10 Awesome Wrestling Matches On Otherwise Terrible WWE Shows
If you think Fastlane 2023 looks a bit below-par, be grateful...
It's all but impossible for WWE to promote a terrible pay-per-view in 2023.
Triple H has developed an almost cynical failsafe formula for acclaim. Tony Khan could probably do with borrowing inspiration from his competition, to an extent. A WWE 'PLE' never outstays its welcome. It isn't an exhausting experience that all but guarantees that at least one match will almost be resented by the knackered crowd.
To ensure that a decent to excellent atmosphere is maintained throughout, Triple H tends to book his B-level events with a maximum of seven matches. He doesn't feel the need to put every key member of his roster on the show, and from a purely business standpoint, this correlates with impressive TV ratings. The big GUNTHER Intercontinental title defences are the preserve of Monday Night Raw. This detracts from the weekend experience, since GUNTHER is a top-five wrestler on the planet, but this allows a rewarding (or at least dryly intelligent) balance between TV and pay-per-view.
In keeping with Triple H's general philosophy, he doesn't pop your head off, but he has managed to avoid fatigue in the content farm era. He uses his excellent talent roster sparingly and can very easily hit a 7/10.
The days of utter dross are over, replaced by a bare minimum of solid, but even in those days, a great match saved the day...
10. Roman Reigns Vs. Braun Strowman - Fastlane 2017
Fastlane 2017 was yet another WWE pay-per-view in which Vince McMahon heard what fans wanted, and in response, sprinted all the way down to the away end with his hands behind his ears after scoring a last-minute against them. His audience!
The one time that fans didn't actually want Charlotte Flair to lose, Vince McMahon beat her, for the first time on PPV, a month before WrestleMania. Who needs huge stakes and a monumental win on the biggest show of the year?
The undercard reeked, incorporating two impromptu matches like it was some terrible, run-of-the-mill episode of Raw. Actually, the simile isn't required.
The main event was hilarious. Not exactly funny haha if you were Kevin Owens, who was squashed for the Universal title by Goldberg after a musical distraction from Chris Jericho, but on the bright side, it was this sort of b*llocks that created the conditions for AEW.
Roman Reigns Vs. Braun Strowman however was utterly fantastic. Roman, forever underrated as a babyface worker, took on the rising Strowman in an intoxicating bomb-lobber of a heavyweight sprint - the sort of magic, how-are-they-keeping-up-that-pace match that reduces you to a fist-pumping dumbass in your living room.
9. The Rock Vs. Hollywood Hogan - WrestleMania X8
WrestleMania X8 was unacceptably bad on a principal level because WWE, having monopolised the entire North American wrestling industry a year prior, boasted every resource available to them.
This informs much of the critical backlash against WWE in general: the promotion has no excuse to be terrible or even bland. WWE is more moneyed than any promotion ever.
'Mania X8 was a disaster. The main event reeked of arrogance, so much so that it would have been cathartic were it not so tedious. The idea that Triple H, babyface, could have gone last after Hulk Hogan Vs. the Rock - after yet more oppressive McMahon family melodrama in the build - underscored where everything was and where everything was headed.
The undercard was also just...dross. Which exciting former ECW or WCW star worked a feature singles match with Kurt Angle?
Why, Kane of course!
Booker T only got 6 nothing minutes with Edge. Steve Austin hadn't been less of a concern since January 1996 in a demotion against Scott Hall. The Undertaker Vs. Ric Flair was good for what it was, but virtually everything else was short, forgettable and small-fry.
Rock Vs. Hogan was pure, deafening pro wrestling magic - an expertly conducted symphony of crowd psychology highlighted by a masterful use of the space between moves - but as a referendum on the state of the company, 'Mania X8 was bleak.
8. Seth Rollins Vs. Brock Lesnar - SummerSlam 2019
SummerSlam 2019 probably wasn't actively terrible, but, again, it was unacceptably mediocre.
AEW had just launched, promising the world to its enthused audience - much of which had lost interest in WWE - and so it was really beyond time that WWE sorted itself out. The range of AEW was a huge selling point, but the intoxicating idea that the talent could become the best versions of themselves stood in bleak contrast to a very bland SummerSlam offering.
As a key example, Ricochet Vs. AJ Styles would have been exponentially more exciting in an AEW ring. In WWE's ring, it was a patterned, methodical, heavily agented gentlemen's three.
If it were possible, Kofi Kingston Vs. Randy Orton was even more of a WWE cliché of a match - a plodding, boring 17 minutes of nothing complete with a double count-out finish that functioned, as most matches back then did, as an excuse for a rematch.
The main event was a cracker, though: Seth Rollins, who had floundered as a babyface, proved that he had the skill-set in the ring, at least. Brock was on imperious form as a bully - he treated Rollins like a hapless geek plaything when swinging him around by the surgical tape wrapped around his waist - and Seth's fiery comeback was the most respectable he looked all year.
