10 Contenders To Replace JBL On WWE SmackDown Live

Who is going to step up and replace the Wrestling God on the blue brand?

William Regal NXT
WWE

Just a few short months after everyone was convinced he was going to be forced out, John ‘Bradshaw’ Layfield has announced that he is to step back from the SmackDown Live commentary team. The furore surrounding the Mauro Ranallo issues earlier in the year has since died down, and as such JBL’s announcement came as a major surprise to the wrestling world.

The wheel never stops turning however, and all of a sudden a spot is open on the blue brand’s commentary table. WWE is yet to announce who (if anyone) is going to replace the former WWE Champion, but there are plenty of options available to the company.

Whether that means promoting someone from NXT, putting an employee in a different role, or hiring someone entirely new remains to be seen. The days of ‘BALL GAME’ and not-quite-correct rugby references are over - so who is going to become the new voice of SmackDown Live?


10. Jerry 'The King' Lawler

Jerry Lawler Max Mini
WWE.com

Jerry ‘The King’ Lawler proved last Monday that he still has what it takes to put in a solid performance on commentary. His glory days of the Attitude Era may be long, long gone at this point, but then WWE is a completely different animal in 2017. The product is no longer pushing the envelope and making juvenile car-crash TV - this is a family-friendly fare now.

'The King' is a truly outside bet however, as he has made clear on a number of occasions that he has no intention of returning to the WWE schedule. His health is also a concern, and there is a general feeling that the less live television Lawler does, the better. He has paid his dues, and he owes the business nothing at this point.

If WWE was struggling to decide on the correct long-term replacement for JBL, they could do worse than giving the 'King of Memphis' the headset for a short run.


9. Dolph Ziggler

WWE

If Jerry ‘The King’ Lawler is an outside bet, then Dolph Ziggler may be one of the few realistic names that sits a little further out in the odds. Ziggler hasn’t been used on WWE TV in an active manner in two months now, and rumours of his retirement have followed him for years.

The last two weeks have seen Ziggler promise a new character, one that is all style and no substance, with many expecting him to soon debut his Southpaw Regional Wrestling persona, Nicci Lee Styxxx. That may be entertaining for all of five minutes, but it could also be one of the most embarrassing moments of Dolph’s career.

Ziggler has done well on commentary when he has been pushed into a guest-turn in the past. It may not fit his current bitter character, but it is easy to imagine Dolph calling the action on Tuesday nights. A lot of work needs to be done on rebuilding him in the ring - why not rebuild him outside of it?


8. Steve Corino

Steve Corino NXT
WWE

WWE has a number of experienced commentators in the company, but some of these are now performing training roles down at the WWE Performance Center. Matt Bloom did a more than decent job on NXT a couple of years ago, but the big man has his hands full as head trainer at the PC.

Steve Corino is also a trainer at the Performance Center, but it isn’t inconceivable that his schedule could be altered so that he could fly into SmackDown Live shows on a Tuesday night. Corino has done plenty of announce work for Ring of Honor and NJPW and is also a student of the game. There would be no catch-up period with The King of Old School at the desk.

The 'Trouble King' is another outside bet for the desk, but if WWE is looking for a fresh voice with experience and expertise, Corino could be the guy.


7. Road Dogg

Road Dogg
WWE.com

If times have changed for Jerry ‘The King’ Lawler, the same is even more dramatically true for ‘Road Dogg’ Jesse James. The former six-time tag team champion in WWE now works as the lead writer for SmackDown Live, and he also takes a very prominent role in producing the entire show.

It is that last role that probably works against the 'D O Double-G' taking on a position alongside Phillips and Saxton. But it is unlikely that anyone knows SmackDown Live better than the former WWF Intercontinental and Hardcore Champion, who would provide in-depth analysis of the show in his own inimitable style.

Working in front of the live audience would also give Road Dogg a better handle on how the WWE Universe is enjoying the show, a closer look at the performers that the crowd are responding to and those that are as cold as a Yakutsk winter morning.


6. Renee Young

Renee Young Commentary
WWE.com

As soon as news broke of John ‘Bradshaw’ Layfield’s departure, Renee Young’s name was the first one to be championed as a possible replacement. Young is another integral part of SmackDown Live, working as a backstage interviewer after her excellent run as host of Talking Smack. Oh Talking Smack, how we all miss you…

Renee herself has said that she doesn’t feel like she did a good job commentating on NXT, but the decision may not be hers to make. Young seems like one of the most adaptable performers in the entire company, and the introduction of a female voice would be another refreshing move made on the blue brand.

The fact that Lita was chosen to do commentary on the Mae Young Classic may not be a good sign though, as many assumed that position was Renee Young’s to turn down. If she did decline the role, then the chances of her taking the SmackDown gig would be slim to none - but Renee is another good option already working on SmackDown Live.


