10 Biggest Secret GENIUSES In Modern Wrestling

Giving galaxy brained grapplers their well-earned flowers.

Danhausen AEW
AEW

Though a collaborative business, wrestling will always be defined by its top stars. Whether these are the company-pushed faces who do the talkshow circuit and increase the sport’s reach or the critical darlings who rack up five star matches, in any given era it’s always easy enough to discern who sits atop the mountain.

Flying under the radar, though, are their contemporaries whose wrestling acumen, creativity, and ability to develop themselves often goes underrated. These are the superstars who might not be competing for parts in Hollywood blockbusters, but whose deep understanding of the business means they’re a joy to watch, and essential parts of any good promotion.

From performers with wild ideas no one else could dream of to those who’ve honed their craft over time, workers pushing their brand or lifting up the rest of the roster alike, these wrestlers have some of the most exciting brains in the business.

They may never get the plaudits they deserve, holding belts for record breaking reigns or topping industry polls, but if you want fresh ideas in an industry frequently crying out for them, these are your guys.

10. Penta El Zero Miedo

Penta El Zero M
AEW

The Lucha Brothers are one of the best tag teams around at the moment, and with his breathlessly creative high flying style, Rey Fenix often takes the lion’s share of attention. The glue, however, is often older brother Penta, whose mask and moveset belies one of the most fundamentally sound performers in AEW and beyond.

The best of seven series between Death Triangle and The Elite was, unsurprisingly, built primarily on wild spots and chaos, but in the midst of the madness, Penta’s character work was something to behold. Corrupted by PAC, the Lucha brother turned hammer brother, turning to the dark side in increments and attempting to drag his white-clad sibling along with him. It’s a shame, once the series ended, they didn’t push this further.

Penta can play light or dark without really shifting much in his persona, and is just at home exchanging madcap superkick sequences with the Bucks or bloodletting with Jon Moxley.

He has become one of the most popular stars on the roster while remaining ultimately unknowable, not to mention anonymous outside of the ring. It takes a rare level of physical charisma to pull that off.


9. MVP

Bobby Lashley MVP
WWE

MVP didn’t reinvent himself so much as gradually evolve into the best version of himself. In his initial WWE run he wrestled well against the likes of Chris Benoit and Matt Hardy, but was stymied by a bit of a boring sports-themed gimmick that was never going to see him rise above a certain point.

His 2020 return was overshadowed by that of Edge, but the impact Montel Vontavious Porter has had on his second run shouldn’t be understated. The Hurt Business was one of the best (and most bizarrely disbanded) stables in recent company history, spearheaded by an older, wiser MVP finally free to cut loose.

Now clad in smart suits and shades, Porter was allowed to inject far more personality into proceedings, and his influence on Bobby Lashley (in kayfabe and otherwise) saw The Almighty finally reach his potential.

Without resorting to gimmicks and tricks, MVP can sell a match as well as anyone. His character motivations always make sense - he attaches himself to the most dominant guy he can find in a bid to make money out of the business. It can be as simple as that.


8. Toni Storm

Toni Storm
AEW

If Toni Storm’s acquisition by AEW wasn’t quite the coup it should have been, that isn’t for lack of trying on her part. The Australian may only be 27, but she’s already a veteran talent, possibly the most gifted in-ring performer in the division, and someone a roster can be built around going forward.

Even for the uninitiated, Storm is clearly a rockstar the moment you lay eyes on her. From the attitudinal intro to the steely gaze in her eyes, she carries herself with an old school swagger, a serious persona in a division that isn’t taken nearly seriously enough.

Once the bell rings, she can work wonders with anybody, from longtime rivals like Jamie Hayter to up and comers like Sky Blue. Most women who tangle with Storm will come out the other side having had one of their best matches.

She has been the victim of bad timing thus far, becoming champion during the interim period then losing it to a red hot Hayter, and now stuck in the effective but somewhat repetitive Homegrown vs Outcasts story. There’s no doubt, though, that Storm is the present and future.


7. PCO

PCO Ring Of Honor
ROH

Most wrestling fans at some point dip in and out of the business, and on returning after a hiatus, it can be funny to see how things have changed. This has rarely been exemplified better than a hypothetical fan of mid-90s WWE checking out the indie scene two decades later to see Quebecer Pierre transformed into a wrestling Frankenstein’s monster.

As a last roll of the dice in a solid if unexceptional career, PCO is something special. Journeyman Pierre Ouellet had enjoyed a WWE heyday, but had chugged along until he came up with the idea of becoming a violent, reanimated corpse with designs on winning the Ring Of Honor World Title.

The gothic gimmick sounds like something out of WCW’s worst days, but in Ouellet’s hands, it works. You can see the thought he’s put into the character, wrestling a stiff, aggressive style that reflects the lack of panache a corpse probably would have.

It’s a character built for ROH and Impact, where PCO plies his trade. He stands out from the crowd, a silly but perfectly realised character with whom you know you’re in for a good time.


6. Danhausen

Danhausen AEW
AEW

If you’re a - relatively speaking - fairly slim, not especially imposing wrestler trying to make it in the indies and beyond, there are a few directions you might take. You can try your best to bulk up as far as your body will allow, demonstrate a willingness to absorb immense punishment, hone your mic skills to an undeniable level.

Or you can create a gimmick so hilarious, ridiculous, and undeniably charming that you’re rocketed to the status of beloved cult figure and beyond. Danhausen shouldn’t work - he’s a skinny guy clad in old school movie demon makeup, who speaks in the third person, has a jar of teeth, and speaks in a voice based on Conan O’Brien.

