10 Big Questions From WWE SummerSlam 2015

Was it smart to make Jon Stewart a factor in the WWE Title match?

The biggest WWE event of the summer is over and SummerSlam should be considered a success although it was also a very controversial show due to the endings of the two biggest matches. It's not easy to put on a four hour show, nor is it easy to come up with ten different finishes to matches that are going to satisfy all WWE fans. Just because a major match takes place at a big event like SummerSlam doesn't mean it has to have a clean finish. WWE is all about looking ahead the next show. Jon Stewart did a good job as the host of the show, but seeing him do a promo with Mick Foley to start it made it feel like an episode of Raw. What wasn't expected later on was Stewart becoming the deciding factor in the WWE Title match. There wasn't a match of the year contender and it wasn't as good as NXT Takeover Brooklyn one night earlier, but it was still an above average PPV event that had a lot of moments fans will remember for a long time. The idea behind this feature is to discuss most of the booking decisions that happened. It's easy to say "this match was great" or "that match sucked" so this is case of considering what WWE did in terms of the creative team and trying to make sense of it all. Since there were ten matches, there will be one question about each match as well as plenty of opinions about the matches as well.


10. Will Randy Orton's Feud With Sheamus Finally Be Over?

It's the feud that never ends, yes it goes on and on my friends. That's a parody of a children's song, but it applies to this rivalry because they just keep feuding all the time. Orton got the clean win at Battleground five weeks ago. Sheamus got the clean win at SummerSlam. Is there a need for more from them? Not really. This is where the "but" comes in because WWE loves this feud and they will keep going to it if they have nothing for either guy to do it. What I'd like to see is Sheamus feud with a guy like Roman Reigns or Dean Ambrose just because at least those would be fresh rivalries. I just think they might keep this rivalry going strong since Orton rarely loses feuds clean. My hope is that it's over because I'm sick of their matches. However, knowing how WWE operates, it wouldn't shock me if there's one more big match for them since it's 1-1 in recent PPV matches.

9. Should Fans Celebrate The New Day As Tag Team Champions Again?

Yes they should absolutely. The best team in WWE are the champions again and hopefully this second reign lasts much longer than the first one did. The match didn't have great build, but give a lot of credit to the four guys for doing some big moves and taking some big bumps. For a match that didn't have a lot of hype, they ended up providing us with a few "wow" moments. It was a cheap finish with Kingston doing the blind tag and then stealing the pin after Titus O'Neil hit the Clash of the Titus move. Since Kingston pinned one of Los Matadores, it also sets up a rematch feud with the Prime Time Players because the PTPers weren't pinned in the match. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bnsKd09Ay_0 On a recent Steve Austin podcast (it may have been after Battleground), he was talking about how great they are as a team and he was absolutely right. He also made a good point in saying they should team together for two or three years so that they can be a dominant tag team that the company can rely on. Too often in WWE they break up teams before they should. These guys have something special and should not be broken up for two or three years at least.

8. Were The Fans Right To Boo Double Countout Finish For Rusev's Match With Dolph Ziggler?

They were very vocal in terms of giving a negative reaction to that finish and they had every right to be. It's understandable why the fans would boo a double countout because a match at a PPV event is something that should have a better finish. That felt like a finish to a TV match, but not at a major show like SummerSlam. The fans were right to boo it. What I would have done is had Rusev get the cheap win thanks to some Summer Rae interference or something like that, which could lead to the post match fight that they did. The future seems obvious because they're probably going to do the mixed tag match at Night of Champions where Ziggler and Lana can get the win to end this rivalry after two or three months of building it up. If they don't want to put the women in the match for some reason, Ziggler should get the win. By the way, Lana changing her attire to a jean jacket and skirt look was tough to get used to. I think she looks better in the business suit, but I understand wanting to change because then it shows she has moved on with her life.

7. Did Stephen Amell Look Like He Belonged In A WWE Ring?

The tag team match with Neville and actor Stephen Amell beating Stardust and King Barrett was pretty good. I thought Amell did a great job of hitting some impressive offensive moves, selling the moves of the heels pretty well and then doing that big spot with a cross body block that took out the heels outside the ring. It was Neville that ultimately won the match for the team with the Red Arrow, which was a bit of a surprise. I thought they might do something where Amell pins Stardust. They might want to save that for a match down the road, so for that reason it makes sense. There are some celebrities that look totally out of place when they are on a wrestling show, but Amell's a lifelong wrestling fan that loves the business. He looked like he was having a blast out there. The Brooklyn crowd loved him too, so it's hard to say anything negative about what they did out there. I've been impressed by Cody Rhodes' work as Stardust in the last couple of months. While I would love for him to return to using the Rhodes name, I'd be fine if he stayed with Stardust too.

6. Did Ryback Look Impressive In Retaining The Intercontinental Title?

He did not. It was a short match with a poor finish, but thankfully this boring three way feud is over after over nearly three months of building up to it. The finish to the match was weird. Big Show hit the KO Punch on Miz, Ryback sent Show out of the ring and then Ryback pinned Miz. Remember how I said that it was nice to see Kofi Kingston steal the pin in the tag title match? That's because he's a heel. A face like Ryback stealing the pin on Miz after Big Show knocked out Miz was not something a babyface should be doing. I'm not really sure who came up with that finish or why they thought it was a good idea. A face like Ryback should be the one that hits his move leading to the win. That makes him look strong and like a great champion.

