10 Biggest Shocks In WWE WrestleMania History

Taken by surprise on the grandest show of all.

Mick Foley Edge Wrestlemania 22
WWE.com

Going into a WrestleMania, more often than not you know what you’re going to get. This isn’t necessarily a bad thing - the event sees storylines come to a grand conclusion, and if this means giving the fans what they want to see, that sounds like a sound strategy.

Occasionally, though, WWE has the capacity to shock us. Whether this takes the form of a storyline swerve, an appearance or comeback that has us blindsided, a spellbinding spot, or a performance that way exceeded anything we could possibly imagine, these are the moments that lift WrestleMania to a notch of its own in the sports entertainment character, where something special just might happen.

Not all shocks are for the best - some of these exhibited short term thinking on the part of WWE, the desire to get a reaction for the sake of it - but some of these showed the company’s willingness to take a risk with its product at a time when the eyes of the world (of wrestling fans) were watching.

Whether this year’s ‘Mania will present us with a straight ahead show or something to get us out of our seats, it’s worth remembering the company can surprise when they want to.

10. The Hardyz Return

Matt Hardy At WrestleMania 33
WWE.com

As we’ve just seen on AEW Dynamite, there are few bigger pops than those afforded to a surprise Hardy return. OK, in the case of AEW, it wasn’t a huge surprise - Jeff’s appearance has been on the cards for a while - but it was a huge reaction, all the same.

Place the Boyz at WrestleMania, make it a genuinely unexpected bit of booking, and you’ve got a seismic response on your hands. At 33, the New Day interrupted a tag title ladder match to announce that another team would be taking part. They hinted that they’d be overstepping their position as hosts - the fans were fine with this. And then, the theme music started.

The best thing about Matt and Jeff’s return is the sweeping shot across the fans. Grown men with hands on their heads in shock, clutching each other with glee. The pair had been gone for eight years; this was the last thing anyone expected to see at WrestleMania.

The team were smuggled in mid-show to preserve the surprise, and it paid dividends. That they went on to win the belts in a pretty cool match made this all the sweeter.


9. Hogan Slams Andre

Hogan Andre GIF
WWE Network

Obviously this one seems a little tame nowadays, but context is everything in wrestling. Back in 1987, the idea of Hulk Hogan - or indeed any mortal man - lifting the majestic Andre The Giant off his feet and slamming him to the canvas seemed the stuff of fantasy. It just couldn’t be done.

But WrestleMania III was no ordinary event. The stars aligned that night; few matches have ever been built so well, and the sheer force of narrative and razzle dazzle turned a fairly stodgy match into something majestic.

When Hogan managed to deliver the body slam to Andre, the response tells the story - this was a feat of astonishing strength, and a moment which still ranks up there with the most iconic in wrestling history, no matter what has come since.

Indeed, it’s presented with such conviction that you can forget the fact that Hogan himself had already done this at least twice. History disappears for this moment in the Pontiac Silverdome; the legend becomes reality.


8. Bianca Cracks The Whip

Sasha Banks
WWE.com

Sasha Banks and Bianca Belair put on a historic main event on the first night of WrestleMania 37, working a terrific match that sealed Belair’s ascent to the top table, illustrated why Banks is one of the best of her generation, and provided a source of inspiration to fans across the world.

There are many takeaways from the instant classic, but what burned itself into the memories of most viewers - as well as Banks’ flesh - was the moment Belair took her long ponytail and used it like a whip. The crack as it strikes Sasha’s side is a breathtaking one - whatever was done to milk the sound, it’s an undeniably visceral noise.

The effects are immediately apparent as the welt begins to form. WrestleMania 37 features cages, chairs, and kendo sticks, but nothing induces such a wince as this moment. What’s more, it makes Bianca look superheroic, a special power that only she can utilise.

They’ve used this spot a few times since (though not as often as you might expect), but its placement in the match and the execution on the grand stage makes this a stunner.


7. Mick Foley And The Flaming Table

Mick Foley Edge Wrestlemania 22
WWE.com

In the grand scale of mad Mick Foley moments, this perhaps wouldn’t scrape the top three, but as far as WrestleMania extreme spectacles go, it takes some beating. The ‘Mania 22 hardcore match between Edge and Foley was a proper show stealer, and the intention was to give Mick a moment to remember at the big show.

The majority of the match skirted around that, with great spots and storytelling (including Foley wearing a barbed wire vest to neutralise Edge’s spear), blood and guts. It needed something to tip it over the top, though, and it got that in the form of the finish.

As is WWE’s wont, a table had been set up outside the ring. A simple bump wouldn’t suffice, though; instead, Lita set it on fire, Edge hit another spear, and he and Foley went piling into the inferno where Edge picked up a fortunate win.

It’s a crazy risk delivered with perfect timing by all concerned, and sold magnificently by Edge, who looks shaken to the core even as his hand is raised in victory. Best of all, it gave the Hardcore Legend the WrestleMania moment he deserved.


6. Bad Bunny Steals The Show

Damian Priest And Bad Bunny Wrestlemania 37
WWE.com

There are a couple of matches in contention for the best of WrestleMania 37, but if we’re talking about the biggest surprise, there’s only one place to look. When Puerto Rican megastar rapper Bad Bunny got involved with WWE programming, most fans were sceptical at best, if not downright dismissive. Oh ye of little faith.

Randy Orton stated that the musician had been putting in hard graft at the gym, but what we got in his match teaming with Damian Priest against Miz and Morrison was simply outstanding. Bunny worked the majority of the match, and did everything absolutely right. From psychology to selling to timing, he just got it.

