10 Best WWE Debuts Of The 2010s

There have been many memorable debuts in WWE over the past decade, but which are the best?

Paige Debut AJ Lee
WWE

There's nothing quite like a first impression, especially in wrestling.

There have been many memorable debuts in the company over the years; Kane ripping off the door of the Hell in a Cell; Diamond Dallas Page revealing himself as the stalker; the Gobbledegooker bursting out of a giant egg. We said memorable, not good.

These maiden appearances have gone down in history (for one reason or another) and always come up in conversation when wrestling fans discuss "the best debuts of all time". But do any recent debuts deserve to be included in this discussion? Well, the following ten are certainly in with a shout.

WWE have had such an influx of talent over the past ten years and whilst it feels like the main roster has forgotten how to do a good debut right, there have been some exceptions to this.

The following ten debuts have been ranked on quality, memorability, and significance. There will be a few caveats for some of these debuts, but we'll get into those as and when we have to...

10. Bobby Roode

bobby roode nxt
WWE.com

There was nothing particularly spectacular about Bobby Roode's first appearance in NXT, but it began a beloved tradition that is still alive and well to this day.

Fans of TNA knew exactly who Bobby Roode long before he ever arrived in WWE. He was one of the promotion's biggest stars, winning almost a dozen championships with the company, including their top title twice.

He became a free agent in 2016 after over a decade with the company. Speculation ran rampant about where he would end up next, but very few people could have predicted that the next place we'd see Roode would be standing in the front row of an NXT show.

At TakeOver: Dallas - NXT's biggest show to date - Roode was shown standing in the crowd and everyone went ballistic. Here was one of the biggest unsigned acts in the world and he was just sat in the crowd, like just another fan.

Roode wouldn't make his first NXT TV appearance until four months later; the story of his signing being dragged out for months and months. Roode began the tradition of future signees sitting in the crowd of TakeOver events and, for that reason, he deserves an inclusion on this list.


9. Shinsuke Nakamura

Nakamura kick Zayn Turnbuckle DDT NXT TakeOver Dallas
WWE.com

NXT TakeOver: Dallas was a good night for debuts.

Not only did Bobby Roode start the tradition of the one-man NXT kiss-cam, but we also saw the debut matches of two top independent stars. One of which was Austin Aries (the less said about his WWE career, the better) and the other was The King of Strong Style, Shinsuke Nakamura.

Nakamura had been signed from New Japan in early 2016 and made his presence felt in NXT in the lead up to TakeOver: Dallas.

Nakamura was announced as NXT's latest signing by William Regal and appeared at Full Sail via video to confront Sami Zayn. Both men were positioned as huge babyfaces, which only heightened anticipation for this marquee match.

Right from the beginning, Nakamura had the crowd in the palm of his hand. His incredible entrance was followed up by an outstanding match which made both men look like absolute stars.

Nakamura wowed the NXT audience, bringing strong style to WWE for the first time. This match would be the launchpad for an incredible career, which saw Nakamura win the NXT Championship twice.

The first match in WWE to receive the "Fight Forever" chant, Nakamura's debut did exactly what it needed to do - show off what an incredible wrestler he is.


8. Ronda Rousey

Ronda Rousey Royal Rumble 2018
WWE

Pinning down the exact moment Ronda Rousey debuted is harder than it seems.

Many people would go straight to her tag match with Kurt Angle against Triple H and Stephanie McMahon at WrestleMania 34. However, she first appeared in WWE at a different WrestleMania three years before the one in New Orleans.

At WrestleMania 31, Rousey was pulled from the crowd by none other than The Rock to back him up against McMahon and Helmsley. This was the first time the MMA star set foot in a WWE ring, but it wasn't as a wrestler. More like a special guest.

The moment that Rousey first appeared with clear intentions of competing as a wrestler was at the end of Royal Rumble 2018. Rousey's music hit following the end of the first ever Women's Royal Rumble match and the crowd came unglued. This appearance was such a shock and it lead to one of the most remarkable rookie years in company history.

