10 Best Split-Brand Pay-Per-Views In WWE History
Less is more!
On Sunday, WWE presents Backlash, the first split-brand pay-per-view of the new brand extension. That show, which will exclusively feature Smackdown talent, is to be headlined by WWE World Champion Dean Ambrose defending his title against AJ Styles.
Backlash may be notable for many reasons, but it's not the first time WWE has run a brand-exclusive PPV event. From 2003 to 2007, the company's so-called "B-show" PPVs were split across Raw/Smackdown lines, meaning that only WrestleMania, SummerSlam, Survivor Series and the Royal Rumble could feature the entire WWE roster.
Without the risk of overexposing talent as quickly, WWE was able to expand the PPV calendar, featuring a record high 16 shows in 2006.
Eventually, the business model proved to be untenable. Fans didn't want to purchase expensive shows with only three weeks' break, and cards didn't sell as well as they would have with all of the roster's stars. Thought the brand split lasted until 2011, the split PPVs ended four years earlier.
This time, PPV isn't an issue - fans subscribe to the WWE Network for a flat fee, so there's no risk of over-saturating the market or demanding too much money. In 2017, WWE will run 19 PPVs a year, shattering the old record.
Still, to make sure the endeavour is a success, it would behoove the company to look back at some of the best single-brand PPVs of the split era. Building strong midcard programs and promoting hot matches are essential, as these 10 best split-brand PPVs in WWE history prove.
10. Vengeance 2004 (Raw)
In the summer of 2004, Chris Benoit was the World Heavyweight Champion, but it was still Triple H who headlined Raw brand PPVs. At Vengeance, though, Triple H got a title shot, so it was back to the top of the card for the champ.
The match between the two men wasn't their best one-on-one bout (and the interference-based finish left a lot to be desired), but it was still a solid main event during a time when JBL was ruining the top of the card on Smackdown.
Perhaps more notable, though, was the Intercontinental Title match between Randy Orton and Edge. Orton - who would capture the World Heavyweight Title from Benoit one month later at SummerSlam - may have come up short, but both guys showed why they would soon become two of the stars around whom the company would be built.
Those bouts, plus a strong number one contendership match for the Women's Title in the form of Victoria versus Molly Holly, make this show a modest winner from a several-month span when WWE was consistently failing to deliver on PPV.
9. No Way Out 2004 (Smackdown)
No Way Out 2004 may be little more than a one-match show, but when that match is one of the greatest bouts in WWE history, it's enough to make the whole card special.
In the main event, dominant WWE World Champion Brock Lesnar defended his title against Eddie Guerrero. Guerrero was riding an incredible wave of popularity, and just prior to the bout, had cut his famous "addiction" promo on Lesnar - so the crowd wanted him to win more than anything.
The two had an incredible match that saw Lesnar deliver the best performance of his career - he absolutely overwhelmed Guerrero in a way that would make "Suplex City" Brock nervous. Guerrero battled back, though, and some timely interference from Goldberg saved the challenger's attempt. Finally, he countered an F5 into a DDT, then hit the Frog Splash for the win.
The rest of the card was largely forgettable, though a three-way match between Kurt Angle, John Cena and The Big Show was pretty good.
8. Judgment Day 2005 (Smackdown)
John Cena became the face of Raw in 2005, but he cut his teeth on Smackdown. He defeated JBL to win the WWE World Championship at WrestleMania 21, then in his final PPV with the blue brand, defended the belt against the former champ in a rematch.
That bout, an "I Quit" match, headlined Judgment Day 2005 and was easily the best match of JBL's career. Even though Cena would go on to become the face of the PG movement, it was a brutal, bloody battle that saw Cena and Bradshaw both destroy each other. They fought up to a truck that Cena had ridden into the arena for his entrance, and the champion tore a steam pipe off it. Before Cena could hit JBL with it, the challenger quit, but Cena smashed him through a window anyway.
The undercard was also strong, with the highlight being a bout between Eddie Guerrero and Rey Mysterio. That was the first encounter in a feud that would come to include Mysterio's son, Dominick.
7. One Night Stand 2005 (ECW)
Even though ECW wasn't revived as a brand until 2006, it returned to pay-per-view the previous year with One Night Stand, a card that easily stands as the best wrestling reunion show ever.
Though there weren't any great matches at the event - with the exception of a brutal Mike Awesome-Masato Tanaka brawl that reminded everybody just how great the two men were - the show remained wonderfully true to the ECW brand. Even though many of the stars on the show had gone on to become regular members of the WWE roster, they wrestled and presented themselves like it was the old days.
WWE also pulled in several stars from the original ECW who weren't part of the WWE roster, from Sabu to Super Crazy. In addition to all that, ECW owner Paul Heyman cut the promo of the year, verbally crucifying JBL and the contingent of WWE wrestlers present in the name of "EC-F*cking-W". All in all, the show went down in history as a classic.
6. Judgment Day 2006 (Smackdown)
By all accounts, Judgment Day 2006 shouldn't have been a very good show. Though Smackdown's roster had talent, the storylines on the show were getting stale and a lot of the feuds weren't making the best use of the stars available. Despite all that, Judgment Day was great, with every match performing at or better than expectations.
