10 EVOLVE Stars Who Will Wind Up In WWE

Cultivating the superstars of tomorrow.

Ever since its founding in 2010, EVOLVE has been one of the premier independent wrestling organizations in the country. Founded and run by former Ring of Honor booker Gabe Sapolsky, the company quickly built its reputation on delivering top-level in-ring action and putting emphasis on wins and losses. EVOLVE has thrived for the past six years, but in 2015 it reached a new high - the company began working in tandem with WWE. Though the full relationship between EVOLVE and WWE is unknown to outside parties, the cooperation has already borne fruit for both sides. WWE has sent NXT talents Sami Zayn, Chad Gable, and Jason Jordan to EVOLVE shows to make appearances, boosting the independent promotion's ticket sales. Likewise, EVOLVE has allowed talent to compete on NXT shows, and in one case, has even given a fledgling talent work and experience at WWE's request. The relationship runs deep - in an image that's already become famous, Triple H tweeted his own backstage appearance at an EVOLVE show in Orlando only 24 hours before he won the WWE World Heavyweight Championship at the Royal Rumble. Months earlier, top EVOLVE stars Biff Busick and Rich Swann were signed to WWE contracts. It's clear that before long, many more of the talented competitors of EVOLVE will be given a shot in WWE. Which ones have what it takes to get that chance?


10. Anthony Nese

Like current and former WWE superstars Zack Ryder, Curt Hawkins, and Trent Barreta, Anthony Nese trained under ECW Champion Mikey Whipwreck and first cut his teeth in the Long Island-based New York Wrestling Connection. Today, Nese is a talented high flyer with considerable technical prowess, and part of EVOLVE's Premier Athletic Brand stable. Nese has already appeared on WWE TV before, albeit in inauspicious fashion - he played a tech worker whom Bray Wyatt threw at Roman Reigns during their feud last year. The talented grappler has far more to offer the company, though, and he'd fit in perfectly on NXT - or the WWE Network's upcoming cruiserweights-only show.

9. Jonathan Gresham

Jonathan Gresham has been wrestling for over a decade, and he's finally broken out as one of the most underrated talents on the independent scene. Though he's only wrestled a single match for EVOLVE thus far, his work in ROH, CZW, and IWA-Mid South has earned him comparisons to a young "American Dragon" Bryan Danielson. Gresham's size would have kept him out of WWE in years past, but the company's hiring process has changed. He's still small enough that the odds would be against him being used properly (just look at Evan Bourne and Neville), but he'd likely have no problem building up a following. Like Nese, he'd be ideal for the Network's cruiserweight tournament, but an underdog push for Gresham could take him to the main roster and up the card.

8. Drew Gulak

As the leader of EVOLVE's submission-style-oriented stable Catch Point, Drew Gulak has made himself one of the focal points of the promotion. While his team came up short in EVOLVE's recent tournament to crown Tag Team Champions, Gulak is still a threat to anyone in the promotion - provided WWE doesn't snatch him up. Like Biff Busick, whom WWE signed last summer, Gulak is larger than the average independent star, with a throwback attitude and a smash-mouth style. He's not afraid to get his hands dirty in a fight, and what he lacks in high-flying finesse, he makes up for with a Cesaro-like technical acumen. The current landscape of WWE - and especially NXT - offers a place for grapplers with all sorts of different styles, and Gulak's submission-based offense would be a welcome addition to the program. As part of a tag team, especially, Gulak could reach great heights.

7. Timothy Thatcher

2015 was a very important year in the career of Timothy Thatcher. After a breakthrough performance against Chris Hero at WrestleMania weekend's WWN Supershow, Thatcher began receiving quite a bit of press. He followed up on that victory with an even greater one in July, beating Drew Galloway for both the EVOLVE and Dragon Gate USA Open the Freedom Gate Championships. Since then, he's been defending both titles with a combination of technical mastery and hard-hitting, do-whatever-it-takes violence. Believe it or not, there's some debate online as to whether Thatcher is actually British. No matter where he's really from, though, he represents Europe well - he's got the look of Wade Barrett, the precision of Cesaro, and the ring generalship and aggression of William Regal. Plus, he's 6'3", 224 pounds, which WWE has undoubtedly noticed. Thatcher was actually one of a number of EVOLVE talents mentioned in a WWE.com article late last year, and he's sure to get a tryout with the company soon.

6. Caleb Konley

Caleb Konley teams with Anthony Nese in the Premier Athletic Brand, and together, the two grapplers make a skilled pair. The comparisons stop there, though - while Nese is a high-flier, Konley is more mat-based in his approach - and while Nese lets his actions speak for him, Konley has a Dolph Ziggler-style brand of arrogance that gives him an extra bit of star appeal. An independent journeyman, Konley first broke out in the American Southeast. Since then, he's undergone a number of image changes, but he's never been firing on all cylinders the way he is right now. The reigning FIP Heavyweight Champion, Konley is just as good as a tag or a singles wrestler, and could undoubtedly be used either way in NXT. While so many independent wrestlers tend to fit into a mold, Konley's style assures that he can make a mark in a single appearance. Like many other EVOLVE talents, Konley would be a great candidate for the WWE Network cruiserweight show, and he could potentially make the biggest impact.

