10 Awful Things Wrestling Needs To LEAVE In 2023

AEW promised "fast-paced, high-impact competitions" in 2019. In 2023, AEW did slow-mo comedy...

Dominik Mysterio boo.wav
WWE

2023 was the year in which mainstream U.S. pro wrestling underwent yet another paradigm shift.

The idea of WWE entering a period of resurgence, drawing critical acclaim and energising and growing its base was even more unfathomable, in 2018, than the emergence of a new major arena competitor. In December of that year, Vince McMahon apologised for how bad his product was, in an "if I have to..." marketing ploy, and couldn't get through the first minute of his mea culpa without putting himself over as a genius and lashing out at the audience. WWE never felt more doomed than on December 17, 2018.

Now, under the stewardship of Triple H, WWE is on fire. A fixed cast heavily featured as important star players; very long title reigns that have elevated the prestige of championships that were once worthless; characters with depth who agonise over the decision to turn: WWE can feel repetitive and basic in 2023, but Triple H is nailing the basics.

AEW meanwhile is cold, the magic has evaporated, and often feels slippery and unfocused with its convoluted approach.

While each major promotion is experiencing mixed fortunes, both are guilty of irritating turds that need flushing in 2024...

10. Dissension Within Every Stable

Imperium GUNTHER Ludwig Kaiser Giovanni Vinci
WWE.com

What tends to happen in wrestling - and this will become a recurring theme - is that, when something catches fire, everybody wants to do it, all of the time, to diminishing returns.

WWE was ablaze to a white-hot level in 2023, entering its most popular period in years. Decades.

The Bloodline saga drove this resurgence - in particular, the incredible chemistry between Roman Reigns and Sami Zayn. It was a gripping storyline, at once warming and ominous. Sami's joy at being accepted informed some lovely light material undermined, with masterful episodic tension, by Roman's manipulative behaviour.

Now, because that worked, dissension within stables became WWE's primary narrative driver. The Judgment Day became Bloodline Raw. While repetitive, this was done well enough. There was in contrast zero point to the tension within Imperium. Giovanni Vinci wasn't rendered sympathetic by being cast as the weak link. He wasn't the bullied good guy destined to break out; he was just a loser, a victim of a trend that made no sense in that context.

This trend was so default that Bobby Lashley and the Street Profits barely got on the second they formed. Most factions exist with a split in mind in the future - it's an easy, organic-feeling means of building a grudge - but the illusion of a heel group intent on taking over was barely established.

The original Four Horsemen simply kicked ass, felt like tight brothers who loved making the towns together, and sold fights with incredible promos for two years.

There are significantly worse models to follow than that.


9. AEW's Pre-Taped Skits

Adam Cole Kingdom
AEW

AEW is meant to act as the alternative to WWE.

As part of this, Tony Khan refused to utilise the impromptu match and invisible camera. He wanted to create the effect that AEW Dynamite was a sporting emulation that happened to be broadcast, and not a clearly written show operating with a flawed internal logic.

This more realistic approach is now under threat as a result of AEW's new obsession with the pre-taped skit.

Some of the Better Than You Bay-Bay "bro sessions" were amusing - the material was significantly better in the live arena, which makes its own point - but why were the cameras there?

Both MJF and Adam Cole acknowledged the existence of the camera crew, but this felt like having cake, eating cake - a thin excuse to "get away with" bending AEW's storytelling rules. Who was editing these vignettes, with their terrible slo-mo effects and music cues, and, more pertinently, why?

By the time Cole suffered an ankle injury and Roderick Strong's passive-aggressive character reached parody levels, fans were left with contrived and utterly charmless NXT-adjacent material.

What is funny about watching peanut butter being spread, slowly, on bread? What is funny about Cole and Strong playing the roles of actual children?

The worry now is that, if a character stumbles upon something funny organically - and this happened with Toni Storm - they will instantly undergo a process of Flanderisation, and AEW will butcher the charm right out of it.


8. The Word "Opportunity"

AEW Collision Ricky Starks
AEW

The ghost of Vince McMahon's AEW cannot be exorcised.

For years, WWE was broken; an anti-meritocracy in which fan support drove almost nothing in the narrative, despite pro wrestling's function as an interactive performance art. You were to like who you were told to like, but because this isn't how it works, a new vernacular evolved. As WWE cast itself as a heel promotion that only pushed its favourites, the downtrodden babyfaces started to use the word "opportunity" a lot. They just needed an "opportunity" to become stars and champions. The days of a fictional character winning matches to achieve this goal seemed long gone.

This trend persists, for some ungodly reason, in AEW. AEW is an actual meritocracy, despite various nepo babies (like QT Marshall and the Hardyz) littering Rampage. Where it matters, though, the most worthy acts are allocated the most television time.

The vernacular is normalised now, like the invisible camera and the entrance music pop. Ricky Starks is a sensational pro wrestler, better at emoting and projecting himself like a star than the vast majority of his contemporaries - but he is guilty of this off-putting meta business on occasion.

