10 Best WWE Wrestlers Of 2017

Time For Heroes

neville wwe
WWE.com

In a year that's offered wrestling fans some of the best action ever (the best, if Dave Meltzer's rankings are your guide), it’s harder than ever for performers to sustain plaudits on the main roster.

WWE’s present day super-service results in the talent wrestling all the bloody time, but that's just a small problem feeding into a much bigger one. The standard of work shooting up has simultaneously sent excitement levels plummeting. Grainy footage of grizzled 1950s crowds losing their minds over a ten minute headlock is now just about as big a joy to watch as a Seth Rollins singles match. In both cases, you know all the beats and rhythms long before they happen, but at least a less-than-comatose crowd give you a reason to keep watching. And less people spent months on the shelf through injury thanks to a particularly tight toe-hold.

Wrestling’s never been so good, but it’s never been so hard to be a good wrestler. It's subjective of course, but Vince McMahon's irrational and erratic decisions force the most incredible patience from fans that would even tolerate the TakeOver-to-TakeOver management of NXT as a worthy replacement to WWE's unending churn.

A spot with the organisation isn't even enticing well paid independent stars as much as it used to. It's all, if anything, further reason why these performers deserve as much credit as they do. Being the Best In The World is p*ss easy compared to being the Best In World Wrestling Entertainment.

10. Alexa Bliss

alexa bliss
WWE.com

Aside from brief belt swaps with Naomi and Sasha Banks on SmackDown Live! and Monday Night Raw respectively, Alexa Bliss has maintained control of her brand's Women's Title for the entire year. Clearly a huge sign of trust from management, Bliss' in-ring efforts are gradually improving to match the outstanding character work that helped her break out of the pack as one of the division's two pillars this year.

And whilst Sasha Banks, Bayley and others have suffered horribly from bad booking, she's just about managed to avoid the poison of the pencil. In truth, the idiocy and abject failures of her contemporaries has only boosted her profile further as a legitimate Champion.

Fans back winners, and even as a heel the audience has taken her on as a credible contender quashing their favourites. A 'This Is Your Life' segment trashing Bayley was perhaps WWE's worst televised moment of 2017, but Alexa was categorically not to blame despite the company's decision to throw her under the bus for it a week later. Her delivery of p*ss-weak content was remarkably strong - arguably the most vital skill to master in the overwrought WWE of today.


9. The Bar

Sheamus Cesaro The Bar
WWE.com

If recent stories are to be believed, a spinal stenosis issue may punctuate Sheamus’ career long before the Irish star was expecting to hang up his Brogue-kicking-boots. From a fan perspective, there’d also never be quite as worse a time for him to disappear back across the Atlantic.

From the embers of a best-of-seven series that had fans yawning their way to the concession stands, ‘The Celtic Warrior’ and partner Cesaro have crafted an utterly sublime united front. Enjoyable foil as a mixed heel/babyface duo earlier in the year, the pair truly came into their own as characters when ‘The Swiss Superman’ re-embraced the darkside during their Tag Team Title wars with The Hardy Boyz.

Matt and Jeff’s return raised the ire of the former Champions, having carried the grunt work of the league since relieving The New Day of the Raw Tag Team Titles the prior December. Regaining them from the North Carolinians in bruising battles, they then moved on to an exhilarating series with a reunited Dean Ambrose and Seth Rollins. Unearthing new drama with The Shield boys, the rivalry hasn’t yet ran out of steam, even if Sheamus doesn’t have the physical capabilities to hold steady. The tag division and the company in general would be worse without him.


8. The Usos

The Usos SmackDown Tag Team Champions
WWE.com

To tag wrestling on the main roster what American Alpha and The Revival were to it in NXT, The Usos’ post-heel turn period has been one the best of their career. Jimmy and Jey’s stewardship over SmackDown Live! was further enhanced by the arrival of The New Day in April’s ‘Superstar Shake-up’.

Trading titles with every combination of the talented trio on multiple pay-per-views, the five drew rave reviews for series that arguably peaked with nobody watching. Relegation to the SummerSlam Kickoff show was criminal - so the quintet responded by stealing the show. One of the best WWE matches of the year, the utterly mesmerising finishing sequence that saw them commence a record-setting second reign with the blue brand belts over Big E and Xavier Woods was only topped by an even better one three months later earning victory against The Bar at the Survivor Series.

It was in this contest where both duos showed their pedigree. Outperforming a New Day/Shield match that opened the show, the clash of the champions was more heated, physical and enjoyable than the triumvirates tussle. It was another stellar night in a seemingly endless parade of them in 2017.


7. Roman Reigns

roman reigns
WWE.com

Roman Reigns looks set to end 2017 as the Intercontinental Champion, and there's perhaps been no better time to let him loose with such a prestigious belt. With two major exceptions, its been another flawless year for 'The Big Dog', particularly on television.

