10 Creepy Wrestling Curses

Walking through the broken mirror that is professional wrestling itself.

Brutus Beefcake mask
WWE

Curses aren't real.

Consider (much of) this list a spot of spooky ephemera with which to distract from the very real horrors of everyday life.

Incidentally, top tip: watching films in which the protagonist(s) endure an horrendous ordeal isn't, from experience, too shabby a way to wile away lockdown. As Ric Flair famously said, you don't want to see somebody doing better than you, which limits your escapist entertainment somewhat. At a minimum, fictional characters are usually allowed to go outside.

Shutter Island while as predictable as a WWE main roster non-title match functions nicely in this regard; yes, you can't go to the pub and "the man" keeps telling you to wear a lame cuck mask that reduces transmission and prevents death and might bring sports back earlier and sh*t, but at least you're not losing your sanity surrounded by the criminally insane in the pissing rain.

It's summer. The criminally insane surrounding you now are under the sun.

In some haunting, tragic cases, however, there's a potent if not entirely real sense that, when the stars align eerily in the pro wrestling world, and they do - this is an industry in which pissing blood from one's face is termed "fortunate juice" - they do so under a bad moon...

10. The Von Erich Family Curse

Kerry Von Erich Intercontinental Title
WWE.com

A ghastly and statistically irreconcilable wave of death, to put into perspective how awful the Von Erich story is, consider this bone-chilling quote from Kevin Von Erich:

"I used to have five brothers. Now I'm not even a brother."

The first of the clan to die was Jack Adkisson, Jr., who at the age of six suffered an electric shock and drowned in a puddle outside of the family home. Years later, in 1984, with three of the children riding high as athletic, tough guy heartthrobs in the white-hot WCCW, David passed in Japan, a tragedy mired in whispers of panicked drug flushings but pronounced formally as enteritis.

The death plunged the family into an inexorable sequence of tragedy that critics of the patriarch Fritz - ethically, even registering the story becomes uneasy, since how the hell do you criticise a father who lost five sons? - claimed he was complicit in. Mike, Chris and Kerry all died by suicide in later years. If a brain-damaged Mike had no business returning to the ring after his life-altering bout of toxic shock syndrome - he did so under what was at least the implicit pressure to continue the family legacy - Chris had no business even entering it. He was asthmatic, and his bones were so brittle that he could barely bump without breaking them. He killed himself because he could never realise the ideal of what being a Von Erich was to him.

Kerry, in a state of overwhelming grief and imminent trouble with the law, was the last of the clan to die in 1993.

Random tragedy tacitly encouraged and multiplied.


9. The Hart Family Curse

The Hart Family
WWE.com

The children of the Hart family were all the direct or indirect victims of tragedy.

The sad reality, based on the extent to which pro wrestling was awful - it still is now, just in different ways - is that, statistically, a family of that size was very likely to encounter it in magnitude.

Owen Hart was tragically and needlessly killed, in 1999, when the WWF opted, despicably, for cheap alternative equipment with which to facilitate a stunt that in no way was necessary to get the character over. His brother Bret was concussed into a multifariously grim retirement throughout which he suffered significant health issues.

The cursed DNA of the British professional wrestler extended the Hart Family and its misery by law through the marriages of Davey Boy Smith and Diana Hart and Dynamite Kid and Michelle Smadu. The British Bulldog died prematurely, while Smadu endured a disturbing cycle of physical and psychological abuse.

The industry the Harts were born into callously ripped them apart.

There's a stark, sobering lesson to be gleaned from the history of the Hart family: professional wrestling, a grim paradox of an industry, is to be taken both very seriously and not at all. It's a silly fiction that can tragically claim young life with a merciless inverse bathos.


8. The Armstrong Family Curse

bob-armstrong 1
wwe

'Bullet' Bob Armstrong, a pro wrestling legend and impossibly tough bastard - he once wore a mask to conceal the hole where his nose used to be while wrestling through surgeries that reconstructed his entire face (!) - sired four sons.

Between them, their respective characteristics made up a megastar, but they each excelled at a particular facet of the art: Brad was the workhorse, Brian the charismatic talker, Scott the hoss, Steve the stud.

In a bid to conceal Brad's lack of onscreen magnetism, he was churned by a dire WCW creative regime through a repackage wringer that, notoriously, spat out the inadvertent n*nce that was the Candyman and the copyright law-triggering Arachnaman. Bemoaning his luck backstage, Armstrong claimed the Armstrong sons were "cursed," ostensibly breaking a mirror, since WCW's dismal creative was folded into onscreen canon by Larry Zbysko, essentially making it real through stigma.

