10 Biggest WWE Summerslam Controversies

Backstage fights, non-PG moments, broken bones and more WWE SummerSlam drama!

Chris Jericho Brock Lesnar Randy Orton Paul Heyman WWE SummerSlam 2016
WWE

SummerSlam is often regarded as the 'second most important WWE pay-per-view of the year'. That's the first controversial statement handled here, because many fans of a certain vintage would point to January's Royal Rumble as the true backup for undoubted kingpin WrestleMania.

WWE's "Biggest Party Of The Summer" has been newsworthy since its inception in 1988 though - there's no denying that. Some of the most dramatic moments in company history have taken place on the July/August supershow, and a fair number of them didn't even happen inside the ring.

Ageing bad boy rockstars have gone against WWE's PG certification during short cameos, top stars have held Vince McMahon up for bigger paydays behind the scenes, and one of the most unlikely fights sort of/almost/kinda happened backstage in 2016.

SummerSlam has witnessed mid-match temper tantrums, broken necks that nearly ended careers for good, main events which only happened because one party wouldn't put another rising star over and more. Sprinkle on some "stripping", the complete annihilation of a top faction and even one legend taking the p*ss out of another too.

SummerSlam? It should be SummerScandal...

10. HBK Has A Tantrum Because Of Vader

Shawn Michaels Vader
WWE.com

When: SummerSlam 1996

What Happened: Vader was Vader.

Yes, that sounds ridiculously simple and smart-arsed, but it's true. One could, however, have opened the entry by saying: "Shawn Michaels was being Shawn Michaels". The then-WWF Champ was feeling the pressure of his title reign and wasn't exactly a mega-positive chap in 1996.

HBK's ego collided with Vader's stiffness to cause miscommunication aplenty at SummerSlam. During the main event, Shawn leapt off the top rope for...something on the big man. Vader didn't move as planned, so Michaels landed on his feet, stomped on his peer and yelled, "Move, A*shole!"/"Move, dumb sh*t!" (Jim Cornette has said both in interviews since).

Earlier, Vader had peppered Michaels with relentless strikes in the corner. Apparently, the champ didn't like that either, and he was already smarting from the former WCW man's 'eat you alive' approach on house shows. Seeing two top stars break down this way during a featured match was shocking at the time.


9. Miss. Elizabeth “Strips”

Miss Elizabeth
WWE Network

When: SummerSlam 1988

What Happened: Miss. Elizabeth ditched her wholesome image temporarily to help distract the heels during a hot SummerSlam '88 main event. Liz whipped her skirt off to reveal red panties, and everyone watching immediately complained to their local pay-per-view provider that they wanted wrasslin' not pornography.

OK, that didn't really happen, but this was risqué stuff considering the family friendly image of Vinnie Mac's WWF back then. Looking back, it's as tame as you're likely to get; Elizabeth was reportedly supposed to wear something more revealing, but Randy Savage put the brakes on that and wouldn't let it happen.

Fair enough.

Amazingly, people were still talking about this when yours truly was at the peak of his fandom during the 'Attitude Era' and beyond. That's even more surprising, because Liz strolling across the apron in her outfit wasn't anywhere close to some of the stunts McMahon's fed had women perform between 1998-2008 pre-PG.


8. John Cena No Sells Nexus

John Cena, Wade Barrett
WWE.com

When: SummerSlam 2010

What Happened: Onto something a little different.

Wade Barrett's Nexus faction dominated WWE's product in the summer of 2010. "You're either Nexus or against us" sounded a bit daft, but it was a punchy catchphrase that helped catapult Barrett's motley crew into headline positions on major shows like SummerSlam.

Then, unbelievably, John Cena ran roughshod over the whole thing and stomped Nexus out like someone had dropped a blazing bag of dog sh*t on his doorstep. Cena's "Team WWE" partners were all eliminated when he took a Barrett DDT outside the ring, then miraculously healed in time to pin both Wade and Justin Gabriel seconds later.

