10 AEW Wrestlers You Won’t Believe WWE Passed On

The AEW roster would look A LOT different today if WWE chose to sign these terrific talents.

MJF AEW
AEW

WWE has been renowned over the years for passing on some superb talents.

Only recently it was reported they chose not to sign ROH World Champion RUSH, believing he was asking for too much money, even though he’s regarded as having a huge upside and could be moulded into one of their premier Superstars.

It took years for WWE to even consider signing talent that made their names and reputations elsewhere on the independent scene like Samoa Joe, CM Punk and Daniel Bryan. Vince McMahon even reportedly went as far as telling AJ Styles "I wish I would have hired you ten years ago" after he excelled in every match and angle the company put him in when they eventually did sign him in 2016.

Thankfully NXT, the brainchild of Triple H’s vision for the future of the company, has been a Trojan Horse of sorts in the last decade for getting ‘indie darlings’ into the WWE system and fine-tuning them for the main roster.

But even with NXT, WWE has missed massive opportunities in signing these talents that have thrived in their main competitor AEW.


10. Wardlow

Wardlow AEW
AEW

AEW was on the lookout for some monstrous and dominant wrestlers to fill out its roster when it was being formed in 2019. So Britt Baker recommended Wardlow visit the pro-wrestling training facility The Nightmare Factory, where Cody Rhodes first took note of him and got him signed with AEW.

Since then, Wardlow has shined as MJF’s personal bodyguard, with many hoping they can replicate the same breakout success Diesel and Shawn Michaels had together in the WWF in the mid-90s. And AEW are keenly aware of this, with Wardlow regularly having an intimidating presence on TV where he’s protected in storylines and angles.

But before AEW, Wardlow had his sights set on WWE. He had an official tryout with the company but amazingly WWE didn’t follow through on hiring him. Standing 6'3 and weighing 270 lbs, with his athleticism and sharply dressed attire, it’s a shock WWE passed on him. Wardlow has spoken on how he believes WWE officials were far more concerned with recruiting ex-NFL athletes and college wrestlers at the time, even though they had little to no experience, and weren’t even fans of wrestling.

Wardlow spoke of his tryout on the AEW Unrestricted podcast:

“So I smoked that tryout, I’m like, ‘I have this in the bag.’ And so much so, I literally sold my motorcycle, sold my house. Literally got rid of everything, because I’m like, ‘I’m gonna put everything into moving into Florida and starting.’ So when the email came in that I was not, man I remember I actually had to pull over on the side of the road. Because I just couldn’t believe it.”

9. Sammy Guevara

Sammy Guevara Blood & Guts
AEW

Sammy Guevara has flourished and stood out in AEW as a member of The Inner Circle for matches that regularly attract 3-4 stars in the Wrestling Observer, as well as for noteworthy angles like crushing Darby Allin's throat with a skateboard and hilariously being run over by a golf kart in the middle of a street fight.

Considering his young age at 27, you can only expect him to get better in the ring and outside of it, and be a major player for AEW in the future. His work has even led to praise from Randy Orton, who openly spoke on how he wanted to one day work with him.

Prior to AEW, Sammy competed in a few dark matches for WWE. He wrestled Primo & Epico as The Los Matadores at one point, which the referee of the bout according to Sammy went out of his way to call “the greatest dark match he has ever seen.” His performance led to praise from Mark Henry backstage and a proper tryout for WWE with other recruits in front of influential personnel like William Regal and Norman Smiley.

But Sammy has spoken in recent years how the whole experience put him off signing with WWE, commenting on Talk is Jericho:

“I don’t think any wrestler got signed. I think a collegiate wrestler got signed. It felt that if you want to do this for a living f**k you, but these models, ex-football players they treated them really good and almost shame on you for actually wanting to be a wrestler. It seemed like when the cameras were on they really played it up. It felt like a whole gimmick to me because everyone was chill until the cameras were on and suddenly they start drilling and yelling at you. I’m like, alright, I see what this is. It definitely opened up my eyes because I wouldn’t want to be there, maybe not ever, but certainly not now just because of the way they treated me. Maybe it’s different now, I don’t know, but during that time I saw that unless I was a somebody it’s going to be hell here.”

