10 Confusing Wrestling Moments That Nobody Understands

Bow down to the God of 'McMahonism'!

Vince Shane Church
WWE

Let's be clear on this: there are an awful lot of crap wrestling storylines and angles out there. If you were watching WCW in 2000, or TNA, well, ever, then you've probably suffered enough in the name of professional wrestling, and I wouldn't want to add to it and cause you an episode or something.

So this article isn€™t about bad or anti-climactic storytelling, like streaks being broken by the wrong people or non-wrestlers being made World Champion. It's also not about stories that fizzled out, like limos exploding, anonymous general managers or the illegitimate children of a certain billionaire owner.

There's nothing on a pole in this article. There are no matches where the rules have been changed without telling anyone. Fundamentally, this isn't an article that exists to expose a mediocre lack of competence, in the ring, on the mic or in the book.

No, this article (and accompanying video above) celebrates the moments in wrestling that genuinely make no sense: that confused you then, confuse you now, and will probably confuse your children when they find your wrestling DVDs hidden in the basement with all those dead tourists, you naughty, naughty people.


10. The Heartbreak Kid Tags With God

Shawn Michaels God
WWE Network

As everybody knows, Vincent Kennedy McMahon invented sports entertainment and Wrestlemania, created Hulkamania and the Attitude Era, defeated, destroyed and then purchased his biggest rival and beat the US government when they came for him*. What else? Oh yeah - the man beat God in a match at Backlash in 2006.

Embroiled in a feud with Shawn Michaels leading into WrestleMania 22, Mr. McMahon had the unholy hell beaten out of him by Mr. Wrestlemania. You'd think that would have been the end of it, but Jesus no. The very next night on RAW, McMahon informed the born-again HBK that his victory had been an act of God and that, as a consequence, God would be his tag team partner leading into a match at Backlash against Vince and Shane McMahon.

In the weeks leading up to it, McMahon would claim to have started his own religion, the implication being that he was a kind of deity himself. On the night itself, following increasingly bizarre backstage skits in which Vince pretended to have miraculous powers, 'God' was represented in Michaels' corner by the presence of a spotlight. In what was obviously a handicap match, all the people who'd attacked HBK at WrestleMania attacked him again. Without his special WrestleMania powers, the Heartbreak Kid wasn't able to fight them all off.

Eleven or so minutes in, McMahon grabbed a mic and began trashtalking 'God' in Michaels' corner, claiming that Michaels' Maker was abandoning him at ringside and leaving the arena. This was the point that Jim Ross felt compelled to mutter "...this is uncomfortable."

No one knew what to make of it. McMahon clearly thought it was wonderful, getting a win over God Himself but no one else did. Fortunately, Michaels was the one who was pinned, meaning that the stage was set for God to challenge McMahon to a rematch some years later, where McMahon would have to put him over.


9. The Christmas Creature

WWE.com

Was it a Christmas tree come to life? A version of the Grinch? Who can truly say. One thing's for certain, it's the second most embarrassing thing that Glenn Jacobs ever had to do. Think about THAT for a second.

Created in Memphis for the United States Wrestling Association, the Christmas Creature was inexplicably popular - fellow USWA wrestler Mad Man Pondo recalls Jacobs being asked to dress in the costume more than once after it was supposed to have outlived its usefulness. Supposedly, the territory was low on high-level villains, and the gimmick was intended to help a rookie get over as a heel without having to build a rapport with the crowd first. That rookie was Jacobs.

Now, the Memphis territory was notorious for its ridiculous high concept characters, so it€™s not as out-of-place as it sounds. Still, the thing looked like a Skrull auditioning for a role on The Wizard Of Oz.

No one ever really explained who (or what) the Christmas Creature actually was, or why it was wrestling. Its presence on the card was a mystery. It was like a sh*tty festive version of the Gobbledy Gooker, arriving in USWA in late 1992 specifically for a title vs mask match with Jerry 'the King' Lawler.

Lawler would tease the real identity of the Creature prior to the match, hinting that he believed it was someone from the WWF underneath the mask, come to take his title away. Imagine the confusion when it was revealed that the Christmas Creature was a complete nobody.

Not only did the gimmick have everyone baffled, but the reveal of who was under the hood was even more confusing. They really should have thought that one through.