Then, he hit a Canadian Destroyer on John Morrison outside the ring, leading to frenzy on the commentary desk and the shocked reactions of Priest and Miz. This wasn’t just a good night’s work for a celebrity cameo; it was good full stop.

Best of all, Bunny’s packed schedule means WWE hasn’t been able to return to the well too many times and dilute the experience. It’ll be very tough indeed for Logan Paul to follow this act in 2022.


5. Ronda Rousey Attacks

Ronda Rousey WrestleMania 31
WWE

WrestleMania 31 was a great show that had a bit of everything, from great matches and high spots, nods to the past, and a keen eye on the future. Perhaps the most important example of the latter was the first WWE appearance for the future headliner Ronda Rousey, who made as impactful a debut as any celebrity guest.

Triple H and Stephanie McMahon came to the ring to announce the attendance and do some heel schtick. In due course they were interrupted by The Rock, and the three indulged in a face-off and exchange of views. “Indulge” is certainly the right word, as this went on forever, before a much needed jolt of energy was added in the form of Rousey.

To the delight of the crowd, she hopped the fence and took to the ring, which she claimed as her own. She solidified this by chucking HHH to the ground and slapping Stephanie as the crowd ceaselessly chanted her name.

The Rousey/WWE connection was teased for a long while, to the extent that it felt like it might never actually happen. It would be three years before Rousey performed (and excelled) in her debut match, but this was when the magic first happened.


4. Warrior Saves The Day

Ultimate Warrior Hulk Hogan Wrestlemania 8
WWE.com

WrestleMania VIII is a lacklustre show on the whole, marred further by a terrible main event. Hulk Hogan vs Sid Justice wouldn’t have been a classic had everything gone to plan - and it very much didn’t. A botched finish saw Papa Shango miss his cue, and the American hero Hogan triumph over the odds by winning via DQ.

The saving grace - and it’s not often this sentiment will be expressed - was Ultimate Warrior. As Hogan took a pummelling from the heels, Warrior’s music hit to the jubilation of fans. He sprinted to the ring, demonstrating a hustle that Shango sadly lacked, and made the save, giving the fans something to remember from the finale of the show.

Though wrestling scuttlebutt wasn’t so widespread back then, the reality was perhaps even more of a shock, with Warrior leaving the company under a cloud the previous summer after reputedly holding Vince McMahon up for more money. On this night, Warrior made his triumphant return, and all was forgiven until he left again a few months later.


3. Brock Beats The Streak

Streak 21-1 Wrestlemania 30 Brock
WWE

Should Brock have been the one to beat the streak? Maybe. Should the streak have been beaten at all? Maybe not. Was the match a bit of a letdown due to Undertaker absorbing a bad blow to the head early doors? Unfortunately, yes.

Recriminations and fantasy booking aside, though, Undertaker’s first WrestleMania loss created an all-time great moment of disbelief. The incredulity can be read on the faces of everyone present at WrestleMania XXX (one instantly meme-able man particularly), and the slightly underwhelming nature of the finish only added to the realism of the moment.

Most wrestling fans probably thought the day would one day come - being the wrestler to beat the streak is too good a gift not to give away - but after seeing Undertaker overcome so many opponents at past WrestleManias, it was impossible not to back him for the win.

Instead, three F5s and a cornucopia of suplexes finally did the impossible, and Lesnar’s hand was raised as a stunned crowd watched on. Unsure how to react, but without a doubt they’d seen something historic.


2. Austin’s Deal With The Devil

Steve Austin, Vince McMahon, WrestleMania 17
WWE.com

Never has a WrestleMania been packed more full with thrills and spills than X-7, but they saved their biggest twist until the end. After an all-time great brawl between The Rock and Stone Cold Steve Austin to close the show, Vince McMahon came striding to the ring clutching a steel chair.

The animosity between Austin and McMahon was legendary, and the boss no doubt had malice in his mind - but few could have predicted that Vince would take the opportunity to side with his most hated foe, dish out shots to The Rock, and ultimately assist in Austin’s quest to seize the gold.

Austin and McMahon went on to form a team alongside Triple H, with the WWE owner concluding that he couldn’t beat the Rattlesnake, and choosing instead to join him. The fans couldn’t believe it, and it’s highlighted by the histrionic greatness of Jim Ross, bawling that Austin has made a deal with Satan himself.

The turn isn’t for everyone, with even Austin stating he wished he’d made the call to stun Vince instead of shaking his hand. There’s certainly something to that, but as dramatic choices go, this was bold stuff.


1. Rollins Cashes In

Seth Rollins WrestleMania 31
WWE.com

While it’s true that WWE tend to write themselves into corners, at times they can write themselves out of them, too. It’s 2015 and against all common sense, the company had ended up with a main event of Roman Reigns vs Brock Lesnar. The former wasn’t clicking as the marquee babyface, and the latter was in mercenary mode.

The fans were ready to dismiss the match altogether, but the two men put on too good of a match for that; physical, smart, and exciting. Still, no matter who won, a large proportion of the crowd was going to reject it. That is until Seth Rollins’ music hits, and the former Shield man sprints to the ring clutching his battered Money In The Bank briefcase. A few stops later, he’s the new WWE champion, having pulled off the heist of the century.

Not only was it a proper surprise - we’d never seen a mid-’Mania match cash in before - it was exactly the right storytelling decision, one that woke the crowd up as the dusk drew in and gave them a proper “I was there” moment.


In this post: 
WrestleMania
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Yorkshire-based writer of screenplays, essays, and fiction. Big fan of having a laugh. Read more of my stuff @ www.twotownsover.com (if you want!)