10 Best Wrestling Gimmick Changes Of 2016
Some are better broken, others better decayed.
A gimmick can make or break a wrestler. We all know this by now, a sentence that probably didn't need to be written but was nonetheless. A great wrestler can become a true superstar with the right gimmick (hello Stone Cold Steve Austin) after all, and the various merits and issues of others can be truly accentuated by the character they are portraying.
Professional wrestlers are always evolving too, and whilst some end up portraying one character forever others cycle through persona after persona after persona. For a number of individuals on this list their newly-discovered 2016 character is just the latest in a long line of personalities. For some it is their finest yet.
2016 has been a strange year in professional wrestling, and arguably two of the strangest happenings came from men on this list Whether it was a slight tweak in the wrong direction or full-blown madness, gimmick changes have led to the reinvention and resurrection of numerous careers in 2016.
I'm not including plain old heel turns and haircuts in this, so no Usos and no Braun Strowman (sorry Braun). Nonetheless, here are the 10 best gimmicks changes in wrestling this year. Well, so far this year, at least.
10. Bone Soldier
We're yet to truly see the fruits of this labour, but Captain New Japan turning his back on the company in his name to side with Bullet Club as Bone Soldier deserves a place on any list. It was proof once more than however mind-numbing NJPW undercard booking can seem at times it almost always leads to something wonderful, something beautiful.
CNJ spent most of 2016 teaming with Yoshitatsu in the truly woeful Hunter Club team, which acted as a way for Yoshi to try out an awful Triple H cosplay whilst the Captain continued to get pinned. CNJ's continual defeats led to Yoshi conducting an old-fashioned Twitter poll (as in like to keep, re-tweet to not) to see whether the Captain would be allowed to stay in Hunter Club
Well, the Captain took matters into his own hands recently at Destruction in Kobe, turning his back on Yoshi and New Japan Pro Wrestling by joining up with Bullet Club as Bone Soldier. Whatever happens (and Bone Soldier getting pinned a lot is the only likelihood), Captain New Japan is truly interesting again for the first time in forever.
9. Naomi
One little side-note, I really don't understand why WWE's female wrestlers rarely have last names. Sure, things have improved in the last year with the addition of Alexa Bliss, Sasha Banks, Becky Lynch et al, but does this mean we can't now update all the one-name wonders in the division? Naomi, Bayley, Charlotte, Paige and the rest could do with it.
Up until the brand split Naomi had carved herself a fairly comfortable niche as midcard heel in the women's division. She'd performed well in the role over the last couple of years, but something was desperately needed to freshen her up. She was a veteran, but she was beginning to become a pretty boring one.
Enter a whole host of glowing.
Who knew, but a wrestler can instantly become more interesting with the addition of a mass of UV lighting and fun dancing. Naomi's glow persona has revitalised her career, and that elusive championship reign could be a real prospect in the future.
8. Hangman Page
Back to New Japan Pro Wrestling and in particular Ring of Honor for number eight, but 2016 will be looked back upon as the year in which Adam Page woke up and began to stand out somewhat as a professional club. Much like Captain New Japan it took aligning with Bullet Club, but rather than becoming just another face in an overcrowded bunch Page seemed to gain an aura along with a new persona.
Simple old Adam Page transformed into Hangman Page, and if you weren't aware of what that meant he would walk around with a noose and literally hang battered bodies after his match. It all makes for a shocking visual, and has helped Page get over as a truly bad man.
He's also upped his game in between the ropes too, pulling off the biggest victory of his career at ROH Death Before Dishonor by defeating Jay Briscoe clean as a whistle in a street fight. 2017 may well be a big year for the Hangman.
7. The Shining Stars
Some may groan and moan at Primo and Epico featuring on any list with the word 'best' in the title, I don't think anyone can disagree with the change they have made in 2016. Los Matadores was fun for all of five minutes, but quickly headed into bullsh*t territory. With El Torito gone, there was truly no point to the gimmick anymore.
The Shining Stars may have taken forever to actually debut, but disingenuous but overly-enthusiastic Puerto Ricans is a much better fit for the duo. They can float around the tag division, and a tag title run isn't out of the question eventually for the two. This was practically unthinkable as Los Matadores.
Sure, they aren't the world's most entertaining duo, but in a division that contains New Day, Gallws & Anderson and Enzo & Big Cass they don't need to be. Quietly proficient pro wrestlers from a really nice place is a big upgrade from offensively stereotypical bullfighters.
6. Abyss
In 2016 Abyss joined that rarest of professional wrestling clubs; he removed his mask and became all the better for it. A number of folk raised their eyebrows when the TNA original sided with Crazzy Steve (so crazy, so many z's) and Rosemary as Decay, but as the year trundles towards its climax it is difficult to argue with the change being anything other than a total success for the monster.
It wasn't the first time Abyss had joined up with a stable of lost souls. Heck, it was the second time in two years he'd decided to do that. Still, Decay has ended being a much bigger success than James Storm's Revolution ever was, a seven-month tag title reign being the highlight.
