10 Embarrassing Times Wrestlers Tried To Look Cool

In which Triple H and Stephanie McMahon wear worse hats than Buff Bagwell.

Stephanie McMahon
WWE

Your writer - a bespectacled, earnest, and let's face it pretentious 35 year-old who tries too hard to go for lo-fi indie nerd chic - really isn't best positioned to determine that which is and is not cool.

But there are certain pro wrestlers who simply are and are not. It's a disposition thing, and it's all linked, inextricably, to effort. That punctuation and the friggin' word "inextricably" supports that first point. Jon Moxley is very cool, and he would never use the word "inextricably". He doesn't use Twitter - an awful hell-scape of a digital second life in which waves upon waves of uncool people call one another lame - because he doesn't need the validation or the petty, exhausting drama.

He rolls out of bed, drinks straight liquor, beats the sh*t out of people after advising them of the specific way in which they are to endure painful head trauma, drinks more straight liquor, and drives his van back to his remote home with Metallica blaring in the speakers. He still has the same CD he burned from the library. He wears leather and gets away with it. He is piss funny and he does not give a f*ck. He could also get away with riding a hog. But he doesn't. That is the key difference.

These people are not Jon Moxley...

10. Stephanie McMahon Wears A Kangol Hat

Stephanie McMahon
WWE

Yes, maybe Stephanie McMahon knew what she was doing in 2001.

Maybe a shred of self-awareness drove her to wear a leather Kangol hat emblazoned with the ECW logo. Maybe the idea was that you were meant to receive her as an overbearing corporate pretender to the underground throne. Maybe the hat itself put the horrific juxtaposition over the top.

But if WWE truly was self-aware, they'd have actually cared about what its audience thought about the Invasion angle in the first place. They might have realised that there was more money - and less audience-haemorrhaging nihilism - in positioning ECW and WCW as threats. If Steph herself had an ounce of this human quality, she wouldn't have compared the 9/11 terror attacks to her father's indictment.

The leather Kangol hat, therefore, was not heat. It was something Stephanie McMahon wore to look cool, perhaps after first learning of the existence of MTV2. It looked like she thought she was hot sh*t, palling about with the gang.

Her aesthetic was so painfully try-hard for what was kewl at the time that it's a miracle she didn't tell you f*ckers to get up and get down with the sickness.


9. And So Does Triple H

Triple H Kangol
WWE

More supporting evidence in the "Stephanie McMahon wasn't being self-aware" file - in addition to the fact that her surname is 'McMahon' - is that, were she actually wearing a Kangol to make herself look cringe on purpose, she'd had to have acknowledged that her husband looked cringe by accident two years earlier.

"Darling, you looked a right t*t with that hat on when you were trying to get over as a main eventer - can I use that to look like an idiot?"

Triple H eventually got it, or was given it, four or so years after making his WWF debut. Sh*te gimmick; boring, heat-bereft matches; a very good breakout babyface run overshadowed by the fact that his heel opponent, the Rock, was really the guy the audience wanted to get behind as a babyface: at the turn of the millennium, Triple H was finally undeniable as an elite-tier wrestler. When he fancied it, the man was exceptional at showing ass with his frantic selling all the more effective for how well he built his phases of offence.

After an inadvertently hilarious summer, he almost didn't. The embryonic 'Game' character was fatally try-hard - he was the one who could say "f*ck" on TV, because he was that damn edgy - and with his Kangol hat and hippy-adjacent shades, he didn't know which generation of cool person to look like.

The Franchise-uh instead tried very hard to look like them all.


8. Justin Credible's Weird Snarl Thing

Justin Credible
WWE.com

There's an asterisk next to this entry because it's not entirely clear whether Justin Credible recognised his inherent cringe and used it for heat.

Was he trying to look cool, or did he know that lounging snarl thing he did was actually detestable?

As a member of the risible X-Factor stable, Credible made his entrance to the ring with his mouth dropped open positively radiating douchebag energy. It was as if he was too cool to even close his mouth. He leaned to the side, as if recalling that a teacher once told him to stand up straight, emoting "No you f*cking square, I will not because you're the establishment. Bitch."

To answer those questions, context must be considered. 2001 was a different time to 2021. Back in "the day," the ass-showing heel was not in vogue. Nu-metal was a fashionable music genre. Coming across as the most insufferable d*ckhead imaginable wasn't just a popular thing to do. Everybody did it: the babyfaces and the heels alike. 2001 was the peak (or the nadir) of the "cool heel era," in which the baddies were simply too badass to function.

On that basis, Credible thought he was the dog's b*llocks as opposed to dog sh*t.


