10 Biggest WrestleMania 31 Losers

Showcase of the defeated.

WrestleMania XXXI is officially in the books and while the WWE Universe may have been the biggest winners, thanks to a number of truly memorable moments and matches that have the potential to stand the test of time, not everyone was a winner coming out of the Showcase of the Immortals. For every Seth Rollins, The Rock, Ronda Rousey and John Cena, there are Superstars and Divas who lost considerable ground Sunday night and will now have to work harder than ever to regain some of the momentum that was erased by their booking on the grandest stage known to sports entertainment. From an icon the likes of Sting, who wrestled his first match in a World Wrestling Entertainment ring Sunday night, only to lose to the COO of the company, to the WWE Divas, who were once again robbed of time and left to wrestle what was essentially a bathroom break match, there were plenty of notable stars, male and female alike, who could use a shot of adrenaline and a boost of momentum in the wake of this year's otherwise critically acclaimed WrestleMania. Who joined the buxom beauties of WWE's main roster, as well as the face-painted vigilante, on the list of Superstars who lost a considerable amount of ground Sunday night? Glad you asked.


10. Bad News Barrett

In the weeks leading into WrestleMania, Bad News Barrett was repeatedly made to look like a chump, rather than a champ. Routinely losing, then enduring the indignity of having his WWE Intercontinental Championship stolen from him, Barrett was the furthest thing from a strong champion. He was even repeatedly outsmarted by R-Truth, further diminishing his status as an intellectual human being, let alone the quality of his championship reign. Sunday night, Barrett turned in a fine performance, nearly crushing Stardust with a superplex of a ladder before laying a few of his opponents out with the Bullhammer. But after dealing out a series of his finishing strikes, he disappeared from the equation. The champion was not involved in the outcome, a booking decision that put the nail in Barrett's coffin and killed any chance he had of being considered a credible titleholder. Going forward, it will be imperative for Barrett to get back to the heart of his Bad News character, which had him as over as he had ever been prior to his injury last spring. Focus on that aspect of his performance would behoove of WWE Creative, who is dangerously close to allowing the Brit to lose considerable momentum. Again. Something that has happened numerous times in the five-year career of Barrett.

9. Bray Wyatt

The Reaper of Souls again talked a big game but, when the time came to back it up, failed to pick up a win as he fell prey to two Tombstone piledrivers en route to adding his name to the impressive WrestleMania win-loss record of The Undertaker. Wyatt was impressive in defeat, turning in a performance from an in-ring standpoint that was vastly superior to his match with John Cena at last year's show, but it was for naught as fans are more likely to remember the fact that he lost another huge match in a long line of them. WWE has done a phenomenal job with the character, leading to some haunting moments and promos from Wyatt, a character very much like the Undertaker in terms of presence and aura. But for all of the positives surrounding the other aspects of the persona, the guy has yet to win a signature match that firmly establishes him as the new phenom of WWE. At some point, he is going to have to win on a grand stage, beating an elite star. While some may not have considered Sunday night as the best case for that to happen, what with Undertaker attempting to recover from last year's loss, a win over the Phenom would have instantly made Wyatt as a top heel in the industry. Instead, he must continue to chase that elusive victory in the wake of the event.

8. Ryback

Ryback was on a roll for the majority of the Andre the Giant Memorial Battle Royal, tossing his peers over the top rope and eliciting the strongest reactions from the WWE Universe. Intense and aggressive, it appeared as though the Big Guy would finally make up for his disappointing WrestleMania two years ago by winning the Kickoff Show match. Instead, like nine other guys in the contest, he was caught in the vise-like grip of the Big Show and tossed to the arena floor. The repeated misuse of Ryback is among the biggest disappointments in regards to WWE Creative. The guy has proven himself able to overcome poor booking, a demotion, and he still came back as popular and over as he previously was. Why continue to job him out in situations like this when a win in the battle royal would have helped elevate him in ways Big Show simply cannot be at this point.

7. Rusev

Strictly from an in-ring perspective, Rusev was brilliant. Not once during his match with John Cena did he look like a guy who has only been on the main roster for a year. He was crisp, solid and turned in one of his finest performances to date. After a year of being built up as an unstoppable beast who had yet to be pinned or submitted, he certainly deserved a much better end to his unbeaten streak. Given what WWE Creative is attempting to do with the Bulgarian Brute and Lana, teasing tension and dissension between the two, the finish certainly made sense. But that does not make it any less disappointing for Rusev, who went down to a single Attitude Adjustment on a night when every other major star on the roster kicked out of finishing maneuvers like they were simple clotheslines or something. Surviving a series of finishers and going down to Cena after a second or third A.A. would have been a more suitable way to bring an end to the Bulgarian Brute's impressive and character-defining streak.

6. WWE Divas

The #GiveDivasAChance movement across social media platforms led to World Wrestling Entertainment taking a step back and reconsidering their treatment of its female performers. Episodes of Raw and SmackDown saw the Bella Twins, Paige and AJ Lee received increased television time and, more importantly, freedom to have a match that was not confined to a three minute window. The March 23 episode of Raw gave fans of women's wrestling hope that things had changed for the better when Nikki Bella defended her Divas title in a match against Paige that lasted 10 minutes. That was not the case, however, as the Divas were stuck in the death slot of the show, the post-concert act that lacked crowd heat and attention from an audience hitting the concession stands and bathrooms in preparation of the night's second half. At only six minutes long, and with booking eerily similar to the match fans saw between the Bellas, Paige and Natalya at the Royal Rumble, the contest failed to carry over the momentum of the previous week, leaving the Divas to suffer the results.