8. The Young Bucks

The Young Bucks
AEW

The Young Bucks are among the most acclaimed talents to never once sign WWE contracts. They had the drive and work ethic to become multi-millionaires without Vince McMahon’s chequebook through merchandising and stellar performances whenever and wherever they would compete.

But the Bucks careers and the wrestling landscape would be a whole lot different had WWE hired them when they tried out for the company in 2008 and 2011. They had tryouts in front of numerous WWE agents, but didn’t impress them enough to offer the team contracts. They weren’t interested in signing independent standouts at the time like they are today, with WWE’s developmental system being radically different than it was in 2008 and 2011.

There was also the issue of them generating a lot of heat for famously not shaking hands with the rest of the locker room before their tryout, as well as a confrontation with Booker T for Nick Jackson leaning on Booker’s jacket in the locker room.

They’ve since made amends with Booker, with Nick telling him on his Heated Conversations podcast about the incident and the tryouts:

“I’ll say it right now, being back there at that stage in our career, it’s like walking on eggshells. You don’t know who to say ‘hi’ to. You don’t know if you’re disrespecting anyone, so we were just trying to be out of the way and with us trying to be out of the way, we ended up not being out of the way because I was the one who was accidentally leaning on your jacket, but I had no clue that I was. And when you came up to me, I was so intimidated and scared to death! I was like, ‘Oh no! What did I do?'”

7. Penelope Ford

Penelope Ford
AEW

WWE announced in late 2018 the most recent crop of athletes trying out for the company at the Performance Centre. Amongst the class was former UFC fighter Eric Spicely, 2nd generation talent Cal Bloom, and many more indie hopefuls trying to made it to the big leagues.

But it was Penelope Ford who garnered the most attention online for trying out in the class. She was even heavily promoted by WWE themselves online for being there, stemming from the hype she amassed competing in CZW, CHIKARA and many other promotions, as well as her recent showing against Jazz at NWA’s 70th Anniversary Show.

Unlike others in the class, WWE chose to not go any further with Penelope, which is odd given her natural charisma, passion for the business and background in gymnastics. She in the end showed them it was their loss though. Only months later she signed with AEW and regularly demonstrated her awesome talents on episodes of Dynamite and Dark, managing her real-life partner Kip Sabian and competing in sensational matches with Riho and Hikaru Shida.


6. Britt Baker

Britt Baker
AEW

Britt Baker had made a name for herself in AEW as one of the best female talents in all of pro wrestling. Her unsanctioned "Lights Out" match against Thunder Rosa on Dynamite was a classic where she undertook a huge amount of punishment on her body, and who can forget the sight of her bloodily smiling to the camera with a broken nose in her match with Hikaru Shida?

Britt tried out for WWE before AEW came to fruition, to potentially join her real-life partner Adam Cole in NXT. She went as far as being involved in a squash match with Nia Jax on Raw and being part of the second annual Mae Young Classic. But when undergoing an official tryout with WWE, her training to be a practising dentist outside of the ring actually stopped her from getting signed.

Britt commented on Talk is Jericho:

"I'll never forget at the very end of the camp, Canyon Ceman pulled me aside. If you're an independent wrestler, Canyon Ceman is the gatekeeper. He is, 'You shall not pass or come on in to the WWE.' And he told me, he was like, 'You really impressed a lot of people at this tryout.' I was like, so excited, so excited. But he said, 'As a father, I have a really hard time pulling someone from a professional degree for this business.' And my heart just sank. So a couple of weeks later I got an email from him saying, 'You have a lot of the qualities we look for, however we don't have an opportunity for you at this time, but if you have the passion to succeed in this, you'll find a way to make this work throughout dental school.' And I never forgot that. Didn't work out for WWE but it worked out to my advantage even better because I'm able to do both careers (in AEW). I'm a dentist and a professional wrestler on TV."

