10 Best Wrestling Matches Of 2017
Pro wrestling is f*cking great.
Honourable mentions are vast.
AJ Styles Vs. John Cena, from Royal Rumble 2017, was better than most of Big Match John's Big Matches because his freakish strength was used as a narrative driver, and not something to ignore in service of a near-fall popcorn festival. The leviathan Fatal 4-Way at SummerSlam was very much the insane and spectacular demolition derby WWE promised us. Styles and Lesnar, after inconsistent years, made fools out of SmackDown creative and doubters alike by contesting a phenomenal and totally believable war at Survivor Series.
Prior to their respective break-up and call-ups, #DIY and The Revival crafted several more tag team stunners as athletically exciting as they were psychologically rich. Tomohiro Ishii continued to master the art of ballsy selling in countless dramatic battles. Zack Sabre, Jr. entered what was arguably his best in-ring year yet, grounding Will Ospreay in a recent minimalist masterclass. He still didn't quite make the cut.
Asuka; WALTER; Hiromu Takahashi; Ricochet; the Young Bucks; The Usos; The New Day; Yuji Nagata; Roman Reigns; Braun Strowman; Io Shirai; Shuji Ishikawa: all wrestled matches ranging from excellent to minor classic territory.
In any other year, their superb matches would comprise this list.
This wasn't any other year.
This was arguably the greatest year ever for the grand art of the pro wrestling match.
10. Keith Lee Vs. Donovan Dijak - PWG Battle Of Los Angeles Night 3
In 2013, Katsuyori Shibata and Tomohiro Ishii wrestled a categorical classic - a brutal p*ssing contest masquerading as a pro wrestling match, in which both strong style specialists almost politely smashed each other into smithereens.
Keith Lee Vs. Donovan Dijak adopted a similar narrative template, in that the two goliaths shared an unspoken agreement to wrestle a vintage PWG-style match despite their apparent physical limitations. With an explosion of backflips and cartwheels, the 6' 3", 332 lb Lee and the 6' 7", 270 lb Dijak performed moves, threaded with a narrative of oneupmanship, that they had no physical right to pull off.
For a grasp on the size of these two men, and the stage on which they wrestled, the ring broke with a simple Irish whip - which lent the subsequent carnage a genuine atmosphere of anxiety. Every time they ascended to the top turnbuckle, or flew into one other with stunning moonsaults, the ring threatened to collapse. More than a hollow succession of marquee spots and exhilarating one-count kick-outs, the element of showmanship and body language was unreal; when Dijak kicked out of another ridiculous bomb, Lee clung onto his shoulders with an expression of rage and disbelief.
The Monstars t-shirt trade-off tease could not have acted as a more fitting visual metaphor; this was a literally awesome pro wrestling match contested by two men as ultra-talented as they were ultra-gigantic, tearing a human-sized stage to shreds.
9. Tyler Bate Vs. Pete Dunne - NXT TakeOver: Chicago
This incredible UK Title match really could not have been executed any better.
Performing in front of a vast arena crowd, about half of which got in on the ground floor, this was structured to get the entire building shaking by the final three count. Bate and Dunne performed a beautiful display of technicality in the opening minutes, framed as a sort of transatlantic courtship ritual for those unfamiliar with their state-of-the-art update on the British style. Dunne, outclassed and humiliated, suckered Bate into the outside to escalate this match into a fight.
Strength vs. viciousness, showmanship vs. sociopathy, the pure of heart vs. the cold of blood: this was a match of meshing contrasts wrestled by two men with stunning chemistry. The sight of Dunne reversing a standing shooting star press into a choke, and wasting no motion as he hammered Bate on the top of the head with wincing elbows, fused the gritty integrity of British chain wrestling with the sort of spectacular agility that cemented the fashionable cult appeal of the "graps" scene.
It's easy enough to encourage an American crowd to chant "USA!" at a wrestling show. Even Jinder Mahal managed it in patches throughout the dismal summer months. The sound of thousands and thousands of Chicagoans screaming "UK! UK! UK!" was the commendation for the sheer awesomeness that was this match.