It was a ludicrous decision to job Nexus out, and everyone knew it. The stable's momentum was stopped dead on the pay-per-view, and they'd never recover despite lasting into 2011 and getting a spin off (The Corre). This was babyface power-madness at its worst, especially because JC had no-sold being dropped headfirst onto concrete.


7. Gene Okerlund’s Outburst

Summerslam 1989 Mene Gene
WWE.com

When: SummerSlam 1989

What Happened: God bless Gene Okerlund.

No, seriously. The legendary stickman remains WWE's greatest ever backstage interviewer, and he will never be topped - Okerlund's blend of professionalism, smooth delivery and product knowledge made him the best. Then...SummerSlam 1989 happened and 'Mean' Gene gave everybody watching afterwards a right good chuckle.

During an otherwise-rudimentary promo with Rick Rude and Bobby Heenan, a part of the SummerSlam set fell behind Okerlund and he just about sh*t his pants. "F*ck it!", the announcer yelled. Scrambling, the WWF's producers went back to Tony Schiavone and Jesse Ventura on live commentary and tried to pretend nothing had happened.

Bruce Prichard later revealed via his podcast that this promo had been pre-taped earlier that afternoon. In fact, the company had a retake ready to, but somebody stuck the wrong footage on the live pay-per-view broadcast and nobody noticed until it was too late.

"F*ck it" indeed. Hilarious, albeit controversial.


6. Fred Durst Gives Fans The Finger

fred durst summerslam
WWE.com

When: SummerSlam 2012

What Happened: Okerlund shouting curse words out on pay-per-view in 1989 was one thing, but ageing rockstars giving the bird to fans watching at home during the 'PG Era' was another. Limp Bizkit frontman Fred Durst must've thought he was still at WrestleMania X-Seven in 2001, or something.

This was a different WWE.

Vince McMahon surely sighed when he saw Durst flip a middle finger during his mid-show cameo. The cameras didn't exactly cut away quickly, but Kevin Dunn's production crew refused to linger too long on Fred (y'know, incase he performed the gesture again) and everyone borderline went all 'nothing to see here, folks' on the incident.

This was funny for multiple reasons. Firstly, WWE's PG certification meant lewd gestures were banned. Second, Durst was hardly the coolest rocker on the planet by 2012, and so just came across as a p*ssed off dad looking to relive his youth by rebelling.

J'eah!


5. Steve Austin Won’t Put Triple H Over

SummerSlam 1999 Steve Austin Mankind Triple H
WWE.com

When: SummerSlam 1999

What Happened: Eek!

It's important to point out that this wasn't 100% 'Stone Cold'. Vince McMahon called the shots in the WWF, and he agreed with his top star that future son-in-law Triple H wasn't quite ready to beat the meal ticket at SummerSlam 1999; Bruce Prichard has discussed that before on his pod.

However, it is true that Austin didn't think Hunter should be bagging the WWF's top prize on the August '99 pay-per-view. That's why Mick Foley, as Mankind, took the belt on that show then dropped it to Trips 24 hours later on Raw. He was a buffer between Austin and 'The Game'.

This is rather controversial in retrospect, because Triple H obviously went on to become one of the biggest stars in WWE history. The fact he was deemed unworthy to win the WWF Title at SummerSlam is mind-boggling stuff today, not least because Hunter and Austin proceeded to work extensively afterwards.


4. Shawn Michaels Takes The P*ss

SummerSlam 2005   Hulk Hogan Vs Shawn Michaels 11
WWE.com

When: SummerSlam 2005

What Happened: You just knew Shawn Michaels was going to pop up again.

Being honest, HBK was ripping the ever-living-sh*te out of Hulk Hogan's act before their colossal first-time-ever meeting at SummerSlam '05. Shawn said Hogan's "Brother" catchphrase more times than the red and yellow hero himself, and he was clearly having a great time verbally laying into Hulk.

Come bell time, Michaels decided to over-sell like his name was Neymar and he'd just been leaned on inside an opposition box during the Champions League Final. Shawn hurled himself around the ring, and made light of everything from Hogan's punches to his trademark big boot.

