10 Best WWE Gimmicks That Were Only Used Once

Hot Dogs and Leap Frogs.

Concessions Kane
WWE

Going to the well once too often is the type of saying you've surely only heard from wrestling commentary. You especially, visitor of a wrestling website and/or reader of this wrestling article. Along with cities and states, spending more time than you should thinking about woodsheds and if having a head on a swivel will eventually be part of the human evolutionary process.

It's traditionally saved for a babyface high spot gone wrong or a heel's attempt to cheat that one last time without getting caught, but wrestling's repetitious reputation in general lends itself quite well to the old adage. Derived from the 14th century when going down wells for water was deemed worth the risk to get the reward (wait a minute...), WWE in particular will revisit old ideas all the time in an effort to milk what might of remained of the first attempt.

In their long form chats with Conrad Thompson, both Bruce Prichard and Eric Bischoff have, when the narrative has suited them, noted that Vince McMahon and Hulk Hogan would more than likely try what worked before than taking a risk on something new. Stone Cold Steve Austin went back to swigging beer at the end of 2001 when his heel turn's commercial revenue didn't match his critical acclaim. Ric Flair was, is, and will always be Ric Flair.

These one-and-dones were outliers. How? Why? And could they be given a second go?

10. Psychotic Wrestling Clown

Doink The Clown
WWE.com

It's important to distinguish the difference between most wrestling clowns and...well, Doink, mostly because WWE themselves never bothered to for fans that only found the show from the Attitude Era and beyond.

A product of the (mostly) post-Hulk Hogan/pre-New Generation 1992/1993 experimental period, Doink felt like a clap-back to critics that had long suggested that Vince McMahon's vision of pro wrestling had always been a circus. Sports Entertainment grew the industry through globalisation and licensing, not necessarily creative innovation. Territories and wrestlers still made money in the 1980s, but McMahon wanted all of it and the men he paid handsomely were happy enough with the renumeration and acclaim they'd receive to be part of his relentless travelling sideshow.

It'd be enough to send anybody apesh*t, which is ostensibly what happened to Doink at some point in his character's life. The performer behind the paint could wrestle - announcers always got this across - but had selected this specific persona to (badly) mask the psychotic urges and tendencies he indulged in between the ropes.

It'll almost never return, nor be given a fairer appraisal. That value range Money In The Bank cameo, in all its listless sadness, spoke to what the organisation actually think about it.


9. The Throwback Tag Team

The Revival
WWE.com

Throwback, or Revival. But don't call it that - after what happened to them, why would anybody want this impossible job anyway?

Dash Wilder and Scott Dawson were the first wrestlers not just to pay tribute to how things used to be but dedicate every facet of their act to it in order to make new what was deemed too old. In the glorious tapestry that was NXT, they were given room to do just that. They harboured no expectations of singles success, nor thirst to turn boos into ego-boosting cheers to sell more merch. The pair never betrayed their modus operandi as a couple of cheating pr* ks who knew exactly how to work around the rules, but constantly had bangers, as if to prove that the two things weren't mutually exclusive.

The Revival were the still points in an ever-changing doubles division, but making the move to the main roster themselves was where it all went wrong. After leaving the company in early 2020, the pair revealed how game they were to do any old Sports Entertainment bullsh*t if given the green light to have their matches afterwards, but Vince McMahon was all take and no give when it came to their booking.


8. Past-Middle Aged & Crazy

Kurt Angle Mae Young Angle Slam
WWE.com

It was vitally important for WWE fans to know that Terry Funk was in his mid-50s in 1998.

For one, he looked even older than that due to a life giving his body to the wrestling business, and also because the company were so obsessed with age as a stick to beat the WCW roster with that they then couldn't push this mad old f*cker without making it clear that his success was on him, not them finding space for it.

Context was all but lost when it came to explaining why (if, at all) age mattered on a wrestling show, but never had it been less needed than when Mae Young started taking sh*tkickings on the reg. This - and christ there really is nothing else like wrestling is there? - made sense. She was in her 70s, could be believably cast as older still, and was willing to take and sell the brutality of flying table spots or chairs and guitars to the head.

Horrifying yet darkly humorous, it's a tricky concept for a cleaner contemporary product to revist. Only Vince McMahon himself would fit the bill (he'll turn 76 in 2021, the age Young was when Bubba Ray Dudley powerbombed her off the stage), and his segments are now reduced to b*llocking his subordinates and negging his son-in-law.


7. Older People Have Sex

Mae Young Royal Rumble 2000 Censored
WWE Network

Right.

Before this turns into an "all the things they did with Mae Young in the Attitude Era" list (but after your writer adds that to his iPhone notes), this is not a call for another character to give birth to a hand, or have prosthetics attached to her chest in order to facilitate a way to get naked on a pay-per-view.

