10 Biggest "Out Of Left Field" WWE Booking Decisions

You never saw them coming...and you'll never forget they happened.

Not every major booking decision that unfolds on WWE television has to make sense within the context of a given storyline. Throughout the company's long and illustrious history, some of the greatest and most memorable moments have been the result of some serious off-the-wall booking. They are moments that shocked audiences, leaving them either sat in stunned silence or full throat as they witness history. Some were inconceivable losses. Others were inexplicable victories, the result of power plays that did more harm than good. Still others were unimaginable, cross-promotional occurrences that had never been seen before and, most likely, will not be seen again. They are rare in nature, and generally pack a big emotional punch whenever they do occur. Recently, the road to WrestleMania 32 produced another such occurrence when the prodigal son, Shane McMahon, returned to the sports-entertainment world for the first time in seven years. With the build to the year's biggest event underway, and a sense of desperation on the part of management setting in, the WWE Universe should be prepared for more booking decisions to come from way out of left field and shake the foundation of the company. Just like these 10 historic moments did...

10. Brock Lesnar Ends The Streak (2014)

Prior to WrestleMania XXX, there were but three certainties in life: death, taxes and The Undertaker winning at the grandest event of all. Then along came Brock Lesnar and changed everything fans thought they understood about the industry. In one of the most shocking moments in wrestling history, Lesnar dropped The Phenom with a third F5 and pinned his shoulders to the mat for a count of three. Fans stood in awe, their jaws dropped. A deafening silence falling over the 70,000-plus fans inside the SuperDome. No one could believe what they had seen, if only because it had come out left field. Nothing about the way the feud was booked to that point suggested that The Beast would be the first man to defeat Undertaker at WrestleMania. Most expected the legendary competitor to bowl over Lesnar and extend his undefeated streak to 22-0, preserving his streak for one more year. But WWE shocked the audience in an era where doing so is nearly impossible, thanks to the Internet and backstage leaks. The decision brought about the end of an era, as well as Undertaker's drawing power in relation to The Showcase of the Immortals, leaving many to wonder what the point was.

9. Heyman, McMahon & Bischoff In The Same Ring At The Same Time (2005)

May 26, 2005. For the first time, the three most influential men in modern wrestling history stood in the same ring for a promo designed to reintroduce Extreme Championship Wrestling to the masses as the inaugural One Night Stand approached. It was a moment that was completely unexpected, a historical summit that should have been advertised ahead of time to draw in fans that had not watched wrestling since the glory days of WWE, WCW and ECW and the Monday Night War. Heyman unleashed on his peers, cutting one of his greatest, most impassioned and scathing promos to date. He defended his brainchild's place in history and the men that broke their bodies contributing to it and threw some shade at his competitors. It was brilliant and beautiful, brutal and venomous. It was history in the making, something never seen before. It likely won't be seen again. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pPQnffjwNd8 Unfortunately, if you were not watching the show that night, you had no idea that the segment would happen.

8. Shane McMahon Buys WCW (2001)

Ahead of the March 26, 2001 episode of Monday Night Raw, rumors persisted that Vince McMahon had purchased WCW. When the Chairman of the Board popped up on WCW Nitro, those rumors were validated and it appeared that hell had indeed frozen over. In typical fashion, McMahon found the opportunity to toy with the livelihoods of the men and women that worked for the company. Rather than signing the contract that made it official, he demanded that Ted Turner himself walk the contract to the ring at WrestleMania. His hubris allowed son Shane to walk to the ring in Panama, Florida (home of that night's Nitro) and announce to the world that he had purchased the company out from underneath his father. 'The contract reads McMahon...' The stunned expression on Vince's face represented the feelings of fans everywhere. Not only had they been surprised by the sale of WCW but, from a storyline standpoint, fans were left shocked by Shane's actions. Suddenly, the foundation had been laid for a battle between the two storied companies, one that would play out over the course of the year and change the landscape of the company forever. Though not necessarily for the best.