Elsewhere in this list, a curse is best explained by wrestling's inherent toxicity; here, the Armstrong curse - though this did in the case of Steve 'Lance Cassidy' Armstrong extend to the WWF - is best explained by LOLWCW.

A quasi-kayfabe curse that invited fate's relish, Brian as the Road Dogg famously wore a t-shirt emblazoned with 'LOOK MOM NO CURSE' when an Armstrong son made it to a big match on the WrestleMania stage.


7. The 4th Of July Curse

Brutus Beefcake mask
WWE

July 4th, a day of celebration, developed cursed, ironic energy in the late 1980s.

Adrian Adonis was a flamboyant, prodigious heat-seeker. He made an indelible impression on the WWF's Golden Era with his horribly dated but effectively sleazy act, for which he grew out his belly to make a problematic suggestion that bit more unappealing to the brawny bros of the wrestling audience. He died in a road accident so mysteriously that a mythology has bloomed around it involving the blinding Canadian sun and a stationary moose blocking the road.

Eerily, a year later, another vehicle crammed with professional wrestlers swerved off the road in a non-fatal crash in the same country caused, indirectly, by the same animal. Chris Benoit was mildly injured, but Jason The Terrible and Davey Boy Smith were seriously hurt. The Bulldog required 135 stitches after crashing through the windshield and and flying 25 feet onto concrete pavement.

In 1990, Brutus Beefcake's facial skeleton was crushed in a frightening parasailing accident that removed three years from his in-ring career- aside from a few months in which he played a masked assailant who - Christ almighty - threw headbutts in the direction of various heels.


6. The Modern Lineage Of The Impact Wrestling World Title

Tessa Blanchard
ImpactWrestling.com

Less "tragic wave upon wave of familial death", more "wrestling is swarming with wrong 'uns and Impact was left with the dirt worst of the lot because nobody else would touch them", this is where the list takes a turn from the macabre and into the curious, coincidental, and/or perversely hilarious.

The lineage of the Impact Wrestling World Title starts off well enough, even if first holder Kurt Angle was stripped of it within a day just to win it back. Titles won in fictional tournaments have more auspicious beginnings than that.

And for years, the title was a modest success, or had arrived at that description on balance (earnest attempts at promoting homegrown talent versus strapping totally broken down geezers). But then, over the last few years, the holders have painted a less than stellar image of the company, which is seemingly cursed to suffer an endless series of embarrassing fates. Those holders range from talents that couldn't wait to get the hell out (Pentagón, Jr., Brian Cage, Johnny Impact) to problematic headcases no other promotion would touch that brought the company into further disrepute (Alberto El Patron, Tessa Blanchard, Austin Aries).

It is possible to curse oneself, and Impact, realistically, knew damn well they were walking under a ladder.

Sounds like a stipulation Vince Russo would come up with.


5. The Lineage Of The NXT Cruiserweight Championship

enzo amore
WWE.com

The lineage of the NXT Cruiserweight Championship is remarkably plagued. It's as if it is being booked by 1998 Kevin Nash with a low, demented cackle.

Inaugural holder TJ Perkins contrived to get sacked in an era in which WWE was so intent on hoarding every available talent that there is still insufficient locker space in the Performance Center. Rich Swann fell afoul of WWE after a very ugly domestic violence incident with his partner. Neville's contract was frozen for almost a full year after he walked out on the company. Enzo Amore was booted out of the door and tried to get back in - astonishingly and hilariously - through the cat flap.

Akira Tozawa is a ninja now, and he fared better than most.

Cedric Alexander was subsequently buried deep into the solid inner core of the planet, otherwise known as Main Event. The lineage becomes uneventful for much of 2018 and 2019 - at which point, proving Enzo right, 205 Live descended into almost complete irrelevance.

But the switch to NXT, Jesus; those who have held the cursed silver have been accused of seriously awful abusive behaviour, have been released, or have been released and rehired as a babyface tactic.

"We gave one guy his job back after we released him in a year of record-breaking profits. It's heartwarming fare!"

And some people actually thought so!


4. The Royal Rumble Curse

Royal Rumble Curse
WWE

#14 typically isn't a number drawn by the wrestler that sets the pulse racing by starting a dream-match-within-a-match with entrant #1 or #2. They aren't a behemoth or superstar that enters at #27 or #30 to dramatically alter the complexion of the Rumble match late in the day.