5. Is That The End Of Roman Reigns' Feud With Bray Wyatt?

Roman Reigns and Dean Ambrose beat Bray Wyatt and Luke Harper clean in the middle of the ring fairly easily. In terms of the work in the match, it was very good because they had an intense match from the moment the bell rang. Then they did the basic stuff Reigns making the hot tag and cleaning house to win the match cleanly. If that's the end of the Reigns feud with Wyatt it would be a bit disappointing because I think they need to do more with it. To answer the question, I'll say no since Wyatt could attack Reigns to keep the feud going strong. It was a bit disappointing that there was no tease of a heel turn by Ambrose. It would have been better if there was some miscommunication by the faces leading to the heels getting the win because then at least there's some buzz about a possible turn. Instead, it was a basic match designed to make Reigns look like a star. If it is the end of this rivalry, look for Reigns and Ambrose find some new rivals. It could be Sheamus and Kevin Owens just based on who else got wins at SummerSlam.

4. Was It Right To Have Jon Stewart Factor Into WWE Title Match Finish?

Jon Stewart did an okay job as the host of SummerSlam. He's a funny guy that has made me laugh so much over the last twenty years, but some of the jokes he did didn't work that well. Then there was his random appearance in the WWE/US Title match following the ref bump. With the ref down, Stewart went into the ring with a steel char and teased attacking Seth Rollins and John Cena. People probably assumed it would be Rollins since they have had verbal altercations in the past, so when he attacked Cena it was a shock, which led to Rollins winning the US Title to go along with his WWE Title. The finish happened after an exciting match that went nearly 20 minutes with Rollins looking like he was the best in the world. Rollins had a phenomenal showing in that match while he wore some new white gear as well. A big reason why WWE did it is because they wanted to make the mainstream press with something from this show, so they used their host Stewart to do it. After looking around various non-wrestling sites today, that plan obviously worked well. Great move? No, but it easy to see why they did it. In addition to that, this will likely keep the Cena/Rollins feud going, which was necessary since they might be headlining the Night of Champions event on September 20. Cena already lost clean once this year when Kevin Owens beat him at Elimination Chamber in May. WWE isn't going to have Cena lose clean like that again for a long time, so it's no surprise that they went with the Stewart interference finish. As a final note on this match, this makes it the fifth year in a row where Cena lost at SummerSlam. His last win was in 2010.

3. Did The Right Team Win The Divas Tag Team Match?

Team PCB won the divas 3 vs. 3. vs. 3 elimination match. The "Team B.A.D." trio were eliminated first, which wasn't a big surprise. It was a bit disappointing that Sasha Banks was barely in the ring considering she had a match of the year candidate one night earlier at Takeover. She may have been tired, but probably not. The finish to the match wasn't that great. It would have been better if all six women were brawling, hitting big moves and then doing a finish. Having Becky Lynch take advantage of a missed Brie Bella dropkick leading to a pumphandle suplex wasn't that exciting. People weren't ready for it to be the finish because Lynch usually uses an armbar to win matches. As a result, the finish wasn't received that well. At least the right team got the win because Paige, Charlotte and Becky are the face team right now. Since Team Bella are usually heels, now they can focus on continuing the feud. With Lynch getting the decisive fall, perhaps she'll be the one to challenge for the Divas Title. The positives are that the match was good and they got about 15 minutes, which is much longer than the divas used to get.

2. Will That Win By Kevin Owens Get Him Going In The Right Direction Again?

Kevin Owens had a big win at SummerSlam when he beat Cesaro clean with the Popup Powerbomb. The crowd was really into it and both guys put in a great effort. The match came one day after Owens lost his rematch for the NXT Title against Finn Balor, so he really needed the win. The Owens/Cesaro match was placed second last because WWE wanted to give them a big spotlight to have a great match. Sometimes at WWE PPVs, they put a short match or a comedy bit prior to the main event as a way to do something light before the big match. Not this time. It was great to see Owens/Cesaro in the second last match. It was smart to give Owens this much needed victory. WWE is in need of strong heels right now and Owens is a guy they should really invest a lot of time into. He can be an asset going forward as a rival to guys like Roman Reigns or Dean Ambrose, which I mentioned earlier. As for Cesaro, he's still gaining steam as a babyface and he needed the win too, but that can come in his next feud whoever it is with.

1. Was The Finish Of The Undertaker's Win Over Brock Lesnar A Smart Decision?

The biggest subject that fans are debating about with regards to SummerSlam is the controversial win by The Undertaker over Brock Lesnar. It wasn't clean and it ended with a finish that isn't very common at all. When Lesnar had Undertaker in the Kimura arm lock, Undertaker was tapping out. The live camera didn't pick it up and the ref Charles Robinson didn't see it either. The timekeeper apparently did (how?) because the bell rang, which is when the chaos began. People wondered what happened while Undertaker capitalized with the Hell's Gate submission, which led to Lesnar passing out. The ref gave the win to Undertaker while replays showed after the match that he did tap out. After thinking about it for most of the day, I don't think it was a smart decision. What they were going for was a disputed finish that would keep Lesnar looking strong while also not making Undertaker look weak. What Undertaker did with the low blow was heelish and it's not like he's going to be a heel going forward because he's loved too much. The concern with a finish like that is insulting the audience by having the second straight PPV end without a clean or decisive winner. Remember that at Battleground there was no result for the main event at all - it just ended when Undertaker showed up. Why should we care about main event matches if the finishes are going to be cheap? While it's important to tell interesting stories, fans also want winners and losers, especially in the biggest matches at a huge event like SummerSlam. It was a cheap ending to a match that couldn't end any other way, at least from WWE's perspective. Right or wrong, the follow up will be very important and could lead to another match between them at WrestleMania 32 where this rivalry can end once and for all.

Contributor
Contributor

John wrote at WhatCulture from December 2013 to December 2015. It was fun, but it's over for now. Follow him on Twitter @johnreport. You can also send an email to mrjohncanton@gmail.com with any questions or comments as well.