The X-Files: 10 Things We Learned From Home Again

Can you really go home again?

Home Again, the fourth episode of The X-Files current revival, had some big shoes to fill. It was given the less than envious task of following in the wake of Mulder and Scully Meet the Were-Monster, one of the most critically acclaimed X-Files outings since the early days of the show. Wisely, it's a darker, monster of the week style episode, so there will be no direct comparisons to the light-hearted outing that came before it, nor any confusing mythology that newer fans of the series might have a hard time grasping. Instead, it's thrills, chills, and blood spills ahead. And surprisingly, a fair amount of melodrama. While many had speculated ever since the title of the episode was announced this past summer that Home Again would be a follow-up to the classic inbred mutant episode Home (especially since a sequel in the comics shared the same name), the producers insisted that was not the case. Instead, there's a terrifying new monster - dubbed the Band-Aid Man - and a lot of darkness as well. So, what to make of Home Again? Was there any connection to Home, and how does it fit into the overall story of the revival thus far? Lets examine ten things we learned from the fourth episode of the season.

10. It Featured Another Killer Teaser

No pun intended, but Home Again did have another killer teaser, which featured a hapless public servant having his arms ripped off (and pretty much being ripped to pieces) by the ominous Band-Aid Man. It's a silly name, and the moniker of his creator, the Trash Man, might have been better suited, but it's descriptive enough (he has a band-aid over his nose at all times, for reasons explained later in the episode). And that entrance... well, that's how you make an entrance. You can feel the fear in Alessandro Juliani's Joseph Cutler, the city servant tasked with relocating the homeless in downtown Philadelphia, and who the Band-Aid Man has targeted. Scrambling to call 9-1-1, rummaging for the gun in his desk drawer, all for naught... The Band-Aid Man makes a hell of an entrance, and whatever you think about the rest of the episode (it was neither bad nor stellar, just your average Monster of the Week X-Files outing), he was certainly a solid addition to the show's rogues gallery.

9. Though Not A Sequel To Home, There Were Connections

Home Again was not a direct sequel to Home. It cannot even be seen as an indirect sequel. However, there were connections, mostly in style and theme. Of the two, style was the more obvious. There were several shots that seemed almost lifted from Home, most notably the Band-Aid Man crawling into the back of a garbage truck feeling akin to the surviving Peacock brother climbing into the trunk of his car, and the use of overly upbeat music - Wonderful! Wonderful! in Home, and Downtown in Home Again - as the soundtrack to a brutal murder scene. Speaking of brutal murder scenes, the murders of Sheriff Andy Taylor in Home and Nancy Huff in Home Again were strikingly similar, though while the Peacocks ascended the staircase of Taylor's home, Band-Aid Man descends the one in Home Again in scenes that almost serve as bookends. As for theme - you have the small town law enforcement, or well local law enforcement, since Home Again is set in Philly, butting heads with the FBI but ultimately being grateful for their involvement, and the idea of an isolated community within the greater world at large, albeit poverty is a far cry from incest. In any case, the connections are there, though Home remains far and away the better episode. Still, the Downtown scene was pretty damn cool.

8. The Show Doesn't Have Enough Time To Find Balance Between Dark And Comedic

You're a dark wizard, Mulder. It was a great line. No question about it. Uttered by Scully, this would have been a classic, were it not delivered next to her comatose mother's hospital bedside. We'll get into the return of Margaret Scully more in a bit, but first, consider this: When the X-Files was in its original run, it generally had between 20 to 24 or so episodes per season, and with that, it could find balance between dark, disturbing, and scary, and light and humorous. Between episodes, and within the episodes themselves. It managed this incredibly well in the first five seasons and a bit before going off the rails sometime around the latter half of season six, but even then, the show hit that balance more often than it missed it. In the revival thus far, it feels as if the writers are trying to be everything all at once, with the exception of Mulder and Scully Meet the Were-Monster, which went for straight-up laughs, as it should have. However, the show should have stopped with the quips and one-liners there, and saved them for some future outing. Instead, some of the quips in Home Again felt forced, especially given it was dealing with some very gory subject matter. Did Mulder really need to ask if two future victims of the Band-Aid Man were married just because they were arguing? Was that the right spot for the dark wizard line? Probably not.

7. Seeing Margaret Scully Again Was Bittersweet

This may be something of a personal pet peeve, but bringing back a character from a beloved show's early years late in its run just to kill them off is pretty annoying. The great thing about Scully's mom on the original run of The X-Files was that Margaret Scully wasn't generally a part of the insanity. She was just a good mom - warm and loving and genuine and outside of all the drama. In Home Again, a call from Scully's brother Bill notifies her that their mother has had a heart attack, is in a coma, and by the end of the episode - with the exception of a brief awakening to mention Mulder and Scully's son, William - she's dead. It's moving only because we as fans of the show know who she is. Frankly, however, it feels rushed - the downside of the six episode run. It's also just a downer. We get it, parents die, and we all have to cope with it, grieve, and move on. Still, both Mulder and Scully are now parentless, and while we feel for Scully, the whole plotline seemed unnecessary.

6. This Was Not The Time To Start A New Mystery

Speaking of unnecessary: while in the hospital, Scully finds that her mother has been wearing a mysterious coin she has had put on a chain, and that she has asked to see her youngest son, Charlie, from whom the entire family seems to be estranged - though the exact reason is never explicitly stated. This might have been interesting sometime back in season six or so, but in 2016, it feels a little too late, and again, a little too forced. There's no way the show can address any sort of new mystery within the family in the two episodes they have left this season, and if the show is never brought back - or only has another limited run, or a final feature film - then you've got a throwaway plotline that wasted screen time for no good reason. Besides, does anyone even remember that Scully had a younger brother? Older brother Bill appeared several times, as did her sister and mother, but Charlie was only ever seen on screen in flashbacks once or twice, and mentioned a few times beyond that in name. Why not throw in a zany cousin while you're at it?

