The X-Files: 10 Ways To Continue The Franchise

The truth is still out there, but how will we find it?

Fox
Fox
The X-Files has come and gone - for now. The revival, however, outperformed all expectations, generating more fan interest, media interest, and turning in better numbers that most could have ever dreamed of. The premiere event was watched by over fifty million people worldwide. The show seemed to pick up in the ratings right where it left off, despite the decline in viewership suffered by most major networks in the wake of the expanded cable universe. Creatively, well, the season was a mixed bag. Six episodes meant that the show did not have time to find its footing, and there was little room for error. Mulder And Scully Meet the Were-Monster became an instant classic, yet the attempt to steer the mythology of the show in yet another new direction was puzzling, when most fans were looking for closure to that storyline. There were also plenty of open endings, pretty much an X-Files trademark at this point. Yet one thing is certain: the show will continue, in some form. Just what that continuation looks like, however, is up for debate. There have been talks of additional seasons, a larger episode order, another feature film - lots of options, but little talk of their merits. With that in mind let's examine 10 possible ways The X-Files could return!

10. A Second Shortened Season

Fox
Fox
It worked well enough once, so why not try it again? This is the obvious route to take, which is why it comes in last, even though it might be the most likely. Both David Duchovny and Gillian Anderson have pretty busy schedules, even with Hannibal off the air. Both are also parents, and no doubt want some family time. That's what made the shortened revival season so appealing in the first place - it was like a summer project, rather than a full year commitment. The big stumbling block, however, is that as the tenth season showed, the producers are unwilling to wrap things up, and just have too many ideas for a paltry six episodes. If their desire is to continue the franchise on for years, this really doesn't allow for fully developed story lines.

9. The Einstein And Miller Spin-Off

Fox
Fox
Danger Will Robinson, danger! While a spin-off with new characters would allow for story lines to be expanded, Einstein (Robbie Amell) and Miller (Lauren Ambrose) failed to strike a chord with viewers in season ten. While they were positioned as Mulder and Scully Jr. (believer and skeptic, male and female, handsome leading man and petite redhead scientist), they were such clones, such generic clones, that they were almost parodies of the originals. They weren't even Doggett and Reyes level. Doggett and Reyes were at least interesting. So while this is a possibility, one that was actively considered apparently, with the two being included as a sort of back-door pilot, this is not the way to go. It's an option - just not a very good one.

8. A Skinner-Centric Mini-Series

Fox
Fox
Has anyone ever considered giving Walter Skinner his own series? Skinner is one of the most popular supporting characters on the show, outside of The Lone Gunmen. They had their spinoff, which sadly tanked after a handful of episodes and a premiere that involved a plane crashing into the World Trade Center just months before it actually happened. So what about another character? As an Assistant Director at the FBI, Skinner lives in a slightly different world than Mulder and Scully. He's more in-house, and this is where the conspiracy angles and political schemes could be played up. Plus, we really don't know all that much about the man. So there's a wealth of potential material there, especially if you flash back to his Vietnam days. The only problem is that at 63, Mitch Pileggi has a limited window to helm a show, but even a limited series could be entertaining... and Harrison Ford is going back to Indiana Jones one last time, proving you're never really too old.

7. An Animated Series

Fox
Fox
Buffy was going to do it, but it never got off the ground. Why not try it with The X-Files? If the actors can't handle the workload - and that's no fault of theirs, as they all have busy careers - why not try an animated series? The X-Files comic book run has turned out to be relatively popular, as has other tie-in material, such as several original novels. With the added publicity from the revival, an animated series could work - provided it was done right. Key to it would be look and tone: it would have to be adult-oriented, dark, with top notch animation. Fans simply wouldn't stand for it otherwise. And what about voice work? You might be hard pressed to sell anyone other than the original actors voicing Mulder and Scully.

6. The X-Files: Unit 2

Fox
Fox
Rather than a direct sequel series, or continuing on with the original, why not introduce a second X-Files unit, right alongside the main series (which could also continue to run in some form)? Think CSI or Law & Order on this one. Those franchises have excelled by spreading out the stories to additional units. The X-Files could easily establish a second unit. It could even be specialized: one dealing in fringe science (Fringe did just that, and was an excellent series in its own right), one dealing specifically with alien sightings, etc. Or just a second unit in a different part of the country, as Mulder and Scully have always been based out of Washington, but travel an awful lot, which can't be cost effective.

