1 Up & 6 Downs From WWE NXT UK (13 May)
Meiko Satomura advances, Noam Dar runs through Nathan Frazer, SUBCULTURE arrives.
Last night's NXT UK wasn't good.
What's surprisingly, really, is that every match on last night's show was actually good in its own way. Noam Dar and Nathan Frazer's show-opening Heritage Cup Rules match was a banger, as we'll touch upon at the end. The other two matches - Mark Andrews vs. Levi Muri, and the five-woman Women's Championship number one contender's gauntlet match - were also fine contests in terms of what they offered from an in-ring perspective.
It was the booking that held them back. Andrews, who was debuting his new SUBCULTURE schtick on the episode alongside Flash Morgan Webster and Dani Luna, shouldn't have been made to look like an incapable grappler against the perennial jobber that is Levi Muir. As for the gauntlet match - where does your writer even begin? Again, a solid match, but it simply couldn't be an Up because of how it played out.
Elsewhere on the show, Pretty Deadly spoke of their NXT UK Tag Team Championships win over Gallus despite it occurring three months ago, Sam Gradwell got into it with Trent Seven at the UK Performance Center, and Sid Scala sat down with A-Kid and Tyler Bate before their Heritage Cup Championship match next week.
Let's get to it...
Downs...
6. Daddy's Home
Sam Gradwell has been surprisingly enjoyable throughout this entire Trent Seven story arc. He’s rarely been able to have a genuine stand out moment, despite being with NXT UK from the announcement of the inaugural United Kingdom Championship Tournament. That said, this was dire.
‘The Thunderstorm’ confronted Trent Seven as he was consoling Jack Starz at the UK Performance Center; a minor Down for this alone. Gradwell reiterated that he too is a founding father of NXT UK, before mocking Seven for playing the overbearing father act, always getting himself involved in everyone else’s business.
Although he made some fair points, this was entirely weak stuff. Having a go at your rival for offering support is never going to hit the right spot. There simply isn’t enough fire in such a story. Seven’s single slap to Gradwell did absolutely nothing to help proceedings.
A Johnny Moss appearance to help separate the two popped your writer, anyway.
5. Experience Matters, Apparently
Watch the intense confrontation between the #NXTUK Heritage Cup Champion @AKidWrestler and his challenger before they collide next week! pic.twitter.com/E0Y7XvARsG
— NXT UK (@NXTUK) May 13, 2021
NXT UK’s usage of sit-down interviews ahead of marquee title matches rarely fail to stand out. A-Kid and Tyler Bate’s take on he segment was no different.
Joined by assistant general manager Sid Scala, the Heritage Cup’s champion and challenger did a whole lot of talking without actually saying anything. A-Kid noted how the Heritage Cup gives him a story to tell himself to get through hard times in his life, which was a WWE line if there ever was one, while Bate stated that the cup was made for him.
You see, the Moustache Mountain man isn’t chasing A-Kid, nor is he chasing the Heritage Cup Championship. He’s in his own lane, a lane that the Spaniard simply can’t see. But, right now, isn’t that lane heading in the direction of A-Kid? Bate wasn’t making a single bit of sense here.
Instead, ‘The Big Strong Boi’ spoke of his experience and the marquee matches he’s had in NXT UK. Because of this, he’s going to become the new champion. Experience always wins, except, it doesn’t. A dire skit that is sure to be saved by the third excellent outing between the pair next Thursday.
4. Pretty And Deadly
The dapper @SamStokerPD & @LewisHowleyPD reflect on their rise to the #NXTUK #TagTeamTitles and look forward to the future! pic.twitter.com/7XUaNKZGiz
— NXT UK (@NXTUK) May 13, 2021
To avoid any confusion, your writer adores Pretty Deadly. They’re a class act who are legitimately a step above the NXT UK roster, not only in their fashion style, but their in-ring style also. Every match of theirs is a joy to watch because they’re utilising some genuine innovation throughout.
Their promos, however, aren’t quite as innovative.
Sam Stoker and Lewis Howley spoke about how they came into NXT UK as a pair of unknowns, but they always knew they’d be Tag Team Champions one day. Their ending of Gallus’ record-breaking reign began their own reign of dominance. Cool story lads; it would have helped if they could do it cleanly, though. A DDT onto a title belt shouldn’t be what ends such an important title reign, even more so if the new champions are intended to be some rising prospects.
