The X-Files: 15 Creepiest Creatures

The X-Files is known for scares, and these are the worst culprits!

The X-Files spent the better part of a decade scaring the socks off of television viewers by presenting a twisted menagerie of creeps and ghouls unlike any other show on television. Sure, Star Trek had the coolest alien races, and Buffy had some pretty awesome monsters, but most of them were pretty obviously just guys in rubber suits or with prosthetics glued to their faces growling a whole lot, and a lot of times they came off more campy than scary. With a bigger budget than most of its closest competitors, The X-Files was able to branch out and come up with some incredibly unique creatures, aided by the fact that the show had a knack for hiring some generally unheard of yet extremely effective actors to portray them - a credit to their excellent casting department. Take the infamous Donnie Pfaster, for example. Though Pfaster had no real special power other than being absolutely, one-hundred percent creepy. Pfaster was played to perfection by Nick Chinlund, an actor who would go on to appear in Con Air, Training Day, Chronicles of Riddick, UltraViolet, Buffy the Vampire Slayer, and The Sopranos among other movies and television series after his original 1995 appearance as the necrophiliac Pfaster in the episode "Irresistible" (he would reprise the role in the season seven episode "Orison"). Pfaster managed to make audiences cringe just by being so incredibly sick and twisted, right down to his overly normal appearance and cold, dead voice. That's just one example. There are plenty more of all shapes and sizes from The X-Files over the years, some human (or humanoid) with powers that made them extremely creepy, others altogether unrecognisable as anything close to life as we know it. That was the joy of the show when it came to the monsters - while in many cases human beings could be the worst monsters of all (we're looking at you, Cigarette Smoking Man), you could have a microscopic organism killing hapless innocents, or a mutated animal, or just about anything else. Now, lets take a look at the fifteen creepiest creatures from over two hundred episodes of The X-Files.

15. The Arctic Worms

Appeared in: Season 1, Episode 8 - "Ice" One of the creepiest sensations imaginable is the idea of a worm or parasite getting in your ear, squirming its way inside - so if that makes you squeamish, you might want to avoid the first season episode "Ice," one of the great early episodes of The X-Files. "Ice" does a lot of things right, most of all setting up the feeling of isolation at the remote Arctic research station the episode is set at. It's The X-Files' homage to The Thing, and it's done quite well. Only instead of a mutant alien, it's a parasitic worm brought up in an ice core sample that turns hosts aggressive that is the real enemy. All the other nods to The Thing are there however, from the locale to the paranoia between rescue team members, to the station's original inhabitants killing themselves off (think of the Norwegian camp in The Thing) - heck even a dog plays a major role in "Ice" which has to be a wink at the horror classic. When it comes down to saving the day, the cure is almost worse than the disease - a second parasite introduced into the body via the ear canal does the trick, as the two parasites kill each other off. These little worms were simple, yet extremely effective in creeping out the audience.

14. Mrs. Paddock

Appeared in: Season 2, Episode 14 - "Die Hand Die Verletzt" The fact that she has human eyes in her desk drawer is probably a sign that Mrs. Paddock isn't someone you really want to get to know - but for as much as we knew her in the second season episode 'Die Hand Die Verletzt" (German for "the hand that wounds"), we certainly enjoyed our time with her. A fantastically creepy character, there is something reptilian about Mrs. Paddock, a substitute teacher at a high school being plagued by rumours of devil worship and human sacrifice right from the start - though it isn't shown outright til the very end of the episode. Paddock in initially played up as a caring supply teacher, brought in at the school as Mulder and Scully investigate claims of devil worship, but she is quickly revealed to be behind the evil taking place at the school and in the local community - and in the end, she uses her otherworldly powers to compel fellow black magic practitioners in the town to kill themselves. At the same time, Scully manages to uncover that Mrs. Paddock is not what she seems, having no background to her - but by then it's too late. She leaves the world of The X-Files as mysteriously as she entered it, leaving a simple message on the classroom blackboard for our heroes before vanishing: "Goodbye. It's been nice working with you."

13. The Doll

Appeared in: Season 5, Episode 10 - "Chinga" Dolls are just inherently creepy, especially old-time-y ones. You know, porcelain dolls, anything with a painted face really. Now add in the concept of a demonic doll dreamed up by Stephen King. The outcome could be terrifying. King had expressed an interest in writing for the show after the first couple of years, which was by the fifth season a global phenomenon, and wound up doing this episode in conjunction with Chris Carter (the two never met face-to-face - drafts were sent back and forth between them), who re-wrote many of the Mulder and Scully moments in the episode. The doll itself, brought up from the depths by a fisherman and given to his daughter, winds up being an object of pure evil that acts almost as a conduit for its keeper, the young Polly Turner. What Polly wants, she seemingly gets thanks to the doll - only, things eventually get out of hand, with the doll being responsible for many deaths thanks to its ability to control people's actions (though not their minds). Uttering the eerie line "I want to play" whenever activated, the doll makes for one of the more downright scary creatures of the series.