7. Roman Reigns For Virtually All Of 2015

Roman Reigns
WWE

Roman Reigns is cool now.

This has to be mentioned because not only is it true and fair - and impressive, given that WWE at large is so powerfully lame - but also because his stans are particularly deranged. The Head of the Table is a tremendous act, and even if you can't get jazzed by WWE's creaking, standstill promo-heavy format, that has to be acknowledged. He has developed a menacing superstar aura, and he is as unsettling as he is badass with his facial expressions.

Roman Reigns was not cool in 2015. At all.

Roman Reigns was not cool because he was instructed to emulate a gurning children's clothing line baron in John Cena. This manifested, variously, as Roman reciting fairytales and winking to the camera after "nailing" what was literally the most embarrassing line of dialogue in professional wrestling history. Roman winked to the camera after saying "Sufferin' succotash," which is rather like a vet saying "WASSUP?!" after putting down a cat.

At Fastlane '15, opposite Daniel Bryan, he actually did something like "WASSUP?!" when trying to pin Daniel Bryan. He did the radical "hang ten" sign and headbanged a bit.

Because Michael Hayes probably produced the match thinking Roman would get over as the Teenage Mutant Ninja Tribal Chief.


6. Seth Rollins Tries To Own The Room

Seth Rollins dork
WWE

WWE does this thing, and this thing is awful.

Years and years after the Rock first got over as a trash-talking phenomenon so funny that he effectively doubled as a stand-up comedian, we see the same old sh*t. His timing was incredible, the best material was delightfully cruel, and his supernatural presence was so powerful that he could get any old sh*te over. Except "Cookie Puss," which didn't even make sense. He wasn't CP Munk. Should've called him Cookie Mott.

Now, because Rock was so great, WWE has for years imposed this promo style on virtually every top babyface. It is rancid. In 2019, Rollins was the latest uncool man WWE tried to make cool, and, building his match with Brock Lesnar at SummerSlam, he referred to his opponent as a "real Godzilla-lookin' bastard if you ask me," complete with an impression of a caveman. This was harrowing. Proper tumbleweeds stuff. It was not unlike Josh Matthews doing a Netflix special. Actually, no. Rollins himself is a sufficient analogy.

Far, far superior in the heel role, Rollins was so dire in his attempts to own the room as an easy-going babyface that he had to turn heel later that very year.

The Fiend did not change him, people. Creative did. Without trying.


5. Vince Russo In General

Vince Russo WCW
WWE.com

Now that he is out of the picture forevermore, and not actively killing the careers of really talented wrestlers you want to see succeed, one can look back and laugh at the drastic extent to which Vince Russo thought he was hot friggin' sh*t.

This is a man who walked around the WCW locker room with a baseball bat thinking he was the hardest guy in the building, who got up in the face of Goldberg, and generally adopted the snarling disposition of a street tough at all times. He wore a helmet and looked like an a**hole at one of those times, admittedly, but by then, he'd already became a total mar-uk for himself.

He was even funnier in TNA. If you watch his various returns and early big angles, you will marvel at the deafening volume at which he instructed poor Mike Tenay to say the word "SH*T".

HOLY SH*T IT'S VINCE RUSSO Tenay once screamed in a tone that would adequately have captured the seismic shock of seeing Jesus Christ of Nazareth in the flesh.

Russo himself was fond of saying the word himself, of course, because he was primarily interested in coming across as the most dangerous and controversial edgelord of all time.

YOU PIECES OF SH*T, it's AJ Styles! was a line of his. Genuinely.

He just loved despising the audience because he hated and was better than them.


4. Jeff Jarrett Joins The Bullet Club

Jeff Jarrett GFW
ImpactWrestling.com

"That's B-I-Double Z, ha, ha, C-Double L-I-Z..."

The Bullet Club were a legitimately cool and youthful unit: a major factor behind New Japan's awesome resurgence in the 2010s. The premise behind the stable was a masterstroke. Years and years after the foreign wrestler was no longer received by Japanese fans as a heel by default, Gedo sensed that a return to this archetype would sting all the more following their acceptance.

That it did.

The stable was so over as a gang of cheating d*ckheads - within, crucially, a sporting framework that valued fair, clean competition - that the office was bombarded with complaints. Prince Devitt was cool as the frontman state-of-the-art worker. His successor as the top star (not leader per se), AJ Styles, hadn't yet grown out his soccer mom hair. In the background, Tama Tonga was a smirking sh*t disturber, Bad Luck Fale looked like a level boss, and Gallows and Anderson were super-animated heat machine bruisers. It was never too cool. The wonderful obnoxiousness of the Young Bucks assured that.

