10 Crazy Wrestling Gimmicks That Should Have Never Worked (But Did)

A lot of gimmicks beggar belief, and yet despite this, they manage to thrive.

Over the years, professional wrestling has seen many a bizarre, crazy gimmick. In general, it's pretty much an anything-goes industry. However, just because anything goes doesn't mean that anything works. From farmers to aerobics instructors, teachers to dentists, along with cowboys, fairies, millionaires, bodyguards, garbage men, plumbers, race car drivers, truck drivers, bikers, Mortal Kombat characters (or close facsimiles thereof), rednecks, rappers, country singers, supermodels, and so on, many gimmicks simply beggar belief. In other cases, there are those gimmicks which just seem so strange, so out there that it feels like there is no way the audience could ever invest themselves in someone wearing the persona of a particular gimmick. And yet, despite all the odds to the contrary, they not only manage to survive... they manage to thrive as well. Of course, many of these don't tend to go very far. In some cases, it depends as much on the person playing the part as it does the part itself. For instance, few would argue that Bray Wyatt has done more with the Cape Fear-inspired gimmick than Waylon Mercy ever could. Here, then, is a look at ten gimmicks which did just that, thriving against all odds, no doubt due in part to those who were chosen to portray said gimmick. However, a word of warning: Most entries on this list don't consider more current, shorter-lived gimmicks such as Bray Wyatt above; for those, it's simply too early to judge. While they may indeed go the distance, the future is yet to be written, and the last thing we want to do is jinx anyone working their magic at present. Instead, our focus is to look at the absurdity of the gimmick, how long they've been able to keep it going, and what titles/accolades they've won while performing in that role.

10. Disco Inferno

Disco Inferno "Disco is dead" has been a common refrain from... well, pretty much the point disco died. And Disco did die in the ring, over and over again as a jobber in World Championship Wrestling, at least for a little while. Though he started out as a heel (because disco, you see), the more oblivious, humorous aspects of his character began to win fans over, such as when he would forget how to apply his own finishing maneuver and had to resort to a diagram mid-match. From his start in 1995, Disco Inferno's tenure lasted until the time WCW shut its doors as a part of AOL Time Warner, when the then-WWF purchased their rival. During that time, his star would rise, allowing him to join the nWo Wolfpac and become a founding member of the nWo Elite, effectively placing him squarely above such members of the "B-Team" in the nWo hierarchy as former Harlem Heat member Stevie Ray, Curt "Mr. Perfect" Hennig, and The Giant, better known to WWE fans today as The Big Show. His success didn't just come in who he got to hang out with, either; Disco's accolades include one run as the WCW Cruiserweight Champion, twice as the WCW Television Champion, and nearly held the WCW Tag Team Champions with partner Alex Wright as The Boogie Knights before being sidelined with an injury. Though he did not join WWE in the WCW Invasion, Disco did continue to work for World Wrestling All-Stars, TNA, and the independent circuit until a few years ago. Earlier this year, an episode of WWE Countdown took a look at the most "infamous gimmicks," and ranked Disco in 6th, with fellow WCW alumni William Regal, Bill DeMott, and Scott Armstrong defending him and noting that he fully embraced the gimmick and got it over with the fans.

9. Godfather

A wrestling pimp? This feels like one of those gimmicks that would sit somewhere between the pig farmers and a member of the Internal Revenue Service, but after being packaged as a a voodoo practitioner and the relative blank slate that was "The Supreme Fighting Machine", one could see how it might be considered a step up for Charles Wright. Debuting the "Godfather" name as a part of the Nation of Domination, it would further develop as he began to delve more into the art of pimping, reflected not only by his evolving ring attire, but also by his penchant for bringing ever-growing numbers of "hos" to the ring. In some cases, The Godfather wouldn't even have to wrestle on a given night, should his opponent accept his offer of having their ticket punched for "The Ho Train" in exchange for throwing the match. As an aside, it probably goes without saying that Jerry "The King" Lawler gave his all in putting the gimmick over. It worked, too, as The Godfather rode his popularity as the conductor on The Ho Train straight to the Intercontinental title, the crowd singing along all the while. Unfortunately, the train would eventually be derailed by the over-attentive Parents Television Council, who believed that WWE's product was inappropriate for prime-time television on the UPN. The Godfather was a specific target of theirs, and much of what he was able to say or do was restricted, hurting his overall popularity and leading to his "going straight" as the conservative Right to Censor's "Goodfather." He has made occasional and brief appearances as The Godfather since, hos and all, but the magic was never quite able to be recaptured.