"Fight forever" was another chant bestowed upon the two Brits. It was just as well they didn't take it literally; at 15:28, this didn't need a self-consciously "epic" length - nor traditional "big match" stalling and build - to put it over as a big match.
8. Kenny Omega Vs. Tetsuya Naito - NJPW G1 Climax Final
Not a mere exhibition of athletic brutality, this, the classic final of a classic 2017 G1 Climax tournament, acted as Tetsuya Naito's absolution.
Naito won the 2013 tournament to apathy at best, resentment at worst: he simply did not get over as the manufactured successor to company Ace Hiroshi Tanahashi. His self-proclaimed status as the top star of New Japan Pro Wrestling rang hollow. In order to do, and not say, he adopted the aloof attitude of his latter CMLL Los Ingobernables faction mates en route to capturing the imagination of NJPW fans as a tranquilo wrestler for the millennial generation.
The 2017 final, opposite Kenny Omega, subverted that career arc. He feigned insouciance in the early exchanges before, in a pacing masterclass, putting his physical wellbeing on the line in a spate of insane spots. In something unprecedented, Naito even took a DDT into the ring post for his art. Naito emerged from the match as the undisputed top star of New Japan. He d*mn near destroyed himself to prove himself worthy of the accolade, and he d*mn near detroyed Omega to put himself on his Best In The World level.
As unbelievably good as this was, even by New Japan's meteoric 2017 standard, Omega drilled Naito with such brutal, crunching V-Triggers that anxiety superseded the drama at the finish. The aural sensation experienced by the viewer was almost as sickening to absorb as the impact must have been to Naito. Moreover, Omega's neck looked like an accordion following a gruesome top-rope reverse Frankenstein spot.
It was a match that, because and in spite of itself, generated concern and optimism for the future.
7. Kazuchika Okada Vs. Minoru Suzuki - NJPW The New Beginning In Sapporo
It's hard not to rate this in a comparative context. It was impressive for what it wasn't, as much as for what it was; after inflicting a knee injury on Okada in a pre-match press conference, Suzuki targeted the weakened appendage with his trademark psychopathic zeal throughout the epic 40 minute duration.
That, essentially, was the entire narrative heft. There were no top rope dragon suplexes, no dangerous table spots - this was a pure and strategic wrestling match elevated into classic territory through the magic of Kazuchika Okada's expert selling. Not that Suzuki was there purely to supply the fuel; his psychotic facial expressions, contrasted with the agony etched across Okada's face, put this over as something intensely believable despite the sports entertainment hijinks of the interfering Suzuki-gun stable.
But even in isolation, this was something deeply impressive. It was no mat slog; Okada displayed his trademark, tremendous athleticism to escape Suzuki's wrath, but in a match of endless peaks and troughs, crumpled to the mat in agony in order to yield every last dramatic and psychological wrinkle. Suzuki's smooth and sudden submission transitions restored that narrative crux just when it was thought Okada himself had recovered - all of which made the grand reckoning of Okada's last comeback all the more satisfying.
This all might read as dry - as if the match was something to admire, more than to actively enjoy - but the sheer realism of Okada's selling wrenched elusive, genuine sympathy from an audience used to something more cosmetically spectacular.
6. Hiroshi Tanahashi Vs. Tetsuya Naito - NJPW G1 Climax Day 17
Once in awe of Hiroshi Tanahashi, Tetsuya Naito wrestled him in the first few minutes of this emotional war as if he could not give a toss about him.
Tanahashi, incensed, twice slapped the sh*t out of him to establish - at least initially - a heel role. It made sense from a psychological perspective; Tanahashi, ostensibly fighting with one arm, felt he had to infuriate Naito into abandoning his strategy. The Ryogoku fans, already firmly in Naito's corner, hated Tanahashi for this - until Naito worked over his bandaged bicep. Tanahashi's selling was so consistent and so believable that he split the partisan crowd with biblical psychology. A true wrestling God, Tanahashi performed here with the character complexity of a Tony Soprano or a Chuck McGill, creating an internal conflict within the crowd externalised as a deafening cacophony.
