10 Exact Moments WWE Killed Careers
When WWE itself is fully responsible for wrecking characters and careers.
It takes a lot to snuff out someone's WWE career.
Most fans tuning in know the deal by now - they know that Vince McMahon is fond of "taking performers out of their comfort zone". That's why Cesaro used to yodel on his way to ring, and it's why Natalya couldn't hold her gas during embarrassing backstage segments.
Both of those workers survived such humiliation and went on to enjoy some success (they're still around today too), but things could've gone off the rails so, so easily. Others? Well, others weren't quite so fortunate. They all suffered moments that outright killed any chances they had of either continuing under the gimmick or even being repackaged as something else entirely.
Here's the trick: NOBODY LISTED HERE IS ACTUALLY TO BLAME.
No, they were booked into oblivion and given some of the worst ideas in pro wrestling history. Keep in mind that all of this was supposed to get them over and maybe even make WWE some money. That's a scary thought when you see some of the stupidity wrestlers have been tasked with stomaching over the years.
10. Dr. Death Gets Knocked Out
BOOM!
One meaty punch was all it took for Steve Williams to watch (when he regained consciousness, at least) his WWF career go down the pan. The company's dreadful 'Brawl For All' shoot fighting idea was flawed from the start back when it kicked off in 1998, especially because it was supposed to be a vehicle for 'Dr. Death' to look like the fed's new hard man.
So much for that. Bart Gunn stiffed Death with a punch so hard Doc probably thought he was back in All Japan, and that was a wrap on Williams' credibility. He'd been brought in under assumptions that he'd blast through the competition with ease and then possibly work a program with golden boy Steve Austin.
Instead, the grizzled veteran found himself staring at the lights for Bart. Disgusted, Vince McMahon's braintrust moved on from Williams like he'd never even happened. He did show up again in early-1999, but not for long.
9. Johnny, Mitch & Mikey Get Sent Packing
D-Generation X jokers Shawn Michaels and Triple H probably thought they were just working a fun comedy skit on the 27 November 2006 episode of Raw. There, the DX twosome packed The Spirit Squad into a production crate and sent them off to Ohio Valley Wrestling.
Back to development for you lads!
Incredibly, for three of the five members, this turned out to be a shoot situation. Johnny, Mitch and Mikey were barely seen on WWE television afterwards; Mikey did make a brief return as part of a reprise (The Miz brought he and Kenny Dykstra back to antagonise Dolph Ziggler) in 2016, but that was a cameo-type deal and very short-lived.
Nobody really knew it at the time, but HBK and Trips were legitimately ending some careers on Raw that night. Johnny and Mitch, in particular, would never see the big time again. Their WWE runs came to a screeching halt within a matter of seconds.
8. Feet Are Snitsky’s Motivation
Talk about screeching halts.
Christ knows why this abomination happened back in 2005, or what WWE thought fans were supposed to feel when intimidating monster heel Gene Snitsky suddenly revealed that he was really into feet. Did WWE think that people would hate the guy because of his sexual fetishes?
Sure, most tummy's turn at the thought of chewing on toes, but it's hardly like ol' Gene deserved to be hated for his...interesting proclivities. That was the insinuation though - that peers in the locker room and peeps watching at home alike would boo Snitsky because he liked kissing tootsies in his spare time.
Later, Nick Dinsmore (Eugene) told the wrestling media that Gene's fetish was real. Again, meh. That still doesn't excuse WWE for thinking that anybody needed to see it play out on TV. Did someone think this would catch fire like Al Snow's 'Head' did?
It's a good thing they didn't run with that. Small mercies, eh?
7. Hornswoggle Is The Anonymous GM
There was a time when this writer just wanted to see Finlay punt Hornswoggle in the head to write him off television. Yes, this dude had an irrational hatred of the pint-sized grappler's gimmick for years, so imagine the scenes in his living room come the 9 July 2012 edition of Raw.
There, in a sh*tty reveal that reeked of a company cop out, lil' Horny was revealed as the 'Anonymous Raw GM' who had previously been calling shots between 2010-2011. WWE thought they'd put the idea to bed by...using Swoggle as a barrier against fan annoyance because they didn't have a satisfactory solution.
Oh man, this was horrible.
Worse, it wrecked the little dude's relationship with those in the stands who didn't mind him. He'd been placed in a no-win scenario as the sacrificial lamb on this occasion, and it was a step too far for most. Post-GM reveal, Horny drifted from lame idea to lame idea without any sense of direction before leaving the promotion.
6. ‘Fake’ Razor Ramon Debuts
Rick Bognar had no chance after this dire debut.
A heel Jim Ross (remember that?) promised to bring "Razor and Diesel" back to the WWF in September 1996. Then, to everyone's amazement, the announcer wheeled out guys cosplaying as Kevin Nash and Scott Hall. Fans, understandably, were miffed at what they were seeing play out before them.
