10 Biggest Wrestlers Not Signed To WWE Or AEW
Ooooh, what a Rush!
The (sigh) 'second wrestling war' is in full swing, and the battle lines have long been drawn. The cream of the proverbial cup of cocoa has been lapped up by each of the monied belligerents, and just about anybody who is anybody in the business finds themselves on either side of theatre of combat.
With some exceptions. There still remains a veritable No Man's Land belonging to neither the McMahon men or the AEW army, housing an array of potentially decisive would-be soldiers, currently plying their trade for a range of private paramilitaries.
This, for the sake of clarity - and for the sake of putting this over-extended metaphor out of its misery - does not apply to New Japan Pro Wrestling. In spite of their attempts to expand into the USA, they are fighting fit on their own front. Their talent doesn't belong on this list.
But who are the other top stars around the world today, not signed to either of the 'Big Two', who could add extra ammunition to their already considerable arsenals? And what are the chances we'll see them conscripted to Stamford or Jacksonville some time soon?
10. Flip Gordon
The Man that Forgot Gravity has seemingly been forgotten by AEW, despite being a sizeable component of All In's proceedings, where he dramatically emerged from the mask of Chicho El Luchador to prevail in the pre-show battle royal and later compete for Ring Of Honor's championship.
Gordon's prominent role in Chicago was the culmination of his embedded involvement in Being The Elite, and with Cody in particular cooing over the flipping Flat Earther, a place in the newly founded All Elite Wrestling would have been an absolute guarantee - but for the fact he signed a two-year contract with ROH last November.
The start of his renewed tenure with the company has been a little rocky. A nasty MCL tear ruled him out of the first quarter of 2019, and dreaded visa issues prevented his inclusion in this year's Best of the Super Juniors link up with New Japan. If he regains his form, could we be discussing a move to one of the 'Big Two' for Flip this time next year?
9. Joey Ryan
Like many on this list, Joey Ryan was a huge, ahem, member of All In's presentation, the supposed stiff rising from the dead to ejaculate Joey Janela from the show. The purveyor of the Penis Party was still under lock and key with Lucha Underground at the time, so AEW's inability to snag his signature shortly after their formation was out of their hands.
Ryan gained his release from the clutches of the El Rey Network as a part of the class-action lawsuit against LU in May, and yet his services remain strictly independent. In spite - or perhaps because of - his tongue-in-cheek, dick-in-hand gimmick, Ryan rejected a role in WWE, where he worked a dark match in 2013. Unwilling to give up his money spinning routine, and a little too young to take a coaching role, the snub made sense. But why hasn't he turned up in AEW?
The man with the most powerful todger in wrestling told the Not Sam podcast back in May that he realised Tony Khan's venture would be successful without him, and he without them. Presumably then, for now, it's a financial reason.
8. Tessa Blanchard
Tully Blanchard might be one of the more surprising wrestling comeback stories of the year, a significant and some might say essential piece of the Shawn Spears jigsaw in AEW, but the fact his daughter continues to pull up trees over in Impact came as no surprise to anybody.
Even though the company is in a seemingly permanent state of financial impecunity, Impact were quick to tie 'The Diamond of Professional Wrestling' down as their highest paid earner ($20 and a Curly Wurly). It's not without good reason; Blanchard is widely regarded as one of the finest female performers out there, and would be a considerable asset to both AEW's slender women's roster and even WWE's ballooned selection.
The fact Blanchard has not turned up on Dynamite so far confirms that, unlike some of her Impact colleagues, her contract is entirely waterproof. And nor is she seeking pastures new. For now, she's quite content being the star of a tenured albeit tepid product.
7. Marty Scurll
All Elite Wrestling, as the name logically suggests, was propagated by the web success of YouTube hit Being The Elite, a road journal/cum skit-show revolving around the exploits of the Bullet Club's eponymous Elite. Marty Scurll was a key component of that kliq, and as his Bullet Club buddies, one of the fulcrums of last September's Elite-heavy All In.
When AEW launched, the Elite's heavy involvement was implicit, and sure enough, Executive VPs Cody and co. were plastered all over the PR. But The Villain was missing from the lineup. Scurll had signed a contract extension with Ring Of Honor last August; the company were happy for him to appear at All In, but less inclined to break their agreement after AEW had effectively stabbed them in the back.
Marty's deal expires in November, after which we can almost certainly expect to see him alight on Dynamite - even if he has apparently fielded tentative overtures from WWE.
6. Colt Cabana
AEW's failure to move for Colt Cobana is in no way through political expediency; both he and CM Punk shared the floor at Starrcast III, in spite of their very public and very bitter legal spat, and it doesn't seem to be a case of not one nor the other one. It's a little odd: the Chicago native was a popular constituent of All In, and his commentary services could have proved valuable for a startup company literally struggling to find its voice.
