The Walking Dead: 5 Reasons You're Better Off Reading The Comic

Walking Dead Banner Even before AMC's The Walking Dead premiered in Halloween 2010, there was already a huge amount of hype. The reason for this was simple €“ the show was an adaptation of a hugely popular Image comic-book series written by Robert Kirkman. It was the huge fanbase of the comic book series and positive word of mouth to those unfamiliar with its pages which stoked the anticipation fires and made people clamour for the on-screen version of Rick Grimes' struggles against the undead. Yet for better or worse, we got a series which was somewhat different to its literary forebear. Adapting a comic book into a TV show allows certain liberties to be taken with characters and plot, which is cool. Just to be clear, I'm not hating on TV TWD completely €“ while it's been inconsistent, there are moments where the show really picks up and surprises me with some impressive episodes. Characters who aren't even in the comic like Daryl and Merle Dixon are some of the best parts of the TV show and continue to make it worth watching. So if The Walking Dead is your favorite TV show, then that's great, more power to you. It's better than some of the other current TV shows out there and when it's good, it's really good. But unless they've taken the time to research around the show's origins, many new Walking Dead fans won't know about the fantastic post-apocalyptic source material from which the series took its name, and frankly that's a shame. It's frustrating to know there are people out there who are turned off to The Walking Dead in other forms after watching the TV show, because they're depriving themselves of something brilliant. It's the same feeling you get where people say they've seen the Harry Potter movies, but they haven't so much as skimmed a few pages of Prisoner of Azkaban. Frankly, these guys are missing out on something brilliant €“ the original black-and-white series can offer the full-fat awesome survivor vs. zombie moments the show only gives us in diet form, so with this in mind, I'm going to tell you why you should drop the TV control and head down your comic store immediately. WARNING: There will be spoilers.

5. It's The Original, Critically-Acclaimed Story

Walking Dead Comic

In the ten years since the debut issue of the TWD comic book, the series has brought about favorable reviews from comic and critics alike. In the three years since the TV TWD premiered on AMC, it has yielded huge ratings and a whole new fan base for Rick Grimes and co. while also receiving a fair amount of criticism concerning pacing and overall character behavior. Creating a television series from the comic was a great step for TWD to reach a new audience, but when comparing the comic and the show, the original story depicted in the comic still holds up better than the first season of TWD. Any film or TV adaptation can be accused of being inferior to the source material. However, when you think about it, the huge following of TWD's comic was a big part of why AMC bothered to produce a big-budget zombie drama in the first place. Just by reading the first two or three volumes of the graphic novels you can see what made the story of Atlanta survivors fighting off zombies and corrupt human nature so addictive. If you're only familiar with characters like Rick, Shane,Lori, Andrea and The Governor through the show, then you'll be shocked to see how they behaved in the comic. Any type of adaptation is bound to contain a certain amount of artistic liberty that allows the plot to differentiate from the plot of the source material. Despite this, many of the TV show's most memorable moments and seasonal plots are taken directly from the comic. The television show has done a decent job translating the majority of the the comic's story and characters onto the television screen, but if you're tired of spending forty minutes an episode waiting for something to happen, you can instead read TWD comic and burn through expertly-crafted plot development in half the time it takes you to get through a season of the slowly-paced TV series.

4. More Creative Freedom And Possibilities

The Walking Dead Comic

Since the conception of publishing imprints like Vertigo and Image, comic creators have been able to create work with content meant for mature readers. Characters could say "F**k" and the plot could depict graphic violence and sex whenever convenient. These mature comics have essentially become the graphic novel equivalent of works produced by the likes of HBO or Showtime. While AMC does provide amazing special effects with the decaying walkers and offers great moments of zombies getting their heads caved in, it still falls under the blockades of network censorship. Because the TWD comic is rated for mature readers, censorship is unnecessary and the decapitations, swearing, and sexual themes are unashamedly present. On a live action television show there are also financial concerns to consider, which can be a burden for production.With the TWD show on a channel like AMC, there is bound to be a large budget set to create the world the audience watches. As seasons pass and the story introduces more characters, settings and zombies, the budget for the show may see an substantial increase as well. Budget concerns are very unlikely in the production of a comic book so there would rarely be any problem with budget restraints diverting the direction of the story. For the TWD comic, the series has the advantage of being, well, a comic book, and is only limited by what artist Charlie Adlard can draw. A cheap point in comparing two different genres of storytelling but it still provides evidence why there is more potential for story developments in the comic than there are in the TWD show. We're three-and-a-half seasons into the TWD television series and so far each season has been restrained by the setting the Atlanta survivors have stumbled upon. Whether it was the Atlanta camp, Hershel's Farm, the Prison or Woodbury, there was always a closed radius to how we were seeing the larger picture and how the zombie outbreak was affecting the environment beyond our protagonists. Robert Kirkman wrote the comic to delve deeper into the world he had created by having Rick and Company run into the other survivor communities and exploring how the zombie-infected world can bring out the best or the very worst in someone. To be fair, the show has had moments of peeking into the lives of survivors outside the Atlanta group but unfortunately it is in a way that feels disjointed from everything else.

