exist, and so it wouldn't make sense for anyone to use the term. Kirkman further explained:

"For this story to work, you can't just have people saying, 'You shoot them in the head, y'know… just like the zombies from the Romero movies!' So you have to assume this is a universe where George A. Romero didn't create the modern zombie. So, we coined the term 'walkers' for the show."

Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.