10 Best Matches In ECW History

Strip away the flaming tables and hardcore spots and you'll find some classic ECW bouts.

Tajiri Super Crazy
WWE.com/PWI

With the tragic passing of Balls Mahoney earlier in the week, Extreme Championship Wrestling has received renewed focus from wrestling fans worldwide. Eulogies pour out in the shape of nostalgic run-throughs of old shows, revisiting classics we remember and rediscovering some we forgot.

ECW closed its doors in 2001, and no wrestling company in history is mourned in the same way. It still incites rabid passion from fans today, which leads to seemingly annual reunion shows and angles in various promotions. In an industry where everything is striving to be unique, ECW and its memory truly stands out.

Of course, large portions of those memories involve tables on fire, thumb-tacks strewn on the canvas and chair shot after chair shot after chair shot. The promotion wasn't called 'Extreme' without good reason, and to this day hardcore spots worldwide are often accompanied with an 'E-C-DUB' chant.

Because of this (chair shots can lead to viewer memory loss too I guess) the sheer quality of a lot of the actual wrestling is forgotten. Sure, ECW gave us violence, but it also gave us luchadores and puroresu in the United States, Dean Malenko/Eddie Guerrero classics and a whole lot more.

ECW had some absolute classic matches in its storied history. Here are 10 of the best...

10. Yoshihiro Tajiri Vs. Super Crazy - Guilty As Charged 1999

Super Crazy Tajiri Guilty as Charged 1999
WWE Network

As mentioned in the introduction, ECW was responsible for properly introducing American audiences to the glory of professional wrestling from Mexico and Japan. My memory may be fuzzy, but I cannot think of a better combination of the two than the great matches put on by Yoshihiro Tajiri and Super Crazy.

For a short while, the two seemed to redefine what 'opening match' meant. They took the knowledge that they had to get the crowd hot and took it to new heights, working a frantic pace every time with matches that harked back to previous battles with impressive subtlety.

The match the two had at 1999's Guilty As Charged is most likely their best. What it lacks in psychology it more than makes up for in athleticism and speed, with sequence after sequence flowing as smooth as you like, an example of two professionals whose chemistry could not be improved. 

Tajiri was still fairly new to the audience at the time, and he was able to pick up the win via a wicked Dragon Suplex. Excellent stuff.


9. 2 Cold Scorpio Vs. Shane Douglas Vs. Pitbull #2 Vs. Chris Jericho - Heatwave 1996

douglas jericho 2 cold scorpio pitbull ecw heatwave
wwe.com

When an individual is tasked with coming up with the most important names from the category titled 'ECW Original', Shane Douglas more often than not gets overlooked. There may indeed be many reasons for this, but the role he played in the company at the time cannot be ignored. In a world of cartoon violence aggressively dragged out of the modern world, Shane Douglas was an old-school wrestling heel who cheated to win matches and pissed people off in the process.

2 Cold Scorpio is another who may not get the appreciation he deserves. The man WWF fans may remember as Flash Funk was flying around the ring way back when, and was responsible for some of the most entertaining ECW matches of the time. Sure, the idea of story and psychology was lost on him now and then, but the guy sure could entertain.

Add to this mix a pre-Best In The World At What He Does Chris Jericho and you know you're in for something special. Pitbull #2 was involved too, and it is difficult to think of a wrestling moniker that can incite less enthusiasm. Not only are you anonymous, but you are also the second most important anonymous individual in a two-man team. Unfortunate.

Jericho is eliminated first, meaning a new champion was to be crowned. Douglas and the second most important Pitbull conspire to get rid of Scorpio, and after nearly forty minutes of fantastic action Shane Douglas comes out on top as your new ECW TV Champion. The real story here was Francine turning on the Pitbulls to align herself with Douglas of course, but this match still stands up to this very day.


8. Rey Mysterio Vs. Juventud Guerrera - Big !*$% Extreme Bash 1996

rey mysterio juventud guerrera
wwe.com

As it was building momentum, ECW consistently did a great job of plugging holes left by their big names moving on to pastures new. When Dean Malenko, Eddie Guerrero and other technical greats moved on to WCW, the company responded by introducing American wrestling audiences to the glory of Mexican lucha libre. 