Although as we all know it didn’t stop Baker from accidentally cameoing on NXT TV (when the camera zoomed in on her concerned face at NXT Takeover: War Games after Adam Cole took that huge bump through the table from the top of the cage).


5. Jungle Boy

Jungle Boy
AEW

Being the son of TV icon Luke Perry, you would think WWE would snap up Jack ‘Jungle Boy’ Perry to a contract. They love publicity by association, after all, having previously signed David Otunga to a contract partially to be associated with megastar/his then-fiancée Jennifer Hudson.

But Jungle Boy’s 5’10 and 150-pound frame prevented WWE from taking him seriously, regardless of his unique look and a lifelong passion for the business (look as far back as SummerSlam 2009 and he’s shown with his Dad in the crowd). He spoke to The Young Bucks on their Wrestlers On The Road Ordering Room Service show about the tryout he had with WWE and how it didn’t go in his favour:

“I did some extra work. And they basically told me, they were like, ‘Look, if you put on 30 lbs or whatever, we will give you a job, but the way it is, it’s not going to happen.’ And I was just so bummed. I was like, ‘It bums me out that that’s the one thing that it gets hung up on because I know what I can do and I can do a bunch of stuff, but I think there are a bunch of guys who are way bigger than me who are not nearly as good and it’s silly to me to get so hung up on that.'”

Thankfully it worked out for Jungle Boy in All Elite Wrestling, where he has the freedom he never would have found in WWE with his Jurassic Express trio with Luchasaurus and Marko Stunt. He’s gone as far as speaking publicly on how AEW helped him cope with his father’s passing too, saying he could use the promotion as an outlet and focus all of his energy on bettering himself in the ring.


4. MJF

MJF smirk
AEW

MJF surprisingly once auditioned for WWE’s reality series Tough Enough, with WWE even uploading his audition tape to its YouTube page which has garnered over 300k views. It was for the 2016 class which featured stellar talents like Chelsea Green, Sonya Deville, Mandy Rose and Velveteen Dream trying to get noticed by WWE executives.

In the one minute video, MJF exuded the confidence that is quickly promoting him to be a headline star in AEW. He goes so far as calling Triple H ‘Trip’, and states with conviction “The question isn’t, if I’m Tough Enough, no. The question is, are you smart enough to know when the future of your company is looking at you dead in the face?”

He might not have been wrong. Maxwell Jacob Friedman’s only getting better with age and experience, and has recently expressed whilst AEW runs deep in him, he’ll go with the promotion where the most money is being offered.

You can only think with his undeniable charisma, if he was the same height and build as Randy Orton, they would have taken far more notice of his audition tape.


3. Eddie Kingston

Eddie Kingston
AEW

It took years of grinding and hard work for Eddie Kingston to get noticed by a national wrestling organisation with AEW.

After 18 years clawing away in too many promotions to name, Kingston revealed he broke down crying when AEW finally offered him a contract. And with every opportunity AEW has given him, he’s knocked it out of the park. From his match with Cody on Dynamite for the AEW TNT Championship to his savage feud with Jon Moxley to regularly cutting raw and honest promos you wouldn’t hear from anyone else.

WWE had been interested at different points over the years in bringing Kingston in as a coach to help teach developmental talents. But he always rejected the opportunity, believing he would have resented the talent he was coaching who were getting the shot he so desperately wanted in the industry.

In 2016, Kingston actually got his shot to officially try out with WWE but it didn’t go as well as he would have liked, being slotted in with women trying out for the upcoming Mae Young Classic.