8. The Higher Power

Triple H Vince McMahon The Undertaker Higher Power
WWE.com

In 1999, The Undertaker was knee-deep in his heel role as a satanic cult leader and had begun performing sacrificial rituals on people like Stephanie McMahon and 'Stone Cold' Steve Austin. That was the catalyst, weirdly enough to turn Steph's dear old daddy Vince babyface, despite his heinous actions for the last eighteen months while feuding with Austin. He would be ousted from his evil stable The Corporation by his son Shane, and even develop a grudging alliance with the Rattlesnake.

For months, The Undertaker had been muttering darkly about the mysterious 'higher power' that he took orders from. Given the Dead Man's gimmick at that time, the implication was that this 'higher power' was tantamount to being the Devil himself. Everyone had their own theory as to who it would end up being.

Of course, wrestling history shows us that the man behind the curtain was Vince himself. He'd orchestrated attacks on his own family (and upon himself) with the sole purpose of screwing with his former nemesis 'Stone Cold' Steve Austin.

No one could ever fully understand how or why the Ministry Of Darkness was motivated by this goal, or why McMahon believed that having his own daughter assaulted by a giant undead wizard would persuade Austin to come out to save her. The reveal didn't culminate in some kind of dastardly trap, either. Austin wasn't really affected by it one way or another.

No, it made no sense: possibly because it wasn't the original plan. Scuttlebutt (like gossip after a pointless heel turn) says that someone else was originally intended to be the 'higher power', but that the person became unavailable. Regardless, the whole thing ended up as a confusing, nonsensical mess, and the inspiration for GIF-based memes in years to come.


7. The Greatest Love Trapezium Ever

lana rusev dolph ziggler summer rae
WWE.com

The horrible, horrible angle between Lana, Rusev, Dolph Ziggler and Summer Rae was tantamount to a car crash for all concerned. No one could quite figure out who was supposed to be getting over.

Lana had turned USA-loving babyface, thereby destroying everything about her character that had made her so popular until that point. Summer was once again cast as in the heelish gold digger/home wrecker role as Rusev's new girlfriend. Ziggler had been in a freefall for months, and despite being nominally a babyface was clearly playing a heel in the angle.

Rusev, supposedly the big bad villain of the four of them, came off the most sympathetic, both because the other three were clearly awful, awful people, and because the real-life Miroslav Barnyashev was the only one in the whole storyline who was trying to get it over, delivering the best promos of his career, even while performing injured. He was so good in the role that he actually made Summer herself seem like a babyface by association.

Of course, that was a problem as well, because Rusev and Summer were supposed to be the antagonists. That was the storyline but, as is so often is the case these days in WWE, the story being told didn't match up with the character beats being played out. The material they were being asked to deliver told an entirely different story, one where Rusev and Summer were being victimised by Ziggler and Lana.

Matters became even more hopelessly confused when the angle was abruptly terminated after a stray Instagram post revealed that CJ Lana Perry and Miroslav Rusev Barnyashev hadn't broken up at all, and were in fact engaged (in real life). Fans were horribly confused by the whole thing.

I've confused myself just typing this, if it helps...


6. Overblown, Overcrowded And Overbooked

WWE.com

WrestleMania 2000 was a nightmarish mess of an event. Only one out of the nine matches on the card was a singles match (the scrappy catfight between two non-wrestlers, Terri Runnels and Stacy 'The Kat' Carter). Even that one had a special guest referee and nothing but outside interference in every one of the three minutes it lasted for.

It was typical of the Attitude Era's tendency to overbook the big matches, instead of relying upon stories that made sense. And that was WrestleMania 2000 - overblown, overcrowded and overbooked. Nothing really made sense, and nothing got over.

The main event was the final straw, though. A four-way elimination match for the WWF Championship was bad enough, and the fact that one of the participants was an out-of-shape Mick Foley (appearing only five weeks after 'retiring' at No Way Out) was worse. But the participants (rounded out by the Rock and the Big Show) were there representing the feuding McMahons, like champions in some kind of rubbish Gladiator knock-off.

That meant that there were eight people involved in the main event, each with storylines and angles going on with some or all of the others. The match was hard enough to follow on its own but, at the end, Vince McMahon turned heel (because of course he did) and attacked the Rock with a chair, allowing Triple H to make the pin and close WrestleMania with a heel champion retaining the title.

