10 Abandoned Wrestling Gimmicks That Would Have Been Awesome

Hey, I'm not telling you anything you don't already know...

Sean OHaire
WWE

Every so often, the creative team at WWE throws a gimmick at its viewers that is so mind-bendingly terrible that we have to wonder if the writers completely loathe the guy they've decided to put into that centaur costume.

There's certainly no shortage of awful WWE gimmicks from over the years, and we can only assume there are even worse character ideas that were scrapped before they ever appeared on television (just imagine the level of atrocious those had to reach).

Yet, considering how bad Vince McMahon's track record has been with diagnosing the validity of any given persona, one might assume that he's probably passed on some pretty great ideas, too.

And you would be correct. It turns out the WWE's ineptness for developing gimmicks goes both ways, as they occasionally let a perfectly good character slip through the cracks without giving it the chance it deserves to shine and, you know, get over.

Some of these were very briefly tested in front of audiences, while others never actually moved beyond the brainstorming stage. But rest assured, each and every one of them is ten times better than Bastion Booger or Repo Man every were...

10. Dan Severn In The Ministry Of Darkness

Dan Severn 666
WWE.com

"The Beast" Dan Severn had a short career in the WWE during a time when it was all the rage to bring in UFC fighters to make the product look more "realistic".

He and Ken Shamrock feuded for a while, with Owen Hart eventually being thrown into the mix. Severn's matches may not have been classics, but at least they were different enough to be interesting.

The main problem with Severn is that he didn't really have a distinct character. At a time when WWE was boiling over with attitude, Severn was presented as an ill-defined bad !*$%. 

He didn't really cut promos, he didn't have a bold personality, and even his ring attire looks like it was designed specifically to be as boring as possible.

To fix this lack of characterization, WWE creative wanted to make him a member of Undertaker's Ministry of Darkness stable. According to Severn, they approached him with the idea of "tattooing" 666 - the mark of the beast - on his forehead and becoming a disciple of The Dead Man.

Imagine someone as forceful as Severn joining the ranks of The Ministry. Hell, he could have been the third Acolyte!

Apparently, this was too much for his small town mentality to take, and Severn refused to do the angle on account of locals possibly disowning him went he went back home.


9. Seven

Seven WCW.jpg
WWE Network

Even though the man portraying the character wasn't a big fan of the gimmick - according to his worked shoot during Seven's debut, anyway - there's no doubt that this character at least had some potential.

Granted, this was WCW during the Vince Russo era, so Dustin Runnels was probably right to have reservations about where this storyline might have led, but it was sinister and dark enough to have worked.

Reportedly based off a group of mysterious characters in the movie Dark City known as "The Strangers", Seven possessed mind powers that could allow him change people's personalities and replace their memories. And while that sounds pretty out there on paper, it's not as if modern WWE gimmicks haven't effectively portrayed brainwashing. 

Vignettes showed him standing outside of a child's bedroom and touching hands with the boy through the window, beckoning him to "come to me and live forever". The boy then turned to the camera and revealed black demon eyes. 

It was equal parts creepy and intriguing, but Turner Standards and Practices thought it invited too many comparisons to a child abductor and pulled the plug on the idea. 

This ultimately led to the aforementioned worked shoot where Runnels compared the character to Uncle Fester, thus burying the gimmick on camera and ensuring that it wouldn't be brought back. 


8. JTG's Split Personality

JTG WWE.jpg
WWE.com

Despite the frequently racist storylines JTG and Shad Gaspard were put in, Cryme Tyme managed to be pretty damn entertaining in the ring most weeks. 

Though their talent outweighed their gimmick tenfold, it at least got the job done. But according to JTG, he had a much more engaging gimmick lined up for himself.

While participating in "promo classes" that Vince would have with some of the wrestlers before shows, JTG was called on to give a promo based on a random word. 

He ended up cutting the promo with a split personality, talking to himself as much as to the camera. Vince evidently loved the idea, and they began developing the gimmick a little more.

JTG named the "second" character Self and came up with an idea to create a Muppet type of thing that looked exactly like him, and use that puppet as the vessel for his other personality. And only JTG and the fans could see and hear Self.

