10 Best WWE PPV Matches That Ever Happened In September

A look at several classic matches involving the likes of Cena, Edge, Michaels and more!

The month of September isn't really known as a strong month for WWE. It falls right after the major August show called SummerSlam and Survivor Series in November is still two months away. A lot of the time the September PPVs feature rematches of feuds from SummerSlam. It's no different this year in WWE since the main event of Night of Champions will be Brock Lesnar vs. John Cena for the WWE Title in a rematch from SummerSlam. There are some awesome matches that took place in the month of September. In many cases, they're matches that would have been remembered as all-time greats if they took place at a WrestleMania or SummerSlam, but since they took place in September they're oftentimes forgotten. Here's a listing of all the PPV names that WWE has used in the month of September. In Your House (four times), Unforgiven (1999 to 2008), Breaking Point 2009 and Night of Champions from 2010 to this year's 2014 event. They also had a One Night Only PPV in England in 1997 too. It seemed like WWE was going to stick with the Unforgiven name forever since they used it for ten years, but for whatever reason they went to Breaking Point. Night of Champions is a concept that works, so it's okay that it's the annual September show. If you have WWE Network or you just want to re-watch some great matches from the past that aren't as celebrated as those at major events, you should give these ten matches a re-watch because they're all great.

10. The Rock Vs. Ken Shamrock Vs. Mankind - Steel Cage For WWE Title No. 1 Contendership (In Your House: Breakdown 1998)

It's a match that was a lot of fun to watch because you had The Rock as an ascending star that was getting over really big. This was right after his major SummerSlam ladder match with Triple H and two months before his corporate heel turn at Survivor Series. Mankind was also getting love from the fans while Shamrock had a long feud with Rock, so it was smart to involve him too. They had exciting match where Rock was cheered for everything he did, hated anything that Shamrock did even though he was a face and were supportive of everything Mankind did too. There were so many cool moments like when Mankind missed an elbow off the top of the steel cage and it was shot from the perfect angle. The finish of the match was something that put over Rock for being a smart guy while Mankind was a fool. Mankind knocked out Shamrock with a steel chair. A really stiff chair shot. Instead of pinning him, he tried to climb over the cage and that allowed Rock to cover Shamrock to win. I was at this show. It wasn't a great show from top to bottom, but this match was so memorable and is one of my favorite live experiences after going to shows for 25 years.

9. The Undertaker Vs. Shawn Michaels - (In Your House: Ground Zero 1997)

This match was the much anticipated first ever PPV match between two of WWE's top guys. At SummerSlam a month earlier, Michaels was the referee for the Undertaker's World Title loss against Bret Hart. He hit Undertaker with a massive chairshot that was intended for Hart and that's what led to this feud. Michaels was a full fledged heel again for the first time in over two years as Degeneration X began while Undertaker was humanized more than he ever was before. The story of the match was that Michaels was scared of Undertaker and tried using cheap tactics the entire time. The crowd was really buying into it as they brawled before the bell and the refs had trouble containing them. Every time Michaels tried to attack, Undertaker just kept on coming back. The only way Shawn got control was when he used a chair and the ref was bumped. There were lots of believable false finishes too. There's even a cool spot with Michaels using brass knuckles, then Undertaker stole them and used them himself. For the finish they went with Undertaker giving a Chokeslam to a ref and it ended as a No Contest. After the bell rang, other wrestlers came out to break things up. That set up a memorable ending as Undertaker did a huge no hands dive over the top rope onto about eight guys. It was one of the first times he ever did that spot. It's a match that is forgotten because of the Hell in a Cell match that followed it, but it's still awesome to watch. Plus, it made sense that they would do Hell in a Cell since this was such a wild brawl and in the cell they would be contained more.