8. Val Venis

What could be crazier than a wrestling pimp? Well, how about a wrestling porn star? Such was the standard of the Attitude Era that this gimmick- which would undoubtedly never fly in the PG era we have today- would go on to effectively parallel the rise and fall of The Godfather over the course of the late nineties into the early aughts, his constant innuendo and gyrations facing the same trials and tribulations as his ho-toting cohort at the hands of the Parents Television Council. Prior to that, however, he managed to claim the Intercontinental Title twice and the now-defunct European Title once. Unlike The Godfather, Venis would swap back and forth between his porn star gimmick and others, such as being Eric Bischoff's Raw "Chief of Staff" under his real name, Sean Morley. For the most part, however, he spent his time in WWE under the Val Venis monicker with the porn star gimmick, and despite gradually dropping down the card after Right to Censor disbanded, managed to get about ten years or so of mileage out of it before finally departing the company in 2009.

7. Hornswoggle

Little people are nothing new to WWE. But while they've been around for years, you don't tend to find one that has actually been around for years. Perhaps it's the gimmick that sets him apart, as he's not simply a little person, but a leprechaun who lives under the ring in a world of other people sharing his smaller stature. Originally named "Little Bastard," he would later take on his "real" name of Hornswoggle as he continued his antics over the years. As of this writing, Hornswoggle is less than two years away from celebrating a full decade of service to World Wrestling Entertainment, showing that his otherwise absurd gimmick *ahem* has legs. What's more, he wasn't even able to speak (in character, mind) until late 2011, when he gained the ability from Santa Claus after defeating fellow Irishman Sheamus in a battle royal to get his wish. Prior to that change in the status quo, however, Hornswoggle managed to win the Cruiserweight Title, and was the last to hold it before it was unceremoniously retired by Vickie Guerrero, as he was pretending to be Vince McMahon's illegitimate son at the time and she didn't want him to get hurt defending it. He would also go on to become the official mascot of D-Generation X (even appearing on their merchandise) and the Anonymous Raw General Manager. Most recently, art would imitate life (well, sort of) when he starred in Leprechaun: Origins, WWE Studios' reboot of the film franchise. In a place where the biggest men are said to have the greatest advantage, Hornswoggle has unquestionably managed to succeed beyond what many of his larger contemporaries have accomplished.

6. The Hurricane

If WWE Superstars and Divas are looked at as "real life superheroes," then what does that make it when one of them takes on the gimmick of an actual superhero? Such was the case of one Gregory Shane Helms, who joined WWE as a part of the WCW Invasion storyline. After being spurred on by "Stone Cold" Steve Austin during a conversation about his Green Lantern tattoo, Helms donned his own emerald-hued superhero costume and began wrestling under the guise of The Hurricane. He fully embraced the gimmick, even going so far as "requiring" his cape in order to "fly" across the ring. What might have helped sell the gimmick is the fact that everyone else on-camera did. Rather than dismissing the notion of meta-humans among us, other talent from the announcers all the way to The Great One himself would play off of The Hurricane's part with all the sincerity they could muster, from looking on incredulously to the "whoosh!" of him flying away (off-camera, of course) all the way to disavowing his origin and time as "Hurricane Helms" when he played the "secret identity" card and doubled as a backstage interviewer. Admittedly, Helms' success wasn't necessarily tied to the Hurricane gimmick; among his other accolades in wrestling, he held both the WCW Tag Team Championship and Hardcore Championship with his fellow members of 3 Count, and the WCW Cruiserweight title on his own, as well as WWE's version of the title while between stints as a superhero. As The Hurricane, he became a two time WWE Tag Team champion while holding the WWE Cruiserweight (for a grand total of two times), Hardcore, and European title once apiece. Save for roughly a year and some time out for injuries, Helms ran with the Hurricane gimmick in WWE for the better part of a decade, and he still wrestles under the gimmick on the independent circuit today.