5. Scully Clearly Has Second Thoughts About Giving Up Her Son

It was clear from some of the earlier episodes this season that Scully has been having issues coming to terms with not having her son in her life, and it's even clearer, after Home Again, that she is having second thoughts about giving him up in the first place. William is a background part of Home Again, but that doesn't mean the connection to him in this episode isn't crucial to Scully's development this season. When she gets the initial phone call from big brother Bill (aka William Scully Jr.) that their mother is in hospital, she sees only William. Again, when Mulder calls her, she sees the name William on her call display. Chalk that up to seeing things and emotional turmoil if you will, but then her mother's dying words, to Mulder no less, are basically pointing out that William is her son's name as well (Bill Jr.) in reference to Mulder and Scully's child. In essence, her last thoughts were of the grandchild she never knew, which rattles Scully further. Expect, at some point, a reunion. That's really the only closure for her.

4. Back In The Day Is More Fun

Finally, the flashlights come out, the scene is lit by the agents seeking out some creature or other, and all seems right with the show. For all its flaws, Home Again did a few things right - it had a very creepy monster, though one that was sadly underutilized and given a rather hokey origin story, and it paid homage to the flashlights so key to the early, darkest X-Files outings. When Mulder says he doesn't do stairs anymore after letting a suspect flee, and Scully counters with "back in the day I used to do stairs in three-inch heels" (or something to that effect), he pulls out his flashlight and quips that it is "back in the day." It's the one funny line in the episode that really works - okay, the dark wizard line does get some credit - but it's also what fans really, really need more of. Of course, there's not much time left, but visually, this was once again an improvement, so the show has at least been trending in the right direction in terms of look.

3. Walking Clay Monsters Don't Bother X-Files Agents

Mulder and Scully make their way down to the basement of an abandoned warehouse of some sort, in search of the person - or thing - brutally murdering people connected to relocating the homeless in Philadelphia. They've been led to believe, or Mulder has anyway, that it's the Band-Aid Man, who "speaks" for the homeless in the area. Ominous graffiti stencils are left close to where his victims are found, and he has torn people to shreds quite literally (while taking some choice body parts with him). So Mulder and Scully are on edge, and when a walking clay sculpture saunters past them (or maybe it was papier-mâché) - they seem startlingly nonplussed. Within minutes, they seem to have accepted this as the norm, and are chatting away with the Trash Man, a tattooed artist who claims to have put so much of himself into his art that it has come to life. While Mulder debates the man over just how this is possible, and Scully pretty much just listens in, neither bother to actually try and track one of these creatures down. You know, as the proof that they're so badly seeking, or just because they're sort of cool to watch.

2. The Show Has No Problem Going Full-On Gory

From arms being ripped off, to a head being ripped from a torso with a spinal column trailing, Home Again may be one of the goriest episodes of The X-Files to date, and that's saying something. It seems the show is reveling in the gore this season, actually. Founder's Mutation did it as well, but while Founder's Mutation was a sort of weird freaky gorefest, Home Again went the blood and guts route. The Band-Aid Man gets a full five victims in the episode, four of whom are literally ripped to shreds (with one being suffocated with a garbage bag). The final one has his parts left in a nice little pile, which at least makes him easy to identify. Want more evidence? Look no further than the creature's leavings - toxic garbage juice with writhing maggots. A re-watch will remind you how bloody the original series was, but for those who haven't seen it for a while, it's another reminder that The X-Files is not for the squeamish.

1. Opening Endings Are Expected, But Explanations Still Matter

Open endings are part of the charm of The X-Files. They let you fill in the blanks, let you draw your own conclusions. Since the show attracts both skeptics and believers, it's a solid approach - not every "i" need be dotted, nor every lower case "j" - but at the same time, explanations still matter. And they need to be within the realm of extreme possibility. In short - it's no big deal that the Band-Aid Man "gets away" - because we don't know that he even does. His well-meaning creator, Trash Man, the street artist who unintentionally brought the creature to life, moves on at the end of the episode, defacing the clay sculpture he has of the Band-Aid Man before he goes, but a haunting stencil is left behind. Will this thing still roam the streets murdering anyone it feels is endangering the homeless population? It doesn't matter. Maybe Trash Man has put an end to it; maybe Frankenstein can never control his monster. What matters is the explanation behind it all. And that never feels satisfactory. If the show had suggested Trash Man had some psychic power, sure. As a fan, you could buy into that explanation. Psychic powers are part of the show's lore. However, saying Trash Man just put so much emotion into his work that it came to life, and tossing in a couple of new age references? That's a tad weak. Also problematic was the fact that a band-aid collected from one of the crime scenes tests negative for both organic and inorganic matter, something a lab tech marvels at - but the evidence is never revisited, despite the fact that it would be hard, irrefutable proof of, well, something extraordinary. That's where Home Again falters. It hops from one plot point to another, and many of them are interesting in their own way, but there's a lack of cohesion through the episode that drags it down into middling territory. We learned from it how much we miss the scary, violent X-Files - but we need better execution. What did you think of Home Again? Anything you learned? Let us know in the comments. Follow us on Twitter: @WhatCultureTV

Contributor
Contributor

Primarily covering the sport of MMA from Ontario, Canada, Jay Anderson has been writing for various publications covering sports, technology, and pop culture since 2001. Jay holds an Honours Bachelor of Arts degree in English from the University of Guelph, and a Certificate in Leadership Skills from Humber College.