10 Best Non-WWE Wrestlers Of 2017

Star ratings for days.

Kazuchika Okada Kenny Omega
NJPW World

While WWE have experienced a typically up-and-down year at the top of the wrestling pile, those beneath them are thriving.

They'll never compete with Vince McMahon financially, but the business' smaller promotions are currently delivering remarkable feats of artistry, creativity, and athleticism that the restrictive 'sports entertainment' format just can't match. Groups like PROGRESS and NJPW are succeeding where the industry leaders are failing. Their platform is smaller, but there has never been a more rewarding time to follow them, particularly for those sick of WWE's mainstream trappings.

It's a talent-rich scene, with dozens of genuinely world-class performers delivering outstanding matches on a weekly basis, and while standing out can be tricky, the true elite will always find ways of doing so, no matter how crowded it gets.

Things have changed considerably since we last ranked the world's top non-WWE performers. Several names have shot up the rankings, while others have fallen off the list completely, replaced by surging peers. Whatever the case, the names within have stood head and shoulders above the competition in 2017, reducing the likes of Ricochet, The Young Bucks, and Matt Riddle to honourable mentions...

10. Hiromu Takahashi

Hiromu Takahashi
NJPW

Ranked at number two in June, Hiromu Takahashi fell off badly in 2017's second half, to the point where he no longer feels like the NJPW Junior Heavyweight division's star, but a supporting actor in a movie starring Will Ospreay, KUSHIDA, and Marty Scurll.

His in-ring fortunes have declined significant. A middling Best Of The Super Juniors run preceded a needless championship loss to KUSHIDA at Dominion 6.11, and while Hiromu will challenge for the belt in a four-way title fight at Wrestle Kingdom 12, he no longer feels like a white-hot commodity.

Regardless, these complaints aren't enough to diminish the incredible start Takahashi made to 2017. Starting with a career-defining Tokyo Dome win over KUSHIDA, Hiromu was soon putting on some of the most breathtaking matches in the company, regardless of weight class. His 11 February clash with Dragon Lee was a beautiful blitzkrieg, he outclassed the exceptional Ricochet in their title fight, and shone against Ospreay, Scurll, and Lee in the BOSJ tourney. Booking concerns aside, the Dominion bout was a borderline classic too.

Takahashi's wild, reckless style and electric charisma have made him a transcendent performer, and he'd be a lock for our top five if NJPW hadn't cycled him out of the spotlight.


9. Shuji Ishikawa

Shuji Ishikawa
Puroresu Spirit

From a pure workrate perspective, Shuji Ishikawa is the best 'big man' in wrestling today.

At 6'5", 300lbs, the 'Indie Wrestling Big Dog' is a sight to behold, with his power, presence, and mastery of high-level wrestling psychology making him the greatest non-NJPW heavyweight in Japan. He's a giant with genuine five-star match potential, and his talent is as rare as it is special.

Ishikawa is coming off the most successful year of his career. He won AJPW's historic Champion Carnival in April, then went on to face company ace Kento Miyahara for the promotion's Triple Crown Championship on 21 May, upsetting the long-time champ in an instant classic. Presented as something of a new era Jumbo Tsuruta, Shuji's reign lasted just three months, but it was a well deserved acknowledgment for a man entering his 15th year as a professional wrestler, and fans lapped it up accordingly.

His rematch with Miyahara was on par with almost anything NJPW have produced in 2017, and Ishikawa has also recorded outstanding wars with the likes of Suwama, Joe Doering, and an overmatched Jake Lee. He is the Japanese indie scene's MVP, and he deserves your attention.


8. Will Ospreay

Will Ospreay
NJPW1972.com

Staunch wrestling traditionalists with their feet stuck in cement will never warm to Will Ospreay's style, but that's their loss. Yes, the young English is a human highlight reel, but to call him (and others of his ilk) a 'spot monkey' is misguided at best, and knowingly ignorant at worst.

The English flier is about to conclude the most impressive in-ring year of his career. This is no small feat, as the former IWGP Junior Heavyweight Champion has never been anything less than spectacular, but he has taken his game to a new level in 2017, engaging in classic bouts all across the globe.

His clashes with Ricochet and KUSHIDA stand as the most notable. While previous bouts against the former drew an exorbitant amount of criticism, the duo slowed things down in this year's BOSJ, showcasing their versatility by delivering a flawless rendition of the slow, methodical NJPW main event style. Ospreay and KUSHIDA killed it in the Best Of The Super Juniors final, too, with their bout drawing a five-star rating from Dave Meltzer.

Ospreay's New Japan booking is the one major slight against him, as he has never been presented as the guy for a prolonged period. Regardless, his in-ring offerings have been world class.


