10 Best Wrestlers Who Were Never WWE Champion

The reverse midas touch.

Razor Ramon Neville Mr Perfect
WWE.com

Though still broadly protective over its top titles in 2018, WWE is still a place where anybody can suddenly be a somebody.

Jinder Mahal's 2017 WWE Championship reign was a coarse reminder than Vince McMahon still runs his organisation with an iron fist capable of flattening dreams in pursuit of a dystopian nightmare - at least thats what arenas looked like the longer 'The Modern Day Maharaja' spent with the supposed 'Richest Prize'.

AJ Styles' reign hasn't reversed the curse, though it has partially restored the belt to one of it's former glories - the hard-fought acknowledgement that you're the best of what's left. Shawn Michaels and Bret Hart were damned with this faint praise during their own times, but these spells are as important as the ones that propel the company into the mainstream.

For every Austin, Hogan and Cena that dictates a generation's narrative, there must be Hart's, Michaels' and Styles' to carefully control the in-between. Everybody doesn't just get a turn as if the strap was a participation medal - despite the Jinder/JBL outliers buried within its legacy. These are men far more deserving than those two, and whilst it's hard to imagine them to pinching a spot on the oft-debated 'Mount Rushmore of Wrestling', it would have been fascinating to see them try.

10. Jake 'The Snake' Roberts

Jake The Snake Roberts
WWE.com

One of a few in this list that had his best years whilst Hulk Hogan was having his, Jake Roberts rightfully felt a touch unlucky to not get a run with a top prize in WWE after turning heel too late in his stint to become a regular 'Hulkster' foil.

'The Snake' was a secondary tier babyface underneath the biggest star in the history of the industry, and turned heel too late to transfer his white hot heat into green before bad luck and personal demons conspired against his career trajectory.

Roberts is the type of performer often underserved by the narrative that he did a lot with a little - he was far smarter than that suggests. Whilst not quite as skilled as his more technically proficient peers, Jake's grasp on psychology made his moveset mean multitudes more than many that appeared ten times as skilled.

He was, in the truest sense of the word, a "worker". He worked and worked and worked to burrow into the emotional psyche of an audience rapt in his every move. In a world without Hulk Hogan, he could have had it all. He was sadly one of the bigger victims of a "Universe" experiencing its first megastar.


9. Brian Pillman

Brian Pillman Jim Ross
WWE.com

Of all the faces (and heels) that had substantial coverage on WWE television in 1997, Brian Pillman was one of the few that would have fit in just fine during the drastically different following year.

'The Loose Cannon' was years ahead of his time in 1996. Two, to be exact. Pillman had the incomparable attitude to believe in himself at the expense of others - and common sense - but knew the ideology was so bizarre that he'd have to be cast as unhinged just to get it over.

Spotting the move away from the kayfabe era later exploited by both WCW and WWE, Flyin' Brian's 1995 metamorphosis into the man that strode out of a WCW deal via the ECW Arena into a fat WWE contract was one of the most remarkable career turnarounds in industry history.

Deft to a fault, Pillman lived the gimmick as he played it, and rode his luck and timing throughout until both ran out on him. Horrific injuries sustained in a car accident didn't diffuse the WWE deal, but destroyed the career he was meant to have. His personality was such that he remained over the the last year of his life despite the obvious pain he felt every time he wrestled. But it wouldn't have mattered had he made it beyond 1998. The company was only just coming round to his way of working when he tragically passed on.


8. Ravishing Rick Rude

Ravishing Rick Rude Wwe Hall Of Fame
WWE.com

A superlative pr*ck heel against the Ultimate Warrior during a 1989 feud for the Intercontinental Title and a genuinely threatening one when both levelled up a year later, Ravishing Rick Rude sadly never got to deploy either version of himself against Hulk Hogan or Randy Savage during their own babyface title stints.

Rude was a villain in a hero's world for the entirety of his time in WWE. A stupendous heel, there was no place in Vince McMahon's heart for a long-standing bad guy on roster dominated chiseled 1980s icons. Rude's body was no less cut, but his cutting remarks instead made his body a show of unfiltered arrogance rather than aspiration.

As brightly as the 'Ravishing One' shone in the 1980s, his star burned out too quickly the following decade. By the mid-1990s he was all-but retired after a decent run in WCW, but his comeback as D-Generation-X's "insurance policy" was his final chance to make history with the organisation. He did so too, but only by leaving it - Rude appearing on a live Nitro whilst also working the taped Raw was a cute way to use and abuse the warring brands, but his chances of a top title run were long diminished before be bantered Vince McMahon off one last time.