Vince's turn was a typical Attitude Era swerve, and made very little storyline sense. It actually contradicted almost all of his recent actions, just as his "higher power" turn the previous year had. The WWF had successfully annoyed and confused their audience at the biggest pay-per-view of the year. Good job, guys!


5. When The Boss Tells You You're Worthless

WWE.com

A little while back, Kyle Johnson at the Wrestling Observer wrote a brilliant column about WWE's counterproductive way of having their heel authority figures bury their onscreen talent in promos, putting down their importance to the company, and failing to make it clear that said promo was the work of an arrogant villain mouthing off.

Specifically, in spring last year, Stephanie informed John Cena that he wasn't a special little snowflake and on the first RAW of this year, she told Roman Reigns that he was just 'the help'. That, ladies and gentlemen, is the de facto heir to the throne telling the world that WWE's top star and the man they're grooming to replace him are both interchangeable cogs in the WWE machine.

If the two main event level babyfaces on the roster aren't important to the success of the company, what on earth are fans supposed to think of the rest of the roster? It's an indirect burial of every performer in the company. Which is just staggering, really.

Again, had this been undercut by an obvious weakness on Stephanie's part, both promos would have come across as bad grace on the part of a horrible boss with no other leverage than calling people names. But Stephanie rarely allows her character to show that kind of weakness, and on both these occasions the segments were booked to allow her to speak unopposed, as if she was the babyface speaking truth to power, not the other way around.

The only reason that wins and losses aren't supposed to be important in pro-wrestling is that the story is supposed to be what gets people over, not the worked outcome. Mick Foley was a master at taking a secondary, losing role in a feud and coming out on top without having to politick or throw a hissy fit to get the outcome changed. It seems as though it's become a dying art.

When the boss tells you you're worthless during an uninterrupted promo designed to get herself over, the story is that you're worthless. So why are we supposed to pay to see you perform? What's the point?


4. Group Hugs And Screw Jobs

The Yeti WCW
WWE.com

I could list a couple of dozen WCW moments that made no sense, but in selecting one for this list, the prime example that I keep coming back to is the single appearance of the Yeti.

Jesus, the Yeti. What were they thinking? Supposedly transported to Nitro by Kevin Sullivan frozen in a giant block of ice to use as a secret weapon against Hulk Hogan, the Yeti was a huge man (Ron Reis) swathed in bandages from head to foot. Not a giant hairy beast from Nepal, buta mummy.

The theory is that the Yeti was supposed to be El Gigante, aka Giant González, aka Jorge González, a former basketball player with gigantism, but González was taken ill and replaced in the role. But the bandages? This was not a Yeti. It was a mummy. Everyone could see that. Everyone above the age of three.

Worse, before the creature staggered out to attack Hogan, his own manager Jimmy Hart had swerved on him, knocked down the referee and hit Hogan with the title belt. When the Yeti came out to envelope him in a bearhug from behind, while Paul 'The Giant' Wight did likewise from the front (it looked like something from a prison movie), Hogan was accused of being behind Hart's attack on the referee, despite the fact that Hart's swerve on Hogan indicated that the opposite was true.

No one knew what was supposed to be happening. What were the Yeti and the Giant doing to Hogan? Was it even legal? Weren't children watching this show? And why was Hogan the one disqualified when he was pretty much the only one that hadn't cheated?

All questions that nobody had an answer to.


3. The Circles That You Find In The Windmills Of Your Mind

Hulk Hogan, Zeus
WWE.com

Another Hulk Hogan storyline - this one from the WWF. While WWF Champion in 1989, Hogan appeared in terrible wrestling feature film No Holds Barred, in which he played a wrestler called Rip Thomas, feuding with his monster heel nemesis Zeus (played by actor Tom 'Tiny' Lister).

In order to capitalise on the film's release, Lister appeared on WWF programming playing Zeus, complaining that Hogan had received top billing over him. That's right: Lister's wrestling character was his character from the film, while Hogan's wrestling character was the actor in the film. Hulk Hogan was being menaced in the ring by a character from a movie.

It could, of course, have been some kind of metatextual thing - a movie come to life, like Woody Allen's Purple Rose Of Cairo, or John McTiernan's Last Action Hero. There could have been levels of kayfabe on top of kayfabe, Terry Bollea playing Hulk Hogan playing Rip Thomas.

