10 Current NXT Stars Who Will Struggle On WWE's Main Roster
Into the fire.
From the moment of its establishment five years ago, NXT has become the place to go for a glimpse of the WWE stars of tomorrow.
And yet there's no guarantee that all those currently plying their trade down in Orlando will reach the heights of which they are expected when they step up to the main roster, where the demands and pressure are far greater than anything they have experienced so far.
From Bo Dallas and The Ascension to Emma and Tyler Breeze, there have been countless examples over recent years of NXT graduates who struggled - at least to match their accomplishments in the developmental ranks - after being moved to Raw and SmackDown.
Most of the time, this stems not from any lack of talent, but rather the absence of opportunity. The first few months a budding young wrestler spends on the main roster can be all-important in shaping their career - this is why Kevin Owens and Shinsuke Nakamura, for example, have done so well.
If you get lost in the shuffle early on, however, it can be incredibly difficult to climb your way back to the top...
10. Kassius Ohno
Kassius Ohno is the wrestler who, in terms of style, most closely resembles Cesaro of any current member of the NXT roster - probably because he spent years teaming with the Swiss Sensation under the name "Kings of Wrestling" in ROH.
From the above, we have to assume that Ohno, formerly Chris Hero, will endure a similarly frustrating time if and when he ever makes the step up to Raw or SmackDown. If WWE wanted a technically sound, fleet-footed big guy in the main event, they'd have done it already.
There's also the fact that the 38-year-old is now in the midst of what might be termed a "rough patch". He's spent the last couple of months jobbing to the likes of Lars Sullivan and The Velveteen Dream, despite only returning to the company in January of 2017.
He could eventually find his niche, like Cesaro, in the tag team ranks, but if the likes of The Ascension, American Alpha and The Revival - two-pieces that have been together from the outset - have struggled on the main roster, what hope is there for one thrown together on a whim? Chad Gable and Shelton Benjamin are currently in the process of answering this question.
9. Tyler Bate
British wrestling fans are desperate for Tyler Bate to be a roaring WWE success. British wrestling fans are also desperate for WrestleMania to take place at Wembley Stadium, though, and at the moment neither are looking particularly likely.
For the latter, you can probably blame the logistical challenges associated with hosting the show in a timezone that is five to seven hours ahead of the North American market in which they do most of their business. The former is to do with reasons much more difficult to overcome: company officials (allegedly) have it out for him.
If reports are to be believed, this is because Bate last year committed the heinous crime of turning down requests for him to appear at NXT events so he could fulfill the outstanding independent dates to which he had already agreed.
You can't fault his professionalism, but upsetting WWE higher-ups is generally not conducive to success in the ring, let alone on the main roster, where - as CM Punk reminded us a few years ago - the ability to get on the right side of the right people goes a long way.
8. Shayna Baszler
This selection is primarily based on the fact that Ronda Rousey has recently filled the vacancy in WWE's female division for a no-nonsense former UFC star looking to move into the world of professional wrestling.
It's possible that two people could perform this function at once, but it seems somehow unlikely. Can you imagine how badly Bobby Lashley would have struggled if he was coming through at exactly the same time as Brock Lesnar?
While Baszler, who unsuccessfully challenged Ember Moon for the NXT Women's Title at TakeOver: Philadelphia, currently has more experience in the squared circle, there is little doubt about which of them Triple H and co would choose to hedge their bets on.
Even if she isn't squeezed out of contention by Rousey, the women's ranks - thanks to some rapid expansion over recent months - are now more competitive than ever. There are bound to be a handful of NXT casualties from that, and Baszler could be one of them.
7. Lars Sullivan
Recent WON reports have claimed that Lars Sullivan has been inexplicably absent from NXT's Orlando Performance Centre for the past month, fuelling speculation that he's either picked up a long-term injury, or worse, got on the wrong side of someone in the back.
At the moment that's all speculation. What we do know is that Sullivan is a serious unit - one whose neck is probably about the same size as Lio Rush's torso - and is therefore absolutely, definitely going to be one of Vince McMahon's favourites when he steps up to Raw or SmackDown.
Or is he? The truth is that, for all the claims that the WWE chairman loves a big guy, there's no end to the list of giant rookies who jumped up to the main roster only to be sent packing within a year or two: Snitsky, Nathan Jones, Heidenreich, Vladimir Kozlov.
You can easily envisage the 29-year-old following the same path, particularly since his own massive man credentials pale by comparison to those of fellow behemoth Braun Strowman, who has been dominating Monday Night Raw almost completely unchallenged over the last 18 months.
6. Buddy Murphy
Saying that Buddy Murphy will struggle on the main roster because he's Australian is too simplistic, but it's hard to avoid that conclusion when you look at the experiences of former Undertaker protege Nathan Jones and, more recently, Emma.
Even if you discount the possibility of an anti-Aussie agenda in the corridors of WWE power, there's still the fact that Murphy has been left with very little to occupy his time over the last 12 to 18 months, despite being on the company's books since 2013.