But - and please, take this leap just as Bubba Ray did back in 2000, back when we were all still happy - was her character actually progressive?

WWE's presentation of it categorically was not. It was thought disgusting by pervert-in-chief that a woman in her mid-70s would want to be held to the same standard as her peers in bikini contests and the like, no matter how satisfied Mark Henry was with their sex life.

Vince McMahon's complex relationship with his own ageism was and is part of the problem. He'd almost certainly want to be portrayed as a "genetic jackhammer" well into his hundreds if and when he makes it, but he'd presumably view a female being cast the same way with the same disdain he once shared with CM Punk about women's MMA.

This sort of sh*t has never been more hypothetical. The world is an impossible cultural shift away from WWE touching anything like this, but there'll come a point where that over-50s demographic they've managed to lock down might want more than they're getting, on and off screen.


6. Loose Cannon

Brian Pillman Loose Cannon
WWE.com

The very definition of backs-against-the-wall booking, Brian Pillman was brought in with a guaranteed contract by a WWE not famed for giving deals like that out in 1996 because they felt they had to.

The 'Loose Cannon' persona was one Pillman had cultivated - and largely lived by - after taking his career into his own hands in mid-1995. Great wrestling had finally gotten him as far as joining the Four Horsemen in WCW, but his creative juices were flowing beyond kowtowing to Ric Flair, Arn Anderson and an act that would rapidly be diminished by insecure babyface Hulk Hogan anyway.

By early-1996, there were few in the industry generating as much buzz. His legendary three-way work of the trio of top promoters in North America saw him convince Eric Bischoff into firing him, Vince McMahon into hiring him and Paul Heyman into keeping him on the agenda in between. His wildness was considered worth the respective risks by all three, even after totalling his car and injuring himself before WWE could make good on the incredible in-ring potential.

His commentary on Shotgun Saturday Night was incisive, hilarious and near-the-bloodied-knuckle, such was his willingness to take risks when he thought he could get away with them. This, more than anything else he did in 1997 before his tragic passing, speaks to why there'll never be another like him. Bravery and agency feel like the first pieces removed from a wrestler's personality at the Performance Center - the 'Loose Cannon' would have been diffused before 'The Ticking Time Bomb' exploded.


5. The Brother Of Legend Becomes A Legend

The Undertaker Kane
WWE

More on Kane later, but it's worth noting just how much life WWE gave to a character that, at best, was to be killed off within six months.

The retconning of 'The Big Red Machine's original origins in later years ultimately tested and proved its immortality. That such a deeply traumatic and personal tale could be f*cked with highlighted how fond enough of the fanbase had grown of The Undertaker's brother, and just how made a man he was in WWE canon. Kane - unlike all the slain monsters before him - was for keeps.

WWE's love/hate relationship with wrestling families seems to get in the way of them booking such a layered and nuanced family history for characters without magical powers. They dialled back Edge and Christian's kayfabe-but--believable relationship to being brother-like. Even if Rick Steiner was an Austin/Hogan hybrid, Scott Steiner's not exactly mates with the McMahons. And nobody in the company never had the faith in Broken Matt Hardy to draw like his brother did in singles competition when the pair were brought back into the fold in 2017.

There's a pretty notable sibling of a bonafide WWE legend doing interesting things in wrestling elsewhere, but it's unlikely he'll be Dashing back to Vince McMahon any time soon...


4. "I'm A Monster!"

Cody Rhodes
WWE.com

Not the sort that would have a run at The Undertaker, or the type of giant big enough to be a megastar at the airport (even if they had a nightmare on the planes), but the one who subverts the frailty of wrestling's image-obsessed landscape by thinking themselves hideous in spite of obvious evidence.

Cody Rhodes' descent to madness after taking a kick to his then-"Dashing" face was inspired. A shift that put over the original version of a pretty silly gimmick as well as giving him motivation to batter and bruise those more at ease with themselves wasn't just the future AEW kingpin making such good sh*t smell like roses - it was brand new ground for WWE to try and break.

There have been limitless figures overwhelmed with their own beauty, much like Cody himself before the transformation. Similarly, there have been those that have worn masks both literal and figurative to hide external and internal scars in an industry that otherwise wouldn't allow for introverted introspection.

In a world grappling with what true beauty even is anymore, there's space for another wrestler to disown their own.


3. Concessions Kane

Concessions Kane
WWE

Some mega-broad WWE comedy that actually got over thanks to the (sometimes overstated) versatility of Glenn Jacobs, Concessions Kane turned the parody his character had become into something we could actually all take the p*ss out of.

