10 Absolute Worst Gimmicks In WWE Right Now

A good character can strap a rocket to your career. But any of these will send it plummeting.

Akira Tozawa
WWE

Being a great pro-wrestler once the bell rings is a hell of a skill. Some wrestlers have gotten pretty far just on wrestling ability alone. Sometimes, a decent wrestler can be elevated to so much more by working the mic like an absolute pro.

One key ingredient that is absolutely necessary to getting over in the crazy world of professional wrestling is having the right gimmick.

Instantly, when you hear the word gimmick, your mind races to the most absurd ones. Doink the Clown, Goldust, The Godfather, The Undertaker and so on. But a gimmick doesn't have to go to extreme lengths for it to work. Look at the likes of Stone Cold Steve Austin, one of the greatest of all time, and his gimmick was a beer guzzling, trash talking redneck who didn't back down from anything. Bret Hart was obsessed with being the best wrestler of all time.

The list of subtle gimmicks goes on and currently in the WWE, there are some fantastic gimmicks. Roman Reigns' 'Tribal Chief' has been a roaring success and even the likes of Happy Corbin have been a refreshing change of pace for a stale character.

A good gimmick can elevate an average performer. A bad gimmick can sink the best. And boy, there are plenty of bad ones...

10. Akira Tozawa

Akira Tozawa 24/7 Title
WWE

How is this still a thing?

Look, during the Pandemic Era, WWE threw a lot of crap against the wall in the faint hope of entertainment. It was commendable that they wanted to keep us entertained, although their slapdash safety guidelines meant it was clearly more profit-driven.

You could almost hear Vince McMahon yelling 'THE SHOW MUST GO ON, DAMNIT!'

One such slap of sludge was during the bizarre cinematic match between the Street Profits and the Viking Raiders (oh, we'll get to them) at Backlash in June 2020. Considering they were ultimately consumed by a bin monster, that wasn't the most offensive part of the ridiculous match.

That was reserved for Akira Tozawa, who decided to turn up in said match, driving a motorcycle and dressed as a ninja. Surrounded by other motorcycle riding ninjas, including a pre-AJ Styles Omos, it was one of the most racist gimmicks they could have conjured up. Because Tozawa is Japanese, that instantly made him a ninja.

In 2020, you expect better from WWE, but Tozawa has kept the gimmick in his constant attempts to win the 24/7 Championship. One can only imagine he wishes he had been eaten by that shark.


9. Mace

Mace Creepy WWE Fan ThunderDome
WWE

What even is a Mace?

When we try to analyse this gimmick, we need to have some sympathy for the poor guy saddled with it.

As Dio Maddin, he was inexplicably promoted to a commentary role on RAW and was slammed through the announcer's table courtesy of an F5 from Brock Lesnar. Then, as a young wrestler trying to make his way in WWE, he is offered the chance to join a new, rebellious faction known as RETRIBUTION.

But holy hell did WWE not just mess RETRIBUTION up, but they have done considerable damage to the careers of those associated with it. As a complete wet fart of a unit, their split didn't even make a main show. It was a sorry state of affairs.

Mace is very green in the ring, and although he removed his mask, continuing on with the silly name and working with T-Bar as an ineffective tag team has rendered him a joke. Recently traded to Smackdown! as a solo star, his promo claiming he was going to annihilate the roster was laughable. It's not really his fault, he isn't ready for the role, but my god, this gimmick sucks.

(T-BAR has been missed off this list because as Dominik Dijakovic, he is at least salvageable.)


8. Keith 'Bearcat' Lee

Keith Lee
WWE.com

How do you get Keith Lee wrong?

Seriously? You would have to actively try to mess things up to get such a special talent, one who defies his look and breaks the mould, one that has limitless (pun intended) charisma and a natural connection with the crowd.

But they have. Well done, Vince McMahon.

Despite stripping him of some of his identity when Lee was promoted to the main roster, the big man still had enough about him to make an impact. Smooth on the mic and still hard-hitting in the ring, things got off to an okay start despite fifty-fifty booking.

But what the hell is this 'Bearcat' nonsense?

Yes, it's a tribute to the legendary Bearcat Wright, but where has this come from? Suddenly, a man who is well known to the fans due to his dominance in NXT, has decided he is now Keith 'Bearcat' Lee, and he has some scary scratch marks on his singlet. Cool.

