10 Biggest WWE Attitude Era Controversies

Domestic abuse, sexual harassment, deaths and nudity, the 'Attitude Era' had it all...

WWE have stated a number of different starting points for the 'Attitude Era', including both the King Of The Ring 1996 event and WrestleMania XIV. On both occasions, 'Stone Cold' Steve Austin was involved, winning the tournament and coining his 'Austin 3:16' catchphrase at the former, and capturing his first WWF Heavyweight Title at the latter. Given that the company first introduced the 'WWF Attitude' branding and logo at the 1997 Survivor Series event, that show will be used as the starting point of the 'Attitude Era' for the purpose of this article. This period extends right up until the company re-branded as WWE in May, 2002, due to ongoing legal pressure from the World Wildlife Fund. Many fans like to stretch and play with the guidelines for exactly what falls under the banner of the controversial era, but few can contend the fact that it was one of the most creatively exciting times to be a pro wrestling fan. WCW were trying their best to dominate the industry, and had actually superseded the WWF as the industry leader, but that would all start to change once Vince McMahon embraced 'Attitude'. The era was well-named, and all of these moments (for better or worse) sum up that incendiary time, when the then-WWF would do anything they could think of to lead the ongoing ratings war with World Championship Wrestling.


10. The Big Boss Man Mocks Big Show's Dead Father

It may seem like a controversial statement, but during his first few years in the promotion, Paul Wight - otherwise known as The Big Show - was not a crucial member of the WWF roster. In fact, even after Vince McMahon stated that he'd show WCW how to book a giant properly, the WWF proceeded to book Wight in a worse fashion than WCW ever had during his time there as The Giant. As if any words were required to go with the picture that accompanies this entry, Big Show went from dominating powerhouse in February, 1999, to short-lived WWF Heavyweight Champion hitching a ride on the coffin of his daddy towards the end of the year. During an ill-fated feud against The Big Boss Man, Show and the WWF courted controversy by including a story arc which revolved around Boss Man mocking Show's deceased father. The idea was that The Big Boss Man would come across as wholly cruel for bringing something like this into proceedings, but it fell largely flat, and fans seemed to feel pretty uncomfortable with the whole deal. A brief match at the Armageddon Pay-Per-View in December did nothing for either man, and Show would drop the WWF Title to Triple H just a few short weeks later.

9. DX Invades WCW Monday Nitro

Throughout the entire 'Monday Night Wars', Vince McMahon and his merry band of creative team members liked to pretend that World Championship Wrestling were far from a successful company. Instead of acknowledging that problems were internal (fans latched onto the cool nWo concept, leaving the more cartoon-like, safe WWF in the dust), McMahon instead poked fun at 'Dubya C Dubya' routinely. By the time D-Generation X decided to 'invade' an episode of WCW Monday Nitro in late-April of 1998, the tide had already started to turn in the WWF's favour. Hot angles including the likes of Steve Austin vs. Vince McMahon, and Austin's confrontation with Mike Tyson, had been extremely popular, and the WWF was suddenly hip and fresh once more. To show just how far each promotion was willing to go to undermine the other, the WWF even doctored pictures of a billboard advertising Nitro, altering the image so that it showed there were still seats available, when in reality the show was pretty darn close to being sold out. DX would never actually get inside the arena for Nitro, but this was a crucial (and controversial) PR exercise from the McMahon family.

8. The Kat Strips Off

By the time the Armageddon Pay-Per-View rolled around in December, 1999, the WWF had long since established itself as the dominant force in North American pro wrestling again. WCW's star had shone brightly for a few years, but the Atlanta-based organisation were showing distinct cracks at the new millennium approached, and didn't seem to have any ideas on how they could turn things around. In a way, Vince McMahon's WWF could do whatever the heck they wanted by this point, WCW were in free fall. Nonetheless, looking to court controversy and get some headline news space, the promotion's brain trust booked Stacy 'Miss. Kitty' Carter to strip off her top on Pay-Per-View, taking the whole 'sex' aspect of the Attitude Era to a whole new level. Also known as 'The Kat', Carter removed her bikini following victory in a 4-Corners Evening Gown Pool Match against Ivory, B.B and Jacqueline for the WWF Women's Championship. This kind of bout was commonplace during this era, as the females of the promotion served no other purpose than to be eye candy. Sable had went topless before, albeit with paint to cover some skin, but Carter went full-on naked!

