10 Best Wrestling Matches With The Worst Builds

For a vegan, Bryan Danielson sure knows how to make chicken salad.

Daniel Bryan Luke Harper
WWE

Every single wrestling match has an in-built story, contrary to the horrific discourse you've no doubt encountered this year.

The idea is to draw on an attribute - strength, technique, resilience, the willingness to take risks, the psychotic abandon of one's senses to just block out the pain and keep punching and punching - and defeat one's opponent in order to make a successful visit to the "pay winda".

If this whole thing was meant to be on the up and up, every U.S. promotion should book cold "fixtures" as a matter of course to make the events of episodic television feel less contrived. WWE doesn't care about this, and increasingly, AEW does not either, sadly.

That should form only part of the weekly experience.

At its core, these are pro wrestling promotions. The idea should be to promote the living daylights out of a match and make it feel enormous, heated, unpredictable, like you cannot wait for it to happen. In the case of major events, events that cost a not insignificant one-off fee or yet another streaming subscription, you should be emotionally engaged before the bell rings.

Some matches are so good, however, that they can shake you from your numbed - or even irritated - disposition...

10. Brock Lesnar Vs. Daniel Bryan - WWE Survivor Series 2018

Daniel Bryan Brock Lesnar
WWE.com

In the old, mercifully dead days of Raw Vs. SmackDown, the World champions of the respective shows wrestled one another.

Up there with the stupidest developments in WWE's modern history - top stars did jobs for stakes nobody gave a hoot about on an annual basis - the format reached a dire lull when, in 2017, WWE seemed to forget which month they were in. Paul Heyman outright said - on television - that even he couldn't promote WWE Champion Jinder Mahal, fellow heel, as a threat to Universal champion Brock Lesnar. Realising that there was no better time to end the experiment, the belt was swiftly awarded to AJ Styles.

Worse, arguably, was the 2018 edition: just five days away from the show, WWE suddenly realised that they had sleep-walked into a second consecutive Styles Vs. Lesnar match, and the decision was made to turn Daniel Bryan heel to win the WWE title and wrestle...fellow heel Brock Lesnar.

What?

It's just as well the Bryan was a pro wrestling genius capable of keeping his heat.

Faced with a cursed set of circumstances - of course WWE gave Bryan his dream match and messed up the dynamic at the same time, of course they did - Bryan laid out a masterpiece of a structure. A sort of squash/sprint hybrid that defied every convention, Bryan seamlessly transitioned from underdog to killer, perfecting an impossible task, by playing dead and lulling Brock into a massacre of strikes. He beat the piss out of him, earning some of the most scorching near-falls ever witnessed in a WWE ring, and he did it not with babyface spirit by conniving heel tactics.

Bryan Danielson's AEW run might be his best ever - but this was his masterpiece.


9. Will Ospreay Vs. Chris Jericho - AEW All In: London

Chris Jericho Will Ospreay
AEW

This will take some unpacking.

Chris Jericho wanted a match with Will Ospreay at Wembley because why wouldn't he want a match against Will Ospreay in 2023?

To get there, a lot of contrivance had to happen.

In May, Jericho acknowledged that he had lost a lot of big matches over the past few months. He was then courted by Don Callis who, and it's important to remember this, is one of the most evil, conniving characters in AEW. Over the next few weeks, Callis attempted, much to the chagrin of the Jericho Appreciation Society, to recruit Jericho into his Family. Jericho made the decision to banter off his useless mates, only Callis, expecting Jericho to say no, turned on him.

Why bother trying to recruit him, then?

This positioned Jericho as a terrible babyface, and Will Ospreay, Essex-born, was always going to be received by the Wembley crowd as a babyface regardless - despite his alignment with Callis.

A total nightmare of gaping plot holes and broken character alignments, it was also a complete waste of time: an infuriating, gibberish build all for a 15 minute match with duelling chants.

The actual All In: London match was fantastic:. Set against a massive, potentially unprecedented backdrop, Jericho worked a lean, abbreviated version of the Will Ospreay classic: a pissy, stiff, lung-bursting back-and-forth in which Jericho, at 52, did more than hang in there.