7. Daniel Bryan Vs. Kofi Kingston - WrestleMania 35
As somebody who attended WrestleMania 35 live, it was a brutal experience. The New Jersey weather frosted over as soon as the sun went in, and everybody in that stadium in effect lived through the ice age, the show went that long.
It was so unreasonably long, god damn. AEW pay-per-views are too long and this was an AEW PPV and a half at least (without the excellent action).
So many matches were just...there, playing out to no heat as around 60,000 people wondered why they were even happening. Again, the modern standard is such that something like Finn Bálor Vs. Bobby Lashley wasn't actively bad, but everybody who watched it thought the same thing: "Ah for heaven's sake. Not another one!"
Daniel Bryan Vs. Kofi Kingston however was a stone cold classic. Bryan, and this should be impossible but it was a day ending in Y, performed in character and reality as the unbeatable best wrestler ever. He crafted the match, exerting total control over Kofi, to drag the performance of a lifetime out of his opponent. Kofi, really for the first time in his career, got nasty and vicious in response. The storytelling was outstanding. Kofi had reveal his own dragon within just to survive.
He beat the hell out of Danielson, and what an intoxicating twist. He was spirited and sympathetic and then he just blew Danielson away.
Awesome, violent, earned justice that tweaked the classic underdog story to perfection.
6. The Usos Vs. Luke Harper & Erick Rowan - Battleground 2014
The post-WrestleMania XXX glow didn't take long to fade, and by July, the hopelessly naive notion that Cesaro and Daniel Bryan would launch WWE into a bold new era had evaporated.
Bryan was injured - Vince had already told him the week of New Orleans that Roman was his man for the next 10 years - while at Battleground, Cesaro made up the numbers in a battle royal held for the Intercontinental title won by the Miz, who by 2014 was as much a fiery youngster as Carlos Colon in 1993.
Oh, and John Cena won the World title in the main event to symbolise that nothing had changed.
Everything else at Battleground was either falsely advertised or just really uninspired with the exception of a white-hot opener between the Usos and Luke Harper & Erick Rowan. That Two out of Three Falls match was absolutely incredible.
Harper was on awesome form in particular. Selling the cerebral monster that WWE inexplicably refused to buy into, in one clever, wince-inducing spot, he used Jimmy Uso's momentum against him to throw him neck-first into the bottom rope. The heat sequence was vile - Rowan was trying to decapitate those poor sods with his back elbows - and the heels moved with such dynamic propulsion that it didn't seem to matter how hard the Usos fought. Their strengths were amplified in their opponents. The Usos could dive, but Harper could throw himself through the ropes like he'd cut the brakes on his truck downhill.
When they made the comeback, wow.
The series of near-falls in the third was just scintillating; the excess was thoroughly earned because look at the size of those heels. The Usos had to throw everything they had at them.
5. Bret Hart Vs. Yokozuna - WrestleMania IX
WrestleMania IX was a breezy and daft watch, pure kitsch and a minor masterclass of production - it was staged in a car park! - but it was awful, undeniably so.
The undercard wasn't without its highlights, but the two halfway good matches (Shawn Michaels Vs. Tatanka, Headshrinkers Vs. Steiners) both went too long and one had a stinker of a finish.
Attire fetishists and nostalgia apologists can have a good time with it to this day, but the matches were largely terrible, the company was in the bin, and in an impromptu main event, they gave the belt to a mercenary so disinterested, Hulk Hogan, that he made Brock Lesnar look like Dax Harwood.
Bret Hart entered a bravura performance in the main event against Yokozuna, though, in a match glowing with his intelligent approach.
He wrestled with a sense of urgency early, knowing that he had to totally overwhelm an opponent he could never out-power, exploding into Yoko with - hell yeah! - a John Woo dropkick. He sold Yoko's size when he couldn't get his arms around him and took an awesome bump to the outside off a mack truck shoulder barge. In any other context, Hart was a master in that ring; in Vegas, Yoko was so mighty that he couldn't even stay in it.
A doomed sprint in which Bret attacked his mammoth opponent at the most logical angles, using what little space existed masterfully, he drew on his immense IQ to fell the tree and would have won were it not for that dastardly Mr. Fuji.
And that knobhead Hulk Hogan, obviously.
4. Fatal 4-Way Ladder WWE Tag Team Title Ladder Match - Armageddon 2006
The mid-2000s was a dire scene.
WWE was in a bleak in-between period. They'd made John Cena, Randy Orton and Batista, but nobody else really, and were years from admitting defeat in their smug campaign against the indie scene. The Armageddon '06 midcard wasn't disastrous, merely solid, but the last two matches were a grim sign of the times.
Mr. Kennedy bombed against the Undertaker in an interminable Last Ride match, one that crystallised the issue at WWE's generic core: he, much like many of his peers, was only ever functional enough to peak at a gentlemen's three. The soulless and homogenised developmental system had produced frozen food and plagued the main roster.