5. John Cena

When John Cena began his WWE tenure, he didn't have a gimmick to speak of; just a new guy in wrestling trunks, basically. But then something strange happened. During a Halloween edition of Smackdown, Cena appeared at the backstage costume party dressed up as none other than Vanilla Ice, cutting loose with some freestyle raps. As a one-off occurrence, it could very well have gone forgotten, but something-- at least at the time-- magical happened.
Fans seemed to eat it up, and the following week Cena rode the spark ignited by his tricky treat. Though the blatant Vanilla Ice aspect was toned down (if not done away with entirely), Cena kept up the gimmick of appearing as a white rapper who would perform freestyle to cut down his opponents and rivals. During this time, as the then-heel Cena came around to become a fan favorite, he won the United States Championship, whose belt he replaced with a spinning variation which better represented his own gimmick. He would then go on to win his first WWE Championship, and gave it the very same treatment (much to the chagrin of fans years later).
Like him, love him, or hate him, there is no denying that John Cena is one of the biggest superstars in WWE, or the wrestling business at large. He's toned down the "thug life" rapping aspect of his character, yet the gimmick still remains largely unchanged. The cap isn't backwards, and the padlocked chain around his neck has been replaced by dog tags, but Cena is still Cena, and has 12 WWE Championship/WWE World Heavyweight Championship reigns, three World Title reigns, three United States Championship reigns, and two reigns each with the WWE and World Tag Team Championships over the course of a 12-year WWE tenure that's still running strong. Even if he quit today, that would still be 22 different title reigns under his belt, and that's not even counting other accolades such as his Royal Rumble wins, his Money in the Bank victory, or his closet full of Slammies. All in all, it's hard to imagine anyone doing better by following up on an anachronistic Halloween costume.

4. Razor Ramon

There has long been overlap between Hollywood and wrestling. Usually, you have actors appearing in the squared circle, or the occasional sports entertainer dropping the "sports" part for a run in Tinseltown. Then you have those who saw something in a movie, and attempted to emulate it in the ring. Enter Scott Hall. Upon joining the then-WWF, he recalls approaching Vince McMahon and Pat Patterson with an impersonation of Tony Montana from the movie Scarface, claiming he did so as a joke. However, to his surprise, McMahon and Patterson were floored by the impersonation and were fully on-board with the gimmick, while Hall apparently knew better than to question a good thing. As he would later learn, neither Vince nor Pat had ever seen the movie, leaving them to believe that Hall was a "genius" who had come up with the idea on his own. Generally speaking, it's difficult to imagine that doing a movie impersonation would help one get over with a wrestling crowd, but seeing as Hall managed to ride the Razor Ramon character to what was then a record four Intercontinental Championship reigns, it's hard to argue with results...
...though, of course, that doesn't mean it would work for everyone, as "Fake Razor" would later prove. Interestingly enough, when Hall would jump ship to WCW and help found the New World Order as one half of the Outsiders, he dropped the Razor Ramon name and theme, but otherwise retained the gimmick, faux-Cuban accent and all. This didn't please WWE, who in a lawsuit filed against WCW to get them to stop insinuating that the nWo were invading WWE talent, felt that Hall was still infringing on their own intellectual property. Ironic, given that the entire idea arose from impersonating someone else's IP to begin with, which is probably why Hall never stopped. Even years later, it would seem that Vince McMahon doesn't follow the films of popular culture all too closely. In 2006, Paul Burchill took up a pirate gimmick inspired by Johnny Depp's Captain Jack Sparrow in the then-red hot Pirates of the Caribbean films, and received positive reactions from the crowd for his efforts. Unfortunately for him (and the WWE Universe), McMahon was reportedly unaware of the popular films and character, and didn't think it would work out as a crowd favorite.

3. Sting

The Crow In 1996, Sting... wait, hold on, wrong picture. Sting Wcw There we go. In 1996, Sting took up a change in character after being betrayed by those in WCW in their ongoing feud against the nWo. Going into seclusion as a free agent, Sting went from sporting shorter hair and colorful face paint to a darker visage, complete with long, dark hair and a trenchcoat, topped off by a new black-and-white face paint design that was undeniably- and later, by admission- inspired by the late Brandon Lee's character in the 1994 film The Crow. As blatant as it was, Sting wore it well. So well, in fact, that he is better known in this persona today than he is by his original California surfer style, which stands to reason: He's spent nearly twice as long (two decades come 2016) in some form of the gimmick, whether in WCW, TNA, or his recent appearances for WWE. Four of his six WCW World Heavyweight Championship reigns came after taking up this gimmick, as well as two of his three WCW World Tag Team Championships. He would then go on to TNA to win the NWA World Heavyweight Championship once, TNA's homegrown version four times after, and one run with their Tag Team Championship alongside Kurt Angle. He also scored a title reign with the World Wrestling All-Stars World Heavyweight Championship, along with numerous accolades from Pro Wrestling Illustrated and The Wrestling Observer. Incidentally, it should probably come to no one's surprise that Scott Hall is to be credited for the creation of Sting's "Crow" gimmick. Who knew that impersonating popular movies could be so good for business outside of the independents?