8. Kurt Angle vs. Steve Austin - WWE Championship (Unforgiven 2001)

Any time Kurt Angle wrestled Steve Austin it was a great match. They had a natural chemistry together, which is why they wrestled so many times in 2001. It was one of those things where they matched up an old school brawler type wrestler like Austin with a technical wrestler that was an amazing athlete like Angle and they just made it work. Following their outstanding match at SummerSlam 2001, Austin was the heel WWE Champion while Angle was the babyface for the first time in his career that did an awesome job of making Austin's life difficult. They also had some added elements in this match because Angle was in his hometown of Pittsburgh and it was 12 days after the September 11 tragedy. They had an entertaining battle with Austin dominating for much of it, but when Angle came back the crowd in Pittsburgh went crazy. There's also something special in the air when somebody is in their hometown and that was the case for Angle as well. Each guy stole the finishers of the other man and were able to kick out. When Austin looked like he was going to be able to finish off Angle with the Stunner, Angle grabbed the foot and the crowd went wild. Austin tried to fight it, but eventually he tapped out while his other hand was under the bottom rope. When Angle won the gold there was a big celebration for him. It was done because the heel Alliance story was dominating WWE, so it was the kind of feel good moment that everybody wanted. Austin ended up winning the WWE Title back within a few weeks, but when Angle won it really was seen as a major moment.

7. John Cena vs. Randy Orton - WWE Title I Quit (Breaking Point 2009)

There have been so many Cena/Orton matches in the last seven years that it's sometimes hard to keep track of them. Some of their matches are pretty boring while others are sneaky good like this one was in Montreal in 2009. Orton was the heel WWE Champion that had a good run as part of the Legacy group while Cena was in his usual role as the fighter that won't give up. What was cool about this one as an I Quit match was they were able to use weapons all around the ring and that's exactly what they did. It was a slow pace with Orton in control for a lot of it, but then they cranked up in the second half. They did something we hadn't seen in a long time as Orton pulled out a bag from under the ring that had handcuffs in it. He cuffed Cena's hand to the top rope, then he cuffed Cena's hands together and Orton methodically brought the pain. Cena was able to fight out of the cuffs by giving Orton a backdrop outside the ring, then he cuffed himself to Orton and made the big comeback. Cena won after using the handcuffs to strangle Orton while had him in the STF submission hold. Orton ended up quitting and Cena became the new WWE Champion. Orton did a really good job as a Jake Roberts-like heel that was smart about everything he did. Cena really performed well too. When you read about the handcuff thing you might not think it would work, but after watching it again it definitely helped the match.

6. CM Punk (c) vs. John Cena - WWE Title (Night Of Champions 2012)

The CM Punk/John Cena rivalry produced a lot of great matches within the last five years. Their best match was Money in the Bank 2011 and many of their other matches were special too, but Night of Champions in 2012 was really good as well. Punk was the heel WWE Champion in the middle of his epic 434 day title reign while Cena earned another title shot. It was a tricky match to book because WWE wanted to keep the title on Punk without hurting Cena (since he's always protected), so they had a very competitive matchup for 27 minutes. Their finish was different than what we were used to seeing. They fought on the top rope. Cena came off with a German Suplex with him on the middle rope while Punk was on the top rope. The ref Chad Patton counted the pinfall. Cena celebrated with the WWE Title. The ref told him that both of their shoulders were down at the same time, so the match result is a draw. That means that CM Punk is still the WWE Champion. After it was over, Punk hit Cena with the WWE Title as a cheap shot and that was it. Matches ending in a draw are not popular with the fans with good reason, but it shouldn't take away from the quality of work in the match. They really busted their ass to have a great match and that's what they did.

