10 Big-Time Wrestling Debuts That Were Totally Wasted

It's...it's...a complete and utter waste of major WWE, AEW, TNA and WCW debuts.

Will Ospreay AEW
AEW

"You only get one chance to make a first impression" isn't strictly true in wrestling circles.

Someone who tanked during their debut in the old WWF, for example, could make their merry way to WCW for a hasty repackage job and give it another go years later. The same could be said in the modern era - if WWE mishandles someone, that's not to say AEW will do the same (and vice versa).

That doesn't excuse promotions for totally bungling what should've been some of the hottest debuts in industry history though. Seriously, some of the introductory ideas included on this list are enough to make one feel queasy, and they're still annoying today.

WCW's legendary f*ck ups get a lot of attention, as do Vince McMahon's most iconically poor debuts/re-debuts. TNA even muscle in on the action, and Tony Khan doesn't get a pass either. There are two All Elite arrivals here that should remind everybody what happens when your roster is bloated.

Are these the worst wrestling debuts ever? Not necessarily, but they were gross miscalculations that should've been better thought out.

Enjoy the carnage...

10. DDP (WWF)

DDP Stalker
WWE

When: 18 June 2001 (Raw).

Why It Was A Waste: Might as well start with a biggie.

Diamond Dallas Page captivated WCW fans by opposing the nWo and presenting himself as an everyman "People's Champion" who battled the odds to become a pro wrestler in the first place. He was one of the company's most popular babyfaces for a reason, and must've been looking forward to defying expectations yet again in the WWF.

Page came crashing back down to earth with an almighty thump when he found out what Vinnie Mac and pals had in store for him though. They planned to turn him into a stalker - he was feuding with The Undertaker, sure, but only as a cowardly creep who apparently wanted 'Taker to kick his ass.

It didn't take long before this flopped, obviously. DDP was married to the smoking hot Kimberly at the time too, which only made the situation more egregious. Christ knows what the WWF's creative forces were thinking when they cobbled this together.


9. Big Show (WWF)

Big Show Debut
WWE

When: St. Valentine's Day Massacre 1999.

Why It Was A Waste: Certain billionaire owners with well-coiffed hair must've been licking their chops after snaring The Giant from WCW's midst. Vince McMahon probably believed that he was about to school those idiots in Atlanta on how to book a giant properly. After all, he'd done a sterling job with Andre.

Yeah, the rebranded Big Show didn't get off to a great start.

It's hardly a negative that Show debuted during a cage match between McMahon and Steve Austin. They were two of the biggest stars in wrestling, and he was surely going to make an impact straight away. Show did; he hurled Austin through the cage wall, and accidentally caused Vince to lose.

This hilariously-thick intro would become a commentary on Show's entire WWF/WWE run. He should've been a bigger success than he was, but that wasted debut set the tone for all the nearly moments, laziness and comedy that was to come.


8. “Razor Ramon” & “Diesel” (WWF)

Diesel Razor Ramon
WWE

When: 30 September 1996 (Raw)

Why It Was A Waste: 'What the hell are these guys doing here?!'.

That's something you're probs asking yourself right now. Think about it though: WWF telly made a massive deal out of the supposed returns of Scott Hall and Kevin Nash in September '96. In the end, fans didn't get Hall and Nash. Nah, they got "Razor Ramon" and "Diesel" instead.

Glenn Jacobs, who'd go on to succeed as Kane, and Rick Bognar looked like Halloween costume wannabes when they strolled out pretending to be WCW's new hires. If the WWF intended to bring Razor and Diesel back at all, then they should've waited until they had the real deal.

Onlookers were horrified when JR welcomed the cosplaying duo "back to the WWF" on the 30 September episode of Raw, and rightly so. This was a slap across the face to anybody who dared to believe their favourites were Federation-bound again.

What a waste of everyone's time.


7. Will Ospreay (AEW)

Will Ospreay
AEW

When: 8 June 2022 (Dynamite).

Why It Was A Waste: Former IWGP Heavyweight Champion, celebrated athletic marvel and all-round pro wrasslin' superstar Will Ospreay showed up by surprise on the 8 June edition of AEW Dynamite. His mission? Stand there smiling like this was Raw in 2017 and he was Finn Bálor.

Man, what a waste!

Ospreay then worked his first All Elite match on the following Friday's Rampage. It was a six-man effort alongside his Aussie Open pals against FTR and Trent Beretta - a workable match, but not quite high-profile enough to make Will's first two showings in Tony Khan's world worth a toss.

The UK standout will be part of AEW's Forbidden Door pay-per-view. After that, who knows? He's just the latest major name to show up on Khan's TV with no real rhyme or reason. Here's Will Ospreay, folks. Yay? The Dynamite bow wasn't enough, and he shouldn't have been in a six-man for his first bout.


6. Miro (AEW)

Miro AEW
AEW

When: 9 September 2020 (Dynamite).

Why It Was A Waste: Ospreay got off lightly compared to the former Rusev.

Miro's very first angle in AEW circles was to pretend that he'd been buddies with Kip Sabian for years. The ex-WWE worker was Kip's "Best Man", but he was starring in one of wrestling's worst debuts. Fans wanted to rally support around Miro, because he'd been poorly treated by WWE for years.

Despite knowing that, and for some unknown reason, Tony Khan elected to blend an obvious 'I'm moving on from that other promotion' promo with some crummy storyline that saw Miro link up with Sabian. It was stupid, and it'd be months before the incoming star looked like the major coup he actually was/is.