We've had no follow up since his return, no explanation for why he has suddenly decided to ditch his own identity and continue the legacy of another wrestler. We don't even know why he has turned heel, for goodness sake.

We just want our Keith Lee back!


7. Eva Marie

Eva Marie
WWE.com

Is there a more pointless wrestler than Eva Marie?

That may sound harsh, but during her first run with WWE, Marie's gimmick was that she clearly couldn't wrestle and she kept finding ways to dodge actually getting into the ring. It was irritating, didn't get over and she was released.

In a time when Vince McMahon and his gaggle of yes men couldn't find space on the roster for the likes of Ruby Riott, Mickie James and the IIconics, they thought enticing Eva Marie back was a good idea. Maybe she had improved and actually developed a basic understanding of how to wrestle. We've seen it before.

So Eva returned... to do the exact same thing all over again.

If it was vaguely entertaining, then maybe it would get a pass, but there cannot be anyone out there who A) finds any of Eva's rivalry entertaining and B) thinks she deserves a spot on the roster above those previously mentioned released wrestlers.

When she isn't trying to avoid wrestling in a WRESTLING company, she is banging in about the Eva-lution, without any evidence that that is anything other than a play on words.

Then you realise what she looks like and the reason for Vince hiring her back is obvious.


6. Mustafa Ali

Mustafa Ali RETRIBUTION
WWE

This is a sad entry.

One of the most wonderful, organic moments in recent WWE history was the rise of Kofi-mania. It was such a wonderful story, of the WWE Universe banding behind a mid-card stalwart, who had always been on the cusp of breaking through and grabbing one of those famous brass rings.

Kofi's rise to the WWE Championship was one of the most faith-affirming moments in recent memory but it came at a cost. Unfortunately, that cost was Mustafa Ali's career.

A wildly talented performer who has a great look, good promo skills, a genuine likeable backstory and killer entrance gear, Ali was the originally planned rival for Daniel Bryan heading into WrestleMania 35.

But what since then? Another wrestler tainted by the stench of RETRIBUTION, there has been zero comeuppance for the man who tried to bring down the WWE system. Once his goons turned on him, he just floated around in backstage segments and has recently been involved in a strange mentor role with Mansoor like he is some grizzled veteran. It just doesn't suit him.

Also, why would Mansoor want Ali's advice? The man's career has spiralled and his whole gimmick is saying cliched nonsense to the rookie about not trusting people. That's it.

Unless, of course, he was talking about WWE creative?


5. The Viking Raiders

The Viking Raiders WWE SmackDown
WWE

They're Vikings.

As War Machine on the independent scene and the less cool, War Raiders in NXT, Hanson and Rowe were one of the best tag teams in the business. Considering we are in a peak time for tag teams, WWE excluded obviously, that is pretty good going.

Both men are incredibly agile for their size, they seem to mesh with any style of opponent, and they put on some of the best tag team matches in NXT's recent memory.

But they're Vikings.

In the eyes of Vinnie Mac, that was enough. Not two big, burly dudes who enjoyed the Viking aesthetic. No, no, no. That's too subtle and so these two hard bastards ended up becoming ACTUAL Vikings. In 2021. It's laughable.

From debuting on the main roster with the worst name of all time, The Viking Experience, which made them seem like a crummy museum attraction, the two men were given more appropriate Viking names in Erik and Ivar.

They do Viking things and don't understand the current world and it's just rubbish. It's such a shame, too, as in a company that has ground tag team wrestling into the dirt, they could be pillars of the division. Instead, they are a lower card novelty act with as much credibility as their cosplay.


4. Alexa Bliss

Alexa Bliss Lilly
WWE

Speaking of rubbish...

Alexa Bliss' descent into the spooky, Fiend inspired gimmick has been problematic from the start. Originally, tying her into the story between Bray Wyatt and Braun Strowman was a rare moment of WWE having their finger on the pulse. Bliss's chemistry with Braun in the Mixed Match Challenge was great and for a long time, fans had wished her into the Sister Abigail role.

But then it just went to hell.

Bliss went from being slightly obsessed with The Fiend, to becoming a full-on sorceress. With the ability to teleport, control minds and spew black goo on command, this entire thing became nonsense way before the WWE basically binned Wyatt off and transposed his once successful gimmick onto her.

