10 Best Debut WWE WrestleMania Performances

Who impressed with their first performance on The Grandest Stage Of Them All?

Ronda Rousey WrestleMania 34
WWE.com

First impressions go a long way in the world of wrestling

A great debut can make or break a career. Just ask The Undertaker. Equally, you can ask The Shockmaster.

A great performance at WrestleMania can have a similar effect on a wrestler's career trajectory. Some of the best matches of all time have taken place under the bright lights of 'Mania and many people have walked into The Show of Shows as wrestlers and left as stars.

So, what happens if you combine the two?

The first time a wrestler walks out for a WrestleMania match should be a career highlight. Be it in a singles, tag, or multi-person match, you're still getting to ply your trade in front of a global audience and share the same stage as countless legends.

Even if you do only last twenty seconds in the Andre The Giant Memorial Battle Royal.

For these ten guys and gals, their 'Mania debuts lasted far longer than twenty seconds and made much more of an impact than somebody's skull hitting the floor after being chucked out by Big Show.

Great matches, iconic moments, and, in some cases, the main event - the following ten performers all made the most of their first time on the 'Mania and their legacies live on to this day in the form of an Internet list written by some guy in his underwear.

Lucky them.

10. AJ Styles - WrestleMania 32

AJ Styles WrestleMania 32 Entrance
WWE.com

It seems like AJ Styles has been in WWE forever now, so it's amazing to look back just four years ago when he first stepped out from Gorilla Position.

The legend of the alternative wrestling scene finally arrived in the big time at the 2016 Royal Rumble. In just a few short months, he was over as hell and reminded everybody why he had been considered one of the top wrestlers in the world for the better part of two decades.

For The Phenomenal One's first 'Mania clash, he would step into the ring with another icon - Y2J, Le Champion, The Ayatollah of Rock 'n' Rolla, The... look, if we list all of his nicknames, we'll be here all week.

It was Chris Jericho.

The pair had fought numerous times in several sporting contests, but when Jericho turned heel on AJ in the build-up to WrestleMania 32, it added some serious stakes to their high-profile rematch.

The result might have been the wrong one with Jericho going over the newcomer, but this was still a great performance for both men and a great introduction to the world of AJ Styles.


9. Mickie James - WrestleMania 22

Mickie James Vs Trish Stratus – Wrestlemania 22
WWE.com

Mickie James made her name in TNA before arriving in WWE in 2005. She was immediately thrown into a high-profile storyline with Women's Champion, Trish Stratus, playing the role of a obsessive fan.

This story stretched out for months, culminating in Mickie challenging Trish for the belt at WrestleMania 22.

Both women are exceptional workers and the plot driving this match was red hot. It may have only gone nine minutes, but it was an action-packed nine minutes.

James would eventually defeat Trish using her own move against her. Well, that was the plan away - she botched the Stratusfaction horribly and won with a kick to the head instead.

Still, that small blip aside, this match was really fun and showed all the sceptics that female performers could put on a high-profile match if they were given a story and given a chance.

Easily the best women's match in 'Mania history at the time, this is a prime example of why Mickie James deserves your respect and should be considered among the greatest women to ever lace up a pair of boots.


8. Kane - WrestleMania 14

Undertaker, Kane, WrestleMania XIV
WWE.com

In the words of Vince McMahon, "That's gotta be... the eighth entrant on this list!"

When Kane debuted at Badd Blood '97, he had his first WrestleMania match all planned out. From the moment he ripped the door off the Hell in a Cell to when he picked up his brother, The Undertaker, and drilled him with a Tombstone, fans knew that WWF were building to a family feud of epic proportions.

Six months later and that's exactly what we got.

The feud between Kane and 'Taker slowly built to this first-ever showdown at WrestleMania XIV. Whilst the match itself was far from a technical masterpiece, the story and spectacle of an undead warrior fighting his demonic half-brother was enough to keep viewers hooked.

The match put over Kane strong, even in defeat. He proved himself to be 'Taker's toughest opponent to date and even became the first man ever to kick out of The Deadman's Tombstone.