5. Shawn Michaels Vs. Chris Jericho - Unsanctioned Match (Unforgiven 2008)

The feud between Shawn Michaels and Chris Jericho in 2008 was the best story that year by far. Jericho was at his absolute best as a heel that did everything he could to upset Michaels. They had several PPV matches that year. Prior to this match, they had an angle at SummerSlam where Jericho accidentally punched Shawn's wife Rebecca in the ring. Jericho went for Shawn, but he ducked and nailed Rebecca instead. That incident at SummerSlam led to this match with Unsanctioned rules. In other words, it was an anything goes type of match. Jericho used the rules to his advantage by having his buddy Lance Cade interfere in the match to make it a 2 on 1 situation for much of it. It looked as if there was no Michaels was going to come back. When Michaels made the comeback the fans were really into it. There was a huge spot where Jericho was on the top rope and Michaels nailed him with a steel chair that sent Jericho through a table that was at ringside. He nailed Cade with a Superkick to eliminate him and also drove him through a table at ringside. Michaels end up winning after beating Jericho with a belt. He focused his attack on the eye of Jericho, which was payback for Jericho attacking him in the eye earlier in their rivalry. The referee stopped the match when Jericho was unable to continue. It was such a different Michaels performance. He didn't really play to the crowd. He wrestled in jeans and a black tank top. He treated it like a fight. That's why Michaels is such a great performer. He changes the way he works depending on the environment he is in.

4. Chris Benoit Vs. Kurt Angle - (Unforgiven 2002)

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GHEgCqjbonc Kurt Angle wrestled Chris Benoit many times from 2001 to 2003. Every time they had a match it was great. Fans remember the match at WrestleMania 17 well because it's the best PPV ever while their Royal Rumble 2003 is one of the best WWE Title matches ever. There was also this match at Unforgiven 2002 when these two were a big part of the reason why Smackdown was so great in the second half of that year with Paul Heyman as the main booker of that show. The story was that Angle and Benoit teamed together often, but they had a hard time getting along. Because of that, they had to settle their differences with this match. It's a story that worked because their familiarity meant that it was going to be hard for either man to get a clean win. This match was a technical wrestling classic as they busted out everything in their arsenal and it looked like either man could come away with a victory. There were so many German Suplexes, belly to belly suplexes, back suplexes and everything else you expect form these two. It looked like Angle might tap out the Crippler Crossface, but he ended up countering it into an Ankle Lock, which led to Benoit countering to the Crossface. They kept on countering each other. Benoit won the match with a rollup by putting his feet on the ropes. It was cheap, but it fit the story that they were going to do whatever they could to win the match. Angle usually won their matches because he was a bigger star, so it was nice to see Benoit get the win in this one even though it was a cheap ending. That's okay because it fit the story.

3. Matt Hardy Vs. Edge - Steel Cage Match (Unforgiven 2005)

It was one of the most personal feuds in WWE history. The real life situation played out on television when the world found out that Lita cheated on her boyfriend Matt Hardy with Edge. That led to Edge turning heel, Hardy getting fired for a few months because WWE was worried what might happen and then Hardy being brought back to feud with Edge when they agreed to work together. They had a bloody brawl with Edge getting busted open and the fans loving it because this was a major match in a real life feud. Matt used the cage to his advantage plenty of times. It also made sense that it was held in a cage because that way Lita wasn't able to interfere. That's something wrestling companies need to do a better job of. Give a reason why people have stipulation matches. Don't just do it for the sake of having stipulations. The ending was great. Hardy nailed a Side Effect off the top rope. Lita entered the ring to break up a pin, so Matt nailed her with a Twist of Fate and people cheered huge for that. Matt could have climbed out to win, but instead he hit a Leg Drop off the top of the cage for the decisive victory. If this match was at a WrestleMania or SummerSlam it would be celebrated a lot more than it is. That's the problem with September PPVs. They're not matches that people remember as well because it's generally a slower month. This feud would be remembered as one of WWE's best if it took place elsewhere.