Tanahashi uses the dragon screw multiple times in his matches, and you never see them coming. This was no different. Several times he inspired hope just as it was thought all was lost - but the move dealt his own health bar a hammer blow, creating a level of unpredictability that was sublime, given the machinations of the wider tournament.
With the time limit hovering in the background, the last few minutes developed an unbearable level of drama; as Tanahashi wrenched Naito in a second Cloverleaf, referee Red Shoes threatened to throw the match out - without realising Tanahashi was destroying his own bicep just to maintain the pressure.
An ingenious lesson in wrestling psychology, this proved that a one-armed Tanahashi > 99.9% of a ROTW in rude health.
5. Kazuchika Okada Vs. Katsuyori Shibata - NJPW Sakura Genesis
Finally: after years in the midcard wilderness, of eating defeat to Toru Yano and endlessly sparring with old college roommate Hirooki Goto, Katsuyori Shibata was finally afforded the platform of a major IWGP Heavyweight Championship match.
A brutal battle between New Japan's golden boy and black sheep, Okada Vs. Shibata was a phenomenal platform on which to both get the former over and put the latter over. Okada, the Ace, simply could not contend with the aural atrocities that were Shibata's forearm blows and kicks to the back. The layout was ingenious, given its purpose; this wasn't a test of Shibata's title credentials, but Okada's ability to survive in the face of a monster who, in the best moment of a masterpiece justified by the intra-match psychology, no-sold the most devastating finisher in all of wrestling.
Okada is very much in the Bret Hart mould. The balance in his performances is incredible. His ability to hoist opponents to his level without lowering his own is astonishing, and this was the closest we'll ever get to a proper sequel to Hart Vs. Steve Austin at WrestleMania 13, bravery-as-blood-trickle and all - but the grim irony is that this was the direct opposite of a career-maker for Katsuyori Shibata, who was forced to retire following the subdural hematoma he suffered.
A classic in itself, but an incrimination of Shibata's brutal update on strong style, it was the most absorbing wrestling cautionary tale ever told.
Wrestling cannot - and should not - get much better than this.
4. Will Ospreay Vs. KUSHIDA - NJPW Best Of The Super Juniors Final
In 2016, Will Ospreay divided the wrestling fandom by wrestling a futuristic match opposite Ricochet in New Japan's Best Of The Super Juniors tournament.
Wrestling wasn't the operative word for some, who condemned it as cooperative performance dance. The beautiful, insanely convoluted aerials weren't enough to convince them that it was a thing of beauty; it was used as a stick with which to beat it.
The progression of Ospreay's work in 2017 is terrifying - as terrifying as the batsh*t bumps he doled out in this outstanding BOSJ final opposite KUSHIDA. Ospreay, apparent transgressor of the art of selling, let out such believable, agonised howls here that you could totally believe KUSHIDA had wrenched his arm out of his socket each time he applied the Hoverboard Lock - the best application of which saw KUSHIDA leap to join a falling Ospreay from the top rope in a perfectly-timed fusion of submission and aerial work. A cheap shortcut it might have been, but Ospreay's "You f*cking little c*nt" rallying cry proved totally immersive in putting this over as an emulation of an actual fight.
The sickening reverse apron Frankensteiner spot stole the headlines - but the real story was of KUSHIDA's belated march to the critical pinnacle, Ospreay's new-found, genius grasp of selling, and their shared masterpiece of strategy and spectacle.
3. Kazuchika Okada Vs. Kenny Omega - NJPW G1 Climax Day 18
What Kazuchika Okada and Kenny Omega achieved in the ring together throughout 2017 was magical. That may read as histrionic, but there is no more accurate way of putting it.