Ospreay was typically incredible, feeding Jericho the back of his skull to make even the most quaint of baseball slides look devastating, but Jericho created some awesome movement of his own with an unfathomable, rapid hurricanrana Stormbreaker reversal.


8. MJF Vs. Darby Allin Vs. Jack Perry Vs. Sammy Guevara - AEW Double Or Nothing 2023

Sammy Guevara Jack Perry
AEW

While it was bold and important that AEW attempted to position the core of its original youth movement as the next fleet of headliners, the premise was asking a lot of the audience.

There was too much tell, don't show here: while MJF had certainly ascended to the main event bracket, and Darby Allin with a better story and build could have challenged him on PPV in a singles, fans simply did not take Jack Perry nor Sammy Guevara seriously at that level.

Unconvincing premise, weird storyline: MJF and Sammy Guevara shared wonderful and legitimately funny chemistry, but Guevara, a natural heel, was booked on a babyface redemption arc by refusing to throw the match. There were babyfaces in the double digits that fans would have preferred to see at that level. Darby Allin was one of them, but he celebrated a bye in an ill-advised Pillars 'Tournament' that meant nothing, since the Four-Way had been signposted. Perry's worked shoot edgelord promo work was annoying, bluntly. This all made sense of his turn in retrospect, but it was exhausting and small fry in real-time.

The match was an incredible spectacle, mind: a 28 minute sprint that never once stopped accelerating, somehow, it was worked with the demented OTT creativity of peak PWG. Folding in wit (the ganging up of MJF), warmth (the tributes to each Pillar's mentor) and absurdly complex and electrifying sequences (the quadruple Canadian destroyer exchange being the highlight), it was a heart-pounding fireworks display.

But a noble failure all the same.


7. Daniel Bryan & Roman Reigns Vs. Luke Harper & Erick Rowan - WWE Hell In A Cell 2019

Daniel Bryan Luke Harper
WWE

2019 might well be the worst year in WWE history.

2004 was horrific - an absolute state of desperate creative and badmatches, in which WWE's arrogance and ineptitude caught up with them. 1995 was the anti-zeitgeist, but Bret Hart was still Bret Hart at least. 2020 was nightmarish, on every conceivable level, but 2019 was madness.

Madness best exemplified by the storyline in which Daniel Bryan's heater Erick Rowan attacked Roman Reigns backstage and fooled Bryan into thinking his doppelgänger just happened to be there. Roman Reigns entertained the notion in a cliffhanger, too. By this point, Vince McMahon had made his idiotic babyfaces impossible to root for with his extravagantly marshmallow-brained creative.

This was all paid off in a match, and what a match. At Hell In A Cell 2019, Rowan was joined by Luke Harper who, despite being incredible, was yet again binned off afterwards.

The resulting Tornado tag was unreal.

It took a while to get going, because the heels went into it with zero heat, but they got there. They got there by, cutting off an awesome comeback, Rowan body-slammed Harper on top of Roman on the outside. In an awesome major set-piece, Rowan and Harper attempted to power bomb Bryan through a table, but he slipped out, and Roman jumped from the other announce table to spear Rowan's guts out.

A thrilling maelstrom of destructive action, beautifully arranged, WWE in a wider sense had rarely felt colder in a box office sense - but this was a white knuckle blockbuster from out of nowhere.


6. The Rock Vs. Steve Austin - WWF WrestleMania X-Seven

Steve Austin The Rock
WWE.com

Fred Durst did a better job of promoting the main event of WrestleMania X-Seven than the creative team.

You could hear him scream the word "YEAH!" over the 'My Way' video package, as Rock and Austin begin the hockey fight, and if you feel nothing - even if you watch it every single day, 22 years later - it's time to find a new hobby.

The package deftly obscures what was a terrible story. Mr. McMahon installed Debra as Rock's manager in a passé twist. That Debra was hardly a good performer hardly elevated what was desperately stale for-the-sake-of-it twisty Attitude Era material.

Debra was retconned out of the story in the classic sit-down interview - "Bam - non-factor!" - which was tense, captivating and foreshadowed the finish. Beyond that, though, Austin and Rock simply stared at one another, when conveniently coming together, before coming to blows and trading and stealing finishers.