2. John Cena vs. Edge - WWE Title TLC (Unforgiven 2006)

The Cena/Edge rivalry was one of the best ones in WWE in the last decade. It was a feud where Cena was already established as a top guy while Edge needed to get to that level. Because of Cena and the storyline they had, his status was raised. Edge became a WWE Champion as well as a believable main eventer. The story going into the match was that if Cena failed to win the WWE Title from Edge then he would go to Smackdown. Edge was the heel WWE Champion that was cheered for this match because it was in his hometown of Toronto. He got to pick the stipulation for it so he went with a Tables, Ladders & Chairs because it was the match he helped make famous and that Cena had never had before. The storyline fit the setting. It was one of the most brutal, physical matches in the career of Cena. He had to prove he could hang with Edge in a match he wasn't used to. Sometimes in a one on one TLC match it can get boring as guys are setting up the weapons for the spots, but they did a great job of telling a story with the weapons. Since they wrestled so many times, they had great chemistry. They were also smart in terms of how they built the match because it wasn't about climbing up the ladder that match. It was about causing physical pain to your opponent. They did a fantastic job in terms of doing huge bumps towards the end of the match. Cena took one of the biggest bumps of his career when he was climbing a ladder and Lita (Edge's on screen girlfriend) tilted the ladder back so that Cena went crashing through the table outside the ring. When Edge was climbing up, Lita hit Cena with a steel chair that knocked Cena into the ladder that Edge was climbing and Edge went through a table outside the ring. Cena gave Lita the FU to take her out. What a lovable babyface he is! Those bumps were just a taste for the ending of the match. Two tables were stacked in the ring right beside a ladder as both guys fought at the top of the ladder. Cena was able to put Edge on his shoulders (two refs held the ladder to steady it) and Cena put Edge through the two stacked tables with the FU. Referees shouldn't be holding a ladder to help a spot, but if they didn't then the wrestlers could have botched it really bad. It's one of the best matches in the careers of both men and the best one in their historic rivalry as well. Cena earned a lot of respect that night while Edge proved that he belonged as a main eventer.

1. Shawn Michaels Vs. Mankind - WWE Title (In Your House: Mind Games 1996)

It's a match that didn't have that much build up to it and they didn't have a lot of matches together, but it's the best WWE PPV match in the month of September. When babyface WWE Champion Shawn Michaels took on the heel Mankind, who had just aligned himself with Paul Bearer, they put on a match that was an example of why fans love both wrestlers. They always found a way to put on different styles of matches depending on their opponents. It was no different at Mind Games 1996. They had such a unique match because they did some innovative spots. Mankind did his usual insane bumps like when Michaels slammed him headfirst on the floor outside the ring. Then there was the time when Michaels gave him a suplex onto the steel steps with Mankind's feet hitting the steps. That led to Michaels working over the legs of Mankind, which gave the match a sense of pyschology. It wasn't just some spot fest with two crazy bumpers. Michaels even used a steel chair to the hand of Mankind to prevent his Mandible Claw finisher. Their big spot towards the end of the match was when Mankind gave Michaels a back body drop off the middle turnbuckle outside the ring and they went crashing through a table although Michaels turned to land on top of him. It was a huge move especially in 1996 when we didn't see those kinds of spots very often. The negative part about the match was the finish. Michaels gave Mankind a Superkick into a chair that looked like it knocked him out. He slowly made the cover, but then he went after Vader for the DQ finish. Others got involved like Sid and The Undertaker, who popped out of a casket to go after Mankind. What's interesting about the finish is that there were reports that Mankind was going to win the WWE Title here. Michaels had rep for changing finishes if he didn't want to put somebody over. Not sure if that's what happened in this case. Mankind was still pretty new, so maybe WWE failed to pull the trigger for that reason. Two months after this Michaels dropped the WWE Title to Sid. It's a shame that Michaels didn't have more matches with Mankind. They were the perfect match for each other because they were willing to put their bodies on the line. This was their first major match and they were able to perform at such a high level. WWE really should have given them a chance to have other matches because they likely could have improved on this one, which was absolutely fantastic.

Contributor
Contributor

John wrote at WhatCulture from December 2013 to December 2015. It was fun, but it's over for now. Follow him on Twitter @johnreport. You can also send an email to mrjohncanton@gmail.com with any questions or comments as well.