Kane was elevated to new heights following this match - a point proven when he won the WWF Championship later that year.

Isaac Yankem DDS and Fake Diesel were now a distant memory for Glenn Jacobs.

Long live The Big Red Machine.


7. Ronda Rousey - WrestleMania 34

Triple H Ronda Rousey WrestleMania 34
WWE

Who'd have thought a mixed tag team match featuring a part-timer, two members of WWE's executive team, and a non-wrestler would be one of the best at that year's WrestleMania?

Ronda Rousey's name had been linked to WWE since her appearance at WrestleMania 31. Three years later and the former UFC champion was stepping into a wrestling ring for her first ever match, teaming with Kurt Angle to battle Triple H and Stephanie McMahon.

In a match that was more smoke and mirrors than a fire at a glass factory, the four participants played their roles to perfection, with Ronda being put over a legitimate badass who could easily hold her own inside the squared circle.

This was never going to win any Wrestling Observer Awards or light up the message boards on Reddit, but it was so much fun. Rousey was made to look like an absolute star, even going toe-to-toe with The Game in a rare moment of intergender combat in WWE.

This match proved two things in swathes - that sports entertainment is as valid a form of professional wrestling as any other and that Ronda Rousey belonged in a wrestling ring.


6. Vince McMahon - WrestleMania 17

Vince McMahon Shane McMahon
WWE.com

Despite not being a wrestler, Vince McMahon sure has been in a lot of great wrestling matches.

In fact, apart from his absolute shocker with Bret Hart at WrestleMania XXVI, every single one of his 'Mania matches has been a standout.

His match at 22 with Shawn Michaels - great. His match with Hulk Hogan at XIX - great. But perhaps the pick of the litter is his match at WrestleMania X-7, where he took on his own flesh and blood.

Vince had been embroiled in a storyline ripped straight from a telenovella. He was cheating on his wife, Linda, with a much younger woman (Trish Stratus), all whilst Linda was in a medically induced coma. To reclaim his mother's honour, Shane challenged his father to a Street Fight at WrestleMania, which would be refereed by Mick Foley, who Vince had recently fired as Commissioner of the WWF.

Did you get all that?

The match itself was an overblown, overcooked delight of a soap opera. There was violence, betrayal, and a stunning moment where Zombie Linda rose out of her wheelchair and kicked Vince square in the nuts.

Say what you will about Vinnie Mac, but the man knows how to put on a show.


5. John Cena - WrestleMania 19

John Cena Wrestlemania 20
WWE.com

At WrestleMania XIX, John Cena was supposed to take part in a rap battle against Jay-Z and Fabolous, but this was put on ice when the latter was arrested in March 2003.

Twelve months after the long arm of the law put a stop to Cena's 'Mania plans, he would be dealing with another set of long arms, as he took on The Big Show for the United States Championship.

The Doctor of Thuganomics took on the much larger man in the show's opening contest and was over like rover with the Madison Square Garden crowd. Cena had not yet been shoved down audience's throats and had actually gotten over on his own, so fans were hungry to see the young upstart capture the Stars and Stripes-emblazoned belt.

After some very Un-Cena-Like cheating, the good Doctor hoisted Show up onto his shoulders for a devastating FU (what the AA used to be called) and pinned The Giant to win his first ever championship in the WWE.

Winning your first belt at WrestleMania is an impressive feat and doing it in a great match is even more so.

Every great journey starts with a single step and the face who would eventually run the place took that step right here.


4. Charlotte, Sasha Banks, And Becky Lynch - WrestleMania 32

Sasha Banks Becky Lynch WrestleMania 32 Banks Statement
WWE.com

You know that Trish/Mickie match from earlier? The one we said was the best women's match in WrestleMania history at the time? This was the match that knocked it off the top spot.

WrestleMania 32 was almost a complete dud. The Jericho/Styles match was good, but we also had The New Day vs The League of Nations, Brock Lesnar refusing to sell for Dean Ambrose, and The Undertaker and Shane McMahon plodding around Hell in a Cell for half an hour.