7. X-Pac

X-Pac Shane McMahon
WWE.com

A nailed-on main eventer if he'd broken through in 2018 rather than 1988, Sean Waltman's size always hampered his chances at the top of the card, particularly in Vince McMahon's land of the giants.

Considered child-like due to his stature in 1993, Waltman was literally labelled as such when the company elected to convert his 'Lightning Kid' superhero name into a moniker based around his propensity for a fluke. In real life, The 1-2-3 Kid was a litmus test for locker room newcomers in a talent-rich time. So said his Kliq friends and others that if wrestlers couldn't have a good match with Waltman, they couldn't do it with anybody.

This applied less by the time he returned in 1998, but only because workrate was secondary in the era of Crash TV. Still a sensation between the ropes, the abject boredom with his gimmick by 2001 resulted in 'X-Pac heat' becoming an unfortunately real thing as a rapidly-moving industry left him in a recent past that felt decades out of date. That X-Pac stood no chance of unseating Stone Cold Steve Austin, but the DX babyface years earlier had every bit the popularity to justify a hotshot win that unfortunately never materialised.


6. Jeff Jarrett

Jeff Jarrett
WWE.com

Tucked away inside Jeff Jarrett's lawsuit against GFW was a boy-popping qualifier about his pro wrestling pedigree, as if it were needed - and it was not. Totting up all the times 'Double J' was entrusted with an organisation's top strap, Jarrett's legal team noted how he was a 17 time World Heavyweight Champion.

The eye-watering figure wasn't technically false. Jarrett included all his runs with the WCW and NWA/TNA gold as well as significantly smaller titles won in USWA, WWA and AAA. Pointedly, 'WWE' were the initials missing from the needlessly loaded list.

At no point did Vince McMahon ever deem him worthy of his top title, and it twice resulted in Jarrett taking his business elsewhere. Furious with the company's decision to rush a feud between him and The Roadie in 1995, he walked out of the organisation on the same night Shawn Michaels took his Intercontinental Title. Just over four years later, he infamously switched sides on the promise of a WCW mega push from old friend and fellow WWE evacuee Vince Russo. Stuck underneath The Rock, Triple H and a Stone Cold Steve Austin vowing never to work with him, Jarrett was a spent force in Stamford yet again.


5. Ted Dibiase

Million Dollar Man Ted DiBiase
WWE

Peaking upon entry to WWE, Ted Dibiase's 'Million Dollar Man' character tried and failed to buy his way to main roster supremacy within the first year of his career. Only by funding his own personalised title could he get near singles title matches after that. And as beautiful as the Million Dollar Belt looked, it didn't match the fleeting moments the ill-gotten WWE Championship sat around his waist.

Like so many fabulous talents of the era, Dibiase's magnificence served a greater purpose than carrying the WWE Championship. Hulk Hogan's legendary run ensured towns and pay-per-views alike were persistently sold out, but the raft of stars such as Dibiase, Rick Rude, Jake Roberts and a practically Perfect performer (more on him later) ensured that secondary shows could run smaller towns with serviceable stars on top.

By the time Hulk Hogan et al were all but gone in 1992-93, Dibiase was well-deployed as a dependable doubles star, forming the broadly enjoyable Money Inc with Irwin R Schyster. Again a reliable hand, Ted's time had passed as the company moved forward with the likes of Bret Hart and Yokozuna in place of trusted headliners from eras past.


4. Razor Ramon

Razor Ramon 1994
WWE.com

In 1995, Razor Ramon Hall asked Vince McMahon what more he could do to try and take further advantage of the "opportunity"-based pay structure within WWE.

In an era before McMahon offered guaranteed contracts, the talents were encouraged by their otherwise-paltry pay packets to work their way up the card for television and pay-per-view paydays beyond the per-night wages of the rank-and-file. Ramon had done so in short order after debuting with the organisation in 1992, but, as a multi-time Intercontinental Champion babyface, felt he'd hit a ceiling.

McMahon rebuffed his requests to turn heel and feud with The Undertaker, and simply never saw him on the same level as his best friends Shawn Michaels and Diesel. Ramon may have wanted the spot for the money first and foremost, but a run as WWE Champion wouldn't have remotely felt unearned from a performance perspective either.

Razor's in-ring record was sensational. Ladder matches against Shawn Michaels were instantly iconic, whilst feuds with The 1-2-3 Kid, IRS and Jeff Jarrett all elevated the opponents far beyond their prior status. Little about him wasn't money, and it remains confusing to this day why McMahon didn't see the megastar aura WCW were only too happy to spend big on in 1996.


3. Neville

Neville WWE
WWE.com

What could have been.

Really. What could have been?