Jeff Jarrett, who briefly joined the stable as part of Global Force Wrestling's inexplicable working agreement with NJPW, was not cool. He was your dad. He was the Vincent and the Stevie Ray of the Bullet Club who did not grasp that, if you're not going to age gracefully in pro wrestling, the least you can do is execute a sh*tty Canadian destroyer.

But no: he smashed guitars over people's heads and thought he was 28.


3. 123 Kid > X-Pac

X Pac WWE
WWE.com

Your periodic reminder that the 123 Kid was amazing, and it's a shame that the performer is more synonymous with the X-Pac gimmick because 'X-Pac' is synonymous with a once-great worker feeling two years out of date.

Two years!

Virtually every WWE star has - sigh - "X-Pac heat" in 2021. "X-Pac heat" is the norm. Think of X-Pac still working as X-Pac in 2006, and you are close to the heavy malaise that saturates WWE programming.

As X-Pac, Sean Waltman was still a dynamo between the ropes, and his brand of edgy humour was a perfect fit for the day, but that day has aged horrendously. To wit: X-Pac, playing the hard man trash-talker in 1998, wasn't particularly convincing in the role, but it was cool that he smoked such copious amounts of weed. That was the standard back then. There was a tag team called Kronik, for f*ck's sake.

Armed with this knowledge, X-Pac was fond of saying "Your ass is grass and I'm gonna smoke it," like a dorm room poster transmogrified into a professional wrestler. X-Pac was essentially dril.

"Ass" and "grass" rhymed, you see, which was sufficiently cool enough to forget about the suboptimal mental image.


2. The Kliq Go Full Geezer At RAW 25

Raw 25
WWE.com

For years, the various DX and or nWo reunions had developed something of a "F*ck off" quality.

Yes, good, gang up on the emerging midcard heel of the day and give him a sh*t-kicking masquerading as "the rub". Didn't you all sell a lot of t-shirts in the boom period. Capital. Well done.

The nostalgia bit got over in arenas, anyway, which half-justified the masturbation. The TV ratings tended to climb for a one-week injection, too, which was rather undermined when the same people didn't tune in to watch the regular schmucks the next week. Probably because the audience had just watched them get beat up.

This development reached a nadir at RAW 25, the event at which WWE killed nostalgia as much as credibility. This was somehow worse than Triple H and the gang beating on the square because, by aligning with WWE's version of the Bullet Club, it was as if the lads of the '90s felt they were still as cool and relevant. They were not.

They were old, established men desperately trying to take credit for a movement they had zero idea how to rip off, much less create.

"We have the Elite at home."

The Elite at home buried the Revival out of the company.


1. Sheamus Regrettably Does Look Stupid

Sheamus Stupid
WWE

God f*cking bless Sheamus, man.

He provides such impossible value to the otherwise deadening viewing experience that is watching WWE Monday Night RAW in 2021. The show is absolutely horrific: just this dismal atrocity that is chaotic and stupid and laughable, but so soulless and long that it isn't even perversely entertaining.

And yet, for 15 minutes or so when he's give the time in addition to some poor f*cker's corpse, Sheamus brings the uncanny valley to life with matches that are as intelligently crafted as they look - even feel - physically painful. Nothing matters in WWE. Nothing. The empty arena backdrop is soul-destroying. The man somehow extracts drama from said nothing.

WWE does not deserve him, and maybe we don't either, because we all told him he looked stupid in 2015. And to be fair, he did. People always look weird when they get a new, radical haircut, and Sheamus got about seven new haircuts at once with his mohawk and braided beard.

The sad thing is that you knew what he was going for - with the new look, he wished to disassociate himself from his good-not-great World Title run years - and he developed a new, even worse stigma immediately.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Michael Sidgwick (Creative Writing BA Hons) is an editor, writer and podcaster for WhatCulture Wrestling. With over a decade of experience in wrestling analysis, Michael was published in the influential UK institution that was Power Slam magazine, and specialises in providing insights into All Elite Wrestling - so much so that he wrote a book about the subject. You can order Becoming All Elite: The Rise Of AEW on Amazon. Possessing a deep knowledge also of WWE, WCW, ECW and New Japan Pro Wrestling, Michael’s work has been publicly praised by AEW World Champions Kenny Omega and MJF, and Undisputed WWE Champion Cody Rhodes. When he isn’t putting your finger on why things are the way they are in the endlessly fascinating world of professional wrestling, Michael wraps his own around a hand grinder to explore the world of specialty coffee. Follow Michael on X (formerly known as Twitter) @MSidgwick for more!