7. The Undertaker 'Crucifies' Steve Austin

The Undertaker's evil overlord gimmick of the late-90's must stand as one of the most prolific and interesting portions of his career. Leading The Ministry Of Darkness, 'Taker excelled as a top heel, following years of playing main-event babyface. It seemed like the man himself was intrigued by the possibilities of what this tweak on his famous character could create, but in December, 1998, that persona would manifest controversy, and a hell of a lot of complaints from viewers. Strapping Steve Austin to his "symbol", The Undertaker would pretty much crucify 'Stone Cold', his opponent for the upcoming Rock Bottom PPV. The pair were set to collide in a Buried Alive match on the supershow, but all eyes were on Monday Night Raw, where the WWF experienced a plethora of criticism for booking such an angle. On the original broadcast of the show, lead announcer Jim Ross outright said that Undertaker had crucified Austin, but when the show was sent to international markets, the commentary was altered to state that 'Taker had simply strapped Austin to his symbol in a show of power. This storyline nuance brilliantly outlines the difference between the Attitude Era and today's product, this wouldn't happen in 2015.

6. Road Warrior Hawk Appears To Commit Suicide

The act of taking one's own life is something which doesn't really have a place in the realm of professional wrestling, but WWF/WWE have visited the thought of suicide on more than one occasion. Not only did long-time referee Tim White appear to kill himself on WWE television in 2005, but 7 years earlier, the idea of Road Warrior Hawk ending it all was also explored. Standing atop the Titantron video wall, Hawk was set to take the plunge, something which acted as a main story thread for one episode of Monday Night Raw. There's no denying that it all came across as pretty unnecessary, and not exactly the kind of thing that people want to think about when tuning into a wrestling broadcast. Hawk had been going through some very real personal demons with drugs and alcohol, something which was written into his on-screen character. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9geNPA9zQPA Struggling with his chemical addictions, Hawk was booked to slur his speech on commentary and generally act as though he didn't want to be alive any longer. Eventually, it seemed the young upstart Droz would push Hawk off the top of the tron, but the insinuation from the announcers was that the man had jumped to his death.

5. Sable Sues Vince McMahon For Sexual Harassment

By 1999, Sable was one of the biggest stars in the WWF. Having posed for Playboy (in one of the biggest-selling issues in the history of that particular magazine) and after showing ample flesh on wrestling television, Sable had gone from cheer-leading valet to her then-husband Marc Mero, to a monster star in her own right. The WWF couldn't ignore what fans wanted to see, more Sable, and she became a featured member of the roster relatively quickly, far outshining Mero and splitting from him. After becoming the largest name in the women's division, Sable would confusingly depart the company in June, 1999, shockingly filing a $10 million lawsuit against the promotion. Citing sexual harassment and unsafe working conditions, Sable would eventually settle out of court with the WWF in August, before returning to the promotion years later in 2003. It was a little strange - sexual harassment is quite clearly a serious issue, but it did seem a little rich to be blaming the WWF for begging her to go topless, when Sable seemed only too happy to be flaunting her goods week-to-week.