Is it wishful thinking to assume that Neville may have made it all the way to the top of the WWE tree had he ever managed to just escape the Cruiserweight Division instead of parting ways with the entire company in 2017? Understandably exasperated, Neville's work on 205 Live in 2017 was almost beyond regular praise.

He took a show, a title and a raft of talents that meant less than nothing and repeatedly made them all matter. He was jobbed out to Enzo Amore. He got the belt itself onto WrestleMania and stole the first half of the show with Austin Aries. Or he didn't, if you watch the US edition of the DVD because the match was cut. Despite his incredible offence, he became a bonafide heel in an era virtually immune to universal disdain. His last act was to be cast as the saviour of his league.

These are no longer the days where men Neville's height don't get a grasp at the WWE brass ring, but the company somehow conspired to chase one of their finest all-rounders thousands of miles in the opposite direction.

What could have been.


2. Mr Perfect

mr perfect
WWE.com

The ultimate example of a talent in the wrong time to take a top title, Mr Perfect could state a case as the company's greatest ever all-rounder, though a disappointing lack of drawing power was both the argument and mark against him ever advancing beyond Intercontinental elite.

It's a shame too - Mr Perfect really was every bit as good as he claimed. The over-reaching seller Dolph Ziggler patterned himself upon, Perfect had psychologically sound long matches in him whenever required that utilised the bumps as features rather than fluff. Relatively small for the time, Perfect played the big-timer with such aplomb that he felt ten-foot tall against Hulk Hogan and The Ultimate Warrior even when both reduced him to mincemeat in the actual matches.

Still considered a seminal Intercontinental Champion, he was a good example of a man making a belt, with his post-Warrior runs reestablishing the strap as a "workers' title ahead of similarly important stints with Bret Hart and Shawn Michaels. Despite fleeting moments at the top of the card, Perfect's status one rung below did more for said level than anything higher could ever do for him.


1. Owen Hart

Shawn Michaels Owen Hart
WWE

Often graced with gold thanks to Tag, Intercontinental and Slammy Award success, Owen Hart was familiar with WWE gold. The company's top prize evading him was as much to do with timing as it was talent.

Though delighting between the ropes for much of 1994, Bret and Owen Hart's WWE Title programme drew poorly at box offices already hammered by a business in decline. He carried the midcard underneath the political minefield presided over by his brother and Shawn Michaels, but fell short as a babyface and a heel during the rises of both Stone Cold Steve Austin and The Rock in 1997 and 1998 respectively.

It was the former's dominance that ultimately doomed his headline aspirations before his utterly tragic death in 1999. Owen injuring Austin ahead of his earth-shaking industry dominance at SummerSlam 1997 marked his cards with 'The Rattlesnake' regardless of his otherwise-exceptional work between the ropes.

One of the great losses to the industry as a performer, Owen's comedic chops ensured even his final days as The Blue Blazer weren't wasted. Resilient in the wake of the Montreal Screwjob that decimated his family's place in company history, the Over The Edge 1999 tragedy was made worse because of his refreshingly realistic take on an industry he'd already planned to exit.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Michael is a writer, editor, podcaster and presenter for WhatCulture Wrestling, and has been with the organisation for 10 years. Alongside the production of daily written, audio and video content covering WWE and AEW, he also provides knowledge and insights on all aspects of the wrestling industry thanks to a passion for it dating back over 35 years. As one third of "The Dadley Boyz" Michael has contributed to the huge rise in popularity of the WhatCulture Wrestling Podcast and its accompanying YouTube channel, earning it top spot on the UK's wrestling podcast charts with over 10,000 episodes and 70,000,000 total downloads. He also co-hosts Benno & Hamflett, In Your House!, Podcast Horseman: The BoJack Horseman Podcast, and has guested on long-running Sunderland AFC podcast Wise Men Say. With WhatCulture, he has provided in-person coverage of some of the biggest pay-per-views and Premium Live Events in wrestling history, including WrestleMania, Survivor Series, All In & Double Or Nothing in destinations such as New York, New Jersey, Chicago, Dallas, Las Vegas, Philadelphia, London and Cardiff. He has also been featured as a wrestling analyst for the Tampa Bay Times, Fightful, POST Wrestling, GRAPPL, GCP, Poisonrana, 411Mania and Sports Guys Talking Wrestling. Michael's background in media stretches beyond wrestling coverage, with a degree in Journalism from the University Of Sunderland (2:1) and a series of published articles in music and culture magazines The Crack, Pilot as well as Sunderland AFC's premiere fanzine A Love Supreme. When not offering his voice up for daily wrestling podcasts, he can be found losing it every other Saturday at the Stadium Of Light, and at Cribs gigs nationwide.