12. Cecil L'Ively

Appeared in: Season 1, Episode 12 - "Fire" If there's one thing we found personally creepy and off-putting about season one's Cecil L'Ively, it was that he offered a pair of small children a chance to smoke. As soon as that scene hit the screen, you knew how evil he really was. It probably says something about modern sensibilities that his temptation of small children with a cigarette ("go on, it'll make a man out of you") seemed more disturbing than the fact that he was very obviously pyrokinetic, an arsonist, and a murderer. Portrayed by Mark Sheppard, who would go on to appear in Firefly, Warehouse 13, Battlestar Galactica, and Supernatural, L'Ively was an over-the-top villain whose final lines might have been cartoon-like if not properly delivered. Instead they worked perfectly - set ablaze using an accelerant to turn his own power against him, L'Ively screams out "you can't fight fire with fire" before falling to the ground, charred. Of course, he's somewhat right - displaying an abnormally rapid healing ability, L'Ively, on the mend, is last heard telling a nurse that he's just "dying for a cigarette."

11. The Silicon-Based Parasite

Appeared in: Season 2, Episode 9 - "Firewalker" There were a number of times that The X-Files went smaller, rather than larger, in regards to its creatures - and to be honest, the silicon based life forms encountered in the second season's "Firewalker" weren't exactly "creatures" per se - but they were creepy. Uncovered by a research team exploring an active volcano, the parasitic life form infected a host by way of spores (we'll get to those in a moment) and eventually reproduced via a growth that burst forth from the victim's neck - very much a nod to the chest-burster of Alien fame. That growth would erupt and release a cloud of spores to spread the life form to new hosts. As with the Arctic worms of "Ice", the parasites changed the personality of their hosts, with the aim of furthering their own survival and the propagation of the species. The entire creep factor of a foreign body, a mindless parasite almost plant-like in nature taking control and later ripping through your flesh was heightened by the horrified reaction of the research crew exploring the volcano, all of whom were infected and deep down, despite being influenced by the parasites, aware that they were doomed - but unable to overcome the need to continue the cycle of life initiated by the release of the spores.

10. Agula Mala's Sea Monsters

Appeared in: Season 6, Episode 13 - "Agula Mala" Every good paranormal show should have a "creature from the deep" sort of episode. It's not just that The Creature from the Black Lagoon is a classic movie monster, or that there was a boom in deep-water themed horror and sci-fi flicks in the late 80s with films like The Abyss, Leviathan, and Deep Star Six (all of which came out in 1989). It's more because, frankly, the oceans are the one great territory on our planet that are still unexplored to the level that the rest of the planet has been (something that clearly led to that late 80s/early 90s boom in deep water themed scary tales). The very depths of the oceans of our planet remain nearly untouched, and we're still finding new, exotic species coming out of them, which in turn sparks our imaginations - the oceans are so close, yet so foreign, all at once, and it's easy to believe that some sort of alien, monstrous species might still be lurking down there. Now keep in mind that not all monsters need to be huge (we've covered this). The creatures in Agula Mala - which literally means "bad water" - vary in size, but they are not Cthulhu-sized behemoths at any rate. And they are, apparently, made of pure water, or just about, so much so that they blend right in - at least in sea water. They eat away at victims slowly, liquefying them in fact. Just about the only thing that hurts the serpentine beasts happens to be fresh water. It's lucky for Mulder and Scully that it happened to be raining throughout a large part of the episode.

9. Leonard Betts

Appeared in: Season 4, Episode 12 - "Leonard Betts" Cancer is one of the great plagues of the human species, something that should realistically scare all of us, because you never really know if you're going to get it. Thus it shouldn't be surprising that a character who both feeds on cancer, and essentially is cancer, should creep us out. Leonard Betts appears in a season four episode bearing his own name, and honestly, initially comes off as a decent guy - an EMT who is incredibly good at his job and saving lives. Then he's tragically killed in a traffic accident while on the job, resulting in him being decapitated. And all is well (though sad) until his body gets up and walks out of the morgue. Then he grows a new head. While this is in the realm of the bizarre, quite firmly really, he doesn't really creep us out until it's discovered that he's willing to kill the closest thing he has to a friend in order to hide the fact that he's a cancer-eating mutant who is basically a walking collection of tumours. He then goes from oddity to creepy killer, and by the time we discover his stash of snacks (cancerous tissue and growths), and that he's willing to feast on his own mother's cancerous flesh, we're completely revolted by him. Oh, and did we mention he's able to create husk-like clone versions of himself, in a process at least visibly similar to a snake shedding its skin? Gross.