Combined with her high-profile appearance at 'Mania 31 and Rousey's debut - despite being stretched out over three years - remains one of the best examples of a transition from the world of MMA to the world of pro wrestling.


7. Adam Cole

Adam Cole Debut NXT Brooklyn III
WWE.com

People remember NXT TakeOver: Brooklyn as the night that The Undisputed Era debuted in NXT. However, this isn't strictly true.

Bobby Fish and Kyle O'Reilly had both appeared on NXT TV before, both in losing efforts to Aleister Black. However, they made themselves relevant when they first attacked new NXT Tag Team Champions, Sanity, and then NXT Champion, Drew McIntyre.

The former reDRagon were the accomplices to the real debutante in Brooklyn - former Bullet Club member and ROH Champion, Adam Cole (Bay-Bay).

Cole, whose appearance at the show had been rumoured for weeks, rushed the ring following McIntyre's NXT Championship victory over Bobby Roode. With help from Fish and O'Reilly, Cole beat the new champion down, delivering his trademark superkick to seal the deal.

Most fans in the know suspected that Cole was going to show up at this TakeOver, but few could have expected that he would be inserted straight into the main event picture and be given a badass new faction to boot.

Cole's debut set him on the path to the NXT Championship he holds today. This was a great moment befitting of a top level performer. And that's... nah, we're not doing that.


6. Paige

Paige Debut
WWE.com

When Paige arrived on the main roster in 2014, she set the bar for all future NXT call-ups to the main roster.

The British star cut off Divas Champion, AJ Lee, bringing the main roster's top women's champion face to face with NXT's biggest female star.

The then-NXT Women's Champion was challenge by AJ to a match for Lee's title. In one of the biggest shocks in WWE's recent history, the young star not only put on a great match with AJ, but she pinned her clean to become the youngest Divas Champion of all time.

Everything about this was executed perfectly. The shock of seeing an NXT star on the main roster. The calibre of opponent that Paige was paired with. The huge win that Paige was given on her first night. It did wonders for Paige and, even more importantly, wonders for NXT.

Fans now expected NXT stars to get the same treatment as Paige when they came up to the main roster. Whilst this hasn't always been the case, it made NXT feel like a big deal and put a whole new batch of eyes on the show.

Most impressively, Paige actually made people care about the Divas title. And have you seen that thing?


5. AJ Styles

AJ Styles Royal Rumble
WWE

There weren't many bigger names in 2016 to have never worked for WWE than "The Phenomenal" AJ Styles.

Styles made his name in the NWA, later becoming one of the biggest stars of TNA when it broke away from the organisation. After over a decade with the promotion, Styles left to pursue other ventures, most notably in New Japan, where he led the legendary Bullet Club faction.

Styles announced he was leaving the Japanese promotion on the day of their biggest show of the year. WWE themselves confirmed Styles' signing on the 20th January 2016 and it was just four days later that WWE fans would get their first glimpse of Styles since he made a handful of appearances for the company in 2002.

The 2016 Royal Rumble match featured a whole host of memorable names, all of whom were vying for Roman Reigns' WWE Championship. The third man to enter and the man who would last almost half an hour in the match was none other than AJ Styles.

The Orlando audience went wild when Styles appeared at the top of the ramp. Some fans believed they would never see Styles in a WWE ring, yet here he was in their signature match, competing for their top title.

AJ's WWE career has gone from strength to strength ever since and this debut played a huge part in his continued success.


4. The Nexus

John Cena Nexus
WWE.com

If this was a list of "promising debuts that led to crushing disappointments", then The Nexus would be a shoe-in for number one.

Before it was Triple H's personal toybox, NXT was a reality show, not that different from Tough Enough. Eight wannabe WWE superstars began the process until only one was left standing.

The winner of the show's inaugural season was Wade Barrett and many assumed he would go onto have a similarly unremarkable career to previous WWE reality show winners as Maven or Nidia. Not this time.