Daniel Bryan's brief return to Raw as a one-night General Manager saw him demote his former partner and ridiculous horror movie rival to the concession stand. Logic checked out - he'd proven he could flit seamlessly between the "Corporate" and "Demon" monikers they'd laughably imposed upon given him because we were all too stupid to differentiate between his red and black wrestling gear/mask and his school trousers.

The skits of him flogging frankfurters and the like are sort of charming. Pre-Sarah Logan Sarah Logan giving him a "Chips! You. Are. Chips!" motivational talk is made even better by his deadpanning, Santino Marella could still pull off this bullsh*t as a punter, and WWE's digital team clearly had some fun with uploading it too, changing his nickname to slogans so awful ("The Devil's Favourite Fry Cook", "The Devil's Favourite Potato Chip Vendor) that they had to be escapist ribs at the writing's expense.

Now more than ever, this feels like something the company could revisit. As a public servant and political figure, Jacobs wants people back in buildings anyway - what better way to tease them back than with chips?


2. The Best There Ever Will Be

Diesel Pins Bret Hart Survivor Series 95
WWE Network

But surely everybody to ever lace up their boots and be given a bit of television time says and believes they're the best, don't they? Possibly. But only 'The Hitman' excellently executed it.

A contemporary WWE has lost sight of wrestlers aiming for the top of the mountain because the writers script the wrestlers to constantly admire the view on the way up. Make moments, be like your heroes, live your childhood dreams without making new ones for the children watching. The show is so reliant on its history that it weighs down the aspiration of the present. It allowed Becky Lynch's drive to make her 'The Man', but she was wise enough not to call herself the best for when the matches couldn't always back it up.

This wasn't something Bret Hart had to worry about. He let his technique do the talking, safe in the knowledge that his work would hold up almost entirely beyond compare. The man was desperate to get his archives out there before he understood just how old content would eventually be preserved on the WWE Network. He knows how good it is, as he did then when he called himself the best there ever will be.

Plenty have been confident, even more have been great, and more still have had retrospective greatness thrust upon them by the company and fans alike. In WWE at least, the wait continues for somebody to have the assuredness to talk one game and outwork it every night.


1. Unbeatable At WrestleMania

Undertaker WrestleMania 24
WWE

WWE appeared to be building up Edge as the next superstar to become one of their in-house living legends thanks to an accidental WrestleMania winning streak.

Victories in two iconic tag team ladders matches, a Shampoo contract clash with Booker T, the inaugural Money In The Bank battle and a breathtaking hardcore outing with Mick Foley saw him suddenly teed up as the man next in line to take on the mythology the company had monetised with The Undertaker.

It collapsed as quickly as the realisation it was even happening. Perhaps in an effort to protect it (if not the man himself in an incredibly painful spot), they blurred the lines when he was taken out injured during the 2007 opener before erasing all hope the following year when 'The Deadman' himself defeated him in an absorbing main event.

Such a record takes luck, terrific booking and an awful lot of patience. Thus, there exists almost no chance of it ever happening again.


Watch Next


Who Said It: Kane Or Gary Busey?

Kane WWE
WWE

1. “Fear Is The Dark Room Where The Devil Develops His Negatives.”

In this post: 
Kane
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Michael is a writer, editor, podcaster and presenter for WhatCulture Wrestling, and has been with the organisation for 10 years. Alongside the production of daily written, audio and video content covering WWE and AEW, he also provides knowledge and insights on all aspects of the wrestling industry thanks to a passion for it dating back over 35 years. As one third of "The Dadley Boyz" Michael has contributed to the huge rise in popularity of the WhatCulture Wrestling Podcast and its accompanying YouTube channel, earning it top spot on the UK's wrestling podcast charts with over 10,000 episodes and 70,000,000 total downloads. He also co-hosts Benno & Hamflett, In Your House!, Podcast Horseman: The BoJack Horseman Podcast, and has guested on long-running Sunderland AFC podcast Wise Men Say. With WhatCulture, he has provided in-person coverage of some of the biggest pay-per-views and Premium Live Events in wrestling history, including WrestleMania, Survivor Series, All In & Double Or Nothing in destinations such as New York, New Jersey, Chicago, Dallas, Las Vegas, Philadelphia, London and Cardiff. He has also been featured as a wrestling analyst for the Tampa Bay Times, Fightful, POST Wrestling, GRAPPL, GCP, Poisonrana, 411Mania and Sports Guys Talking Wrestling. Michael's background in media stretches beyond wrestling coverage, with a degree in Journalism from the University Of Sunderland (2:1) and a series of published articles in music and culture magazines The Crack, Pilot as well as Sunderland AFC's premiere fanzine A Love Supreme. When not offering his voice up for daily wrestling podcasts, he can be found losing it every other Saturday at the Stadium Of Light, and at Cribs gigs nationwide.