5. WCW Fans

How many times do the fans and competitors of World Championship Wrestling have to be reminded that WWE won the so-called Monday Night Wars, put their company out of business and buried most of its talent? The answer, according to WWE brass, is "never enough." Sunday night, a WWE mainstay beat a WCW franchise player as Triple H defeated Sting, further hammering home the idea that everything owned by Vince McMahon is superior to everything that ever came out of Atlanta. Even Hulk Hogan, Kevin Nash and Scott Hall, three Hall of Famers, could not overcome career midcarders such as the New Age Outlaws and X-Pac, who took them out at ringside, then aided The Game in defeating the Icon. JBL reminded fans, repeatedly, that WWE had won again and all was right with the world. At least in the mind of Vince McMahon, who is ignorant of everything beyond his company's doors.

4. Finishing Maneuvers

There was a time when the finishing maneuvers of Superstars meant the end of a match. There were no ifs, ands or buts about it. In fact, kicking out of something like Hulk Hogan's leg drop made for a moment §the like of which were previously unfathomable. The Ultimate Warrior did just that at WrestleMania VI, a moment that led to Hogan's defeat. Sunday night demonstrated just how much the industry had changed in regards to finishers as seemingly every match featured an instance of a competitor kicking out of a finisher. While that lends drama to the matches and help makes WrestleMania that much more special, it also leads to the complete devaluation of the moves. When done correctly and effectively, the spot can add credibility to a wrestler. The perfect example is Roman Reigns during his match with Brock Lesnar. But those instances were hurt significantly by the fact that seemingly no finisher put an opponent down on the first try at WrestleMania. Seth Rollins and Randy Orton each kicked out of each other's trademark move, as did Sting and Triple H. Same with Undertaker and Bray Wyatt. It hurt the audience's ability to suspend disbelief and took away from what should have been a monumental show of strength and resiliency by Reigns late in the show.

3. Hideo Itami

When Hideo Itmai earned the right to be NXT's representative in the Andre the Giant Memorial Battle Royal, it appeared as though he was on his way to his own WrestleMania moment, a moment that would bring the hottest brand in professional wrestling to the forefront. Instead, like Ryback earlier in this list, he was yet another victim of the nonsensical desire to again push Big Show. Itami unleashed a flurry of his kicks and strikes, all the while the fans chants his name. He did not allow the impressive image of the World's Largest Athlete to intimidate him. He unloaded on the giant with open-hand strikes but found himself on the outside of the ring in short order. While commentators will play up Itami getting to perform on the 'Mania stage, he was an afterthought in the same way that Zack Ryder was and no positive spin will change that.

2. The Commentary Team

Some of the greatest moments in WrestleMania history are accompanied by soundbites from Jim Ross, Gorilla Monsoon, Jesse Venture and Vince McMahon himself. When fans look back at WrestleMania XXXI, images of Seth Rollins cashing in, Sting and Triple H shaking hands, The Rock and Ronda Rousey taking out The Authority and Brock Lesnar bleeding while gleefully throwing around Roman Reigns will be burned in the memories of fans. What will not be are those soundbites that enhance the moments. Truth be told, Michael Cole, John Bradshaw Layfield and Jerry Lawler are not cut out to do what those play-by-play and color commentators did. In a generation where everything is based in shilling the corporate sponsor, the next pay-per-view or the latest business venture, it makes it virtually impossible for that to happen. Cole is incredibly talented and does not get the credit he deserves for everything he is put in charge of relaying to the audience. With that said, if there is one glaring weakness in his performance, it is putting over the importance of moments in a way that creates those soundbites. King and JBL are background noise for the most part, the latter being particularly awful Sunday night until he uttered the line, run Mrs. McMahon, run" as she was about to come face-to-face with Ronda Rousey. On a night when so many history-making occurrences unfolded in front of 76,000 fans and millions watching at home, one brilliant call would have been nice.

1. Sting

For years, fans anxiously anticipated the moment that the Stinger would finally find his way to World Wrestling Entertainment. When he finally did in November 2014, fans imagined the scenarios that would present themselves. A feud with The Authority, an epic encounter with The Undertaker at WrestleMania. The options were endless and the merchandising and marketing possibilities were enough to justify the giant contract alone. Then, in one fell swoop, Sting walked into WrestleMania and lost to Triple H, ending any chance he had of becoming the special attraction that fans looked forward to returning. He was cut off at the knees from the start. Originally concerned about joining Vince McMahon's company because of the treatment other WCW stars were faced with, he had his concerns confirmed when he was beaten for one reason: to reaffirm WCW's place in history as WWE's b****. It was a disappointing conclusion to what could very well be Sting's one and only WrestleMania appearance, not to mention a loss that threatens to undermine his entire Vigilante persona.

Contributor
Contributor

Erik Beaston is a freelance pro wrestling writer who likes long walks in the park, dandelions and has not quite figured out that this introduction is not for Match.com. He resides in Parts Unknown, where he hosts weekly cookouts with Kane, The Ultimate Warrior, Papa Shango and The Boogeyman. Be jealous.