Twin Peaks: The Return Premiere Review: 7 Ups & 4 Downs
It's back and weirder than ever.
It's been 26 years, but Twin Peaks is finally back. Arriving with no pre-release reviews and little known plot information, the new 18-episode event began its run with a four-episode season premiere, and it's clear from these early hours that David Lynch has lost none of his skill for crafting deeply unsettling imagery and terrifically compelling characters.
Twin Peaks: The Return is in many ways a starkly different beast to the original ABC show, but there's a prevailing feeling that this is absolutely the show Lynch wanted to make all along, an aggressively peculiar long-form mystery thriller that, on the basis of the first four episodes, just might end up being the his magnum opus.
It's not perfect, sure, and it remains to be seen what shape the entirety of the season will take, but these creepy, hilarious and star-studded opening hours show Lynch at his most dementedly unfiltered, unrestrained and uncensored.
Note that some spoilers will follow for The Return's first four episodes...
Downs...
4. The Atrocious Visual Effects
One of the first things viewers may notice about the new Twin Peaks is that David Lynch has opted to make use of much more CGI in order to achieve his trademark discordant imagery.
The problem is that there clearly wasn't much of a budget allocated for visual effects, and as such most of the digital elements mesh incredibly awkwardly with the live-action fare, looking goofy and cheap.
The original show had its fair share of cringe-worthy effects (Josie in the doorknob, anyone?), but one hoped Lynch would either rein it in or actually have the budget to make them look convincing this time.
Some fans are already claiming that Lynch is employing deliberately garish effects in order to make the experience that much more unsettling for viewers, but honestly, that sounds like wishful thinking.
3. Not Enough Twin Peaks
Very little of the first four episodes actually takes place in the titular town, with the action largely spread between New York City, South Dakota and Nevada, with only occasional trips back to the sleepy locale.
Of course, with The Return having another fourteen episodes to go, it's likely that Lynch is playing the long game and will hurl Coop back to Twin Peaks soon enough, but it's easy to understand fan frustration at the show's namesake getting such a short shrift so far.
Props to him for not just exploiting lazy nostalgia, but dammit if Lucy and Andy need more scenes already.
2. The Brutal Pacing
The original series was never in much of a hurry to tell its story, but The Return has unambiguously one-upped it in the sluggish pacing department. Scenes frequently drag on much, much longer than they need to as Lynch lingers on a glance or focuses on a low mechanical hum for 30 seconds too long.
It does help evoke a certain unsettling, hypnotic rhythm, but it can also make it easy to tune out of what's going on for a moment and just wish he'd get to the point already, especially if you made the brave decision to watch all four episodes in a single chunk.
Simply, this probably isn't a show you'd want to binge when it's all finally released, but week-to-week, Lynch's painstaking approach should prove much more tolerable, if still exasperating to a point.
1. The Lack Of Music
It's been known for a while that the legendary Angelo Badalamenti would be returning to score the new series, but so far, there's been barely any original music to speak of.
Yes, the composer's iconic themes have been sparingly used for marquee moments, but the majority of the show's scenes have played out totally sans music, scored only by a disturbing industrial hum.
Though this is effectively creepy in its own way, most fans were surely expecting Badalamenti to return with a treasure trove of new music. Of course, it's entirely possible his new licks will kick in once Cooper returns to Twin Peaks, but if not, this will likely be the series' most disappointing aspect to many fans.
Thankfully The Return is a mostly rapturous return for David Lynch so far, so here's everything he's getting right...
Ups...
7. It's Darker & More Surreal Than Before
It's difficult to fathom a new Twin Peaks being much weirder than the original show, but the first four episodes essentially see Lynch and co-writer Mark Frost vomiting their most twisted, f****ed up and straight-up bizarre ideas onto the screen.
It doesn't all seem to make much sense yet, but the quirkier tone of the original series takes a back seat to an overall bleaker tenor, and scenes so surreal they feel more like art installations than works of narration fiction.
In just four episodes Lynch has made arguably the strangest work of his career, and with another fourteen to go, it's safe to say he's probably going to take it to places fans can't even imagine right now.