A recent spell of absorbing clashes with The Miz, Elias and Jason Jordan have highlighted how complete a performer Reigns has become in spite of the rampant abuse he'll undoubtedly receive for the rest of his career. Only pay-per-view clangers with The Undertaker and John Cena have hampered his record, but the faults of his opponents were as pronounced as his own in the disappointing affairs.

He pointedly showed remarkable unselfishness in his cinematic feud with Braun Strowman, conclusively losing battles and the war despite being the one chosen to terminate the 'Monster Among Men's undefeated streak in February. More than anything, it represented a new comfort level atop the WWE mountain.

A more effective magic wand for all three men than anybody could have thought, The Shield's recent return afforded him almost universal love from the crowd for the first time in forever. How he'll maintain that around Royal Rumble season remains to be seen, but perhaps due to a couple of well-timed injury breaks in 2017, he doesn't feel half as stale a candidate to hold a top title as he did when last in the hunt.


6. Charlotte

Charlotte Flair
WWE.com

Winning her first SmackDown Live! Women's Championship in November after going the better part of a year without any title at all, Charlotte has navigated her way through a 'Superstar Shake-up' babyface turn to maintain her place as the main roster's current best all-round performer.

2018 proffers big things for Asuka, the new Paige and Ruby Riott-led trios on both brands and much more if separate rumours of Women's Tag Titles and a Royal Rumble are to be believed, but little suggests anybody will topple Flair on consistency alone.

One of the 'experienced' hands on a burgeoning blue brand women's division despite still only clocking up five years experience between the ropes thus far, only a Raw clunker with Nia Jax sullied an otherwise exemplary year.

Her 2017 turn steered into growing respect the audience had for her immense skill, if not any one particularly likable trait - which offers her a return to the dark side should she eventually run out of opponents on the blue brand. She's as yet not reassumed conflicts with Four Horsewoman comrade Becky Lynch, but could pause that if a potential clash alongside Sasha Banks and Bayley against the Shayna Baszler/Ronda Rousey/Marina Shafir/Jessamyn Duke variation at WrestleMania.


5. Samoa Joe

Samoa Joe
WWE

Is Samoa Joe the solution to a problem WWE are pretending not to have?

In Brock Lesnar, they have a Universal Champion that thrives from hardly being anywhere near the actual product. Monday Night Raw is both barren and over-loaded. It's a three-hour creative sinkhole, swallowing in even the most dynamic performers to the minutiae and mundanity of the downtrodden day-to-day life of the WWE Superstar.

As Universal Champion, Lesnar pops up with his mouthpiece once in a while, drops a scrub on a pay-per-view then departs. Samoe Joe, if anybody could be, may be the full-time version of 'The Beast'.

Harnessing an unshakable charisma as an ice cold killer from lengthy unbeaten spells in Ring Of Honor and TNA, the 'Samoan Submission Machine' rediscovered his confidence in NXT and followed through on that promise with one of the best main roster ascensions in the history of the develipmental brand.

Left off of WrestleMania but no worse off for it, Joe went in at the top level undertaking assassin duties for Triple H, and hasn't slid down the card since. Multi-man pay-per-view main events have seen him take a share of the spotlight rather than fading into the background, and his solo run at Brock Lesnar ousted Braun Strowman's effort by some distance. In 'The Beast', the company has a part-time unstoppable monster as Universal Champion. Samoa Joe may be the one to do it four nights a week.


4. Neville

neville cruiserweight
WWE.com

Perhaps the saddest thing about Neville's recent WWE walk-out is how easy the company has found it to erase him from the general make-up of the show. Confined to pay-per-view Kickoff shows, the purple-roped Bermuda Triangle 205 Live or neglected supercard death slots, his contests had a habit of drawing both the most praise and the least attention.

It's fitting that current Cruiserweight Champion Enzo Amore satisfies the entirely opposite criteria considering Neville's planned duties the night he bailed altogether on Monday Night Raw and perhaps the company in general. Set to lose again to the 'Smacktalker Skywalker', Neville's concern was less a personal slight on Enzo and more a reflection of the one he rightfully felt against himself.

As big a scandal as not affording his matches the stature and credit they were the due was the lack of interest in an exceptional 'King Of The Cruiserweights' gimmick he'd built from the ground up. Changing his voice, look, working style and even Twitter game to suit it, the presentation was finally a perfect package, yet Neville somehow found himself squashed up against an even lower glass ceiling than the one he'd suffered under in his original babyface incarnation.


3. Braun Strowman

Braun Strowman Roman Reigns
WWE.com

1987 was the year Hulkamania became ingrained in American pop culture thanks to his slamming of Andre The Giant at WrestleMania 3, 1997 gifted the world the rise of 'The Rattlesnake' with an earth-shattering Stone Cold Stunner to Vince McMahon and a 2007 toppling of a 'Samoan Bulldozer' finally foreshadowed the complete pro lurking within 'The Champ'. Will tipping over an ambulance be remembered as Braun Strowman's 2017 touchstone?