7. Keith Lee

Keith Lee James Storm
Oli Sandler / The Ringside Perspective

The independent wrestling scene was dealt a heavy blow when Kassius Ohno re-signed with WWE in December 2016.

As the world's most consistent four-star match machine, the former Chris Hero was a promoter's dream and a fan's delight. He was never anything less than excellent, and would always deliver a show-stealing performance regardless of who he was facing, making him one of the most sought-after performers in the world.

Thank the heavens for Keith Lee, then.

The hyper-athletic colossus has filled the indies' Hero-shaped hole with aplomb, dazzling audiences with his outrageously diverse skill-set, and carrying himself like the biggest star in the world wherever he goes. Lee's chops are brutal, his power game is incomparable, and his inhuman athleticism allows him to pull off flips and dives with the grace of a man half his size. He's a freak, basically, and his feats must be seen to believed.

As far as individual matches go, his series with recent WWE signing Donovan Dijak stands out, but Lee saved his best performance for 9 November, when he wrestled NJPW's Tomohiro Ishii for RevPro. A perfect microcosm of what makes both men so special, it's a 'must watch' by anyone's standards.


6. Tetsuya Naito

TRANQUILO NAITO
NJPW World

If Kazuchika Okada is New Japan Pro Wrestling's ace and Kenny Omega the company's leading gaijin, Tetsuya Naito is their biggest homegrown star.

The charismatic Los Ingobernables De Japon leader has the world at his feet at the moment. It's widely thought that he'll defeat Okada at Wrestle Kingdom 12 on 4 January and embark on a long, successful run as IWGP Heavyweight Champion, delivering a year comparable to 'The Rainmaker's' incredible 2017. If so, he'll be doing it on the back of his own banner year

Naito started the year as IWGP Intercontinental Champion, defending the belt against opponents as diverse as company legend Hiroshi Tanahashi, powerhouse Michael Elgin, and the up-and-coming Juice Robinson. Tana would take his belt eventually, but Naito's excellence continued. He engaged in multiple wars of attrition with Tomohiro Ishii, a heart-in-mouth masterpiece with Kota Ibushi, and produced a flawless performance against Kenny Omega in the G1 Climax tournament finals, securing his Wrestle Kingdom headlining spot.

The undisputed coolest wrestler on the planet, Tetsuya Naito's work is carried by his carefree charisma, with the 'Ingobernables' gimmick as fresh today as it was at its inception. Okada's had a great run, but we can't wait for his rival to take the to spot.


5. Zack Sabre Jr.

WCPW Zack Sabre Jr
WCPW

It's tough to beat Zack Sabre Jr.'s 2017 output as far as sheer volume of quality matches go. The English technician is the most consistent wrestler in the world, and this year has seen him diversify his game immensely, performing admirably on the American indies and the thriving British scene, as well as debuting for New Japan.

While Zack's ceiling is a tad lower than those further up on our list, his highs were still incredible. His bout with Michael Elgin for Chicago's AAW promotion was a near perfect clash of styles, but his G1 Climax work with Tomohiro Ishii and Kota Ibushi garnered more attention, and understandably so. More recently, ZSJ delivered a late British MOTY candidate against Will Ospreay at RevPro's Global Wars event.

Sabre is a technical wrestler par excellence. Grappling is his wheelhouse, but while his bouts often taken on an exhibition-like tone, ZSJ's strongest output comes when he performs with a chip on his shoulder. These bouts bring out a nasty, ruthless side that isn't always apparent in the Englishman's style, but always carries his work to the next level, particularly against sympathetic opposition.

He's also a massive Corbynite, and one of only a few performers with the sense to turn WWE down in the modern era. What's not to love?


4. WALTER

WALTER PROGRESS
Twitter, @ThisIs_Progress

Now that the big, burly Austrian is finally making waves outside the central European scene that has been his base for the bulk of his career, it's time to recognise WALTER for what he really is: one of the best wrestlers on the planet.

Another three-dimensional giant, 'Der Ringgeneral' commands the squared circle like none other. He's a cold, steely character who works with the confidence and swagger of a man possessing twice his 12 years' experience, and his elite psychology means he could likely wrestle a parking cone and still make it enjoyable.

WALTER's chops are among the stiffest around, as are his suplexes, but he's best defined by his ring IQ and technique. These skills have helped him deliver countless great matches throughout 2017. From attritional early-year battles with Ilja Dragunov and Matt Riddle to more recent bouts with David Starr and Zack Sabre Jr., the big man's on fire, and pushes in PROGRESS, PWG, and EVOLVE should see him shoot to new levels of prominence in 2018.