6. All The Cameos
What an absolutely stunning cast The Return has already shown off, with the likes of Madeline Zima, Ashley Judd, Naomi Watts, Jennifer Jason Leigh, Jane Adams, Matthew Lillard and, most hilariously, Michael Cera, all appearing throughout the opening episodes.
The full cast list of literally hundreds of actors has been available for a long time, and though it initially seemed like Lynch was going to struggle to cram so many famous faces in, the fact that even bonafide A-listers seem happy to spend just a few minutes in Lynch's world should make it far easier to juggle so many household names.
It's incredibly bizarre seeing so many famous faces peeking their heads into Twin Peaks, only further heightening the overall dissonant tone. Seriously, that Michael Cera cameo just might be one of the show's best-ever moments...
5. The Mysteries Are Confusing & Compelling
Even though the early hours don't give much of an indication how things will pan out in the long run, Lynch has done nothing if not serve up a highly compelling series of tangentially-linked mysteries.
The two main threads, of course, are the peculiar glass box in New York City and Agent Cooper's quest to return his evil doppelganger to the Black Lodge, and going by the "it is happening again" tagline, it seems probable that Twin Peaks will end up with another young body wrapped in plastic at some point.
Whatever the end result of these plots, the journey so far is fascinatingly odd and, though thoroughly confusing, incredibly difficult to look away from. It may be weird for weird's own sake, but it has a deeply entrancing appeal all the same.
4. There's Nudity & Gore This Time
The original Twin Peaks series aired on ABC, and owing to their own content restrictions, David Lynch had to keep things fairly clean from a sex and violence perspective. The Return is airing on Showtime, though, where R-rated content is both allowed and welcome.
Lynch takes advantage of this early on, with several nude females adorning the screen, not to mention a number of grotesque corpses doused in gore. It's clear that Showtime has taken a hands-off approach with Lynch and simply let him deliver exactly what he wants to, and he's decided to make the third season much more raw, graphic and unpleasant than the original.
It's pretty jarring at first, but placing arbitrary content restrictions on an artist as singular as Lynch can never be a good idea. Here, there's not much excuse if it ends up sucking.
3. It's Really, Really Funny
Lynch has a very unique, oddball sense of humour, one which slowly seeps through the cracks after a fairly dour two-hour premiere. Be it Lucy talking about a chocolate bunny she ate or Coop damn-near putting a casino out of business with his relentless jackpot wins, the show is positively dripping with wit both dry and outrageously over-the-top.
Again, it won't be for all tastes much like most of what Lynch does, but the humour feels very much in step with the original show's quirkier tone, especially when it comes to inherent comic relief characters like Lucy and Andy.
2. The Ultra-Intense Atmosphere
So many revival shows fail to capture the feel and tone of the original show, but Twin Peaks perfectly nails the eerie anxiety of the first two series, albeit amplified many times over to be almost unbearably intense at times.
The combination of that ominous droning hum of a soundtrack, the jarring visuals and spot-on performances across-the-board combine to make The Return among Lynch's most disturbing works to date, with a pervasive air of dread that few other filmmakers can match.
If he can sustain this discomforting tone for another 14 hours, it'd be damn impressive, but so far, so good.
1. The Legacy Cast Hasn't Missed A Step
Though the legacy cast have appeared only intermittently so far, it's safe to say that they slip effortlessly back into their roles. Thankfully, most of the principal original cast members have aged incredibly well, so there's little need to wince at how badly the actors have let themselves go (and Andy's balloon gut is played steadily for laughs).
Kyle MacLachlan leads the cast, of course, with a fantastic reprise of Cooper (and others) that takes the character to fascinating new places, while the likes of Andy, Lucy, Hawk, Bobby and Laura and Leland Palmer feel like natural continuations from the last time we saw them.
Even several characters whose actors are sadly no longer with us, such as The Log Lady (Catherine E. Coulson) and Agent Rosenfeld (Miguel Ferrer), make appearances, ensuring that The Return feels like one of the most mind-bogglingly complete TV revivals of all time. And a huge chunk of the original cast hasn't even shown up yet.
What do you make of Twin Peaks: The Return so far? Shout it out in the comments!