Batista & John Cena Vs. Finlay & King Booker was just bizarre; at 11 minutes and with Finlay in it, it scanned as a zero stakes house show with a last-minute replacement for an injured star.
MNM Vs. London & Kendrick Vs. The Hardy Boyz Vs. William Regal & Dave Taylor was more infamous than great - it was the night on which Joey Mercury's face exploded - but it was great too. Obviously, the stunts were unhinged - and the near-misses resulting from the unreliable ladders had the crowd shaking - but the tone was more varied than the iconic TLC matches. In contrast to such an insipid wider product, this creative, demented ladder made the crowd feel things. Excitement. Bloodlust. Fear.
Even, when Dave Taylor was too afraid to climb the ladder, wry amusement.
3. The Undertaker Vs. CM Punk - WrestleMania 29
Given everything that fans know about how WWE operates and how it will always operate, and what a television wrestling star looks like, the days of "WWE should push Small Wrestler Lacking In Charisma X' seem hopelessly naive.
Still, you watch something like WrestleMania 29 and can be forgiven for thinking, you know, they should have rehired Kaval and have him win the Royal Rumble.
The show was studded with star power, but it was just so drastically uninspired. The casual audience demonstrably wanted to see the Rock and John Cena wrestle again, because the buy amount was impressive, but it felt just as much a boring obligation as the second Triple H Vs. Brock Lesnar match. That was beyond tedious and counterproductive.
WWE had to break the streak to get Lesnar over again in the aftermath, and the trademark self-indulgence - Triple H went 24 minutes, which was actually KENTA Vs. Ricky Marvin by his overbearing standards - limited the time allocated to the few hot acts, Daniel Bryan and The Shield, WWE had built or who had got over in spite of them.
CM Punk Vs. the Undertaker was a masterpiece, thank God. After a few years of epic back-and-forth matches with greyer character alignments, Punk, like his idol Roddy Piper, changed the question. He didn't make fans wonder if he could break the streak; he made them desperately want Undertaker to maintain it with phenomenal heel work.
He was such a complete, glorious d*ck in that match and, when his sh*thouse antics were foiled, he showed more ass with one facial expression than Triple H did between 2002 and 2004.
2. Kurt Angle Vs. The Undertaker Vs. The Rock - Vengeance 2002
The rot had set in by 2002.
2001 was a disaster of a year for WWE and karma put them through a barricade after they made zero effort to show ass for WCW or even rebuild it in any vaguely meaningful way.
By Vengeance, Brock Lesnar was not ready. His disqualification loss to Rob Van Dam while OK went too long and exposed his act. Edge and Hulk Hogan was a transparent attempt to get the former over as a singles player, and a loss to Christian & Lance Storm was hardly going to do it. Nor was John Cena ready, whose win over Chris Jericho was such a glorified dark match tryout that the scalp he took meant nothing.
Elsewhere, beyond a decent double-header of opening matches - and decent again was nowhere near good enough for a company that had defeated all competition - William Regal Vs. Jeff Hardy was an ugly styles clash that while short was still offensive.
Kurt Angle Vs. The Undertaker Vs. The Rock was absolutely blinding. The layout was exquisite. Angle showcased his range and negated the inherent problem with the Triple Threat genre in a two birds, one stone masterclass. First, Angle displayed his piss-funny comedic chops when Rock and 'Taker double-teamed him at the jump. Whenever he tried to re-enter the ring, he took a silly slapstick bump back out of there. This structure made fans laugh at - and not question - the turn-taking genre formula.
Deeper into a dramatic, perfectly-timed match, Angle evolved back into the intense killer wrestling machine in an electrifying composite performance.
1. Steve Austin Vs. Dude Love - Over The Edge 1998
WWF Raw was on white-hot form as a must-watch, multi-tentacled beast of an episodic TV show.
Austin Vs. McMahon was a sensation and, before it became very broad, was done very elegantly. That word somehow did belong in the context of the lite beer-soaked college campuses that the Fed played to in 1998. Every building felt like Woodstock '99, but McMahon producing saccharine vignettes putting over the WWF as a mom n' pop purveyor of gentle Americana was such great, deluded heel work.
The problem is that the WWF had to do a wrestling show every month and expect fans to pay for it, and the talent roster was mostly abysmal between the ropes (or yet to find their feet). Literally everything beneath the main event was below average. Nothing even reached passable, and Triple H ominously prophesied his main event run by going 19 excruciating minutes in an endless six-man DX Vs. Nation of Domination tag.
But what a main event, the genius of which was that it channeled the breathless twists of the TV product and fused that method of storytelling with a world-class brawl. McMahon's relentless attempts to screw over Austin were thwarted time and time again with just outrageously cathartic physical set-pieces in which obsequious old men, the sort of smug jobsworth you deal with at work every day, were blasted through tables.
Windshield spots, suplexes on concrete, a maelstrom of heat and catharsis: Eric Bischoff must have watched all that and knew he was completely knackered.