7. Bret Hart Wins The WWE Championship In Non-Televised Match (1992)

In the fall of 1992, Bret Hart was one of the best wrestlers on the planet. He was fresh off of a five-star classic with brother-in-law 'British Bulldog' Davey Boy Smith and was among the most popular babyfaces in Vince McMahon's WWE. But his size seemed to limit his upward mobility. He was not the chiseled specimen that many of the top stars in the company had been and that certainly affected how the most powerful man in wrestling saw him. Or did it? On October 12, Hart arrived to Saskatchewan Place in Saskatoon prepared for the night's television tapings. With WWE champion Ric Flair under the weather and preparing to make his exit from the company, McMahon was tasked with selecting The Nature Boy's successor. His options? Proven commodity "Macho Man" Randy Savage, The Ultimate Warrior or Hart. Determined not to allow his associates to influence him, McMahon chose Hart. Later that night, The Hitman weathered a dislocated finger to trap Flair in the Sharpshooter and win his first WWE Title. The booking decision was entirely unexpected. As great as Hart was, most expected him to stay put in the midcard and become a perennial Intercontinental Champion. His WWE Title win, from out of nowhere on an untelevised card, remains one of the great surprises in WWE history.

6. Hulk Hogan Wins The WWE Championship At WrestleMania XIX (1993)

From a genuinely great surprise to one of the most notorious "out of left field" booking decisions ever. Hulk Hogan returned to WWE from a sabbatical just in time for WrestleMania IX, lending his star power to a show notably lacking in it. But teaming with real-life friend Brutus Beefcake to battle Money Inc. for the Tag Team Championship was not enough for the egotistical industry icon. No, he used his backstage political pull to snake his way into the main event later in the night. Moments after Bret Hart lost the WWE Championship to Yokozuna, Hogan ran to ringside to try and argue with the official, telling him that Mr. Fuji had thrown salt in The Hitman's eyes. For some reason, the new champion and his manager issued a challenge to The Hulkster. Seconds later, Hogan dodged another salt attack, dropped a big leg and left the show with the title despite not being in the contention for the gold. Adding insult to injury, Hart was shoved into the background for the next six months as Hogan and others took centre stage, halting the momentum he had built for himself.

5. Vince McMahon Is The Higher Power (1999)

There is no more disappointing conclusion to a single storyline than that of the 'Higher Power'. After months of speculation as to whom The Undertaker was referring to, fans sat in universal disappointment as Vince McMahon revealed himself to be the mysterious entity. The booking was off-the-wall and out of left field, making absolutely zero sense within the context of the story told to that point. McMahon had been the target of Undertaker's ruthlessness. His daughter was kidnapped and nearly wed to The Lord of Darkness. His home was vandalized and a giant burning Undertaker symbol placed on his lawn. He was tortured on a weekly basis, sometimes physically and often emotionally. The decision to have McMahon under the hood was completely unexpected, a booking move that backfired because fans saw right through it. They recognized it was a last-ditch effort to salvage the storyline and create a 'shocking moment'. It was a major disappointment given the effort that went into it. The worst "out of left field" decisions are the ones that lack sense and this is one of the most infamous examples of that.

4. Diesel Wins The WWE Championship In MSG (1994)

When Bob Backlund defeated Bret Hart for the WWE Championship at the 1994 Survivor Series, it seemed that what was once old was now new again. The former All-American had reinvented himself as a maniacal villain, prone to snapping and injuring opponents with his trademark Crossface Chicken Wing. His title win was the culmination of one of the most peculiar journeys of any wrestler in the 1990s. It looked as though he was primed for a decent main event run that would last at least until WrestleMania. Then he ran into a seven-foot-tall Diesel truck who tore through him in eightseconds to take the title inside the historic Madison Square Garden. That's right; Diesel defeated Backlund to win the title just three days after the Minnesotan's grand victory. It was a booking decision that took the wrestling world by surprise, not only because the title switched hands in such short order but because of the superstar who unseated Backlund. Diesel was a midcard villain up to a week before the MSG show, his official face turn coming at the same Survivor Series pay-per-view at which Backlund had achieved the biggest victory of his career. His sudden ascension caught the audience completely off guard and created interest, even if fleeting, in what Vince McMahon had in store for the future of his promotion.