This is a consequence of the inexplicable decision to split the 29-year-old from former partner Wesley Blake, with whom he previously formed one of the developmental ranks' best duos, winning the tag team straps twice.
Ironically, it was the promotion to SmackDown of Alexa Bliss, their former manager, that seemed to completely derail either man's chances of making a splash on the main roster. If present-day Murphy does get there at all, there's a good chance he'll just be the next Heath Slater or Bo Dallas.
5. Wesley Blake
Obviously, it would be wrong of us not give a mention to Wesley Blake after including his former tag team partner Buddy Murphy. The latter has at least been seen (albeit sporadically) on NXT over the last 12 months.
Blake, meanwhile, has practically become the invisible man since parting ways with the Aussie in mid-2016, occasionally popping up for a tag team match alongside Steve Cutler (someone who would be a candidate for this list if there was any chance at all of him appearing on the main roster).
It's not that there's anything wrong with the 30-year-old as a performer, of course. It's just that, as a consequence of his being left to rot for so long, there is little that sets him apart from a whole host of similar-looking, similarly-aged stars currently plying their trade in Orlando.
Like many others on this list, his best bet may be to begin a new tag team - if not get the band back together with Murphy and try a complete reboot. Otherwise, you can easily see him doing a Curt Hawkins when (or rather, if) he reaches the promised land.
4. Johnny Gargano
We know: two weeks ago Johnny Gargano shared the best WWE match in more than six years (according to Dave Meltzer, anyway) when he tore the house down alongside Andrade Almas at TakeOver: Philadelphia.
But having great matches in the developmental ranks is no guarantee of main roster success. For evidence of this, you only have to look at the fortunes of Neville and Tyler Breeze, who received similar acclaim for their NXT performances three years ago.
The problem with Gargano isn't so much that he lacks any major tools, but simply that he will probably be making the step up to the main roster at the same time as contemporaries Adam Cole, Aleister Black and, of course, the aforementioned Andrade Almas.
By the laws of wrestling, they can't all be pushed at the same time, and Gargano - who, until recently, had little backing as a singles star - seems the most likely of them to get the Sami Zayn treatment. That is to say that, while he'll be an unsung member of the roster, main event glory will be forever out of reach.
3. Lio Rush
Like Tyler Bate, Lio Rush has reportedly attracted backstage heat very early into his WWE tenure, despite being heralded as one of the company's great stars of the future after signing on the dotted line in 2017.
With Rush - who made the mistake of Tweeting an ill-conceived joke when Emma was released back in October - it's perhaps a little more understandable that he is currently being given the cold shoulder, although to be fair, it wasn't exactly the crime of the century.
Combine this with the innate fears that male performers as small as the former Ring of Honor star - he's 5'6", making him only a few inches taller than Alexa Bliss - will inevitably struggle in WWE unless their name is Rey Mysterio, and it's difficult to see him having much of an impact on Raw or SmackDown.
Of course, all of this could change rapidly if he mends his damaged reputation backstage (say, by laying on a spread of communal doughnuts in the canteen - but not in the style of Bill DeMott) and 205 Live - now under the exclusive control of Triple H - starts to become the show we once hoped it could be.
2. Drew Mcintyre
WWE's resident Scot perhaps finds himself in a similar position to that of Johnny Gargano, in that, while he is obviously very talented, he is of a similar age and profile to a host of other up-and-coming NXT stars, with no guarantee that all of them will make it it to the top.
What could disadvantage McIntyre over, say, Adam Cole or Anrade Almas is that he carries the burden of already having, if not "failed", then at least failed to set the world alight during his previous spell on the main roster.
This could affect both audience responses - mainstream crowds tend to be very different from the intimate ones assembled down in Orlando - and, accordingly, the way in which the Raw or SmackDown creative teams attempt to book him.
Compounding this is the fact that he's currently injured. Had he remained fit, he may have been looking at a main roster berth in the upcoming post-WrestleMania Superstar Shake-Up. Now, it's altogether unclear what lies ahead.
1. Eric Young
Though former TNA stalwart Eric Young is technically the leader of the group, it's pretty obvious, just by looking at them, which member of SAnitY has the best chance of making a splash on the WWE main roster.
If you need another hint: it's Killian Dain. Vince McMahon's empire has traditionally been a playground for giants, and the Northern Irishman is not only big, but also bearded and super menacing (this combination is pretty in vogue at the moment, in case you hadn't noticed).
What we're getting at here is that it's highly likely Dain will be groomed for a singles role once he steps up to the main roster, which could leave Eric Young shipwrecked, in much the same way that Chad Gable was last year when he split from Jason Jordan.
The Canadian is, without question, talented enough to make a go of things on his own, but he would need to have the backing of company officials to be given any such opportunity, and we know only too well how many others before him have struggled to secure that in recent years.