On a June 2010 episode of Raw, Barrett led the rest of the NXT competitors in a brutal attack on WWE Champion, John Cena. Barrett and his cronies - who included Justin Gabriel, Heath Slater, and Daniel Bryan - laid waste to Cena, as well as the entire ringside area. They destroyed the ring, attacked the commentary team, and even beat up Justin Roberts. That's a line you don't cross.

The Nexus lost a lot of their momentum very quickly after a string of bad booking decisions, but nothing could erase the impact of their incredible debut.

No group in the history of WWE has made a bigger impact upon its debut on the main roster. It's just a shame that WWE decided John Cena was a bigger priority than building seven new stars.


3. Kevin Owens

Kevin Owens John Cena
WWE

Kevin Owens clearly studied at The Nexus school of picking John Cena as your first feud.

Kevin Owens, the former Kevin Steen on the independent scene, has always been in the limelight in WWE. He won the NXT Championship less than two months into his time with the promotion and just three months after that, he exploded onto the main roster.

One of John Cena's United States Open Challenges was answered by Owens' mortal enemy, Sami Zayn. Zayn was unsuccessful in capturing the title, but he put on an amazing match. This riled up KO like nobody's business.

The next week on Raw, it was Owens who answered the open challenge, the NXT Championship over his shoulder. After a tense war of words with Cena, Owens attacked him, dropping the 16x world champion with a pop-up powerbomb. If that wasn't enough, Owens held the NXT Championship up and stomped on the US title.

Owens would go onto defeat Cena in his first main roster match. Putting him in a feud with the biggest star in the WWE showed that the company had huge faith in Owens and really legitimised the NXT Championship and the entire show in the eyes of the fans.

Not to mention the fact that Owens has won the Intercontinental, US, and Universal Championship since he laid out Cena.


2. The Shield

The Shield Debut
WWE.com

It's Survivor Series 2012 and CM Punk is in his now-infamous 434-day reign as WWE Champion. He's defending the championship in a triple threat match against John Cena and Ryback. This was back when Ryback was actually taken seriously.

Ryback is in unstoppable form. He looks like he's about to win the biggest title in sports entertainment when he hits Cena with a Shell Shocked. He goes for the pin, but he doesn't make it to three.

Ryback doesn't score the pin because he is attacked by three men dressed head-to-toe in black. The three men are all talent from NXT - Dean Ambrose, Roman Reigns, and then-NXT Champion Seth Rollins.

The trio beat Ryback senseless and hit what would become their signature move - the triple powerbomb. Ryback is dropped through the announce table, which provides enough of a distraction for Punk to pin Cena in the ring and retain his title.

The Shield, as they would come to be known, would go onto become one of the most popular acts of the last decade. This was a masterstroke in getting over a new act and probably the last time WWE truly created new main eventers.

Just a shame that one of them now works for AEW.


1. Sting

Sting Debut
WWE.com

Another Survivor Series, another amazing debut. Only this one wasn't from NXT or the indies. This was from a guy that many wrestling fans had written off of ever appearing in WWE.

During the final moments of the main event - a 5-on-5 match between Team Cena and Team Authority - Dolph Ziggler was facing Seth Rollins in a one-on-one showdown after overcoming 3-1 odds.

If Ziggler won, then The Authority would be ousted from power. Triple H, leader of The Authority, was opposed to this, naturally. And so he took Ziggler out and Seth was less than a second away from picking up the win. Then a crow cawed.

After decades of speculating, years of fantasy booking, and hundreds of thousands of faked WrestleMania posters, the man called Sting stepped into a WWE ring.

He was the face of WCW, a TNA Hall of Famer, the last person anyone expected to be in WWE. And yet there he was. Face to face with Triple H.

Sting ultimately saved the day for Team Cena and got rid of The Authority, but that wasn't the story. The story was that the greatest wrestler never to work for WWE was now a part of the company and the possibilities were endless.

Ok, maybe he only had four matches and one of them was against Big Show, but let us have this, alright?


In this post: 
Paige
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Jacob Simmons has a great many passions, including rock music, giving acclaimed films three-and-a-half stars, watching random clips from The Simpsons on YouTube at 3am, and writing about himself in the third person.