So if he was talking to a fellow superstar on camera, they would have no idea the Muppet was in the room.

JTG believed Self "was kind of like my conscience". It's certainly a unique idea that would have provided some thoroughly entertaining backstage antics, but apparently Vince got cold feet on the idea after the whole puppet thing was brought up. 


7. Aloisia

Vickie Guerrero Aloisia NXT.jpg
WWE

At 6' 9", there wouldn't have been a more physically intimidating contestant on the third season of NXT than Aloisia. 

Unfortunately, due to some backstage shenanigans - possibly the leak of some racy photos online - she was let go before the show's premiere, explained away in kayfabe as the result of an argument she had with Vickie Guerrero.

Lindsay Kay Hayward, who was built like a brick house and could leg-press 700 pounds, had far and away the most unique look of any female wrestler from the last decade.

She had the ability to become the next Chyna, perhaps even bigger. On the indie circuit, she was known as Isis the Amazon, and spent most of her time competently wrestling against men.

Though her skills were more than a little rough around the edges, she was being trained by Jimmy Snuka for her entry into NXT, and surely would have worked out some of those kinks with "The Superfly" at her side.

Imagine if she and Kharma had been on the program at the same time...

 Speaking of which...


6. Kharma

Kharma WWE.jpg
WWE.com

There was nothing but hope for Kia Stevens when she debuted in WWE as Kharma. 

She ran roughshod over TNA as Awesome Kong, and thanks to some delightfully weird introductory vignettes that featured her dismembering barbie dolls and cackling maniacally - an allusion to what she intended to do to the Divas division - fans were feverishly anticipating her debut.

Even without the clout she'd built up in TNA, there was a desire from true wrestling fans to see a more physically imposing woman on the roster to revitalize the division. And since Aloisia was no longer a possibility, Kharma seemed the most likely savior.

But due to the various circumstances of life, Kharma never got much of a debut. Aside from the vignettes, she only ever made appearances interrupting matches and attacking various divas. 

Because, as it turns out, Kharma had the "misfortune" of getting pregnant just as she was starting her initial push.

And when she returned almost a year later as a surprise entrant in the Royal Rumble, the writing was already on the wall that Kharma would likely be parting ways with the company permanently. 

And so another bright spot on the women's roster was out the door.


5. Mr. Kenney As Vince McMahon's Illegitimate Son

Vince McMahon Mr. Kennedy
WWE.com

Mr. Kennedy will forever remain one of the biggest 'What Ifs' in the history of WWE. 

There was so damn much potential in that character, and in Ken Anderson's abilities on the mic and in the ring, that you can't help but wonder where he might be if he was still with the company.

Though one other 'What If' involving Mr. Kennedy has a much more predictable outcome. 

Back in 2007, during the ill-fated "death" of Mr. McMahon, plans were put in place to proceed with a whodunnit, which ultimately implicated his wife, Linda, as the murderer, and put the ownership of the WWE in the hands of his illegitimate son, Mr. Kennedy.

In this version of the gimmick, Mr. Kennedy would have been naturally elevated to a top heel spot in the company, since he could now basically grant himself title shots on a whim and mess with everyone in his own specific, off-color way. 

Plans were to get him involved in a feud with Triple H and Stephanie McMahon, win the WWE Championship, and then reintroduce his not-dead father, Vince, back into the fold, revealing it had all been faked.

Some of the specifics may be a bit shaky, but there's no doubt this would have been ten thousand times better than the version of the gimmick/storyline we actually got with Hornswoggle.


4. Owen Hart As The Game

Owen Hart Triple H WrestleMania 14
WWE.com

It's unfortunate that Owen Hart's final run with the WWE found him running around in a mask and cape, demanding to be called The Blue Blazer. 

It's not that it was a horrible gimmick - it was meant to be silly and showcase more of Owen's humorous side while also paying homage to his first go-round with the company in the late 80s - it's just not a fitting way for someone with his talent to go out.

But had the tragic events of Over the Edge not occurred, Owen was being primed for a much more intense gimmick, one worthy of his in-ring abilities and talent on the microphone. It seems Owen was set to transform himself into "The Game".

