10 Amazing Wrestling Villains Hidden In Plain Sight

This dastardly lot were edging towards the dark side right under your nose...

MJF Cody
AEW

There's nothing quite like the feeling of being genuinely stunned at the reveal of a wrestling character being a genuine a-hole villain all along.

Now, a wrestler choosing to take a walk on the dark side can sometimes be spotted a mile away, with various obvious hints and anything but subtle suggestions of some evil within ultimately setting the stage for a knife to be inevitably plunged into the back of a beloved babyface.

And that's what makes those times when a crowd are legitimately caught off-guard by a sudden and seemingly out of nowhere fall into darkness so damn captivating.

But when it comes to the following collection of personalities who surprisingly opted for a change of attitude, said landscape-changing decisions were actually very much being secretly foreshadowed and teased in plain sight - sometimes even for months!

Quietly loaded lines that told you there and then what a one-time hero was willing to do to succeed, Cameo videos giving you a cheeky glimpse at the dominant big bad to come, and many a tantrum being largely overlooked are just a few ways these glorious eventual villains hid right under your nose.

10. Steve Austin Needs To Beat The Rock

Steve Austin The Rock
WWE.com

Coming into what would go down in history as perhaps the greatest WrestleMania of all time, the two biggest stars WWE had ever seen sat down with good ol' Jim Ross to talk about their incoming WWE Championship main event epic.

'Stone Cold' Steve Austin was clearly desperate to reclaim a title he hadn't held for nearly two years. And with a colder look than usual in his pale blue eyes, the 'Texas Rattlesnake' told his long-time rival that he didn't just want to beat him on a personal level, he needed to beat The Rock on a professional one more than the 'Great One' could ever imagine.

Sure enough, that need to do whatever it took to walk out of the Astrodome on top resulted in Austin making a deal with another long-time nemesis by the name of Mr. McMahon, one which saw him blast Rocky with a chair on his way to finally taking the title back.

Now sure, your mileage may vary on the divisive run that followed this unquestionably surprising turn of events. But there's no doubting that many enjoyed seeing the anti-hero finally being given a chance to flex his heel muscles at the top of the card.

And it all started back when a determined Austin told Rocky to his face exactly what that belt meant to him.


9. Sting Somehow Doesn't Realise The Nature Boy's Knife Is On Its Way

Halloween Havoc 1995
WWE Network

When you go by the name of the 'Dirtiest Player in the Game', expecting anything other than a knife to the back at some point down the road would be foolish.

But when WCW's 'Icon' Sting went out of his way to note how he felt the star was finally on the straight and narrow heading into Halloween Havoc 1995, even those who were initially screaming at that silly 'Stinger' for daring to trust Flair were given a reason to believe in the 'Nature Boy'.

Flair had been jumped by Arn Anderson on the first-ever Nitro. And when both Arn and Brian Pillman once again attacked 'Naytch' on the night of the PPV, fans were led to believe that Flair would simply have no reason to turn his back on the partner helping him fight off those heels in their scheduled match.

In the end, though, this was all an elaborate scheme designed to catch Sting off-guard at the event. Flair eventually returned to help his apparent pal, only to swiftly beat the hell out of him after making the hot tag.

Folks had refused to trust the despicable Flair for weeks before the two eventually agreed to tag at Halloween Havoc. And it was right when fans were fooled into thinking this leopard could change his spots that the reunited Horsemen's plot finally brought down an 'Icon'.


8. A Cameo Teases The Tribal Chief's Incoming Reign Of Dominance

WWE Payback 2020 Roman Reigns Braun Strowman
WWE.com

Finally being afforded the opportunity to fully lean into the boos right when there wasn't a single soul in attendance to fire hate at the face of the company, Roman Reigns' heelish return to WWE in August 2020 kicked off one of the most fascinating arcs in modern wrestling history.

But far from being a completely out of left field change-up, though, the 'Tribal Chief' had actually been subtly hinting at this change of attitude before and during his time away from the spotlight.

As the two were initially building towards a clash at WrestleMania 36, a visibly more arrogant and entitled Reigns let Universal Champion Goldberg know that the "b*tch bulldog" was holding his title.

Jump forward a few months, and a cheeky Cameo sent from Fightful founder Jimmy Van to Sean Ross Sapp brought with it yet another hint at the 'Head of the Table' heel turn to come, with a deliciously cocky Reigns claiming that when he does return and destroys everyone, the fans were going to be upset.