Cabana is still tied to Ring Of Honor, though it's not likely the 39 year old is locked into a multi-year deal like top stars Rush and Marty Scurll. Obviously, a return for 'Scotty Goldman' to WWE is utterly unthinkable, after his Art of Wrestling podcast ultimately invoked medic Chris Amman to seek legal satisfaction. If, somehow, bygones can become bygones, there might be a place for Cabana in NXT as a trainer; Paul Levesque is more likely to forgive, if Vince McMahon has forgotten.
5. Mercedes Martinez
Two time Mae Young Classic competitor Mercedes Martinez's current status with AEW can best be described as 'indeterminate'. The former Women's Superstars Uncensored star made a cameo as the 'Joker' in the Casino Battle Royal at AEW's All Out, where she was eliminated by Britt Baker. It seemed, for the time being, as if the company were planting the seeds for a programme between Martinez and the MD, but we haven't seen her since.
Having twice been part of their erratically annual women's tournament, WWE bigwigs are clearly somewhat sweet on Mercedes' services. Is she currently embroiled in a contractual tug of war between the rival promotions? We don't actually know. Watch this space.
4. Rush
A whole host of hungry suitors will be rushing for the similarly-styled Rush's signature when his association with Ring Of Honor ends, though given the trouble his commitment to the company landed him in recently - and indeed, the fact he is their top champion - that's not likely to be any time soon.
When the founder of Los Ingobernables elected to skip CMLL's 86th Anniversary Show in favour of his American employers Death Before Dishonor - where he captured the ROH World Championship from Matt Taven - he and brother Dragon Lee found an envelope containing a P45 slipped through their door. The pair had been fired for their impertinence, even though Rush, knowing what was coming, had made his independent status clear a few days prior.
For now, he's very much locked down to ROH then. But his honour bound is only spread across one continent, and who knows if the infamously febrile performer might try to fly the coop early once again?
3. PCO
You have to pinch yourself harder than the concrete the man in question is prepared to throw his rough leather hide onto to properly appreciate the sheer absurdity of legitimately discussing PCO - that is, for those uninitiated, Pierre Ouellette of The Quebecers - amongst a list of wrestling's hottest independents.
And yet here he is. The 51-year-old's unexpected comeback has evolved out of novelty to see him currently positioned as the top contender for Ring Of Honor's premier title. Yes, the company's roster is greatly depreciated, but there's still talent amidst the ranks. That the Montreal man is in this position is no accident, nor joke.
That said, age isn't on his side. There's virtually no chance whatsoever that the one time Jean-Pierre Lafitte will resume his hunt of Bret Hart's jacket in WWE, and any appearances in AEW are likely to be short-term. Still, his comeback couldn't have realistically been predicted, so nothing can be discounted.
2. FreeAgentZ
Lord knows Enzo and Cass... ahem, nZo and CaZXL... have tried to get back through the door. The problem is that nobody with any sense is answering - and unfortunately for the pair, that includes pretty much everybody.
The former NXT stars briefly looked to have made it back into the big time when they gatecrashed Ring Of Honor's huge G1 Supercard special over WrestleMania weekend, their recent history of causing a stir and Bret Hart's own unexpected assault at the Hall of Fame generating something akin to genuine buzz. But the pair stupidly outstayed their welcome, turned the skit into a personal peacock parade, and promptly blued the feet of ROH's head office.
Despite the false start - and more importantly, the pair's disgraced reputations in Stamford - rumours began circulating in August that the team would re-alight in NXT as the former developmental brand prepared to step up to national TV. WWE, utterly aghast at the suggestion, quickly moved to deny any chance of the impossible happening. Heck, there was more chance of CM Punk hosting their new FS1 sh... oh.
So WWE are off the table then, at least for the time being. How about AEW? It seems highly unlikely. FreeAgentZ's name is mud amongst discerning wrestling fans - for their work as much as their scandals - and for a company trading on giving fans what they want, it wouldn't be a good look. Still, they also pride themselves on inclusivity; perhaps forgiveness is part and parcel of that remit?
1. CM Punk
Sigh. This again. There's no wrestling fan alive who doesn't know the (very literal) trials and tribulations of Phil Brooks, from his WWE departure up to his most recent flirtation with FOX Network. The answer on his potential return to wrestling remains the same as ever: don't hold your breath.
The fact the closest Punk has came to getting back into bed with the business he once loved has been as a mooted talk show host tells the story of just how much he doesn't want a return. He has, by all accounts, burned his bridges with AEW - even if that fire could be designed to produce a smokescreen - and at this stage, following a humiliating MMA run, there's no reason for him to trade his 'Best in the World' reputation on a comeback.
It isn't happening. Until it does.