Able to pose a single narrative question and somehow build G.O.A.T-level masterpieces around it, this third bout in their series was essentially a sprint match somehow stretched out to 25 unbelievably dramatic minutes. Though not as epic as their first two matches, there was arguably more to admire here; without the luxury of a proper puroresu main event duration, they wrestled a contender for greatest match of all time, regardless.
This was a true sequel, in that it relied on the groundwork laid in the prior two matches to create do-or-die stakes. The non-final G1 Climax 30:00 time limit stipulation added another brilliant dimension to it. These warriors had wrestled for a combined 1:46 in January and June; 30 minutes seemed like nothing. There was no way of making it believable, in comparison. New Japan booker Gedo arguably deserves a major level of credit; the worked neck injury suffered by Okada throughout the tournament, combined with the time restriction, created an unbearable sense of danger and urgency.
And they still left space for a further match down the line: as quickly as Omega answered the elusive question, the validity of his victory was cast in doubt. He'd beaten Okada - but could he beat Okada at 100%?
Perfectly booked, perfectly worked - this was a triumph that conclusively made fools of everybody who fretted over Okada and Omega sharing the same block.
2. Kazuchika Okada Vs. Kenny Omega - NJPW Wrestle Kingdom XI
The greatest trick this match pulled off was that it somehow left room for a sequel(s).
Kazuchika Okada and Kenny Omega did everything over the epic 46:45 duration: top-rope dragon suplexes, harrowing, dangerous table spots, sick top-rope dropkicks to the back of the head, insane moonsaults, V-Triggers delivered with the crunch of a watermelon exploding on concrete - it was a festival of content that, at first, seemed designed to compensate for the challenger's relative lack of presence on the company's biggest stage.
But it was all woven together with one simple, coherent narrative thread, perfect for the many new eyes focused on New Japan's biggest show of the year: could Omega ever detonate the One-Winged Angel, and could Okada withstand the blast?
Like the greatest works of art, the artists left that question unanswered - Omega never did hit it - and like proper workers, they mined as much heated drama from the space between moves, as much as the moves themselves. It was an athletic impossibility - hermetic and entirely botch-free, despite the ridiculous stamina required to pull it off. Okada's various escapes from atop Omega's shoulders were jaw-dropping. It was as if he was made from rubber at times.
The level of drama and emotion was so incredible that, as Okada celebrated with the IWGP Heavyweight Crown, the cameras captured crying members of the audience. The match was overwhelmingly good.
That sequel also did the impossible: it bettered the original...
1. Kazuchika Okada Vs. Kenny Omega - NJPW Dominion
Was this the greatest wrestling match ever performed?
There is a strong argument in its favour; an hour-long draw that bent space and time in how fast it flew, with an outcome obvious in retrospect but inconceivable in the exhilarating thrill of the moment, this was a multi-layered, athletic masterpiece of subplots performed by two guys with the ability to create a classic from the 'A' story alone. Okada's injured knee; Cody's teased towel throw; the shocking detonation of the One-Winged Angel and the even more shocking rope break: this was an absurdly rich performance that rewards replays with its unending minutiae. The timing of Okada's festival of dropkicks in the final act was tremendous, given how knackered he must have been. The pacing, too - every last one was struck from the death, just as it was thought Omega had finally put him away.
But it was Kenny Omega who devised the pinnacle of the programme's ingenuity.
The greatest spot of the match - the greatest, most iconic spot of the year - wasn't a spot at all. As Okada teed Omega up for a drastically late Rainmaker lariat, Omega, spent, evaded it purely by accident. He slumped to his knees, practically unconscious, before Okada could connect. For a series defined by the transcendence of athletic limitations, this was the psychological work of a genius wrestling a match themed on exhaustion.
What's far more uplifting than pedantic is that the match wasn't quite flawless. Okada's selling was ****3/4, not ******1/4. Omega was shaky on the ropes before he delivered his springboard moonsault.
They can do even better. If they can resist the urge to revisit the series until Wrestle Kingdom XIII, Omega Vs. Okada IV may be the most anticipated match in the modern history of professional wrestling.