He told Renee Paquette on her Oral Sessions podcast:

"To me, that tryout was more for the Mae Young Classic because it was the biggest class for females. I just went in and had fun. I said a couple of things. I'll give you the one I like the most. They had someone filming and (referee) Drake Younger grabbed me out of nowhere and was like, 'King, tell them how hard this drill is.' It was some dumb drill. 'Yeah, it was hard. I've had people shoot at me, try to stab me with knives. I hate this drill more than that.' Put the camera down and everyone looks at me like I'm nuts because I said guns and knives. I was doing the promo class and I said, 'Where I come from, they believe in 2Pac more than Santa Claus.' I saw two writers have this confused look on their face. I was like, 'I'm done. Lemme have my match and I'll leave.'"

2. Powerhouse Hobbs

Powerhouse Hobbs
AEW

Powerhouse Hobbs has featured weekly on Dynamite since hugely impressing Tony Khan in the 21-man Casino Battle Royale at the All Out pay-per-view. His showing in the Battle Royale quickly scored him a contract with AEW, as well as an alliance with Taz.

Before AEW, Hobbs was doing everything he could to get WWE to consider hiring him. He impressed in a dark match against Baron Corbin before an episode of SmackDown that earned him an official tryout. During it, he caught the attention of William Regal when cutting a promo from the heart about his real-life background.

For whatever reason WWE didn’t take it any further and it took two whole months afterwards for Hobbs to receive a rejection email from the company, stating they had nothing for him at that time. He did some extra work with WWE afterwards whenever they toured his hometown but they never seriously considered offering him a deal until he appeared on AEW television.

Hobbs spoke of the experience on the AEW Unrestricted Podcast:

“The try-out was good. Well, that was a long story, but I’ll give you the short story. They said we didn’t have anything for you right now, and then just years later, getting the carrot dangling in front of me, I pretty much told them FU. Right when I appeared up on AEW, ‘Hey, remember me?’ The way I was raised, I don’t got time for that s**t. I’m not ‘boo boo the fool’ as my Grandma would say. ‘Hey, we’ve been thinking about you and are interested in you.’ No, f**k you. I ain’t no sucka. I’d rather you tell me 100% no than try to BS me.

1. Ricky Starks

Ricky Starks AEW Dynamite
AEW

Ricky Starks continues to impress for AEW. His match with Darby Allin on Dynamite last September was outstanding and his heel persona gets more compelling each week as part of Team Taz, with Cody Rhodes tweeting he believes Ricky will one day become champion for the promotion.

Before AEW, though, he was trying to rile up enough attention for WWE to take notice of his talent and potential, having enhancement matches for them with the likes of Jinder Mahal, Ryback, The Revival and even against Kane on Main Event. All of this work earned him an official tryout with WWE.

He spoke on the experience when interviewed by Chris Van Vliet:

“I don't think I was close at all and I'll never understand why. I love wrestling. I've never played any sports, I never did anything, I only watched wrestling. And I have immersed myself and become obsessed with it and I love it to death. So when I did the tryout in 2017 and I was told and saw the reaction when I killed it in the promo class and I was keeping up with everybody when we were doing the workouts and even Matt Bloom was saying how good of a job I did, I realized that they didn't want a wrestler. They wanted someone who wasn't passionate about it that they could probably make into it. And I still don't get why and that was a time period where I kind of went crazy; I dyed my hair and I couldn't figure out what was wrong with me. So I don't know why that happened and I thought every time that I went to WWE I was like 'This is going to be it. This is how I get in' and it wasn't and that's fine. I'm ok with that.

Starks has a similar story to most AEW talents who once tried out with WWE and then debuted for AEW, mentioning how not long after he answered Cody's open challenge for the AEW TNT Championship on Dynamite, he got a call from WWE brass wanting to bring him in. But it was too late, Starks was snapped up by AEW. Starks commented on WWE only wanting him when they couldn’t have him “I really think they dropped the ball majorly on that. I’ll never know why and I guess I don’t care now.”


Watch Next


In this post: 
AEW
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

Rex Jones hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.