Zeus could have revealed himself to be Tom Lister, who then ripped off a mask to reveal Old Man Withers from the amusement park. They could have kept going, revealing themselves to be someone else masquerading as someone else, over and over until finally someone pulled off their face to reveal a bloody skull, screamed and died.

That would have been brilliant. This was sh*t.

Lister couldn't wrestle. Of course he couldn't, he was an actor not a wrestler. Mind you, he couldn't act either but that's okay, because Hogan couldn't act. He was a wrestler, not an actor. Mind you, he couldn't wrestle either but that's okay, because Lister couldn't wrestle. He was an actor, not a wrestler. Mind you*rips off own face to reveal bloody skull, screams and dies.


2. Will The Real Leader Of Aces & Eights Please Stand Up?

bully ray aces and eights
impactwrestling.com

Another attempt at replicating the financial success and impact of the NWO, this long, elaborate storyline across the whole of TNA's programming lasted from June 2012 to November 2013. A criminal motorcycle gang called Aces & Eights (after the poker hand known as the 'dead man's hand'), wearing biker gear and masks, would descend upon TNA performers to ruin matches and administer beatdowns.

The masks were the USP of this gimmick, the idea being that no one knew who was in the stable unless they could be unmasked. Gradually the babyfaces would unmask their sinister opponents to find out who was behind the gang's activities.

Unfortunately, the angle snowballed, much as the original NWO angle had, becoming unwieldy and confusing. TNA's tendency to overbook on the fly came into play, with stories fluctuating week by week, and it was obvious that there was no forward planning involved.

The angle became so cumbersome and clumsy that after nine months, when the big reveal of the secret leader of Aces & Eights was finally revealed at the Lockdown pay-per-view to be top babyface Bully Ray, it literally made no sense whatsoever.

There was no cunning plan at work. The swerve was just that - a Vince Russo style swerve without any logical consistency behind it, and requiring retconning the angle in order to make any kind of sense.

The twist made so little sense, in fact, that TNA felt it was necessary to release a video package explaining Bully Ray's evil scheme, and how he'd pulled the wool over everyone's eyes. The package was split into five separate videos totalling nineteen minutes, Bully Ray talking heelishly to camera as he carefully rewrote history and airbrushed inconvenient events to fit the new narrative.

It clearly hadn't been planned to end up that way, and if the angle had been hard to follow before, it was impossible now. Still, it limped on for another eight months, because, you know, TNA.


1. Sting Gets Hoganed

Hogan Sting
WWE.com

One of the greatest wasted opportunities in wrestling history, Sting's buildup to bomb as WCW's biggest babyface star is a sad, sad story.

The NWO had been around for a while, and fans were dying to see the heels get taken out. Meanwhile, Sting had taken on a new gimmick: a black-clad vigilante with a painted face in a long leather coat, lurking in the rafters of Monday Nitro, rappelling down to beat down NWO members with his trademark baseball bat. The fans knew that Sting was going to step up and take Hogan down, it was just a question of when.

Unbelievably, Eric Bischoff managed to hold off on pulling the trigger for a full eighteen months from start to finish. Crowd reactions grew louder and louder, expectation reaching near breaking point. This was going to be something special.

Finally the match everyone had waited for was booked: Hollywood Hulk Hogan versus Sting for the WCW world heavyweight championship at Starrcade 1997 (WCW's equivalent of WrestleMania). It would write itself: the fiery babyface against the wily old veteran, with Sting going over clean.

Instead, what we got was a dull, Nitro-style match, Hogan dominating the challenger with his 1980s offence until the clean pin came out of nowhereon Sting. At that point, temporary referee Bret €˜The Hitman€™ Hart showed up at ringside, claiming a fast count and restarting the match, which Sting then won.

The only problem was that the count hadn't been fast. Hart had restarted the match for no good reason. Ridiculously, no one seems to know what happened. Many speculated that referee Nick Patrick (in the storyline, the NWO's pet referee) had been persuaded to count normally by Hogan in order that he could keep his heat.

Regardless, Sting's starmaking turn simply vanished. He might have won the match, but everyone knew Hogan had won the war. Sting would never recover the momentum he'd lost. He would always be a star, but never on that level again.


Contributor
Contributor

Professional writer, punk werewolf and nesting place for starfish. Obsessed with squid, spirals and story. I publish short weird fiction online at desincarne.com, and tweet nonsense under the name Jack The Bodiless. You can follow me all you like, just don't touch my stuff.