The Walking Dead: Why Rick Grimes Has To Die

Andrew Lincoln is leaving TWD soon, which means Rick can't really live on.

Rick Grimes RIP
Gene Page/AMC

After eight years, over 100 episodes, varying beard lengths, multiple 'CORRRRALL's, and countless walker kills, it's almost time to say goodbye to Deputy Sheriff Rick Grimes.

It was reported way back in May that Andrew Lincoln was leaving the show, with the actor slated to appear in just six episodes of Season 9. Lincoln himself later confirmed the departure, and now AMC are getting in on the action by heavily promoting the next couple of instalments as Rick's final episodes, promising that he has only two left (which, for those keeping count, is one fewer than reported).

There's been a lot of speculation as to how Rick's departure will go down, ranging from Maggie or Daryl killing him, to suicide, to dying by Negan's hand, but there's also been a plenty of traction for theories that leave him alive and his exit more open-ended. It's an appealing prospect because, no matter how bad The Walking Dead has got, Lincoln has been consistently great and no one wants to see the main hero die.

And yet, when it comes to it, he really has to.


3. Rick & Michonne's Baby Plans

Rick Michonne The Walking Dead
AMC

Rick and Michonne, the two leaders of Alexandria, firmly believe in creating a new, better world for the people who have to grow up in the zombie apocalypse, such as Judith and Hershel, and that may now include their own child too.

In the third episode of Season 9, Warning Signs, Rick suggests that the pair have a baby, which is not only a major step forward for their relationship, but also not the move of a man with leaving on his mind. For that matter, nor is putting all of your time and energy into building a bridge between the communities.

Rick is committed to Michonne, and he's committed to making a brighter tomorrow. It's possible, but implausible, that he'd decide to give that up, but it's much more in keeping with the kind of devastation The Walking Dead became known for if he is killed off now and it's revealed Michonne is pregnant. He already has Judith, although there's a slight out there as she's Shane's (but even then, he's accepted her as his own), and he wouldn't leave one child behind, and certainly not two. This is a big plot point for the series, and there's no logic to introduce it now, two episodes before Rick decides to simply pack his bags.


2. There Isn't Time To Write An Open-Ended Exit

The Walking Dead Season 9 Rick Grimes
AMC

While the writers have had a good few months to prepare for Rick's exit, the opening few episodes of Season 9 don't suggest they have a big plan in place for his departure, at least not in an open-ended sense.

For Rick to simply decide to leave, there needs to be a major explanation for his decision: of why he's going, where he's going, what he plans on doing, if he'd ever return, why he's leaving Michonne, Judith, et al, and many more. And yet, there are only two episodes left.

This isn't some random character, this isn't Heath, it's Rick Grimes. He IS the show. He can't simply wander off into the ether; any exit needs to be properly defined, and while an open-ended one could potentially work in some capacity, two episodes - especially when he's so committed to the communities and Michonne - just isn't enough time to do it.

In The Walking Dead, a death can come out of nowhere, and you can still give most of an episode over to him dying (which is then why you'd have the likes of Jon Bernthal and the late Scott Wilson returning).


1. The Character Deserves Closure, And So Do The Fans

The Walking Dead Days Gone Bye
AMC

Through eight (and a bit) seasons, Rick Grimes has been a fighter, a survivor, and a leader. He takes everything this apocalyptic world throws at him and keeps on going, even with a few wobbles, and what's more, tries to do the best by his fellow survivors too.

After all that - after losing his wife, his son, his best friend, and, briefly, his sanity - if Rick is going to go, then he deserves the chance for some eternal peace, and so too do the fans. Andrew Lincoln's departure is going to leave a gaping hole in the series, and if he doesn't die, then there'll always be the question of whether or not he might come back. Rick Grimes wouldn't be the hero, he'd be the spectre hanging over the entire show.

His leaving, regardless of how it happens, is going to be extremely difficult for The Walking Dead to overcome, but at least with his death they can have a clean break and push forward to a future he's tried to create, rather than continuously looking over the shoulder for the day he might come back.

Do you think Rick Grimes should die? Will he? Share your thoughts down in the comments.

Watch Next: Why The Walking Dead Might Get Cancelled


Contributor
Contributor

NCTJ-qualified journalist. Most definitely not a racing driver. Drink too much tea; eat too much peanut butter; watch too much TV. Sadly only the latter paying off so far. A mix of wise-old man in a young man's body with a child-like wonder about him and a great otherworldly sensibility.