3. John Cena Enters And Wins The Royal Rumble (2008)

When John Cena tore his pectoral muscle in October 2007, it looked as if WWE would be forced to come up with WrestleMania plans that did not involve the leader of the Chain Gang for the first time in four years. Then it happened. At the Royal Rumble in January 2008, Cena stunned the world by returning to the squared circle well ahead of schedule and entering the 30-man over-the-top-rope match. There, the No.30 entrant overcame Triple H, delivering an Attitude Adjustment over the top rope and scoring his first ever Rumble victory. Booking decisions that come from out of left field and double as swerves are rare. When done correctly, they generate tremendous excitement and make for unforgettable moments. Cena's return did just that, drawing one of the loudest ovations ever heard in Madison Square Garden. And in the process, it proved the West Newbury, Massachusetts native's incredible dedication to his craft and his determination to compete on the grandest stage known to professional wrestling.

2. Shane McMahon Returns (2016)

A a time when the Internet spoils EVERYTHING, no one could have ever guessed they would see Shane freakin' McMahon skip his way to the squared circle live on Raw, his "Here Comes The Money" theme music drawing a pop typically reserved for the likes of Steve Austin, The Rock or John Cena. Yet, there he was on the February 25 episode of WWE's flagship show. After seven years away from the squared circle, he had returned to set up an epic encounter against The Undertaker at WrestleMania, the final result of an overly long in-ring promo with father Vince. Eager to ensure the legacy of the McMahon family, he would go on to reveal that he was the heir apparent to his father's fortune, not sister Stephanie and husband Triple H. At a time when fans were less-than thrilled at the prospective main event for WrestleMania, Shane returned and single-handedly lifted spirits with regards to the biggest show of the year. His presence helped re-energize an audience bored with the Roman Reigns project and the general staleness of the product. It was a home run hit by management, a left field booking decision that generated buzz on social media and brought a great deal of excitement back to the WWE television. Easily one of the greatest moments on Raw this decade.

1. Vince McMahon Makes A Deal With The Devil (2002)

Raise your hand if you knew Eric Bischoff would arrive in WWE in July 2002, the new general manager of the brand. Put your damn hands down, you LIARS! The appearance by the former WCW President on Monday Night Raw was one of the most earth-shaking moments in professional wrestling history. After spending years leading the competition, guiding WCW in an attempt to defeat WWE and drive Vince McMahon out of business, Bischoff appeared alongside his business rival and shook his hand in a moment that made the devil shiver. Hell had frozen over and the wrestling world was in awe at the developments that were unfolding before their eyes. With ratings down and interest in the product waning, McMahon put personal feelings aside and reached out to Bischoff. He offered him a starring role on his television show, the same show that the former Turner executive once tried to run off the air, proving he has a strong business mind. The decision to debut Bischoff came from so far out of left field that it was just barely in the ball park. No one saw it coming and there sure as hell was no tease or suggestion that it could ever happen. No one in their right mind predicted the business relationship would ever come to be, nor could they have imagined that the two ego-driven businessmen would coexist under the same roof for four years. Still one of the most jaw-dropping moments in WWE history.

Contributor
Contributor

Erik Beaston is a freelance pro wrestling writer who likes long walks in the park, dandelions and has not quite figured out that this introduction is not for Match.com. He resides in Parts Unknown, where he hosts weekly cookouts with Kane, The Ultimate Warrior, Papa Shango and The Boogeyman. Be jealous.