The finisher trades and thefts in the actual 'Mania event worked to far greater effect.

The idea was that Rock and Austin simply could not be separated in a fair fight. It was real, too: they were the tippy-top household name megastars who somehow happened to come along at the same time. The finisher theft trope conveyed the profound mutual respect between the two, and ramped up the impossible drama, but the core competitive rivalry was illustrated by the incandescent brawling.

The finish practically killed the business, but the match so was undeniable that the terrible idea was executed brilliantly. Austin looked like a psychopath in there.


5. Cody Rhodes Vs. Seth Rollins - WWE WrestleMania 38

Cody Rhodes Seth Rollins
WWE.com

Given that a few months of it were booked by Vince McMahon, WWE has handled Cody Rhodes perfectly. He is the top babyface, raises the roof every time he appears, and sells tickets out the ass. Incredible at firing up, espousing good virtues and charming the arse off the public in a PR setting with his candour and wit, he embodies timeless babyface traits with a modern, self-deprecating sensibility.

Really, the only thing WWE has done wrong, aside from the endless uninspiring Judgment Day matches, was his introduction.

Or at least the bit leading up to it.

Basically, despite being a top star, Seth Rollins was annoyed that he didn't have a match at WrestleMania. At his most clownish, he visited Mr. McMahon's office. Vince called him a failure, but also said that Seth only had to ask to get a match. It was a strange, unfunny skit. WWE had lost the plot of why Vince was why he was. Seth feared getting fired and received the news of getting a match like a competition winner.

The presentation of Cody's debut at WrestleMania was fantastic, but also deeply surreal. Honestly, it was impossible to pay attention to the first five minutes. The visual of AEW Cody in WWE was just insane. He was the face and soul of the competition, and had buried WWE as a hobby.

That only underscores how gripping the basic story was, the masterful pace at which it unfolded. It had to be great to lock everybody in, and it was great.

Proper old pro stuff with none of the boring connotations, in one incredible moment - the first beat of the Story, winning the big one for his father - he stopped short of executing the Cross Rhodes and instead channelled Dusty with the flip, flop and fly.


4. FTR Vs. Young Bucks - AEW Full Gear 2020

FTR Young Bucks
AEW

It's not entirely correct to state that the story between FTR and the Young Bucks was poor.

The booking between Double Or Nothing and All Out 2020 was sublime in how it elevated the World Tag Team titles as a nigh-on unwinnable prize. FTR had to embark on an intricate campaign to destroy the Elite from within, just to disrupt Kenny Omega and Hangman Page's special chemistry. They played the Young Bucks, feigning mutual respect, as part of it.

Between All Out and Full Gear, things went wrong, undermining the ideal set of circumstances. FTR had turned. The Bucks were positioned to take the titles in their company, for the first time, at the expense of the team they had to beat to call themselves the best of their generation.

What went wrong?

In a bid, presumably, to give fans the version of The Young Bucks Vs. the Revival that fans idly dreamt of in 2016, the Bucks played it all with a heelish slant. They pouted, and super-kicked broadcasters and officials, and if the idea was to revert back to the bratty imps of early Being The Elite, it didn't work. They were just sulky.

The match was exquisite, so incredibly dramatic that 1,000 distanced fans felt like 10,000 packed.

While it was a love letter to the medium, it wasn't too pretentious. FTR used many famous moves from great teams past, but did so chronologically, which tied into the finish. FTR slowly lost their head over the course of match, attempting to beat the Bucks at their own heavily modern game, and it all culminated in a defiant, foolhardy Cash Wheeler blowing a springboard 450. This was a great, great set-up for a rematch. FTR lost, but perhaps wouldn't have, if they had stayed true to themselves.

And, if it did threaten to get too cute, Cash Wheeler spearing Nick Jackson out of his skin and through the ropes added some awesome, much-needed muscle.


3. Brock Lesnar Vs. John Cena - WWE Extreme Rules 2012

Brock Lesnar John Cena
WWE.com

"Worst" is a bit of a stretch, admittedly - but the build to Brock Lesnar's WWE return match was as uneven as it gets.