Glenn Jacobs was slightly less-egregious as the ‘Fake’ Diesel, and the coming Kane character also gave him a real chance to right the wrongs of this WCW-bashing experiment, but Bognar? Bognar was f*cked. His Ramon impression was rotten - it was like somebody had ordered Razor from Wish.com.
Rick didn't have the luxury of a masked follow-up that'd build mystique and help him restore his reputation either. No, he's only remembered for doing one of the worst impressionist acts in pro wrestling history. Even the most laid back WWF fan had to be appalled by this, and it killed Bognar's hopes of securing a full-time gig.
5. Rocco Wrecks Hawk
Numerous sources, including Bret Hart on Kayfabe Commentaries, have remarked that Hawk had a meltdown when the WWF introduced Rocco. The Legion Of Doom's new dummy was said to be a childhood favourite that Paul Ellering used to inspire them.
Yeah, the idea was one of 1992's worst.
Hawk was visibly mortified whenever he appeared onscreen with Rocco, and he was never really the same afterwards despite runs in WCW and a second stint in the WWF. The dummy's debut was also booed so heavily that the company refused to air the segment on television. That should've been a lesson to them, but no - Rocco was here to stay.
Things got so miserable for Hawk that he went on a bender in London after SummerSlam '92. Hart believes that the dummy gimmick was largely responsible for this Road Warrior losing his mind. In fairness to Hawk, LOD lost any and all menace when Ellering started his unwanted ventriloquist act.
4. The Gobbledy Gooker Cracks Open
It's amazing to think that The Undertaker once feared he'd be the one to break out of a giant egg at Survivor Series 1990. Becoming 'Eggman' sounded nightmarish to the future legend, but he had nothing to worry about. One Héctor Guerrero was beneath the shell instead.
Hector's WWF career was in the toilet after this guff.
He tried to make it work. No, don't laugh. Guerrero really tried to make The Gobbledy Gooker something worthwhile, and so did Gene Okerlund. Together, the pair danced like goofs on pay-per-view (people paid for this tripe) and did anything they could think of to make Gooker seem like a fun addition to the roster.
People trashed it immediately, and Héctor's hopes of carving out a niche for himself disappeared. The bird gimmick became infamous for the wrong reasons, and Guerrero's name was tarnished because of it. Héctor didn't get another shot at WWF glory, by the way.
3. Lance Storm = Boring
At least The Gobbledy Gooker wasn't "boring".
In 2003, then-Raw GM Steve Austin encouraged fans to change the channel whenever Lance Storm was working a wrestling match. Yep, WWE actually did this. They told people to go watch something else because Storm was so incredibly dull. Wow.
This unbelievably rubbish idea made the product look bad and killed any interest in Lance's watertight technical approach to the mat game. Seriously, Austin lampooning Storm's ring work on episodes of Raw (he even literally snored during Lance vs. Garrison Cade on 16 June '03) was never going to work. It remains one of the worst bits of booking ever, and that's saying something.
Who was going to care about Storm after this? He started teaming with Goldust, and even began dancing to entertain people. Suitably humiliated, Lance retired from full-time wrestling less than a year later. No bloody wonder. He must've been so embarrassed after being called the sh*ts by his own employer on live TV.
2. Rikishi “Did It For The Rock”
Ask wrestling fans to name 10 things they liked about the then-WWF in 2000 and Rikishi/Too Cool will probably be one of them. The super-over undercard act turned big Kish into one of the most beloved babyfaces on the entire roster, and he was still riding high by October.
So, of course, the creative team slowed his roll.
On 9 October, GM Mick Foley blamed Rikish for running over Steve Austin at the 1999 Survivor Series. Fessing up, the thong-wearing comedy character mumbled something about race and said he "did it for The Rock". That unnecessary shoehorning in of racism wasn't even the biggest problem.
Rikishi's change from comedic babyface to homicidal maniac heel was ruined when Triple H was outed as the real mastermind behind behind Austin's near-death experience instead. That revelation left Kish rudderless for the remaining few years of his run, and proved that no-one behind the scenes had really thought this one through before putting it on Raw.
Yuck.
1. DDP Is A Stalker
"Make Me Famous".
That's what Diamond Dallas Page begged The Undertaker to do during his earliest WWF appearances in the summer of 2001. Page, who had been a major star in the dying WCW for years, looked ridiculous when he hauled off the hood to out himself as a wife-stalking weirdo on Raw.
Nothing about Vince McMahon's repackage job made any sense. Page was married to the drop dead gorgeous Kimberly at the time, which fans knew - also, his pleas to become famous only made WCW look like the minor leagues. If that was the intention, then...why? McMahon had literally just purchased its remnants and didn't need to pile on the pain.
DDP's wrestling career would never recover from this sudden assassination. His 'People's Champion' connection to fans was severed, and he bumbled around for a while under various gimmicks until retiring. Thank God for yoga empires, huh?
What other moments killed WWE careers? For more like this, check out 10 More Terrible Wrestlers With One Incredible Match and 4 Ups & 3 Downs From AEW Rampage (Jan 14)!