Some, including Jim Ross, thought this was totally unnecessary and a bit immature from the untouchable veteran. According to JR and Prichard, Hulk and Michaels were originally supposed to work a three-match series. Once it became clear they wouldn't be, Shawn went into business for himself.


3. Owen Hart Breaks Steve Austin’s Neck

Stone Cold Neck Injury
WWE.com

When: SummerSlam 1997

What Happened: Owen Hart wore the same facial expression at SummerSlam '97 as he had when he told brother Bret Hart, "that's why I kicked your leg outta your leg" at the 1994 Royal Rumble. Basically, Owen knew he'd f*cked up when Steve Austin couldn't get up after a sit-down Tombstone Piledriver.

'Stone Cold' was temporarily paralysed on the mat.

Hart could only stall for time by jawing off with fans as Austin desperately tried to regain enough feeling in his arms to roll Owen up for the worst three count ever. Meanwhile, on commentary, Vince McMahon knew that this was a dire situation and that Steve could be benched for quite some time.

There were actually worries that Hart had ended Austin's career live on pay-per-view. Backstage beforehand, Steve had asked Owen not to sit down during the spot, but Hart did it anyway and broke the Texan's neck like a twig.

Potentially life-threatening injuries live on air? Yeah, that's drama.


2. The Ultimate Warrior Wants More Money

The Ultimate Warrior Hulk Hogan WWE SummerSlam 1991
WWE

When: SummerSlam 1991

What Happened: He might've been the perfect character to adorn every pre-teen's school lunch box, but The Ultimate Warrior was an almighty pain in the butt to WWF officials. Warrior had flopped as top champ following WrestleMania VI the year prior, but he was still one of the company's biggest acts afterwards.

Heading into SummerSlam '91 though, the face-painted fave decided to hard ball Vince McMahon for more money. Warrior actually felt like he merited a bigger payoff for 'Mania VII months before, and demanded an extra $500,000 to even show up for August's show.

Left with no choice (Warrior had already been heavily advertised as part of a handicap main event alongside Hulk Hogan), McMahon paid the fee then immediately fired one of his top acts right after SummerSlam. This messy situation almost cost the WWF its headliner for the event.

Warrior wouldn't be spotted again until the following spring's WrestleMania VIII.


1. Chris Jericho Wants To Fight Brock Lesnar

25 Brock Lesnar Randy Orton SummerSlam
WWE.com

When: SummerSlam 2016

What Happened: Chris Jericho would sneak onto a list entitled 'Wrestling's Hardest' just for this story alone. At SummerSlam 2016, the then-WWE star was incensed by Brock Lesnar's behaviour during and after his match vs. Randy Orton in the headline spot.

Brock lamped the crap out of Randy and bust the 'Viper' open hard-way with some seriously stiff elbows and other strikes. Backstage afterwards, Jericho loudly referred to the finish as "bullsh*t" and Lesnar told him it was none of his business. That added fuel to the Canadian's fire, and he wanted to fight the former UFC mauler.

That took some balls.

Others muscled in to break the confrontation up before it could really get going, but the story still made headlines across the wrasslin' world. Nobody could quite believe that Jericho was willing to confront Brock due to fears about Randy's health. In fact, nobody could quite believe he was willing to scrap with Lesnar at all.

What other controversial WWE SummerSlam moments can you remember? For more like this, check out 10 Popular Wrestling Debates That Need To Die and 10 New Directions For WWE After Money In The Bank 2022!


Watch Next


Contributor

Lifelong wrestling, video game, music and sports obsessive who has been writing about his passions since childhood. Jamie started writing for WhatCulture in 2013, and has contributed thousands of articles and YouTube videos since then. He cut his teeth penning published pieces for top UK and European wrestling read Fighting Spirit Magazine (FSM), and also has extensive experience working within the wrestling biz as a manager and commentator for promotions like ICW on WWE Network and WCPW/Defiant since 2010. Further, Jamie also hosted the old Ministry Of Slam podcast, and has interviewed everyone from Steve Austin and Shawn Michaels to Bret Hart and Trish Stratus.