Abyss has reinvented himself in 2016 by finally coming to terms with his role. Rather than being the singles centrepiece of an issue Abyss' role is to be an imposing monster within a group, within a bigger hole. The 2016 change may well have seen his career extended.
5. Heath Slater
A subtle one this, but a change nonetheless. 12 months ago you would have got extremely long odds on Heath Slater being the biggest success story of a WWE brand split. You probably would have gotten shorter odds on Slater actually being released at some point during the year. Yet, here we stand in October 2016 with Heath Slater as popular as he has ever been as well as being one half of the SmackDown Tag Team Champions.
Slater's change has seen him go from obnoxious loser who overstates his own importance and abilities to the everyman's fighting man. Sure, he may still be somewhat delusional, but he's doing this for his wife and for his kids and for his above ground pool. It is a minor tweak, but it has been huge for the career of the Red Dragon.
I wouldn't put money on it lasting however, as it may well have only been a short deal. Once the titles are lost, does Slater return to enhancement level jobbing? Does it matter? No, not really. The last three months have arguably been the best of Heath Slater's career.
4. SANADA
What's that quote again? 'Fool me once, shame on you. Fool me twice, shame on me'? Yeah, that's the one. Well, just a couple of years after humiliating and embarrassing then-future and current-New Japan Ace Kazuchika Okada, TNA may well have let another future Ace slip through their fingertips.
Sanada was a one-time X-Division Champion in TNA, but he is mostly remembered for turning on The Great Muta and joining up with James Storm's stable 'Sh*tstorm'. Oh wait, no, sorry, 'The Revolution'. Sanada was wasted in indoctrinations and cult-rubbish, and when he left TNA in April 2015 nobody was really that bothered.
Fast forward to 2016 and SANADA (now stylised in all caps) finds himself in an alternative stable once more, but holy moly has the perception of him changed. SANADA is quite clearly a can't-miss future main event performer for New Japan Pro Wrestling, and I dare say the inevitable SANADA vs. Tetsuya Naito match will be one of the best we see in 2017.
SANADA's move to quiet cold machine has opened a lot of eyes to his potential. Remember his name folks.
3. Brian Kendrick
Going into the 2016 WWE Cruiserweight Classic, a lot of people where happy to see Brian Kendrick on the brackets. A wildly talented performer, most remembered Brian Kendrick as either one half of a record-breaking tag team duo with Paul London or strutting around with Ezekial Jackson as The Brian Kendrick.
TNA fans might even remember him from a brief X-Division Championship run in 2011, where he portrayed a spaced-out hippy, or something along those lines. We'd also seen posts of him working as a trainer at the WWE Performance Center, so at best we expected him to return as a legend-type character.
Well, what we got instead was Post-Apocalyptic Scavenger Brian Kendrick, a man desperate to make something of his career and putting his best performances in the process. He was a changed man, and no matter how much we may have wanted to cheer him his character work was so strong that we couldn't.
By shedding the character fat, removing any trace of pretence and purely becoming a guy who knows his time is running out, Brian Kendrick has ironically given his career a true renaissance.
2. Chris Jericho
We're all in agreement that Chris Jericho is pretty much the greatest man who ever lived, right? The man has reinvented himself over and over, and whilst not every single change has been a hit more often than not Y2J has been on the money. When Jericho returned again at the beginning of 2016 however, 'Cool Dad Jericho' was falling solidly in the 'miss' column.
One heel turn later and many are claiming that Chris Jericho is doing the best work of his career. In many ways the current incarnation of Chris Jericho is all of the previous ones combined, with a bit of salty veteran on top. He has somehow managed to get the insult 'stupid idiot' over, as well as the word 'it'. If that isn't skill, I don't know what is.
Chris Jericho is one of the most entertaining performers in WWE TV. This in itself isn't a huge surprise, but the changes he has made to his gimmick this year have ended any argument against him being in the 'Greatest Of All Time' discussion.
1. Broken Matt Hardy
It couldn't have been anyone else. When we look back on 2016 there will be a number of things that happened that we truly didn't see coming. AJ Styles and Shinsuke Nakamura arriving in WWE came out of left field, as did the brand split and various stories that came from it. Heck, no one expected The Rock vs. Erick Rowan to happen at WrestleMania, and even less people expected Zack Ryder to win a singles championship.
Even so, the biggest story of the year may well be the fact that TNA has become must-see all over again, and that is thanks to Matt Hardy. Matt, frequently regarded as the second most interesting Hardy brother, not only resurrected his entire reputation by becoming Broken but he also repaired an entire company in the process.
Broken Matt Hardy is true genius, despite the fact it is utterly preposterous. He speaks in a stupid accent, makes absolutely no sense and is able to withstand mist attacks. The whole thing is ridiculous, but that may well by why it is so glorious. Broken Matt Hardy isn't just the best gimmick change of 2016; it may well be one of the best of all time.