Rey Mysterio was the standout star, as he would go on to be in almost every company he worked for. He wasn't alone however, as guys like Psicosis and Juventud Guerrera joined him in making the journey north. Juvi was his opponent here at Big !*$% Extreme Bash 1996, and the two duked it out in a best 2-out-of-3 falls match.

When we think of lucha libre in ECW, we think of being amazed at the high flying antics of these masked warriors. What makes this match stand out however is how creative the two were with the arena, fighting out into the crowd and getting various inventive spots in.

This was Rey's last match before heading to WCW, and he leaves with his hand raised high in victory.


7. Tajiri Vs. Steve Corino - Hardcore Heaven 2000

Tajiri Corino.jpg
YouTube

The Tajiri that the WWE Universe would come to know and love was fun-loving to a degree, and a little bit silly despite being more than capable in the ring. These fans will be surprised then to find out that ECW Tajiri was a violent man who didn't really cater to the comedic, focusing instead on kicking people as hard as he could.

His one-sided destruction of Steve Corino at Hardcore Heaven in 2000 may very well be his finest ECW moment. The feud between the two sparked off when Tajrii won the Television Championship and refused to hand it over to The Network. All of this led to this match.

Corino starts the bout off with a supremely intense heel promo that doesn't hold back on the racism. Whilst this is never welcome in professional wrestling, the story takes the right turn as Tajiri comes out to the ring and proceeds to kick Corino's head in for 10 minutes. Not only this, but the crowd were willing Yoshihiro on with every kick. 

Corino bled and bled, and eventually Tajiri put him out of his misery. Sure, it isn't a technical classic, but as far as story goes this match could not have been any better.



6. The Great Sasuke, Gran Hamada & Masato Yukushiji Vs. BWo Japan - Barely Legal 1997

bwo japan ecw
YouTube

With the exodus of the luchadors to World Championship Wrestling, Paul Heyman and ECW responded with another masterstroke by bringing in numerous Japanese stars for showcase matches. One such bout was a 6-man tag at the very first ECW pay-per-view, Barely Legal, in 1997.

On one side was genuine legend The Great Sasuke, along with Gran Hamada and Masato Yukushiji. This trio went up against the Japanese arm of the Blue World Order, featuring Taka Michinoku, Dick Togo (a fantastic name) and Terry Boy.

This was 17 minutes of absolute professional wrestling madness. In many ways tradition is thrown out of the window, as bodies clog up the ring and moves are hit that audiences in the United States simply hadn't seen at this point. It was intense, it was frantic, it was stiff, and it was awesome.

The Great Sasuke's team came out on top, but it barely matters. 


5. Mike Awesome Vs. Masato Tanaka - Heatwave 1998

mike awesome masato tanaka
WWE.com

Much like Super Crazy and Tajiri, ECW had this strange knack of putting matches on between two random guys who would go on to be indelibly linked to one another in the company, whose matches would stand out over time and stand up strongly today. If Crazy and Tajiri did it in the cruisers, it was Mike Awesome and Masato Tanaka who did it with the big boys.

The brawls these two put on were intense to say the least, but they were always underpinned with sense and logic. Mike Awesome certainly sits in the underrated box, as agile a big man as you wanted to find at the time, and the quiet proficiency of Tanaka brought out the best in him

Their battle at Heatwave 1998 may be their best, one that was won by Tanaka after a Tornado DDT onto two chairs. One highlight of the match sees Awesome springboarding from the ring all the way to the crowd, an impressive spot for a small guy but unreal for a man of Awesome's size.


4. Taz Vs. Sabu - Barely Legal 1997

Sabu Taz ECW
WWE.com

Barely Legal was ECW's first foray into pay-per-view, and a lot of the build for the show centred on this most intense of grudge matches. The bout between Taz and Sabu was one whole year in the making. Taz had been calling Sabu for months with no response, until they finally met face to face in the ring at November to Remember in 1997.

The match was signed for ECW's first PPV (Heyman wasn't a great businessman, but he wasn't totally insane) and no other match in the history of the company can match it in terms of that intangible 'big fight feel'. The atmosphere was the sort of which WWE only seemed to replicate at WrestleMania. This was a 'dream match', and it was treated as such.