And if not that, one of the other memorable stunts he took part in alongside willing victims Roman Reigns, Brock Lesnar, The Big Show, Kane, Kalisto and other. Billed as a 'Monster Among Men', WWE have taken the unique step of preserving the aura not only by having him win routinely and with ease, but engaging in literally unbelievable feats of strength and determination.

Impossible to dislike regardless of who he may be committing his atrocities too, Strowman's performance has always walked the tightrope between force and farce, with his ring work accelerating quicker than the ambulance Roman Reigns drove into him during their chaotic Great Balls Of Fire encounter.

Outside of a disparate loss to Brock Lesnar the company quickly managed to stifle, his momentum hasn't stuttered - another rarity in the modern product. No title match - or worse, the Triple H slot - would be a disappointing WrestleMania payoff for the year he's had, but either Monday Night Raw or SmackDown Live! gold simply has to be in his near future. Audiences will except and expect nothing less.


2. The Miz

The Miz
WWE.com

Though the polar opposite of a castaway, The Miz exists on his own island in 2017. With over a decade of experience in WWE as it philosophically navigated through drastically changing times, he’s now more polished than much of a roster that once literally wouldn’t have welcomed him in a locker room.

An established and believable pro with a microphone, ‘The A-Lister’ has blossomed in confidence between the ropes since a 2016 post-WrestleMania liberation of the Intercontinental Title. And it’s the gumption rather than skill that makes him such a vital performer in the modern age.

Excellent professional wrestling is almost the norm in the post-Performance Center world. Ironically, in finally embracing a sense of diversity, WWE has homogenised the very act of the ‘good’ match. Unless in the ring with super-worker, The Miz’ contests don’t promise Omega-level snowflakes, but instead a hailstorm of intensity as one of the truly great heels in the game. He lack of technical dexterity instead becomes the stick audiences use to beat him with - and he gleefully throws the stick back in their face.

It’s no coincidence that for just under two years, he’s been in complete control of the Intercontinental Title. It’s the ‘worker’s belt’, after all, and he’s the best the company has.


1. AJ Styles

AJ Styles
WWE.com

It had to be AJ Styles. Again.

Proving just how elite he was during his maiden annum with WWE, the ‘The Phenomenal One’ survived a sophomore slump in spite of creative factors that would have sunken a lesser vessel.

Dropping his first WWE Title to John Cena in an outstanding Royal Rumble headliner in January, his increasing frustrations grew into one of WrestleMania's real main event programmes against Shane McMahon. Well, that's the company line obviously, and whilst many dared to afford 'Shane-O-Mac' credit for their 'Show Of Shows' opener, Styles' selfless display was the only thing saving the match from being yet another vanity project for the 'Boy Wonder'.

The blue brand Commissioner knackered AJ's angle with Kevin Owens as well, with virtually every match between the pair hamstrung by the need to build drama between 'KO' and the third man rather than his 'Phenomenal' foe.

Transitioning briefly to US Title level to ably assist Baron Corbin in a way John Cena refused to, he then had one of the company's best matches of the year on about a day's notice when he stepped in for Bray Wyatt against Finn Bálor at October's Tables, Ladders and Chairs show.

Fans were still tripping up to thank him for that when he heroically liberated the WWE Title from the death clutch of Jinder Mahal, then immediately proved how vital he was in the spot when faced with tackling Brock Lesnar eight days later. It was 'The Beast' best match in years, but was barely AJ's finest that month.


In this post: 
Neville
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Michael is a writer, editor, podcaster and presenter for WhatCulture Wrestling, and has been with the organisation for 10 years. Alongside the production of daily written, audio and video content covering WWE and AEW, he also provides knowledge and insights on all aspects of the wrestling industry thanks to a passion for it dating back over 35 years. As one third of "The Dadley Boyz" Michael has contributed to the huge rise in popularity of the WhatCulture Wrestling Podcast and its accompanying YouTube channel, earning it top spot on the UK's wrestling podcast charts with over 10,000 episodes and 70,000,000 total downloads. He also co-hosts Benno & Hamflett, In Your House!, Podcast Horseman: The BoJack Horseman Podcast, and has guested on long-running Sunderland AFC podcast Wise Men Say. With WhatCulture, he has provided in-person coverage of some of the biggest pay-per-views and Premium Live Events in wrestling history, including WrestleMania, Survivor Series, All In & Double Or Nothing in destinations such as New York, New Jersey, Chicago, Dallas, Las Vegas, Philadelphia, London and Cardiff. He has also been featured as a wrestling analyst for the Tampa Bay Times, Fightful, POST Wrestling, GRAPPL, GCP, Poisonrana, 411Mania and Sports Guys Talking Wrestling. Michael's background in media stretches beyond wrestling coverage, with a degree in Journalism from the University Of Sunderland (2:1) and a series of published articles in music and culture magazines The Crack, Pilot as well as Sunderland AFC's premiere fanzine A Love Supreme. When not offering his voice up for daily wrestling podcasts, he can be found losing it every other Saturday at the Stadium Of Light, and at Cribs gigs nationwide.