He talked a lot about being the man but not getting the chance to be the man in 2023, as if some strange, shadowy forces were holding him back. This collided with AEW's narrative philosophy more than once.

Wrestlers should play characters in a fair, fictional world. The word "opportunity" should be retired forever, not least because redemptive opportunities actually exist in AEW.

Look who Ricky's tag team partner is!


7. Piped-In Crowd Noise

Dominik Mysterio boo.wav
WWE

Everybody has their own interpretation of how fake is too fake in wrestling, which assists in making it - at times - the most tedious, repetitive and exhausting thing on the planet to talk about.

For some, the repeated use of a thrust kick ruins the sense of immersion. Why, a wrestler must be as soft as hell if they can't kick somebody in the head and keep them down!

A lot of those same people miss the days of the working punch, which is virtually the exact same thing.

There's no such thing as too fake in a form that has never once felt realistic. The joy is in the creative expression to do almost anything and generate a booming response. If people believe in the make-believe and enjoy or love to hate it, that's wrestling.

That's "people" actually present in the arena, not an uncanny recording of how people once reacted to something else.

The piped-in noise needs to go. The counter-argument is that pressing the boo button for Dominik Mysterio eventually conditioned the fans into a real reaction, but it's just...terrible. It sounds so obnoxiously fake that it's almost too insulting to the intelligence.

The core magic of wrestling, no matter which era or style one prefers, is in its ability to make fans react - lose that, and it actually does become something else entirely.


6. The Transparent Act Of Trying Too Hard

AEW Collision FTR Bullet Club Gold
AEW

Even before the star rating system was popularised by Dave Meltzer, the touring NWA World champions of yore frequently wrestled for an hour in order to give the paying fans the absolute maximum for their money. The belt was positioned as the premier, nigh-on unwinnable achievement. Going 60 minutes was necessary to that end. The idea was to depict the champion as the man who boasted the most accomplished - and compelling - technique.

Working a great match has been the goal for a long, long time, well before critical acclaim became a marketing tool (Best Bout Machine) in wrestling or an overt selling point of it ('The Greatest Wrestling Match Ever)'.

Now that acclaim is the new currency - in the era of five stars and bangers and the like - too many pro wrestlers are transparently desperate to have a great match. The homogenised, grabby tropes are growing exceptionally tiresome. The constant double downs that exist purely to generate a "This is awesome!" chant. The echo of an echo of strong style psychology with no soul.

Some wrestlers even took to summoning a standing ovation mid-match because they were consumed by the idea of people thinking they were great.

The pursuit of greatness can be great, but so many wrestling matches in 2023 were self-conscious and off-putting - and when Kenny Omega exists, a lot of other wrestlers pale in comparison.

In general, less reliance on the 12-15 minute back-and-forth would help this self-indulgence.

Let's get some sprints going.


5. Battle Of The Belts

Luchasaurus Shawn Spears
AEW

Nobody wants Battle of the Belts.

Warner obviously don't care about a brand that was originally envisioned to be a Clash of the Champions-style quarterly two-hour special. Battle of the Belts, with its gentle plagiarism via alliteration, was meant to be AEW's equivalent to the "B-level" pay-per-view.

Something happened, it was shortened, and it transformed into a throwaway one-hour "special" that nobody cares about. AEW certainly don't seem to care. Just one actual title change has happened in a shade under two years. The AEW World title - the men's one that AEW has positioned several levels above the women's - has not been defended on the show on one single occasion. The fans don't care either. Nobody has ever fantasy booked nor raved about Battle of the Belts.

Battle of the Belts has played host to such legendary clashes as Samoa Joe Vs. Tony Nese, Jonathan Gresham Vs. Dalton Castle, and the Lucha Bros. Vs. QT Marshall & Powerhouse Hobbs.

It is closer to AEW Jakked than AEW Clash of the Champions, and exists only to water the content farm and remind fans that AEW promotes far too many championships. It would be nigh-on impossible to do a bad version of the show between 2019 and 2021.

It isn't going away - it is supplemental content that is easy and inexpensive to produce - but it epitomises this new, bleak filler era of AEW.


4. AEW's Endless Indirect Subplots

FTR Convoluted
AEW

It seems like every week, an AEW programme becomes more and more convoluted with the addition of a new act or a new subplot of some sort. In 2023, AEW strayed further and further away from the "personal issues draw money" maxim.

The Don Callis Family is a prime example of this. Powerhouse Hobbs was brought into the stable because his association with QTV - as everybody who hasn't worked a day in wrestling called on day one - was a stupid idea. His explanation was riddled with holes. He said that he was once insulted by Chris Jericho as a child and held onto that rage into adulthood. Why, then, did it take him three years to unleash it?

It's not as if backstage attacks are uncommon in wrestling. They happen every week.