Miro's 'Redeemer' switch improved things exponentially, but not before people were forced to sit through an unwanted tag run with Kip. This just wasn't a good fit for either man, being brutally honest. It sucked the life out of Rusev's arrival in the company.


5. Rob Van Dam (TNA)

RVD TNA
TNA

When: 8 March 2010 (iMPACT!)

Why It Was A Waste: Look above to see Rob Van Dam squashing none other than Sting during his TNA debut in March 2010. Fans popped huge for RVD's debut, and it was surely the start of something special for both wrestler and roster alike. So, why is it here?

TNA made an arse of it seconds later, that's why.

Instead of letting Van Dam look like the man, bookers scripted Sting to get up, batter Rob with his baseball bat and totally p*ss all over his celebrations. Then, almost immediately, focus changed to the Stinger and Hulk Hogan. Poor RVD ended up being a bit-part player during his own debut moment.

One would love to have been the proverbial fly on the wall during that creative meeting. 'OK, we'll have RVD (one of the hottest free agents in wrestling) squash Sting, then Stinger can get the last laugh and we'll concentrate on Hulk".

Terrible.


4. The Ultimate Warrior (WCW)

Hogan Warrior WCW
WCW

When: 17 August 1998 (Nitro).

Why It Was A Waste: Rambling, borderline-incoherent promos were kinda Jim Hellwig's thing. During his pomp as The Ultimate Warrior in the WWF, the dude droned on and on about celestial beings, mystical journeys and spouted all manner of nonsense.

It was engaging...in 1990.

Wrestling had moved on by 1998, so it was laughable that WCW thought sticking a live mic in Warrior's hands for a repeat of his WrestleMania VI build opposite Hulk Hogan was the way to go. WCW fans sat on their hands as Warrior rambled on and on (and on and on) about the same old guff.

Then, he disappeared in a cloud of smoke (through a trapdoor in the ring) and everybody acted shocked. Meanwhile, thousands in Hartford, Connecticut just wanted to go home. Also, whomever came up with the idea of Warrior mimicking a 1960s Batman bit by encouraging fans to tune into "the same Warrior channel" deserved a slap.

Warrior was at his best when he was straight to the point physically. This rant made Triple H's 20-minute 2002 Raw promos look stellar.


3. Hulk Hogan/nWo (WWF)

nWo debut No Way Out 2002
WWE Network

When: No Way Out 2002.

Why It Was A Waste: There's a reason why that sub-heading is split between nWo and Hulk.

The old New World Order wanted to tear WCW's corporate structure apart. They were the rebels, and they very-much marched to the beat of their own drum. That's why it made zero sense when Mr. Hall, Nash and Hogan arrived in the WWF to...do the dirty work of a crazed Vince McMahon.

Fans in Milwaukee's Bradley Center instantly showed why this nWo re-debut was a bad idea. They craved the ol' red and yellow 'Hulkster' everyone had grown up with; it'd been nine years since Hogan ran wild on WWF TV, and the people were ready for a nostalgia kick.

It felt like a waste to ignore that (at least originally) in favour of Hulk's nWo troops working for the boss. Nobody wanted to see it. They wanted to see the leg drop, the posing and the Hulk Hogan of old. Eventually, fans got that, but not before this wonky piece of presentation.


2. CM Punk (WWE)

CM Punk, WWE Backstage
WWE.com

When: 12 November 2019 (Backstage).

Why It Was A Waste: CM Punk's departure from WWE in 2014 created headlines around the world. He'd been unhappy with the system for a while, and the former World Champ wasn't afraid to let everybody know it. Generally, fans were split into two camps. Some supported Punk, whereas others mocked his 'woe is me' whining.

Those folks united in 2019 to roundly bash the man's WWE comeback.

How did Punk return? On Raw as part of a big-time angle? Right at the end of a pay-per-view? Nope and nope. The then-biggest free agent in pro wrestling made a comeback on the 12 November episode of Backstage. As in...the FS1 talk show nobody really paid much attention to.

Granted, Punk's contract was with FOX rather than WWE, but he had to know this was a disappointing way to appear on company-led television for the first time in over five years. Thank f*ck for AEW's hype two years later - no-one wanted to remember Punk for this low-key tripe.


1. Bret Hart (WCW)

Bret Hart WCW Debut
WWE

When: 15 December 1997 (Nitro).

Why It Was A Waste: Nobody was being talked about more than Bret Hart in late-1997. The infamous 'Montreal Screwjob' had literally just happened, and wrestling sided with the 'Hitman'. That should've been a gimme for Eric Bischoff and WCW, but they screwed it up spectacularly.

Nobody can blame Bischoff for announcing Bret's imminent arrival 24 hours after Survivor Series. That was fine. Debuting Hart on the 15 December '97 Nitro and having him become special ref for Eric vs. Larry Zbyszko though? That wasn't fine. In fact, it outright sucked.

The most-talked about face in the wrestling world was a prop for a match between two non-wrestlers. His role on the biggest pay-per-view of 1997 was to officiate a bunfight few cared for in the first place. Great. This was a huge red flag for the rest of Hart's WCW tenure.

What. A. Waste.

What other major debuts did wrestling companies totally waste? For more WWE, check out WWE 2K23: 10 Improvements Fans Demand and 10 Gimmicks WWE Cancelled For Being TOO SUCCESSFUL!


Watch Next


In this post: 
Will Ospreay
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.