But, in every rough there is a diamond, and this diamond shone with the light of a thousand suns.

Charlotte, Sasha Banks, and Becky Lynch had helped revolutionised the way women's wrestling was presented in WWE. The three NXT standouts had been in developmental just six months before 'Mania. Now, they were competing in the most high-profile women's wrestling match of all time.

These three left it all in the ring, all hoping to be crowned the brand new WWE Women's Champion. The match was gripping from start to finish and climaxed with The Queen tapping out Becky Lynch to claim the gold.

Putting these three women in one match at WrestleMania was a brilliant idea. They showed everyone that women's wrestling had arrived in WWE and it was here to stay


3. Everyone In The Triangle Ladder Match - WrestleMania 2000

Wrestlemania 2000 Ladder Match
WWE.com

The Triangle Ladder match at WrestleMania 2000 is basically a performance art piece underlying how much damage a human body can take whilst still functioning.

The three-way tangle for the WWF Tag Team Championships pitted reigning champs, Bubba Ray and D-Von Dudley, against The Hardy Boyz (Matt and Jeff) and Edge and Christian. All three teams were stepping out onto a WrestleMania stage for the first time and they were keen to make it a memorable one.

Chairs were cracked over skulls. Tables were disintegrated. Ladders were left buckled and bent beyond recognition. It's amazing no one was seriously hurt and how a majority of these men are still wrestling to this day is utterly astounding.

Many have called this one of the best matches of all time - certainly one of the best tag team matches. It completely innovated the way in which weapons were used in wrestling and pushed the limits of what was possible in a multi-man match.

It was the precursor to TLC and few (if any) actual TLC matches have ever lived up to their ancestor's legacy.

This is how you make a first impression.


2. Ric Flair - WrestleMania 8

Ric Flair Randy Savage
WWE.com

For years, "The Nature Boy" Ric Flair was the face of the NWA and WCW, WWF's biggest rivals.

However, owing to a dispute with the company's new President, Jim Herd, Flair did the unthinkable and jumped ship. The biggest name in WCW history was now working for Vince McMahon.

Debuting for the company in August of 1991, Flair took just five months to win the WWF Championship in his now-legendary Royal Rumble 1992 performance. A few months later and Flair was stepping into the ring at his first WrestleMania, defending his world title in a dream match against "Macho Man" Randy Savage.

The two icons waged war over the gold and the pride of Miss Elizabeth, with whom Flair professed to have had a prior relationship. The bout is fantastic to watch - a real 'Mania hidden gem - and ended with Flair putting over Savage and dropping the gold.

Flair's first run in the WWF shows what happens when you let a star from another company be a star in your company.

The Nature Boy was a bona fide box office draw and the WWF put him to excellent use by pitting him against one of their biggest and most capable stars.

Woo, indeed.


1. Brock Lesnar - WrestleMania 19

Brock Lesnar Kurt Angle
WWE.com

The night after WrestleMania X8, the world was introduced to a terrifying young man from Minnesota named Brock Lesnar.

Over the next twelve months, Lesnar was pushed to the moon. He crushed The Rock at SummerSlam 2002 to become the youngest world champion in company history. He won the Royal Rumble on his first try,and, in doing so, set up a tantalising fixture with WWE Champion, Kurt Angle, in the main event of WrestleMania XIX.

Like every time these two stepped inside a ring together, this match was a classic. These two had undeniable chemistry between the ropes and were so evenly matched, you never knew which way the match was going to go.

Whilst this encounter might only really be remembered for one of the scariest botches of all time (the one where Brock decided to introduce himself to the ground neck first), it's still a fantastic battle between two of the purest athletes to ever work for WWE

Brock won the belt back from Angle, becoming the first and only man in history to win a world title in his WrestleMania debut.

Not bad for someone who wasn't even on the main roster one year earlier.


Contributor
Contributor

Jacob Simmons has a great many passions, including rock music, giving acclaimed films three-and-a-half stars, watching random clips from The Simpsons on YouTube at 3am, and writing about himself in the third person.