Ordinarily, entrant #14 - said on message boards the internet over to be cursed - arrives on the scene to make up the numbers in the middle phase of a match, the epic duration of which necessitates a cool-down period.

#14, with a disturbing frequency, is the man wrestling no longer has much use for, the man whose push has long since been abandoned. #14 is Rikishi four years removed from his dancing days. #14 is Umaga a year past his peak as monster. #14 is MVP, Chris Masters, and Orlando Jordan, all of whom were released within a year. And, when wrestling had no use for you, wrestling had an awful habit of lulling the downtrodden into its voracious maw. Several of the men who drew #14 died prematurely or struggled through substance abuse issues.

There is no curse; wrestling is itself cursed.

A succession of random curiosities has also deepened the legend; the otherwise happily retired likes of DDP and Kevin Nash endured awful luck after their 2010s nostalgia pops.

The "curse" was "broken" by Shinsuke Nakamura in 2018, who won from #14 in a match structured to convince you otherwise.

Had WWE learned of the legend and manipulated it to their advantage?


3. The SmackDown Vs. RAW Curse

WWE SmackDown Vs Raw 2006
THQ/WWE.com

Death once haunted professional wrestling with such totality that it was impossible to escape even in a virtual reality.

Obviously a grim coincidence doubling, unintentionally, as eerie prescience, for two years in the 2000s even WWE's video game series was cursed with the grim energy that pervaded the industry.

In SmackDown Vs. RAW 2006, chapter two of the game's story mode ('Urning Your Respect') involves Eddie Guerrero stealing the Undertaker's urn and controlling him with it. Eventually, the player assists Undertaker in returning it before 'Taker, as vengeance, slams Guerrero onto a casket with a chokeslam. The game was released on 11 November, 2005 - just two days prior to Guerrero's tragic death.

Moreover, in SmackDown Vs. RAW 2007, in the first story mode chapter 'The Rabid Wolverine and the Dead Man', the Undertaker in a backstage cut scene makes what is retrospectively a very unsettling reference to Chris Benoit's death - one more explicit than his trademark catchphrase and morbid spiel.

Again, this is less a wrestling curse, more that the machinations of professional wrestling curse so many of those who enter its domain - tragedy, almost literally, was hardcoded into the programme.


2. The WWE Universal Title

Finn Balor Dummy
WWE.com

The first winner of the Universal Title, Finn Bálor, had to immediately vacate it after suffering a labrum tear at SummerSlam 2016.

This set the tone for a title that wasn't so much cursed, but was created and contested deep into the ills of what, in terms of popularity, was and remains a catastrophic era for WWE.

The title was subsequently "won" by Kevin Owens in order to build towards Triple H's eventual match with Seth Rollins, a development not later followed up on because Triple H had better things to do, like bagsy the first WrestleMania match with most famous sportswoman on the planet Ronda Rousey. Goldberg gave way to Brock Lesnar, whose stranglehold on the title scene created a vast nihilism from which most haven't escaped.

Seth Rollins broke the wildly counterproductive holding pattern, but not the curse, since he made a spectacular t*t of himself on Twitter and then had to transition into a profoundly tedious heel role as penance. He didn't lose but should have lost to the Fiend in the most cursed match ever, which, of course, Vince McMahon laughed off.

"It's only the Fiend. I'll f*ck 'im again, just watch!"

It's set to be defended in a Swamp match soon, man, for f*ck's sake.


1. Papa Shango Curses The Ultimate Warrior

The Ultimate Warrior Papa Shango Curse
WWE.com

Some kayfabe bullsh*t here to finish off on a less grim note of bathos, this from experience was creepy to the children watching it.

To the adults watching it back, it's a curse, all right. Many of us with a moral conscience feel awful for persisting with an industry rotten to its core. It is as dumb as it is horrific with sprinkles of genius that temporarily rid us of its putrid stench.

Consider this dumb, dumb segment involving the horrific, horrific Ultimate Warrior.

After celebrating a win on Superstars, Papa Shango, who possessed the ability to curse his fellow wrestlers but not locate a wrestling ring, seemed to cause griping pains within the Warrior by shaking a smoking skull and making his eyes go a bit funny. The Warrior was rushed backstage and attended to by medical personnel. There, he vomited what was meant to be bile all over them.

The prop looked like pea soup that he was probably reluctant to eat because it wasn't meat and therefore was gay.

It is entirely, irredeemable awful, but it has developed a nostalgic, so-bad-it's-good patina. Wrestling is awful, but somehow, even its awfulness redeems it.

Wrestling is cursed.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Enzo Amore
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!