Yes, the very same Game gimmick that permanently boosted Triple H out of the mid-card and into our lives with rambling, long-winded promos that you have to believe would have been one thousand times better had they been written and delivered by Owen Hart.

Owen would have told the world that he wasn't just "the best in the game" - perhaps a subtle dig at his on-again/off-again relationship with his brother, Bret - but that he "is the game". 

We obviously don't know if the moniker and gimmick change would have turned Owen into the superstar it made Triple H, but it would have been nice to see it play out anyway.


3. Raven's Seven Deadly Sins

Raven WWE
WWE.com

A lot of good men were lost in the Invasion. It was a weird time to be in the WWE, particularly if you didn't want to be just another WCW leftover jobbing to one of Vince's boys, which is exactly the position Raven found himself in.

In 2001, he'd lost a match which stipulated he'd be banished from Raw, and as a result, spent the majority of his time slumming it on Heat. In desperate need of a re-branding, Raven suggested using the Seven Deadly Sins motif. 

Essentially, Raven was to start searching out the sins on the WWE roster, and making those sinners pay, showing their warts to the world.

He would've gone after jobbers initially, building up the idea in non-feud matches, calling guys out for their Gluttony or Sloth before dismantling them in the ring. Then he would lose an "I Quit" match to a mid-carder - presumably falling victim to his own Pride - and briefly disappearing.

But the angle would have returned with vengeance in a feud with Matt Hardy, where Raven videotaped him going to a seedy hotel with a woman who wasn't his then-girlfriend Lita. 

The broad idea was to have Lita leave Matt, the Lustful, for Raven, the Envious. It's unclear how long the Seven Deadly Sins gimmick would have lasted after that feud, though Raven said he wanted to draw the whole thing out for about six months, which was simply too long for WWE.


2. Vade Hansen

Vade Hansen
WWE.com

Straining to find a new adversary for The Undertaker, Smackdown writer Michael Hayes came up with the risky proposition to bring in developmental talent Hade Vansen and position him in a lengthy feud with The Dead Man.

They aired a mysterious vignette on an episode of Smackdown, featuring the unnamed character talking about punishing The Undertaker with "righteousness and purity" and threatening to take his immortal power and realize "his prophecy". 

Vansen was going to have some followers, as well, in Kevin Thorn and masked wrestler Black Pain.

Basically, Vansen's character was going to be a mix of Bray Wyatt's dark, cult figure and Mordecai's religious extremist (which would later be taken up by Thorn). 

Imagine that going against The Undertaker, complete with his very own pseudo-Ministry of Darkness.

But it seems Hayes jumped the gun in developing the storyline, though, and when Vince McMahon examined the concept a bit more closely, he decided Hayes was out of his mind and promptly ditched the angle - and Vansen's character- entirely.


1. The Devil's Advocate

Sean O'Haire Devil's Advocate
WWE.com

Another casualty of the Invasion storyline, Sean O'Haire was brought into the company and continued his pairing with Chuck Palumbo. The two were packaged together in such a way that they immediately became the most milquetoast tag team on the roster.

After their brief and mostly fruitless team endeavors, Palumbo was kicked out of the alliance and joined the WWE proper, while O'Haire was sent down to OVW for development. 

When he returned, O'Haire debuted his new gimmick as 'The Devil's Advocate'.

In a series of vignettes that featured him with long hair, a goatee, and a sweet duster jacket, O'Haire began prompting the audience - along with his fellow WWE superstars - to do all of the things society has deemed immoral or taboo. 

Adultery will make your relationship stronger, he told us, because "you'll appreciate your wife more". Taxation is a scam, he said, and you shouldn't bother because "the IRS doesn't have time to go after a little guy like you". And drugs? "You just need to take a step back from reality. Tip one back. Light one up". 

He also persuaded Spank to streak and Dawn Marie to flash the crowd.

He was awesome. 

But in yet another case of a conceptual gimmick failing to capture Vince's imagination, O'Haire was all but stripped of the characteristics that made him so interesting in the first place, paired with Roddy Piper for some odd reason, and then shelved once Piper was released.


In this post: 
Sean O'Haire
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor

Jacob is a part-time contributor for WhatCulture, specializing in music, movies, and really, really dumb humor.