Get on the bandwagon now, because the Austrian's finally on the cusp of blowing up, and you'll want to be there when it happens.


3. Kenny Omega

Kenny Omega
New Japan Pro Wrestling

Kenny Omega has been the most buzz-worthy professional wrestler in the world since 4 January, when he and Kazuchika Okada blew the roof off the Tokyo Dome. Their first six-star classic set the internet the blaze, and the fire has never fizzled out: in fact, it now burns brighter than ever before.

'The Cleaner' and 'The Rainmaker' outdid themselves in their second meeting, then distilled their previous bouts into a breathtaking 30-minute clash in the G1 Climax, completing what might be the greatest wrestling trilogy of all time with Kenny's cathartic victory. There's more to his 2017 than that, though. Tomohiro Ishii, Tetsuya Naito, Michael Elgin: Omega excelled against them all, and recent work with Juice Robinson and Barreta helped elevate both to new levels of stardom.

Outside the ring, Omega has positioned Bullet Club and The Elite among wrestling's most powerful brands, and was made the face of NJPW's ongoing United Stated expansion back in July. He's a major international star now, and his upcoming bout with Chris Jericho should only solidify this.

A genuine pro wrestling genius, Kenny is operating at the apex of his game at the moment, and it's hard to imagine his 2018 coming and going without at least one IWGP Heavyweight Title reign.


2. Tomohiro Ishii

Tomohiro Ishii NJPW G1 Climax
NJPW.co.jp

Tomohiro Ishii is fighting spirit personified.

A world-class worker trapped in a manual labourer's body, he is living, breathing proof that pro wrestling isn't about flips, dives, and flashy gimmicks. He stands at just 5'7", tips the scales at a pudgy 220lbs, and sticks to only a handful of different manoeuvres, none of which are more complex than a superplex. Despite this, nobody is more effective at drawing an audience into their struggle, and that's why Ishii is still one of the best in the world at 41 years old.

He'll never be New Japan's ace, nor will he win the IWGP Heavyweight Championship, but it doesn't matter. He's the underdog. The everyman. Dusty Rhodes without the flamboyance, or Mick Foley with twice the in-ring chops. You're elated when he wins, and heartbroken when he loses, because Ishii is the ultimate sympathy magnet. You don't watch his struggle: you feel it.

Excellent for several years now, Ishii took a while to get going in 2017, but found his rhythm soon after wrestling Kenny Omega and Katsuyori Shibata in March's New Japan Cup. A typically excellent G1 Climax run followed, and the gritty, hard-nosed brawler finished the year on a high with an epic RevPro showdown against Keith Lee, underlining his 'Wrestler Of The Year' candidacy.


1. Kazuchika Okada

Okada plays the Crystal Maze
NJPW

The best wrestler in the world wasn't born in Gainesville, Georgia, didn't wrestle Brock Lesnar at Survivor Series, and doesn't carry the WWE Championship. His name is Kazuchika Okada, and his 2017 output is unparalleled.

The Kenny Omega matches are an obvious starting point, but 'The Rainmaker's output is as rich as it is diverse. Renowned MMA badass Minoru Suzuki tried to tear his knee apart in their February showdown, but Okada endured. He performed a thrilling exhibition with Tiger Mask W in March, beat hard-boiled striker Katsuyori Shibata at his own game in April, and survived the monstrous Bad Luck Fale one month later. Okada then dragged Cody Rhodes to the best match of his career in Los Angeles, before embarking on a remarkable G1 Climax run, then concluding his epic year with another successful IWGP Heavyweight Title defence at King Of Pro Wrestling in October.

There aren't enough superlatives for the ace's skills. He's an in-ring storyteller par excellence, with his virtuosity in psychology, pacing, and selling turning every big match into a dramatic masterpiece. The 'Rainmaker' persona is incredibly intoxicating, and he's a certified draw, too, having helped New Japan to one of the most successful financial years since their 1972 formation.

What's most remarkable about Okada is his age. Still only 30, it'd now be a major surprise if he doesn't eventually catch up with, or even surpass, the likes of Mitsuharu Misawa.


Channel Manager
Channel Manager

Andy has been with WhatCulture for 10 years and is currently WhatCulture's Wrestling Channel Manager. A writer, presenter, and editor with 10+ years of experience in online media, he has been a sponge for all wrestling knowledge since playing an old Royal Rumble 1992 VHS to ruin in his childhood. Having previously worked for Bleacher Report, Andy specialises in short and long-form writing, video presenting, voiceover acting, and editing, all characterised by expert wrestling knowledge and commentary. Andy is as much a fan of 1985 Jim Crockett Promotions as he is present-day AEW and WWE - just don't make him choose between the two.