2. Undertaker

There is really just no way that this should have worked. And yet, it's one of the most successful and beloved gimmicks of all time. For starters, just what is The Undertaker? Is he an actual undertaker? Is the "dead man" zombie description supposed to be literal? Both? In an era filled with all sorts of cartoon-like characters for wrestling, Undertaker was just the right cartoon character at the right time. As the Supermans and Flashes of the wrestling world were wearing thin, Undertaker was essentially the Batman among his peers, bringing an element of counter-cultural darkness that children of the 90s so craved to the forefront. Undertaker also brought an element of mystery and intrigue, enhanced further by the "powers" he seemed to demonstrate as arenas darkened and grew colder by his very presence- or his entrance, at least. Mark Calaway not only fully embraced a gimmick that would probably be doomed to a very short shelf life in nearly anyone else's hands, but he evolved it over the years as well. From zombie(?) to a Lord of Darkness to a cult leader to a demon among us, the Undertaker has endured. Even during the stint from 2000 to 2003, where he became an "American Badass" biker, he held the name and the roots of his character close to him before returning to the darkness which birthed him.
The Undertaker has been wrestling under that guise since 1990, nearly 24 years as of this writing. In that time, he has won numerous accolades along with his four WWE Championships, three WWE World Championships, six WWE World Tag Team Championships, and one run each with the WWE Hardcore Championship and WCW World Tag Team Championship. However, as many know, Undertaker's success goes well beyond any championship to an honor he and he alone possesses: A winning streak of 21 victories at WrestleMania. Upon hitting a certain point in his career, the chance to break The Streak was worth as much- perhaps even more- than any title shot one could have at the Showcase of the Immortals. Though Brock Lesnar broke The Streak at WrestleMania XXX, it is widely believed that no one will ever equal it, making Undertaker more than a success, but a legend in his own time.

1. Kane

If it seems like The Undertaker is a gimmick that should never have succeeded, yet did- immensely- then what could top that? His brother, of course. To take something as over-the-top, a one-in-a-million shot as The Lord of Darkness was and say "here's another one"... there's just no way that should have worked in any sort of long term. And yet, here we are 17 years later, and Kane remains one of the most prominent presences in the business.
Certain elements have been tweaked over time, of course, as he began to speak, then eventually lost his mask, and most recently, revealed a dual nature in Corporate Kane and The Demon Kane. Unlike Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde, however, both sides of this persona remain evil- just in different ways. Regardless, he is still The Big Red Machine and still Undertaker's brother. Effectively having two Undertakers on the roster has served WWE well, and while Kane could easily have been a one-off feud along the lines of "The Underfaker," he has survived and even thrived well beyond any relation he has to his on-screen older brother. Add to this the fact he continues to appear week after week while Undertaker manages roughly one match per year (give or take), and one might even suggest that what Undertaker has in prestige, Kane may make up for in longevity. Of course, seeing as Undertaker had a considerable head-start, that remains to be seen. Nonetheless, in addition to his duration as a near-constant part of the main event scene, he has held numerous titles over the years as well. This includes one each of the WWE Championship, the WWE World Championship, the ECW Championship, the WWF Hardcore Championship, and the WCW World Tag Team Championship, twice with the WWE Intercontinental Championship and WWE Tag Team Championship, and a whopping nine times with the WWE World Tag Team Championships. These reigns have also seen to it that he is the eight Triple Crown Champion and third ever Grand Slam Champion. All in all, not too bad for a guy who was basically introduced as "The Undertaker, but with more red." ----- So there you have it, ten gimmicks that for one reason or another managed to defy the odds and prove that they not only had legs and got over with the crowd, but were even worthy of championship greatness. Of course, there are undoubtedly those that you might say are missing from the list, perhaps more deserving of a spot than one of those featured here. Hey, there are a lot of wrestlers out there- it happens. But by all means, feel free to share your own thoughts in the comments below on those gimmicks that seemed guaranteed to flop on paper, yet managed to captivate, entertain, and triumph.

Contributor
Contributor

Former Nintendo Power writer, current Nintendo Force writer. Wrote the book on Mega Man (The Robot Master Field Guide). Was once fired by Vince McMahon. Dabbles in video games, comic books, toys, and fast food curiosities. Once had a new species of exotic bird named after him. It died. You can find more of his writings, musings, and other such things on his websites at Nyteworks.net.