3. Countless Volumes of Proven Awesome Are Already Available

We Are The Walking Dead Before AMC produced the television series, many people like myself originally became familiar with The Walking Dead by binge-reading the graphic novels that were available. For many fans, the moment you finished the first volume and Shane had already been shot in the neck by Carl instead of lingering around for another volume, you knew that this was more than just a another human vs. zombie epidemic story. In the Walking Dead comic, even the most uneventful issues are still written well and leave you satisfied. Granted, with over a hundred issues already printed, the quality of The Walking Dead comic is bound to have its frustrating moments here and there €“ story structure can get repetitious, but it's easy to overlook that as there have already been around 10 volumes of incredible story packed with enough destruction and drama to leave any reader satisfied. The pacing of the graphic novels are very quick in the first several volumes, and while it does slow down later on and sharp-eyed readers will notice slight repetition in the plot here and there, when the comic is amazing, it is really amazing. If you love books that mess around with you're expectations of who will live in a similar vein to "A Song Of Ice and Fire", then you will love Robert Kirkman's zombie saga. Plus, the best part is that after you've finished reading an enormous climactic moment, you don't have to wait months to find out what happened afterwards. Unless you're up to date on the most recent issue, you can just pick up the next volume and pick up where you left Rick and Company. It's a perfect addition for anyone into collecting graphic novels.

2. Characters & Relationships Are Much Better/Tolerable

The Walking Dead Lori

Did you know that dialogue between Rick and Lori doesn't have to be awful, even after he knows that she cheated on him with Shane? Would you believe that Andrea and Dale of all people were actually a romantic couple for a long time? Would you believe that Lori Grimes is actually, a sympathetic and competent character who keeps track of where her son in a zombie apocalypse world? Regardless of these improvements, all the characters in the Walking Dead comic are flawed €“ some more than others €“ but all their actions and behaviors were explored properly with realistic ramifications ensuing from these decisions. One of the television series' major flaws is that the characters who are annoying REALLY stand out and makes for poor chemistry between the rest of an ensemble cast. I don't know if it's the actor's fault in how they portray the character or the screenwriters' fault for trying to create foils to other characters but ended up writing them as obnoxious. Whatever it is that causes the irritating personalities of these characters, whether it be forced love affairs or lacking common sense, it plays a large part in frustrating an audience and proving the comic's superiority. I could spend all day writing about how insufferable the TV Lori Grimes was, and how once she was killed off her annoying personality was transferred to Andrea. I could talk about how Rick's inner struggle in choosing to be dictator, cop, or farmer has become more drawn out than it should have been. I could even mention the parade of characters who weren't lucky enough to have their characters developed and instead amounted to nothing more than zombie chow. Remember the impact characters like T-Dog, Hershel's farm crew and the prison inmates had on the show? No? That's because they were about as memorable as that time you watched a snail move. Surprisingly, the television show proved that original characters to the show aren't a bad thing by introducing the likes of the Dixon brothers, Merle and Daryl. Originally one dimensional red-neck racists, Daryl's character growth has made him a fan favorite and the return and character arc of Merle was one of the best parts of Season 3. However, even fan-favorite characters cannot carry an entire show filled with frustrating protagonists. To the show's credit, it did begin to introduce characters who were actually from the comic like Tyreese, Michonne and The Governor, which in turn increased the quality of the show. However, even a great character like The Governor has faltered in the show €“ in the comics he is much, much, more despicable and irredeemable while on the television show even though they played the seasonal-villain-shtick straight when he first appeared, and he's since gone though an unoriginal failed redemption storyline before biting the dust. This doesn't happen on the page €“ the extent Kirkman will go to to have the antagonistic characters demonstrate their viciousness will make any zombie herd on the show look like a herd of puppies.

1. Consistency

She's whispering ideas for season 4 Frank Darabont's term as show-runner brought two seasons of gripping zombie terror that was muddled by one dimensional characters stuck in their environment. Glenn Mazzara's reign imbued the first half of season 3 with a renewed enthusiasm and set up new threats, only to see them fizzle out in the second half of the season. With Scott Gimple as the new show-runner, so far the pacing has slowed down to a crawl, making the first half of the season feel like padding until the mid-season finale. Even the recent mid-season finale, while action packed, was basically about how the third season should have ended. Now eight episodes too late, the climactic episode has opened up new possibilities for where the characters will go now, but left the demise of a big-time character like The Governor feel underwhelming. With all of the highs and lows the show has experienced over the past three and a half seasons, the change in show runners is impossible to ignore and clearly affects the format of the show. For over one hundred issues, Robert Kirkman has been the writer for the TWD comic series, and he's got no plans of stopping anytime soon. Some comics change up the writers after a certain number of issues but because TWD comic is creator-owned, Kirkman has remained its sole writer. The characters and setting change fairly often in the comic but it feels natural, as the personality of characters and overall style remain constant throughout the series. Even the most brutal and discomforting character deaths feel like it's all part of the plan Kirkman laid out in issue one. A work of fiction like The Walking Dead needs consistency. Without it, there can be a noticeable change in direction that will be evident to the viewer and will feel out of place in comparison to how the show started. While Darabont and Mazzara had their problems, they did have impressive moments of making the show work. It's a big deal if the show runner on a popular show is dismissed and replaced but for it to happen twice now is perplexing. On the other side of the coin/medium, you will most likely never hear news that Image has fired and replaced Robert Kirkman as writer of The Walking Dead comic. The Walking Dead television series may eventually may someday find stability with Scott Gimple, but his current work on the show leaves little to be impressed about. On the other hand Kirkman continues to surprise readers with where he takes what's left of his cast in trying to find sanctuary in an undead world. The Walking Dead comic series is a fantastic read and continues to impress fans today. Anyone who has the slightest interest in The Walking Dead or zombie fiction should pick up the first trade paperback. You won't be disappointed by the better quality of story offered on the page.

Contributor
Contributor

Freelance writer and podcaster from Long Island,New York. Recent college graduate with a BA in Writing. Movie-buff who continues to write his own screenplays and has a passion for Quentin Tarantino movies, Doctor Who, and Radiohead. Loves to write, all about getting the exposure online and finding ways to tell his story.