The best match (not surprisingly) was a 21-minute Chris Benoit-Finlay contest where the two wrestlers simply went out and did an excellent job. The show also saw exciting title matches in the form of Gregory Helms defending the Cruiserweight Championship against Super Crazy and Paul London and Brian Kendrick capturing the WWE Tag Team Championships from MNM.
The main event - Rey Mysterio defending the World Heavyweight Championship against JBL - was excellent from a dramatic standpoint. JBL beat Mysterio down to the point where it looked like Rey wouldn't be able to answer the referee's ten count. In the end, though, Mysterio hit a 619 and a splash to retain the belt.
5. Unforgiven 2006 (Raw)
The John Cena-Edge feud threatened to engulf Raw in 2006. Edge ended Cena's first WWE World Title reign when he cashed in his Money in the Bank briefcase, and though Cena won the belt back, Edge was the champion by summer. He managed to retain the belt in a SummerSlam showdown with John Cena, leading to a final bout - a TLC match - at Unforgiven.
That bout saw Cena take the fight to Edge in his hometown of Toronto, using a ladder to inflict pain on "The Rated-R Superstar". Edge fought back, of course, and very nearly put Cena away by sending him crashing through a table. In the end, though, a top-of-the-ladder Attitude Adjustment through two tables to Edge was enough to claim a third title for Cena.
The show also featured the retirement match of Trish Stratus, who challenged Lita for the WWE Women's Championship. In an emotional moment, Stratus won the belt for a record seventh time, then took her final bow as a full-time performer.
4. No Way Out 2006 (Smackdown)
Though Kurt Angle and The Undertaker battled each other at Survivor Series 2000, it was many years before their paths would cross again in a major pay-per-view match.
By No Way Out 2006, much had changed. Angle was no longer a laughingstock of an undeserving world champion - he was a wrestling machine who was booked as one of the company's top stars. Likewise, Undertaker wasn't the American Bad Ass anymore - he was the Phenom once again. The cards were all in place for the two men to have a classic match.
Even those lofty expectations were exceeded. The two men had a masterpiece of a match, with submissions, finishing maneuvers, and tons of counters. In the end, Undertaker locked Angle in a triangle choke, but the Olympic Gold Medalist flipped forward and turned it into a cover, scoring the three count.
With that match on top and a very solid undercard, No Way Out 2006 remains a gem of the brand-split era.
3. Vengeance 2003 (Smackdown)
Ordinarily, adding The Big Show to a match doesn't help it at all, but in 2003, Kurt Angle and Brock Lesnar could only fight each other so many times. Enter the world's largest athlete, who famously destroyed the ring in a Smackdown bout with Lesnar just prior to Vengeance.
The three men had one of WWE's more exciting triple threat matches, with Big Show playing spoiler to the two world-class wrestlers. Lesnar hit The Big Show with an F5 and, later in the bout, Angle and Lesnar managed to plant Show with a tandem chokeslam, but they couldn't keep the giant down. In the end, Angle hit Show with an Olympic Slam, then hit Lesnar with one to win the match and Brock's WWE Title.
Given that the show also featured The World's Greatest Tag Team versus Rey Mysterio and Billy Kidman, Eddie Guerrero versus Chris Benoit and the sole John Cena-Undertaker pay-per-view encounter. Even the APA Barroom Brawl, Vince McMahon versus Zack Gowen and Stephanie McMahon versus Sable couldn't collectively bring the show down!
2. Vengeance 2005 (Raw)
Batista defeated Triple H for the World Heavyweight Championship in the main event of WrestleMania 21, but the match was a bust. Plus, one little loss wouldn't keep HHH out of the title picture. They had a rematch at Backlash, which Batista won, but it still wasn't over.
At Vengeance, Batista and HHH had their blowoff match - a Hell in a Cell bout. This one was the winner, as the two men finally put on a classic that would have been a great WrestleMania main event. A sledgehammer and a steel chair wrapped in barbed wire came into play, but it was a spinebuster on the ring steps that sealed things for Batista. After that, he hit a Batista Bomb to put "The Game" away.
Meanwhile, Shawn Michaels and Kurt Angle had a rematch of their WrestleMania classic, with HBK picking up the win. Though the bout wasn't as good as their first clash (what is?), that match - plus a John Cena-Chris Jericho-Christian triple threat match - made for an amazing show.
1. Backlash 2004 (Raw)
WrestleMania XX is one of WWE's all-time most-beloved Pay-Per-View shows, with a classic triple threat main event between Chris Benoit, Triple H, and Shawn Michaels. As everyone knows, Benoit won that match to become the World Heavyweight Champion, but less well remembered is the rematch they had the following month.
At Backlash, the same three men met for the same title and recaptured the same magic. Michaels and Triple H pulled out all of the stops to try and become World Heavyweight Champion, but this time, it was HBK who would fall. Benoit caught him with a Sharpshooter and forced him to submit, retaining the belt.
The other classic match on the show was a hardcore contest pitting Intercontinental Champion Randy Orton against Cactus Jack. Given that Orton was seen as a star getting pushed on his look and Cactus Jack hadn't wrestled in four years, fans were skeptical. In the end, though, they delivered an insane, bloody match that proved Orton was every bit tough and talented enough to headline in WWE.
Factoring in those matches - as well as Shelton Benjamin versus Ric Flair and Chris Jericho versus Christian and Trish Stratus - Backlash is the very best of the brand-split PPVs.