10 Biggest WWE Royal Rumble Falls From Grace

WWE Royal Rumble - From Great To Not-So-Great!

Taz Royal Rumble
WWE.com/WWE.com

To many wrestling fans, WWE's annual Royal Rumble PPV is the highlight of the wrestling calendar.

Across its 30+-year lifespan, the Rumble has offered up so many brilliant moments. The Royal Rumble match itself poses so many possibilities where it pertains to surprise returns or shocking debuts, but the PPV as a whole has also delivered so many non-Rumble matches that have long remained in the memory.

While WWE may market WrestleMania as its biggest show of the year, many a fan would happily shun the company's Showcase of the Immortals in favour of the Royal Rumble. WrestleMania may have the glitz and spectacle, SummerSlam may have the sizzle and sun, yet the Rumble forever delivers on a whole host of fronts.

For some wrestlers, though, the Royal Rumble PPV has proven to be both great and not-so-great, for they've had a Royal Rumble outing of legendary status followed up by a Rumble offering that was completely and utterly horrendous for one of many reasons.

Here, then, it's take to take a look at those stars who went from a huge Royal Rumble high to a major Royal Rumble low in just 12 months.

10. The Returning Legend Becomes A Disposable Body - Bob Backlund

Bob Backlund Royal Rumble
WWE.com

With two reigns as WWE Champion under his belt - including one that lasted an impressive 1,470 days before coming to an end at the hands of the Iron Sheik - Bob Backlund made his WWE exit in 1984.

Backlund made a quiet return to the company in late 1992, and he surprisingly became the iron man of the 1993 Royal Rumble that. Not just was Bob somewhat of a surprise entrant in that contest, more surprising was how the veteran lasted over an hour after entering the match at #2 - being the second-to-last person to be eliminated from the contest, as Yokozuna went onto emerge victorious.

Skip ahead a year, and this favourite of yesteryear had a vastly different Royal Rumble outing. As part of Diesel's decimation of the '94 Rumble match, Backlund was eliminated after just 41 brief seconds.

As the insta-smiling, baby-kissing, granny-hugging Bob Backlund character had spent the past 12 months struggling to fully connect with the '90s WWE audience, 1994 wasn't a total bust for the amateur standout - for a character change rewarded Backlund with one final, extremely brief WWE Championship that served as the perfect way to move the title from Bret Hart to Diesel.


9. The Last Man Becomes The First Man - Rusev

Rusev Royal Rumble
WWE.com

The general consensus of wrestling fans and media is that WWE massively dropped the ball with Rusev - and that's because WWE massively dropped the ball with Rusev!

A powerhouse oozing with charisma, who could go in the ring, and who was great as either a babyface or a heel, the Bulgarian Brute should've been a fully-fledged main event act with at least one WWE Championship run under his belt. As it stands, Rusev left WWE last April, and these days can be found as Miro over in AEW.

At the 2015 Royal Rumble, Rusev entered the match at #15 and went onto crack skulls for 35 minutes, eliminating six people, before being the last man eliminated as Roman Reigns won out. It was a brilliant showing from Ru-Ru, and it looked as if this could be a stepping stone to greater things.

Fast forward to the 2016 Royal Rumble, and Rusev would again be eliminated by Reigns - just this time it was 90 seconds into the Rumble match, with the Bulgarian having started at the #2 spot after the Big Dog entered at #1.


8. From Major Debut, To Huge Win Over The Undertaker, To Cannon Fodder - Vader

Vader Royal Rumble 1997 Royal Rumble 1998
WWE.com

WWE's annual Royal Rumble PPV is a great barometer for measuring Vader's tenure with the company.

Ahead of the 1996 Rumble, WWE programming was heavily promoting the impending arrival of this former WCW World Heavyweight Champion. When that year's January extravaganza rolled around, the the Man They Call Vader turned up in the Rumble match and decimated numerous poor souls before being eliminated by Shawn Michaels. Not content with that, Vader returned to the ring and left a trail of bodies in his wake as he finally made his way backstage.

At this point, it was clear WWE viewed Vader as a main event attraction who was destined to tangle with some of the company's biggest names.

Skipping ahead to the 1997 Royal Rumble, WWE still saw value in Vader, as the Mastodon picked up a huge singles win over the Undertaker, and then the hulking powerhouse was utilised as one of the final four in the Rumble match itself later that night.

It's between 1997 and 1998 that the WWE fall from grace over Vader really kicked into gear, though. From a dominant display in 1996 and a mammoth victory over the iconic Undertaker in 1997, the '98 Royal Rumble PPV saw Vader eliminated by Goldust just two minutes after entering the contest at #30 - with Vader having bested Goldie in in the PPV's opening match.

With WWE clearly having no idea how best to use Vader, it came as no real surprise to see Leon White depart the company in 1998 after referring to himself as "a big fat piece of sh*t" on WWE television.