Taz would pick up the victory, but the intensity of the match is actually matched by what happens afterwards. Taz's manager Bill Alfonso would turn on him, siding with Rob Van Dam and Sabu. A year-long build, a dream match and a double turn to end things. 


3. Rey Mysterio Vs. Psychosis - November To Remember 1995

rey mysterio psychosis ecw
WWE.com

Rey Mysterio had many, many great rivals in his early years, and a solid argument could be made for Psychosis being the greatest of them all. As a youngster I could never really get over how silly Psychosis' mask looked, especially with the horns and the massive hair. Still, the guy was more than capable in the ring, especially when up against an opponent of Rey's calibre.

The bout between the two at November to Remember in 1995 was a Mexican Death Match, meaning victory was achieved by pinning your opponent and then them staying down for a 10-count. The action was fast and the action was furious, with the two putting on something of a lucha clinic to audiences that were still new to the style.

One issue that can be thrown at the match is the number of pinfalls throughout, but these also make sense. By taking a pin and then waiting to get up, a competitor could buy themselves some valuable recuperation time. See, psychology kids.

Rey picked up the win after a rana from the Eagle's Nest to the floor. The match only went just over 10 minutes, but what a 10 minutes it was.


2. Rob Van Dam Vs. Jerry Lynn - Guilty As Charged 2001

Jerry Lynn Rob Van Dam Guilty As Charged 2001
WWE Network

As far as in-ring action goes, ECW's most legendary feud would be the one between Rob Van Dam and Jerry Lynn, who battled each other continuously for what seemed like forever but was never truly long enough. Their scuffles began whilst RVD was TV Champion, a strap he would hold for two damn years. No one came as close as Lynn to dethroning RVD.

The chemistry between the two is well-documented, and truth be told you could choose any one of their matches for this list. Their bouts at Hardcore Heaven in 1999 and Living Dangerously the same year get a lot of coverage, but for me it is the battle at Guilty As Charged in ECW's dying days that gets my vote.

There was a clear good guy/bad guy dynamic here, something that may get forgotten from time to time in pro wrestling. They went through their usual spots, but the time spent working together meant that here they came with a smoother fluidity and at a more frantic pace. For me this was their apex.

RVD picked up the win, as he usually did, but Lynn lost nothing in defeat.


1. Dean Malenko Vs. Eddie Guerrero - Hostile City Showdown 1995

eddie malenko.jpg
wwe.com

Up until this point, 1995's Hostile City Showdown had been a wash of a show. Axl and Ian Rotten had taken part in an utterly pointless Barbed Wire Baseball Bat match that showcased everything that was wrong with ECW and its audience at the time, Tommy Dreamer gave Beulah a piledriver to the joy of ECW's woman hating crowd and Tony Stetson and Tsubo Genjin had a match that everyone had forgotten before it had even began.

Out of this filth strode two of the greatest professional wrestlers ever to lace up the boots, for their first match against each other on US soil. Eddie Guerrero was the ECW TV Champion at the time, and Dean Malenko was the challenger here. What follows is as close to a technical masterpiece as you could hope for at the time.

In front of a crowd that wants blood and violence, Malenko and Guerrero proceed to twist and turn each other into various unnatural shapes, trading counters and turning the crowd from confused to enraptured, all within 30 minutes. The match ends with a time-limit draw, a whole host of false finishes dotting out the final few moments.

If you are ever confused as to why Eddie Guerrero and Dean Malenko were held in such high regard, go back and watch that. Then take into account the crowd and the show, and the quality of it truly does stand out. This is akin to Fiona Apple playing in the middle of your local metal festival, an example of beauty and poetry surrounded by frustration and anger. 

It is the best match ECW ever put on.


In this post: 
ECW
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Born in the middle of Wales in the middle of the 1980's, John can't quite remember when he started watching wrestling but he has a terrible feeling that Dino Bravo was involved. Now living in Prague, John spends most of his time trying to work out how Tomohiro Ishii still stands upright. His favourite wrestler of all time is Dean Malenko, but really it is Repo Man. He is the author of 'An Illustrated History of Slavic Misery', the best book about the Slavic people that you haven't yet read. You can get that and others from www.poshlostbooks.com.