It was a flimsy excuse to prolong a programme that could have instead used more focus, a traditional fired-up babyface promo from Kenny Omega, who, despite his otherworldly greatness, never really sold the betrayal. The stakes were diluted to do yet more dithering, stable-based booking, the likes of which feel passé in AEW these days.

Chris Jericho brought in Paul Wight in October to combat the size of Hobbs. The idea of Wight and Sammy Guevara truly hating one another is preposterous. They're just indirectly aligned with people - Omega and Callis - who should sell their hatred of one another with more conviction. Also, Wight was cast as a weird extra guy who just hangs around and does the odd skit in 2023. He did a Captain Insano bit with the Acclaimed and was fished by Adam Cole and MJF. How is he a difference-making destroyer?!

Also: why did LFI immediately make friends with FTR just to facilitate the House of Black's fourth concurrent programme?

The degrees of separation between the Blackpool Combat Club and Best Friends and CHAOS and Ricky Starks and Big Bill and Adam Copeland and Christian Cage and Darby Allin was also just silly and messy.

Why does everything need to be so convoluted?

AEW needs to be more focused and direct with its booking in 2024.


3. Terrible Booking Of Women's Wrestling

Outcasts AEW
AEW

WWE is marginally less apathetic than AEW.

The Women's World Tag Team titles are closer to the 24/7 title than anything else in terns of prestige. Charlotte Flair's storylines are inherently flawed under WWE's insistence that she is a babyface. Often, despite the discourse, SmackDown promotes one shorter women's match than Dynamite.

Still, WWE has made a concerted effort to portray Rhea Ripley as one of the biggest stars of the show, irrespective of gender, and Becky Lynch's excursion to NXT indicated that WWE is very much focused on building the future of the division with a strong conviction. NXT itself is a growth product swarming with women's wrestling: on night 1 of Halloween Havoc, five of the seven matches were from the women's division.

AEW meanwhile continues to promote just one women's match per show with a palpable lack of passion and forethought. It seems to exist purely because "it bloody has to these days".

The stark and difficult reality is that there are stronger draws and better talent - presently! - in the AEW men's ranks. 98% of the men aren't as good as the AJW crew of the early '90s, and the women will never stand a chance with such minimal chances with which to improve and get over. The cycle is endless, beyond tiresome.

AEW is missing a trick; NXT is actually becoming competition, and look what that brand has done over the last two years...


2. Excessive Use Of Tournaments And Battle Royals

Battle Royale AEW
AEW

The abandonment of the rankings system was always going to allow lazy habits to creep in, and Tony Khan's fondness of tournaments and battle royals became a meme with which to mock him in 2023.

Battle Royals, even the best ones, are boring, messy and confusing in the first half. The excessive use of them diminishes the idea of achievement. If it's that easy to contend for a title, how important or elusive can the title be?

Beyond the Grand Slam Tournament of Champions in 2022 - and even that was a way, albeit a shrewd one, of not giving away big first-time singles meetings - has AEW ever booked a great tournament?

Khan signposts the final with his brackets every time, and pollutes the field with too many undeserving participants. He does this in order to avoid beating his big names. A lot of Tourney Khan's booking practises are designed to achieve that end.

The vast majority of mainstream US wrestling fans are millennials who have seen every version of a DQ or a distraction finish a million times, and haven't felt a damn thing for the heel 999,999 of them. The heel isn't a baddie anymore. The booker is a coward. It has been this way for years, and it is time for more clean jobs. Clean jobs forged Hangman Page's ascent to the top of the card.

The gravity of a real loss against a should - and can! - mean something. It means more than beating a washed-up Jeff Hardy - who had lost a video game tie-in match to Jeff Jarrett less than a month prior - in a quarter final.

Then again, perhaps they aren't so grown-up after all...


1. The Discourse

X LOGO
X

Imagine going to an Italian restaurant with your partner, and they ask you what you're going to eat.

"I think I fancy a pizza."

"A pizza?" they reply, tutting disapprovingly. "Hmm. That is biased against pasta."

People, even critics, cannot alter their personal tastes and preferences. It is ridiculous. They are personal tastes and preferences. A critic might not like WWE's presentation, but they're only bad at what they do if they cannot concede that WWE is doing a phenomenal job of engaging its audience.

You know what else is ridiculous?

The idea that, say, GUNTHER is bad or overrated purely because he wrestles for a company with a certain set of initials. You can dislike the scripted promos and recoil at the caterwauling of Michael Cole, but you can't say GUNTHER is bad. It's stupid!

So much of the conversation surrounding professional wrestling is absolutely hideous: a small sample of people who could probably do with getting a life amplified disproportionately in order to score engagement points with a put-down of a take or point so demonstrably stupid that it doesn't warrant one's attention. Wrestling is a great and interesting art form even if the current iteration of it may well have peaked. It should be a lot more fun to talk about.

2024 should be the year of shutting up!


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!