7. WWE Title Match Against Brock Lesnar, To Eliminated In Two Minutes - Hardcore Holly

Hardcore Holly Royal Rumble 2004 Royal Rumble 2005
WWE.com

Did anybody really expect Hardcore Holly to topple Brock Lesnar, become WWE Champion and embark on a lengthy run as SmackDown's top star at the 2004 Royal Rumble PPV? Likely not. But that doesn't stop the 2004 and 2005 editions of the Rumble event being a significant 'drop' for Holly.

Playing off the very real breaking off Hardcore's neck in a match with Brock Lesnar over a year prior, the 2004 Royal Rumble event had the former Sparky Plugg in a role that he'd never before been featured in - that of a World Championship challenger on one of WWE's biggest PPVs of the year.

WWE has so often used the Royal Rumble PPV to experiment with more left-field choices competing for some of the company's biggest prizes, yet the example of Hardcore Holly is likely the most random example of this in the PPV's history.

By the time of the following year's Royal Rumble, it was very much back to normal for Hardcore - with him the second person eliminated from the 2005 Rumble match, lasting just short of two minutes in that bout.


6. Allowed A Genuine Match, To Then Only Afforded 20 Seconds - The Women's Championship

Melina Royal Rumble 2009 Mickie James Royal Rumble 2010
WWE.com

*Sigh*

Until the Divas Revolution, the women of WWE had had a murky past when it came to the company's annual Royal Rumble PPV.

While there were several years where WWE didn't even feature a women's match on the Rumble, one major fall from grace came in 2010.

The previous year's Royal Rumble show saw Melina defeat Beth Phoenix to become the new WWE Women's Champion in a match that, while relatively short at six minutes, was on the higher end of what WWE's female talent were allowed to put on at that point in time.

In 2010, though, the Women's Championship, and the women wrestlers, period, were given an almighty slap in the face when WWE gave its audience a Women's Championship that was just 20 seconds in duration.

To many, this was even more disrespectful than having no women's match on the PPV, with it dismaying to see WWE only able to award 20 seconds to the Women's Championship on an event that lasted for three hours. Adding further to the bad taste of WWE's treatment of its women's division, this was at the time when the SmackDown brand was running with its god-awful "Piggy James" trash.

James did get her revenge here, defeating Michelle McCool to become the new Women's Champion - but c'mon, man, 20 seconds?!


5. The Iron Man Of 2012 Lands On The Pre-Show Of 2013 - The Miz

The Miz Royal Rumble 2012 Royal Rumble 2013
WWE.com

The 2013 Royal Rumble PPV was a fall from grace for the Miz, although there is a slight caveat to all of this.

At the 2012 event, the Miz was the standout iron man of the Rumble match. At 45 minutes, the Awesome One spent more time than anyone else in that 54-minute contest. Along with Cody Rhodes, Miz was key to keeping the Royal Rumble contest ticking along nicely as Sheamus went onto emerge victorious.

From being the workhorse star of the show, the 2013 Royal Rumble PPV saw the Miz reduced to working a swift seven-minute match on the event's pre-show, followed by a lame duck five-minute appearance in the Rumble itself.

That aforementioned caveat? Well, the silver lining in 2013 was that said pre-show match did show WWE's resident A-lister challenging for a title - although that challenge was a losing effort as the Miz went after the United States Championship held by Cesaro.

To think, the 2013 Royal Rumble took place two years after the Miz retained the WWE Championship against Randy Orton at the 2011 Royal Rumble PPV, before then going onto successfully retain the gold against John Cena at WrestleMania XXVII.


4. From Main Event Momentum, To Just... Nothing - Owen Hart

Owen Hart Royal Rumble
WWE.com

The 1994 Royal Rumble PPV was Owen Hart's coming-out party.

Having forever been presented as nothing more than the plucky babyface brother of Bret Hart on WWE television over the prior years, the Rumble '94 saw Owen viciously attack the Hitman as part of a heel turn that kickstarted a main event run that would ultimately be the highlight of the high-flying Hart brother's career.

With the seeds having been initially sowed at the '93 Survivor Series, the 1994 Royal Rumble put into motion one of the all-time great wrestling stories.

Owen would get a monumental win over the Excellence of Execution in a stunning WrestleMania X opener, and Bret's WWE Championship win later that night put the pair on a further collision course - this time with gold on the line.

A King of the Ring win followed in June '94 as Owen became the King of Harts, and SummerSlam '94 saw the Hart siblings put on a cage match that many refer to as the greatest cage match in company history.

So, as 1994 rolled into 1995, Owen Hart was firmly established as a believable main event star, right? The momentum of '94 was to be perfectly harnessed into a strong Royal Rumble match showing in January '95, right?

Sadly not, for Owen lasted just three seconds in the 1995 Royal Rumble, thrown over the top rope by brother-in-law Davey Boy Smith.

If that wasn't bad enough, the Rocket and his other brother-in-law, Jim Neidhart, weren't even good enough to advance past the first round of a tournament designed to crown new Tag Team Champions at that edition of the Rumble PPV.