5. A Full Season Of The Original Series

Fox
Fox
This might be the most unlikely option there is for how to continue The X-Files, but it would be a popular choice among the hardcore fans. A full season of the series would allow for enough time to develop a proper end to the show, tie up all the loose plotlines (or most of them - let's not set the bar too high), and still get in plenty of Monster of the Week episodes to placate fans who prefer those to the alien-centric mythology. It's exactly what the doctor ordered, and the revival season did well enough in the ratings to justify greenlighting it. Sadly, it's about as likely as Santa bringing you that horse you really wanted as a kid. None of the main players have time in their schedule - but in all honesty, it's probably the best option the show could take.

4. Tie Up The Mythology In A Made For TV Movie

Fox
Fox
Made For TV movies often have a low budget feel to them, which is why this option isn't higher on the list. Still, it is an option. Probably more likely than a full series with the original cast, but less likely than several other possibilities. The important thing about this option, however, is that it doesn't rule out future productions. Simply tying up the alien mythology - and only that - means that you can still do a spin-off series with a different focus. Or bring back Mulder and Scully for Monster of the Week specials. Or have a next generation style series follow it. In short, this would be an option to just get the mythology of the show over and done with, once and for all. If it is to end on the small screen, anyway.

3. William: The Series

Fox
Fox
This is what the real Next Generation version of The X-Files should be: not a couple of Mulder and Scully clones, but a literal next generation. There is a wealth of material just sitting around, waiting to be mined when it comes to William. Coming of age, coming to terms with what (if any) powers he has, the conspiracy that has sucked his family into its wake - it's all just waiting, a virtual gold mine of plot lines. The X-Files and the mythology therein already spans two generations of a family, so why not a third? The trouble would be casting the right William, and having him be the right age. Beyond that? It's a perfect setup. Imagine that the show doesn't given you an answer to the season 10 finale right away. Instead, it focuses on William seeking out his birth parents, discovering who and what he is, and eventually, finding out what happened to them on that bridge. And then finding them. This option also allows for David Duchovny and Gillian Anderson to return in guest spots, regardless of their age.

2. Occasional Monster Of The Week Specials

Fox
Fox
Picture a world where there's a two-part X-Files special every February, or around Halloween time. They have nothing to do with aliens, and everything to do with nasty, insane, scary monsters. That's a pretty cool idea, frankly. The X-Files is just dying to be a strictly anthology show in the eyes of some fans. They don't want ongoing stories, but Monster of the Week outings. So once that pesky mythology is tied up, regardless of what form that takes, occasional specials like this - one, two, three hour installments - are still possible. Would Fox and 1013 see the value in this? After the money this revival made them, hopefully!

1. Produce A Third Feature Film

Fox
Fox
A third feature film is probably the best option to properly tie up the mythology story line, especially if it can be done at the same level of quality as the first X-Files feature film. It needs to have a decent budget, and all involved need to agree that regardless of future monster of the week specials or a next generation TV show, the conspiracy/alien colonization storyline needs to end with it. This isn't as left field as you think. Chris Carter has talked about hammering out a script for a third film. Frank Spotnitz, one of the show's co-producers in its final years, has talked about it as well. With the success of the revival, Carter has been talking about it again - but he as well has stressed that the budget needs to be there. It cannot be a low-key outing like 2008's I Want To Believe. There's also a limited time window to go this route. With the success of the revival, doing a movie in the next year or two could pay off. After that? It's more of a gamble. Strike while the iron is hot - that's what needs to happen here. How do you want to see the series continue, or wrap up? Add your thoughts below!

In this post: 
The X-Files
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Primarily covering the sport of MMA from Ontario, Canada, Jay Anderson has been writing for various publications covering sports, technology, and pop culture since 2001. Jay holds an Honours Bachelor of Arts degree in English from the University of Guelph, and a Certificate in Leadership Skills from Humber College.