5. Ethan Page

Ethan Page isn't just one of the best heels on the American independent scene, he's one of the best heels in wrestling, period. While The Authority struggles to get a reaction and so many other would-be bad guys in wrestling try to play the "cool" role, Page has managed to truly turn fans against him via a feud with beloved EVOLVE star Johnny Gargano. After pretending to befriend Gargano and then turning on him, Page proceeded to make the former EVOLVE Champion's life a living hell. He beat Gargano at EVOLVE 47 by getting "Johnny Wrestling's" best friend, Rich Swann, to turn against him, then finally fell to Gargano in an amazing "I Quit" match at EVOLVE 49. Page doesn't have the physique of John Cena or the athleticism of Sami Zayn, but he's a brilliant brawler with an attitude and tactics that draw comparisons to those of another Canadian heel, Kevin Owens. With as much personality and skill as he has, Page would make an excellent addition to the WWE roster.

4. Drew Galloway

Of all the wrestlers on the list, only one has already been under contract to WWE. Drew Galloway competed for the organization as Drew McIntyre from 2007 to 2014, initially getting a huge push as Vince McMahon's hand-picked superstar, but eventually becoming a member of the Three Man Band. McIntyre's talent didn't match his push, and by the time he improved, he was already seen as damaged goods. Once leaving the company, though, McIntyre began competing under his real name and taking independent wrestling by storm. He won the EVOLVE Championship from Chris Hero in his debut match, then unified the title with the Dragon Gate USA Open the Freedom Gate Championship. Though Galloway has lost both championships to Timothy Thatcher, the impact he's made in EVOLVE has undoubtedly caught many eyes. The former Intercontinental Champion is only 30 years old, and another run with WWE seems inevitable.

3. Johnny Gargano

Johnny Gargano has been one of the top names in independent wrestling for years, and in 2015, WWE finally took notice of him - he and Tommaso Ciampa were invited to participate in the Dusty Rhodes Tag Team Classic, beating Bull Dempsey and Tyler Breeze in the first round. Since then, Gargano has continued to compete sporadically for the brand, most recently losing a match to Samoa Joe. Fans of NXT can tell that Gargano is talented, but they've only seen the tip of the iceberg. As a member of EVOLVE's roster since the very first show, "Johnny Wrestling" has been a fixture of the promotion for its entire history. He's a former EVOLVE Champion, and while his reign ended in 2015 and he became embroiled in a career-threatening feud with Ethan Page, Gargano emerged the victor. He's since become one-half of EVOLVE's inaugural Tag Team Champions, along with Drew Galloway. Gargano is a world-class competitor who would fit in as an NXT regular perfectly. It can't be long before WWE realizes that they need him as part of the full-time roster.

2. Zack Sabre Jr.

EVOLVE has long been praised for the quality of its matches, and 2015 was a standout year. Still, for all of the company's classic bouts in the past 12 months, none received as much praise as ROH standout Roderick Strong versus acclaimed English technician Zack Sabre Jr. Sabre has competed for British promotions and Pro Wrestling NOAH for years, but his recent branching out into the U.S. has gained him even more of a following. For two years running, Sabre has been voted the Wrestling Observer Newsletter's Best Technical Wrestler, drawing comparisons to nine-time winner Daniel Bryan. Sabre is skinny by WWE standards, but as his command of holds and maneuvers is only matched by his ability to properly pace a match and control a crowd, the company can't hold off on signing him for long. When both parties are ready, he'll be the perfect addition to WWE - just like Bryan before him.

1. Matt Riddle

While many of EVOLVE's talents should - and probably will - end up in WWE, only one was sent to EVOLVE at the sports entertainment giant's request. Matt Riddle was a contestant on The Ultimate Fighter who went on to have a six-year career with UFC. After being cut from the organization, he underwent a career change, focusing instead on pro wrestling. He debuted in 2015, and after taking part in a WWE tryout, the company asked EVOLVE to give Riddle a shot. Though Riddle was certainly out of his depth among talent with years of experience, he has developed at an amazing rate. He's currently slated to take on EVOLVE Champion Timothy Thatcher for the title in March. Whether or not Riddle wins, he's probably just biding his time there; WWE wants him, and before long, he'll be a part of the company.

In this post: 
evolve
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Scott Fried is a Slammy Award-winning* writer living and working in New York City. He has been following/writing about professional wrestling for many years and is a graduate of Lance Storm's Storm Wrestling Academy. Follow him on Twitter at https://twitter.com/scottfried. *Best Crowd of the Year, 2013