Sure enough, that's exactly what went down just a few weeks later - well, the first part at least - as the dominant villain set about conquering both Braun Strowman and Bray Wyatt at Payback, picking up a World title that he's still yet to drop.


7. A Fed Up Bret Hart Had Been Threatening To Fully Snap For Months Before 'Mania 13

Bret Hart Vince McMahon
WWE.com

WrestleMania 13 will forever be remembered as the night two legends pulled off the mother of all double-turns.

In truth, though, Bret Hart could've likely snapped on a number of occasions in the lead-up to the 'Showcase of the Immortals'.

Back at that year's Royal Rumble, the 'Hitman' was within touching distance of winning his second over-the-top-rope epic, only for 'Stone Cold' Steve Austin to sneak back into the contest, after his elimination was missed by officials, and dump his rival out of the ring for the shocking victory.

And even when Hart managed to somehow get his hands on the WWE Championship as the 'Show of Shows' edged closer, various folks intervening with his matches against Sid in the coming weeks all led to the icon unleashing an explosive worked-shoot promo on WWE management and Vince McMahon on the Raw before 'Mania.

This emotional babyface had been threatening to turn his back on both the company and the fans who had been happily watching him get screwed out of the gold for months. And by the time the dust had settled on 'Mania 13, a fed up villain was finally ready to give up trying to please an American audience who would rather cheer on 'Rattlesnakes' and 'pretty boys'.


6. MJF Doesn't Shy Away From Being A Massive D*ck As Cody Rhodes' Mate

MJF Cody
Scott Lesh

He's better at fooling you into thinking he's your pal, and you know it.

Despite establishing pretty early into his time in AEW that he definitely wasn't a bloke to be trusted, regularly proving himself to be quite the a-hole when left alone with the likes of the Elite, Frankie Kazarian, and Brandi Rhodes, the fact MJF opted to take out the Inner Circle when offered the chance to take down Cody Rhodes on Dynamite back in October 2019 suggested there was still light in this w*nker.

In the weeks that came before Full Gear, Maxwell Jacob Friedman regularly backed up his apparent best mate, too, convincing both Cody and folks all around the world that he could be relied on to support the 'American Nightmare' in the biggest match of his career.

But this was all part of the plan to finally bring down a "mentor" he classed as a "user and abuser" who was trying to turn Maxwell into his own personal puppet.

In the end, the 'Salt of the Earth' cost Cody his chance to ever challenge for the AEW World Championship again under the guise of trying to protect Rhodes from being snapped in half by Chris Jericho via white towel, sealing the villainous switch with a despicable boot to the Nightmare Factory.


5. Dominik's Hints Of Petulance Plant Judgment Seeds

WWE SummerSlam 2022 Edge Rey Dominik Mysterio
WWE.com

The sound that met Dominik Mysterio's pulverising of Edge's b*ll*cks and decapitating of his father at Clash at the Castle suggested that this jaw-dropping trip to the Other Side came out of nowhere.

But Dom-Dom had very much been showing flickers of petulance and frustration for some time before opting to join the Judgment Day in Cardiff.

In the wake of being offered the chance to join Finn Balor, Damian Priest and Rhea Ripley back in July, the seed planted by those purple villains, suggesting that Dom-Dom would forever remain in his daddy's shadow if he chose to remain by his side, ultimately led to the young Mysterio clashing with Edge.

And even after seemingly getting over being accidentally speared by the Hall of Famer, his subtle softening towards Ripley in particular during the CATC go-home Raw acted as another little hint at the swapping of sides on the horizon.

The fact Mysterio teamed with Edge, and not his son, against the heel group in Wales seemed to be the last straw for Dom-Dom as the lad finally snapped post-match and took out both his father and another one-time mentor.

Ever since he made his in-ring debut at SummerSlam 2020, all this bratty future mega heel ever wanted was for his deadbeat dad to get to know him. But Rey-Rey was more concerned with showing his son the ropes than helping him be his own man.


4. Trish Stratus Smiles Through The Disrespect

Lita Becky Lynch Trish Stratus
WWE.com

While it may sometimes feel like Becky Lynch and Trish Stratus have been warring for an eternity at this point, the pair did very much appear to be on the same page on the Road to WrestleMania 39.

In fact, the WWE Hall of Famer was even on hand to help Lynch and Lita win tag gold back in February.

But a closer look at those celebrations, and much of the time the trio spent on-screen in the aftermath, eventually told the story of a veteran who felt entirely disrespected by 'The Man' in particular.