8. The Bat Creature

Appeared in: Season 8, Episode 3 - "Patience" When David Duchovny opted to appear only part-time in the eighth season of The X-Files, producers knew that they had to do something to make up for the pronounced absence of Fox Mulder. As a result, they brought in Terminator 2 alum Robert Patrick to play a new FBI agent assigned to the X-Files, the better-than-you-remember John Doggett - and they also opted to get back to the show's dark, creepy, paranormal roots, something they had moved away from by doing more light-hearted, quirky, comedy-filled episodes of the show's seventh season. An early success at returning to the realm of the scary was season eight's "Patience" - in which Doggett and Dana Scully begin investigating a death in which the killer seems to have both human and animal aspects. That killer turns out to be a human bat, and that is of course where the creep factor comes in. Batman aside, bats are very foreign to us. As a winged mammal (an abnormality in itself), they operate by echolocation, are known to carry disease (rabies, SARS), and generally creep many people out. Remember the scene in The Goonies where they burst up out of the fireplace? The screams of "rabies!" sticks out to this day. Now add the fact that you've got a giant, humanoid bat creature who isn't exactly keeping the streets of Gotham safe, but instead killing off hunters who once attempted to bag it... yeah. That will give you chills.

7. Greg Pincus (Insect Creature)

Appeared in: Season 5, Episode 19 - "Folie à Deux" A lot of good science fiction involves examining how we see the world around us, literally - what is real, and what isn't. Questions of reality come up in The Matrix (basically a riff on Plato's allegory of the cave), Neuromancer, numerous Star Trek episodes, the list goes on - but those are less scary and more science-y. "Folie à Deux" (which is a term meaning "a shared psychosis") from the fifth season of The X-Files brings the creep factor right along with the science. Greg Pincus is an apparently decent call centre boss - but one of his employees happens to see him as a monster, literally, who feeds off his workers, turning them into zombies that can't be seen save by a select few. After taking Pincus and other workers at the office hostage, the employee winds up dead - but not before Mulder and Scully are called in on the case, and not before Mulder becomes able to see the monster Pincus really is, becoming part of the Folie à Deux. What made this insectoid-like monster so creepy? The sounds the creature made were unnerving, and the fact that only Mulder could see it (especially when hospitalized and strapped down to a bed) - it gave you a sense that, for a change, he was actually in danger.

6. Leonard

Appeared in: Season 2, Episode 20 - "Humbug" "Humbug" had a number of recognizable guest stars in it, including Michael J. Anderson (Twin Peaks, Carnivale), Jim Rose (he of the sideshow that gained fame at Lollapalooza in the festival's early years), and The Enigma (you can't miss him - he's entirely covered in tattoos) - but in the end, it was Vincent Schiavelli's (Ghost, Batman Returns) Lanny who stood out, along with his conjoined twin brother Leonard. Leonard hung off Lanny like a massive tumour, and the gross-out factor alone was high for this episode as a result. Once we learned that he was detaching from his brother and chewing up the local townsfolk (rather than it being the Fiji mermaid, as Mulder at one point considered), the yuck factor went up even more. Leonard was human... but he wasn't at the same time. A mutant the size of a small child crawling and scurrying around, covered in blood... really, Leonard was revolting enough to make the rest of the "freaks" in this freakshow-themed episode seem normal. The fact that Lanny was such a sympathetic character made things somehow worse, because you sympathised with Lanny when he proclaimed that Leonard's actions were because he was "merely seeking another brother" when questioned why his brother hated him so.

5. Robert Patrick Modell (Pusher)

Appeared in: Season 3, Episode 17 - "Pusher" and Season 5, Episode 8 - "Kitsunegari" The only reason Robert Patrick Modell, a.k.a. "Pusher," doesn't appear higher in this list is that at his core, he's really just a human character. A bad guy, for sure. Creepy? Definitely. A creature? Well that's debatable - but he's just too evil not too include. "Pusher" appeared twice on The X-Files and was one of the more popular "MOTW" (Monster of the Week) characters, though not a monster in any supernatural way - aside from the fact that he had a wicked case of cancer-driven ESP (of sorts) that allowed him to control people's actions, against their will. As Mulder described it, he was able to "push" his will upon people. A rather regular guy before developing the tumour which gave him these powers, he engaged in a cat and mouse game with the FBI after committing murders that seemed to be suicides at first glance, drawing in the authorities by providing details only someone with intimate knowledge of the crime scenes could provide. Pusher's atrocities included coercing a cop to douse himself with gasoline and immolate himself, and forcing Mulder into a game of Russian roulette. Perhaps his creepiest moment in the show, however, was talking an overweight detective into experiencing a heart attack - while Mulder pleaded and begged with the detective to hang up the phone.