Again, Pretty Deadly are incredible and a true asset to NXT UK. We’ve heard this same promo time and time again, though. They need to change this up before they become stale. A good tag team shouldn’t rely solely on their in-ring offerings.
3. Andrews Falls To Pieces
Mark Andrews vs. Levi Muir was a technically sound match. Muir overpowered Andrews on numerous occasions simply because he had the strength to do so. Andrews, meanwhile, showed a tad more ferocity in his strikes.
Why is it a Down then? Because this was supposed to be the rebirthing of Andrews in his new SUBCULTURE faction. Instead, it felt more like Mark was merely overcoming Muir because he got lucky.
Levi had far, far too much offence in this one, and even though his uppercut and Torture Rack were both fine executions of the manoeuvres, they had no place in the match. Andrews fought like he was the jobber of the contest, rather than dominating Levi throughout. His Fall To Pieces shooting star press was gorgeous; not enough to save his performance, though.
The whole SUBCULTURE group feels a tad iffy thus far. This was the first time any of the three members had actually wrestled since forming the group, yet, Flash Morgan Webster and Dani Luna refrained from staying at ringside. Sure, Luna had a gauntlet match to prepare for, but Webster easily could have stayed. Minor gripes, but everything adds together when it comes to the repackaging of a character(s).
2. Build One, Bury Two
The Women’s Championship contendership gauntlet match was a weird one.
Johnny Saint and Sid Scala worked to find a replacement for the injured Xia Brookside rather than saving themselves a job by placing Amale in there. The order of entry for the participants didn’t make sense either; favourite to win Emilia McKenzie entered second, while surprise entrant Meiko Satomura came in fourth, rather than entering last for the ultimate surprise reaction. This meant that she and Jinny were the final two, two ladies who have already had Women’s Championship opportunities, rather than someone who hasn’t.
Your writer’s biggest gripe with the bout, however, was that the creative team fought they could get away with wasting Emilia McKenzie and Dani Luna here, so long as they did something of note with Isla Dawn. As enjoyable as it was to see Dawn succeed for a bit, she had no right doing so against two others who needed building.
Like with the Mark Andrews situation, Luna has just formed SUBCULTURE. She shouldn’t have been eliminated without getting at least one elimination herself. McKenzie, meanwhile, shouldn’t have been losing full stop. She’s been built up as the one to end Kay Lee Ray’s title reign, yet she was the first one eliminated.
Seriously questionable booking.
1. Who Needs New Stars?
So, that gauntlet match was supposed to find someone who had a chance of ending Kay Lee Ray’s dominant reign as NXT UK Women’s Champion. Surely this then meant it was going to be someone who hadn’t already had a crack at ‘The Forever Champion’? You know, someone like Emilia McKenzie, who’s still a newcomer to NXT UK?
Nope. It’s Meiko Satomura.
Now, this is no blight on Satomura as she’s a credible talent, but she was literally the most recent challenger for KLR. She shouldn’t have been in the match, let alone winning it. You can say all the good things you like about her performances vs. Isla Dawn and Jinny in the closing stages of the bout, but nothing can warrant her victory.
Keep in mind that NXT brands are intended to be about WWE’s future stars, and then question why Satomura – a 41-year-old – is about to challenge for the Women’s Championship for the second time before the likes of Emilia McKenzie, Isla Dawn, and Dani Luna – all in their twenties – have had even one opportunity.
Kay Lee Ray vs. Meiko Satomura II will be an epic for sure, but that’s far removed from the point right now.
Ups...
1. Nova Rollin' On
Noam Dar and Nathan Frazer’s opener was a hot bit of business. While a critic could easily say that all Heritage Cup Rules contests are one in the same, this one was a tad different.
It was crucial that Frazer got the first fall, but it was arguably more crucial that he gained it through a cheeky rollup. He’s the plucky underdog; he shouldn’t be winning the first fall with his finishing frog splash, especially not in the first fall anyway.
By having Nathan pick up the first fall, it set up the perfect trajectory for the remainder of the bout. Noam had to bite back. That he picked up the final two falls was enough to warrant this an Up as it told a decent story throughout the match, but it’s the way he executed this.
‘The Scottish Supernova’ was put off by losing the first fall to the point he demanded Sha Samuels come out to his corner. His in-ring style was entirely vicious; a genuinely jaw-shivering uppercut could have gained a pinfall in itself. The interference of Sha towards the end of the bout wasn’t needed with regards to the match, but it was needed to develop the characters of the Pinky Party lads. This was a hoot.