Alexa's Playground is a poor substitute for the Firefly Fun House, and despite her best efforts, Bliss just doesn't have the chops to play the role in anything approaching convincing. Weaving in a nonsensical, sentient doll into the act has been the most Wrestlecrap thing WWE had done in years and that's saying something.

Worst of all, her entire depiction is problematic, as she dressed provocatively but essentially acts like a child. It's just very uncomfortable.

Thankfully, fans have rejected the gimmick since they have returned and we can only hope that when Bliss returns from her current hiatus, she is back to something resembling her old, normal self.


3. Drew McIntyre

Drew McIntyre
WWE

Remember in the middle of the pandemic when Drew McIntyre was the coolest guy in the company and carrying the company on his broad shoulders as a likeable champion? Pepperidge Farm remembers.

Drew McIntyre needs a gimmick change. Shunting him over to Smackdown! to feud with Roman Reigns isn't going to save the man from the fans turning on him. In fact, it will only speed it up as despite being a heel, the 'Tribal Chief' is beloved for his awesome character work.

Unfortunately, WWE has let McIntyre down.

When they first introduced the sword into McIntyre's entrance, it was a cool visual, but slowly and oh so surely, they have made it his prominent feature. Tag that onto boring fans senseless with nonsensical promos about Scottish history and they turned one of the coolest babyfaces they had into a man we wanted to go away.

Fans rejected McIntyre at Money in the Bank when they returned, and there have been desperate attempts to get the crowd on his side with his dull feud with Jinder Mahal.

The man is now just there, whining about getting title shots and not coming across as likeable in any way at all.

Think back to Reigns vs Drew in 2020. Now think about current Drew in the same spot and it's sadly what the next few months of Smackdown! will be.


2. Doudrop

Doudrop Eva Marie
WWE.com

What's in a name?

That famous Shakespearean line from Romeo & Juliet will stand the test of time, however, this writer has the answer. If the name is Doudrop, then it contains a career-killing gimmick before the career has even begun.

To be honest, Doudrop is on this list because her name is Doudrop. Someone in the back, most likely Vince McMahon, took one look at Piper Niven and thought... Doudrop. A fully grown woman, who is actually very good in the ring and has a different look to the rest of the roster.

Doudrop.

We know that Vince McMahon likes a certain kind of aesthetic for his women wrestlers (we already covered Eva Marie's baffling employment) and it doesn't take a genius to know he most likely gave her that name because he thinks bigger people are comic relief. Usually, if he sees value in a performer of a certain ilk, he usually throws them in a shameful t-shirt or full length outfit ala Kevin Owens or Nia Jax.

But not Doudrop.

She hasn't been booked particularly well, has been fed garbage to say on the mic, and let's face it, will never get over with such an awful name. The whole gimmick needs scrapping and Piper Niven deserves a chance of actually getting over.

Doudrop. Jesus Christ.


1. Karrion Kross

Karrion Kross
WWE

And the obvious choice goes to... weird gimp man.

Karrion Kross may not be the most exciting wrestler when the bell goes, but NXT did a damn good job of making him seem like a dominant force and a dangerous man. Those early, close up promos and the eerie sand timers created a sense of impending doom and he was fed some of the biggest names on the brand to build his credibility.

Then, with the NXT Title slapped around his waist, he walked out on RAW without the usual pomp and pagentry and looked like generic jobber number two. Then, he was beaten swiftly by Jeff Hardy.

It was a disaster and the WWE creative machine needed to come up with something big to save what seemed like a main roster sure thing. Maybe they could bring back Scarlett and give him the massive entrance? Perhaps have him cut an ominous promo and then batter someone with credibility.

Or, send him out dressed like a literal gimp, complete with leather straps that stay on during the match and a goofy mask. There is sh*tting the bed and then there is this. The man is a busted flush already and although they are trying to have him inherit the beloved Sean O'Haire gimmick from seventeen years ago, it feels like too little, too late.

Kross could have made a splash on the main roster, but all he has done is make a splat. A hilarious, Shockmaster-esque splat.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Akira Tozawa
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

A wrestling fan for over two decades, a proud father of an awesome little girl. Am also an international best selling independent author of mindless action novels!