3. Former World Title Contender Gets Eliminated Off-Screen - Scott Steiner

Scott Steiner Royal Rumble 2003 Royal Rumble 2004
WWE.com

When WWE assimilated WCW in 2001, one of the big WCW stars who initially remained out of reach was Big Poppa Pump, Scott Steiner.

Upon Steiner making his WWE return and immediately being lined up against Triple H for the 2003 Royal Rumble, anticipation was high as to what to expect from the Big Bad Booty Daddy. Unfortunately, Scott Steiner of 2003 wasn't Scott Steiner of 2000, and a fused ankle massively restricted what the former WCW World Heavyweight Champion was able to do between the ropes.

Regardless of how awful his Rumble contest against Triple H was - and their subsequent rematch - there's no disputing that WWE thought of Steiner as a big-time player, as reflected by his spot going up against Vince McMahon's perennial golden goose, the Game.

By the time of the 2004 Royal Rumble PPV, though, the bloom had come off the rose for Scott Steiner's second WWE run.

While Triple H was again in action defending his WWE World Heavyweight Championship at the 2004 Rumble, it was a drastically different situation for Scott Steiner - with him a generic body in the Royal Rumble match, lasting six minutes before being eliminated by WCW rival Booker T.

Making things even worse in 2004, the WWE production crew actually missed Steiner's elimination in real-time, and thus it was only viewable via a replay.


2. An All-Time Rumble Great Goes Out With A Whimper In Saudi Arabia - Chris Jericho

Chris Jericho Greatest Royal Rumble 2018
WWE.com

Chris Jericho was about to fly the nest rather than fall from grace as he entered last in 2018's controversial Greatest Royal Rumble, but the '61 Minute Man's iconic WWE legacy was parked in rather sour fashion just a year after breaking a record in the January classic.

It was during his mammoth 2017 stint that Y2J became the wrestler to spend the longest cumulative time in Royal Rumbles, all to inform an eventual WrestleMania match with Kevin Owens. The exceptional breakup was reduced to United States Championship fodder at the 'Show Of Shows', but Jericho was far from unfazed. By the end of 2017, he was setting up a monster Wrestle Kingdom showdown with Kenny Omega in New Japan Pro Wrestling.

'Alpha Vs Omega' proved to be a transcendent moment for the entire industry - not that you'd have any idea at Greatest Royal Rumble. The man that had just played a part in something that would finally birth a North American opposition to Vince McMahon wrestled just three minutes in a bloated and unappealing slab of evidence for why the monopoly needed to be broken. He's not been in a WWE ring since.


1. White-Hot Debutant Becomes Just Another Victim - Tazz

Taz Royal Rumble
WWE.com/WWE.com

Being totally honest, Tazz was the inspiration for this entire article.

When the Human Suplex Machine made his WWE debut at the 2000 Royal Rumble, it felt huge. The Madison Square Garden crowd went absolutely nuts when the former ECW World Champion was revealed as Kurt Angle's mystery opponent at that PPV. And even better than that, Tazz went on to choke out the Olympic Hero, ending Angle's undefeated streak in the process.

This felt special, this felt like a genuinely big deal, and it even now holds up as one of the great WWE debuts.

It's just utterly baffling, then, to reflect back on how things played out for Tazz's in-ring WWE days.

From being introduced as one of the hottest acts in the company, 12 months later we found Tazz just another generic body in the 2001 Royal Rumble match. There, he lasted a legitimate 10 seconds and got zero offense in on his way to being eliminated by Kane.

Sure, that 2001 Rumble had Kane running roughshod, but it's spectacular to look at Tazz's 2001 Rumble fare when compared to that of the year prior.

Things would get a little better for the Redhook native at the 2002 Royal Rumble, as he and Spike Dudley dethroned the Dudley Boyz to become WWE Tag team Champions. Still, that was a far, far cry from the brooding badass who rocked up in WWE on 23 January, 2000.


Watch Next


Senior Writer
Senior Writer

Once described as the Swiss Army Knife of WhatCulture, Andrew can usually be found writing, editing, or presenting on a wide range of topics. As a lifelong wrestling fan, horror obsessive, and comic book nerd, he's been covering those topics professionally as far back as 2010. In addition to his current WhatCulture role of Senior Content Producer and Presenter, Andrew previously spent nearly a decade as Online Editor and Lead Writer for the world's longest-running genre publication, Starburst Magazine, and his work has also been featured on BBC, TechRadar, Tom's Guide, WhatToWatch, Sportkskeeda, and various other outlets, in addition to being a Rotten Tomatoes-approved film critic. Between his main day job, his role as lead panel host of Wales Comic Con, and his gig as a pre-match host for Wrexham AFC games, Andrew has also carried out a hugely varied amount of interviews, from the likes of Robert Englund and Eli Roth to Kevin Smith and the Russo Brothers, to Kevin Conroy and Frank Miller, to Bret Hart and Sting, to Mickey Thomas, Joey Jones, Phil Parkinson, and Brian Flynn, to many, many more. Where his beloved Wrexham AFC is concerned, Andrew is a long-standing season ticket holder and an FSA Award-winner for his time co-hosting the Fearless in Devotion podcast.