5. Vic Joseph

Vic Joseph Corey Graves
WWE.com

His work has somewhat flown under the radar, as 205 Live is seemingly watched by only the most hardcore of hardcore fans. Vic Joseph has been doing play-by-play duty on the cruiserweight show for a couple of months now, and his work alongside Corey Graves has been exemplary.

WWE has bravely promoted inexperienced announcers to prominent SmackDown roles in the past, and Joseph could be the next in line for the jump. Joseph has shown that he knows how to work the WWE commentary style, and if given the chance could well shine in a more major role.

The logistical side of Vic Joseph moving to SmackDown is also taken care of, as 205 Live is taped immediately following the Tuesday night main roster show. That would mean a long night of work for Vic Joseph, but when opportunity knocks one can't complain about such things. If Joseph were to be a success, the SmackDown table would be in safe hands for years to come.


4. Nigel McGuinness

Corey Graves Nigel McGuinness NXT TakeOver
WWE.com

I should preface this by saying I am against Nigel McGuinness moving to the SmackDown brand, as I am all in on the Brit acting as the new J.J. Dillion at the head of an NXT version of the Four Horseman, shepherding the careers of Adam Cole, Roderick Strong, Kyle O’Reilly, and Bobby Fish.

WWE is unlikely to go down that route with the former Ring of Honor stars, so McGuinness must be considered a possible contender for ‘promotion’ to SmackDown Live. The former ROH World Champion did a great job at the WWE United Kingdom Championship tournament, good enough to secure him a role replacing Corey Graves on NXT.

McGuinness’ work on NXT has been somewhat overshadowed by Mauro Ranallo’s move to the brand, but he has shown enough quality to convince many that a role as heel commentator on the main roster awaits him. The thought of Nigel McGuinness having to talk up the ability of Jinder Mahal is somewhat depressing, but you can’t win them all.


3. William Regal

William Regal
WWE.com

From one NXT Brit to another. How has William Regal not been given a full time announcing role on the main roster yet? Granted, Regal is a vital component of the WWE developmental structure, working as NXT General Manager and head scout for Triple H’s wet dream indy, but it still feels like his talents are going to waste.

Regal’s work on commentary in FCW and NXT was almost universally celebrated, and a move to the main roster announce desk is long overdue. The only problem with promoting Regal to this role is that he will likely make Tom Phillips and Byron Saxton look worse, but then working alongside top talent is how individuals get better.

Phillips and Saxton would benefit hugely from working alongside Regal. This is more out of hope than expectation, but putting William Regal behind the desk on SmackDown Live would be best for the entire show. The man from Blackpool could easily transition to General Manager when Daniel Bryan inevitably leaves in 2018 too.


2. Nobody

Tom Phillips
WWE.com

WWE seems to be fully in on its three-man commentary booths, despite the awkwardness this often brings. Having three voices jostling for air time does kill the dead air that WWE hates, but it doesn’t give any of the announcers a chance to develop their own personalities either. Tom Phillips and Byron Saxton are fine on SmackDown, but fine won’t quite cut it in professional wrestling.

If WWE decided to leave Saxton and Phillips alone on SmackDown, it could well act as a huge confidence boost for both men. The two are still immensely young, and their work so far should really be commended a lot more than it is.

36-year-old Saxton has shown that confidence plays a big role in his work, and this vote in his favour could do wonders for him. Tom Phillips is even younger, still only 28, and with the right shepherding he could well be the voice of WWE for decades to come. He has the talent to carry SmackDown Live, free of the extra distraction a three-man booth brings.


1. Mauro Ranallo

Mauro Ranallo Smackdown
WWE

Far and away the most popular choice for this spot, there is an overriding feeling that Mauro Ranallo should never have been removed in the first place. There would be a sweet irony in Ranallo replacing John ‘Bradshaw’ Layfield behind the desk of course, taking his spot just months after JBL was reportedly so instrumental in Ranallo’s initial move.

WWE would also get the added boost of promoting arguably the hottest voice in combat sports today. Ranallo was the main announcer for the recent ‘boxing’ match between Floyd Mayweather and Conor McGregor, and a more prominent role on WWE TV seems like a no-brainer for the company.

It all comes down to whether Mauro wants it or not. After doing such a good job on Mayweather/McGregor, Ranallo is in a position of real strength. WWE should be bending over backwards trying to get him back on SmackDown Live, and they won’t have a more opportune moment to do just that.


Contributor
Contributor

Born in the middle of Wales in the middle of the 1980's, John can't quite remember when he started watching wrestling but he has a terrible feeling that Dino Bravo was involved. Now living in Prague, John spends most of his time trying to work out how Tomohiro Ishii still stands upright. His favourite wrestler of all time is Dean Malenko, but really it is Repo Man. He is the author of 'An Illustrated History of Slavic Misery', the best book about the Slavic people that you haven't yet read. You can get that and others from www.poshlostbooks.com.