4. The Peacock Family

Appeared in: Season 4, Episode 2 - "Home" "Home" was the only episode of The X-Files to actually be banned from television for a while: a self-imposed ban by the FOX network, to be fair, but it did not air again for years. Generally considered to be one of the scariest and most disturbing episodes of the series, "Home" touches on themes of incest, small town life, and the encroachment of urban city centres on rural areas - in essence, the loss of a simpler way of life. It also plays up the old stereotype that "small towns have their secrets." At the centre of all this is the horrifically inbred Peacock family, three brothers (and later, we learn, a severely injured mother) living together on a small farm at the edge of town. "Everyone" knows about the Peacocks, and how they "keep to themselves" (a sly reference to their habit of inbreeding), yet no one wants to suspect them, at least at first, when the body of an infant is found buried in a makeshift baseball diamond at the sandlot next to their farm. Buried alive, based on the dirt inhaled by the small corpse. Of course, not knowing about the mother's existence initially, it's easy to see why you wouldn't suspect three brothers of somehow giving birth to a newborn - but the Peacock's were so creepy that Mulder and Scully should have just known (and soon enough, they do - but not before the boys murder the likeable local sheriff). Because of the incest/inbreeding angle, things here were creepy enough, but the deformities of the boys, and the condition of their mother - kept under a bed at their dilapidated home - takes this one over the top.

3. Donnie Pfaster

Appeared in: Season 2, Episode 13 - "Irresistible" and Season 7, Episode 7 - "Orison" If there was a character on The X-Files that could be described as "pure evil" it would be Donnie Pfaster. A necrophiliac/death fetishist, we first meet Donnie when he's desecrating corpses at a funeral home he works at, and we later find out he has been digging up graves, but as Mulder speculates when he and Scully are brought in on the case, he's likely to expand to taking real, live victims and killing them to fulfil his sexual needs. The actual sexual/fetish actions involving Pfaster are mostly just hinted at, but it's creepy enough even when it's happening off-screen. Nick Chinlund plays him to perfection, and in the end, Pfaster was such a memorable villain is his first outing (where he's eventually captured after attacking Scully) that he was brought back several years later, for season seven's "Orison" - which sees Pfaster breaking out of prison with the help of a holy man who believes he's doing "god's work." Only ever seen as a man in "Irresistible" in the second season, in "Orison" he is at one point clearly seen as demonic - though it could be interpreted as symbolic rather than literal (however John Shiban, a producer on the show, stated it was an intentional decision to have him actually be a demon).

2. Eugene Victor Tooms

Appeared in: Season 1, Episode 3 - "Squeeze" & Season 1, Episode 21 - "Tooms" One of the creepiest "human" characters to ever appear on The X-Files, Eugene Victor Tooms wasn't exactly human, but rather, an immortal (or incredibly long-lived) creature who extended his life by eating human livers, then nesting and hibernating for years at a time. Played by Doug Hutchison, who would also appear in The Green Mile (but become better known in recent years for marrying sixteen year old bombshell Courtney Stodden), Tooms was the only monster of the week character to appear twice in the show's first season. How creepy was he? Well, he had the ability to elongate his body, squeezing into the tightest of spaces, making him a very, very proficient killer, and one who could leave the cops guessing as to just who was seemingly breaking into locked rooms and extracting human livers. He also built his nests using bile, which was simply disgusting. Oh, and he takes little mementos from those he kills, giving him a serial killer element. Hutchison's portrayal of Tooms - with facial expressions and movements done to perfection - is nothing short of fantastic, and made for one of the most memorable creatures in X-Files history.

1. The Flukeman

Appeared in: Season 2, Episode 2 - "The Host" Stephen King once said €œI recognize terror as the finest emotion and so I will try to terrorize the reader. But if I find that I cannot terrify, I will try to horrify, and if I find that I cannot horrify, I'll go for the gross-out." "The Host" went for the gross-out. Since the moment the episode first aired, the "flukeman" - a mutated part fluke, part human creature born out of the aftermath of Chernobyl that takes centre stage in the episode - has both fascinated and grossed out X-Files fans the world over. The physical look, the fact that it lives in sewers and at one point gets sucked out of a portable toilet, the way it lays its eggs - by biting a human victim and infecting him or her - it's all just so damn gross and creepy. The flukeman was actually future X-Files writer Darin Morgan (brother of executive producer Howard Morgan), who would later appear on screen in the episode "Small Potatoes" in a suit, but it didn't take away from the fact that the creature was one of the most disgusting characters ever to appear on the show. For bonus disgusting points - Morgan had to wear the suit for extended periods, and couldn't take it off to go the the bathroom. Just use your imagination from there... That brings us to the end - who would you add to the list?

In this post: 
The X-Files
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Primarily covering the sport of MMA from Ontario, Canada, Jay Anderson has been writing for various publications covering sports, technology, and pop culture since 2001. Jay holds an Honours Bachelor of Arts degree in English from the University of Guelph, and a Certificate in Leadership Skills from Humber College.