4. McMahon Makes Trish Stratus Bark Like A Dog

There's no doubt about it, this is the kind of angle that WWE officials were hoping would be forgotten about during Linda McMahon's run for office in politics. Unsurprisingly, Linda's opponents in the race for Senate didn't overlook her middle-aged husband forcing a woman 20 years his junior to strip off her clothes and bark like a dog on live television. Just before the acclaimed WrestleMania X-Seven Pay-Per-View in 2001, this sorry angle came to a head on Monday Night Raw. Looking to belittle his 'assistant', Stratus, McMahon lorded it over the woman, stripping her down to her lingerie and telling her to get down on her hands and knees and beg him for forgiveness. The live crowd lapped it up, but there were a few uncomfortable looks as Vince made Trish bark like a mutt, and beg him to give her another chance. A flood of complaints came in as soon as the segment was finished, but it's been said that controversy creates cash, all this did was turn more heads towards what the promotion were doing, and the monster buyrate for 'Mania didn't suffer one bit.

3. The Montreal Screwjob

So much has been written about the events of the 1997 Survivor Series show main event between Shawn Michaels and Bret Hart that it's almost impossible to give a fresh take on things without retreading old ground. With that in mind, this is one issue which will never stop being explored, because it was one of the most fascinating nights in wrestling history. About to leave the WWF for WCW and not entirely chuffed about the prospect of losing the WWF Heavyweight Title to his real-life rival Shawn Michaels, Hart went into the title match at Survivor Series thinking that the bout would end in disqualification. Unfortunately for he, Vince McMahon, Michaels, Triple H and referee Earl Hebner had concocted another plan. Once Michaels locked Hart in his own Sharpshooter submission move, Vince called for the timekeeper to ring the bell. Thus, Bret had effectively been screwed out of the belt, and wasn't allowed to leave the WWF with his head held high. The incident is explored in-depth during the compelling 'Wrestling With Shadows' documentary, showing incredible backstage footage before and after the match.

2. Steve Austin & Debra Domestic Abuse Woes

In the Summer of 2002, Steve Austin was in a weird place in his life. Having been a mega-star since his explosion as 'Stone Cold' in 1998, Austin had also been a very well-regarded pro wrestler for years before that. Sadly, injuries mounted up for the man, and by the time 2002 rolled around, his star wasn't shining quite as brightly as it had before. To make matters worse, his personal life wasn't exactly running smoothly either. Marrying Debra Marshall in September, 2000, the pair would divorce officially in February, 2003, but not before allegations of domestic abuse were levied against Austin, thrusting him into the news headlines for all the wrong reasons. Shortly after Austin had walked out on WWE in early-June, 2002, police were called to the residence he shared with Debra on June 15th. Arrested for apparently becoming aggressive with his wife, Austin was ordered to pay a $1,000 fine, fulfill 80 hours community service, and handed a year's probation. Needless to say, this was not good press for the guy, who thankfully was able to get his career back on track in 2003 for one big last hurrah against The Rock at WrestleMania XIX.

1. Owen Hart Tragically Dies During Pay-Per-View

It's still one of the most sensitive talking points in WWF/WWE history, and one of the most controversial nights to ever take place in the name of professional wrestling. When Owen Hart plummeted to his death from the top of the Kemper Arena in Kansas City, Missouri on May 23rd, 1999, the entire wrestling world was left shocked and saddened. Reading Bret Hart's words in his autobiography on how he found out about the passing of his brother is especially harrowing. On a flight when he was told the news, it must have been hell for Bret to sit and ponder what had happened to his younger brother. There would have been understandable anger towards Vince McMahon and the WWF for allowing this to happen, but the over-riding feeling must have been one of shock. An equipment failure caused Owen's death. Set to rappel from the rafters of the arena into the ring, the safety harness failed, and the man fell from his lofty perch, striking the ring ropes with his chest and subsequently laying prone in the ring. On his way to hospital, Owen Hart died, and Vince McMahon's decision to continue with the Over The Edge Pay-Per-View is still one of the most controversial choices in WWF/WWE's rich history. What other controversial moments which happened during the 'Attitude Era' can you think of? What are your thoughts on the ones included in this list? Let us know down in the comments section below!

Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.