Whenever Lynch and fellow tag-champ Lita were spotted lifting their belts up high, Stratus was never too far away, grinning through the pain of never being thanked by the WrestleMania main eventer for paving the way.

Stratus simply wanted to keep an enemy who claimed that the women's revolution started with the Four Horsewomen close.

And so she spent the next few months acting as a sidekick of sorts, waiting for the right moment to strike Lynch at her weakest.

That moment finally came after taking out Lita before the pair's title defence on Raw back in April, with Stratus then spending the subsequent months having the time of her life demanding both fans and her Irish nemesis to thank her for being, in her obnoxious words, "the single most important figure in the history of WWE."


3. CM Punk Had Been Tired Of Being Overlooked For Too Long

CM Punk The Rock Raw 1000
WWE.com

"The fact that Dwayne is in the main event of WrestleMania next year, and I'm not, makes me sick!"

Even at the height of his 'Voice of the Voiceless' anti-hero fame, a certain 'Chick Magnet' was evidently fed up with part-timers stealing his chance to close out the biggest show of the year.

It didn't matter that the 'Best in the World' was the reigning WWE Champion heading into 'Mania XXVIII, Dwayne and John Cena were still guaranteed their main event spot. And that frustration was unquestionably simmering from the day he unleashed that iconic pipebomb to the moment he shocked the world with a heel turn at Raw 1000 a year down the road.

Rocky had boldly claimed that he would be facing whoever held the WWE title at the Royal Rumble early in the night because... well, he was the 'Great One' and that's what great ones get to do.

Tired of having the attention stolen away from him by golden boys like Rocky and Cena, though, Punk opted to finally wipe out the 'People's Champion' after his bout with the latter was brought to an end thanks to the Big Show's intervention.

Punk let folks know a whole year earlier that he was done being overshadowed.

This was merely him resorting to new methods to ensure the person holding the WWE Championship was given the respect and attention they deserve.


2. Don Callis Subtly Grooms His New Meal Ticket

Don Callis Konosuke Takeshita
AEW

Alongside the aforementioned Dom-Dom, there isn't a person appearing on weekly television generating quite the same level of genuine vitriol and hatred from an audience than the walking piece of crap known as Don Callis.

His screwing over of former pal/meal-ticket Kenny Omega during the closing stages of the 'Cleaner's steel cage fight with Jon Moxley reminded the world what kind of selfish and loathsome acts the 'Invisible Hand' was capable of when the right opportunity arose.

And the fact this definitely wasn't a spur-of-the-moment decision only made the horrendous betrayal even worse.

Callis, while pretending to very much still be committed to all things Elite alongside the far less dastardly trio, had been going out of his way to groom the super talented Konosuke Takeshita for months in the lead-up to Double or Nothing 2023.

The bald a-hole offered his services to the star of tomorrow backstage, never missed a moment to praise the lad on Twitter, and even welcomed the sensation to Winnipeg with some Japanese drums.

Sensing that Kenny may not be the same Omega he was pre-injury lay-off, Callis was blatantly eyeing up his next golden brother/goose to profit from and putting his Don Callis Family pieces in place long before Takeshita's Zahi connected with his former pal's mug.


1. Cody Rhodes Stabs Bob Holly In The Back To Join Ted DiBiase Jr

Cody Rhodes Hardcore Holly Ted Dibiase
WWE

He may rank as the undisputed top babyface in WWE at this current moment in time, but the 'American Nightmare' wasn't always a fiercely loyal hero of the people. Hell, less than a year into his first WWE run, Rhodes actually helped pull off one of the finest heel swerves of the late 2000s.

The future AEW EVP had eventually formed a team with Hardcore Holly after the two feuded and Rhodes ultimately earned the respect of the abrasive veteran. A World Tag Team Championship run would follow, only for the partners to find themselves being challenged to a match by another wrestler with the business in his blood: Ted DiBiase Jr.

That confident newcomer claimed he would only reveal his mystery partner for the teams' title fight at Night of Champions 2008. But in a move that just about nobody saw coming, his heel teammate was none other than Cody himself, with the two youngsters turning the contest into a handicap bout as they walked out with the straps.

Just like that, every subtle knowing look shared between the eventual Legacy boys before the fateful match now sat as evidence of the two's devious plan heading into the PPV.

That "baby boomer" never stood a chance.


Watch Next


In this post: 
MJF
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Gareth has 6 years experience writing and presenting articles/videos covering all things professional wrestling within the fantastic WhatCulture team. Gareth is also a life long wrestling fan, so is clearly living the dream!