In one of the best pull-apart brawls in WWE history - one so good that WWE repeated the trick in every Brock Lesnar programme over the subsequent 11 years - Lesnar split John Cena's lip. Cena tried to smile defiantly through it, but looked so obnoxious that the anti-Cena camp were desperate to see Brock finish the job for $50.

Then, Lesnar conducted a sit-down interview and was asked what was running through Cena's mind. In one of the best lines of that era - not that competition was exactly fierce - he said that it isn't about what's running through his mind, but down his leg: "piss".

Then, they screwed it.

They screwed it by doing, yes, a contract signing that aimed to play on Lesnar's capricious nature and mercenary behaviour. He had a lot of demands. He said that he had a lot of demands about 800 times to John Laurinaitis. His intimidation factor eroded throughout the segment, and by the 600th time, the decision was made to bring back Paul Heyman as his mouthpiece at some point.

The Extreme Rules main event was frightening, so relentlessly and atypically brutal that suspension of disbelief - if it was even required, the hole in Cena's head was bigger than Headhunters A & B combined - has never been easier.

This was the bear scene from The Revenant masquerading as a wrestling match, differing only in that Leonardo DiCaprio didn't kip up and no-sell his mauling afterwards.


2. Money In The Bank Ladder Match - WWE Money In The Bank 2016

Money In The Bank 2016
WWE

The Money In The Bank ladder match should be as serious as business gets in WWE.

The entrants go to war of a horrifically violent kind, all in the pursuit of an all-but guaranteed World title win.

Leave it to late-period Vince McMahon to insult the intelligence of the audience, and make the wrestlers look even more stupid, by doing terrible comedy with a less-than-ideal visual.

You see, you are thick. You do not know how ladders work. To give your donkey brain half a chance of understanding the concept of a multi-man ladder match - they do one every year, but you'd forgotten, you dumb f*ck - each participant was shown on top of a ladder. A heel, if they had half a brain and were mean, like a heel should be, would have simply scarpered down and toppled them over.

Why not sell the most dangerous, high-stakes match in WWE by having wrestlers climb ladders - remember, they must do that in order to retrieve the briefcase - and trading terrible sub-three camera sitcom insults at one another?

Dean Ambrose begged them all to get to fighting, so at least one of them knew how absurd it was, but he also said he'd fight a polar bear or the mole people because even he couldn't be cool.

This did not do a thing to arouse a sense of bloodlust within the audience, which was dumb, because Kevin Owens and Sami Zayn in particular went hog wild in the match itself by bumping on upturned ladders.

The wild tonal shift from exposition and abysmal comedy to some of the sickest violence witnessed on the WWE stage was nonsensical, but that was 2010s WWE for you.


1. Trish Stratus Vs. Becky Lynch - WWE Payback 2023

Trish Stratus Becky Lynch
WWE.com

Sometimes - despite the defining discourse of 2023 - WWE does not actually tell a story. Or at least a good one.

Yes, Zoey Stark was added to the Becky Lynch Vs. Trish Stratus programme, which spanned from April to September. She helped Trish at Night of Champions and at Money In The Bank, so the feud was plotted. Incidents happened. But it was still so banal, nowhere near hefty enough to go as long as it did. It was a premise - Trish was jealous of Becky and the plaudits she received for elevating the division that Trish had in fact rescued from the depths - masquerading as a storyline.

Interferences, count-outs, DQs: the full carny gamut of uninspired WWE cliché was ran just to pad this premise out.

It didn't help that Becky and Trish shared anti-chemistry in the ring, either. The failed pursuit of the Women's Tag Team titles instigated the whole thing on the April 10 Raw, and it was a shambles. At Night of Champions, Becky had to grab Trish's legs in order to take a hurricanrana by herself. Idealess and actively bad, shockingly, the whole thing was rescued at the death.

The Payback Steel Cage blow-off was a triumph.

Remarkably tight and snug, given their previous form, Trish used her yoga-drilled flexibility to create a moment of heart-pounding terror when she flopped over the side of the cage before taking a superplex.

Much as it was built with great suspense as a modern genre affair, with spectacular, committed high spots, the all-important grudge tone was there - and they traded working punches in one class sequence that, while not '80s Memphis-tier exactly, were thrown with awesome gusto by Trish, who was a woman possessed to go out on a high.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!