And yet, every time Danhausen emerges (and he does almost exclusively emerge, often from under the ring), the value erupts. He may be very evil, but he’s very nice, too. He’s a force of pure good; it’s impossible to grow tired of watching the weirdo place curses on those who’ve crossed him.

What makes Danhausen work, though, is the level of detail put in. Nonsense pseudo-supernatural characters are a dime a dozen in wrestling. This one feels fleshed out, lived in, somehow logical. If you can’t have fun when you’re watching wrestling, then what’s the point?


5. Great-O-Khan

Great O-Khan
NJPW

New Japan is a consistent source of high classroom uncompromising wrestling, but it’s not always so hot on its characters. When you get lost in the shuffle, you can get lost in a big way. This seemed to be the future for Tomoyuki Oka, a skilled amateur but little to set him apart.

This changed big time when Oka reinvented himself as Great-O-Khan. Exploding back onto the scene with a fearsome new Mongolian-inspired look, the performer went from anonymous young lion in black trunks to one of the most excitingly broad characters on the roster.

Great-O-Khan commits like few others in the company, his warrior spirit and larger than life persona a welcome response to the po-faced action that can personify NJPW’s product. If his in-ring work isn't necessarily the best on the roster, he guarantees you something different, and understands his limitations.

He even managed to bring an act of real-life heroism (saving a teenage girl from drunken harassment) into his character, taking a letter of commendation to the ring with him. As far as character evolution goes, it’s thorough stuff.


4. Xavier Woods

Xavier Woods
WWE.com

Xavier Woods was never going to get the career plaudits of his stablemates Kofi Kingston or Big E - he knew that when forming The New Day, even stating that one of his aims was to see the perennially underutilised Kingston elevated to main event status. He doesn’t win a lot of matches, or even work a huge amount of them. All the same, he’s one of WWE’s most valuable assets, one of a few workers who most likely has a job for life if he wants it.

Woods’ charisma, attention to detail, and obvious deep love for the craft of wrestling allows him to improve anything he’s involved in. His decision to start playing the trombone (with no experience) helped turn the tide on a stable that wasn’t finding its feet. He might be the best comedic straight man in the business (witness him selling for the List of Jericho). He understands his place on the card but he knows his worth too, firing off zingers at any opportunity (“we are effectively cutting the ring in half” at WrestleMania 37 being a high point).

With all that and his Up Up Down Down format, Woods is, like The Miz, a performer of such slick, reliable professionalism as to be invaluable to a company like WWE.


3. Kairi

KAIRI NJPW x STARDOM Historical X-Over
NJPW/STARDOM

After several abortive attempts, finally there’s a wrestling pirate we can stand behind. Move over, Paul Burchill - Kairi combines nautical excellence with in-ring talent like nobody we’ve ever seen.

It shouldn’t work - it risks being cutesy if not downright embarrassing - but the former NXT Women’s Champion star taking to the ring with some or all of a captain’s hat, ship’s wheel, and telescope somehow adds up to one of the much-missed black and gold brand’s best gimmicks. The joy is in the execution: Kairi may look sweet on the way to the ring, but when she gets in there, she’s a killer.

Smartly, she shifted gears just enough when moving to New Japan (where she holds the distinction of being the first IWGP Women's Champion). She continued to use her real life penchant for yachting, but notched up the intensity, adding krakens and the like to her entrance presentation and becoming a surly sea dog.

Kairi delivers every time and boasts one of the most instantly delightful gimmicks in the business. As a recent free agent, she could offer an immense amount wherever the winds might blow her.


2. Bayley

Bayley WWE
WWE.com

A wrestler who seems doomed to occupy that underrated slot in WWE’s women’s division, Bayley has been mucked around something fierce by weird booking, seldom more so than over the past year. And yet, you’ll rarely find a wrestler who can make more with less than the Role Model.

The finest example of this is WWE’s pandemic era. While some performers struggled - understandably - in the eerie empty arenas, Bayley stepped up and then some. She more than anyone understood the importance of filling the crowdless silence, and would harp on constantly. Bickering with Michael Cole or sledging her opponent, her chatter always relevant and on-brand.

As heel or babyface, she’s as good at anyone in the company as making a rival look the business, from Asuka’s rag-dolling of the then-hugger to bouts that have elevated and solidified Sasha Banks and Bianca Belair as the roster’s top women.

Ultimately it may be Bayley’s all-rounder status that keeps her from being truly appreciated, but she’ll be massively missed when she’s gone. Were another company to offer her a spot at the top of the tree, it’d be a call worth taking.


1. Orange Cassidy

Orange Cassidy
AEW

Through a mixture of gleefully goofy gimmickry and undeniable wrestling fundamentals, Freshly Squeezed has become arguably the most popular performer in AEW’s roster. While some traditionalists may not be able to look beyond the limp kicks, blue jeans, and Jansport backpack of it all, look closely and you’ll see that Orange Cassidy has become one of the most complete wrestlers in the game.

The gimmick is, of course, the immediate selling point. Genuinely funny comedy in wrestling is such a rare thing, and Cassidy brings it - the Justin Roberts “wherever/whatever” introduction, the obsession with putting his hands in his pockets - it’s good stuff.

When the slacker is provoked into trying, though, he’s capable of wowing any crowd. Early matches against PAC and Chris Jericho were eye openers. Last year’s bout with Will Ospreay was next level, appearing way up there on many match of the year lists.

It’s a multifaceted build on the performer’s part, first setting expectations way down low, then evolving from comedy character to AEW’s fightingest champion. He has forged an amazing connection without appearing to do anything at all - now that’s genius.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Yorkshire-based writer of screenplays, essays, and fiction. Big fan of having a laugh. Read more of my stuff @ www.twotownsover.com (if you want!)