Ask any wrestling fan who the most divisive figure in pro-wrestling is, and you're bound to get a lot of the same answers - Seth Rollins, Roman Reigns, John Cena, etc. But all of those answers would be wrong, because the correct answer is not even a professional wrestler.
No, the most divisive figure in wrestling is none other than the publisher and editor of the Wrestling Observer Newsletter, David Allan Meltzer.
Since 1980, Meltzer has been wrestling's most prominent journalist, providing insights and (mostly) reliable insider information that, still today, spreads like wildfire throughout the Internet Wrestling Community. He is considered a controversial figure not because he, like your local weatherman, is incorrect in his predictions, but because of his famed match rating system.
Inspired by a childhood friend and, interestingly, Jim Cornette, Meltzer adopted a system that rates pro-wrestling matches on a scale of 0 stars to 5-stars.... well, originally. Since then, he has gone below 0 stars and above 5 stars on several different occasions, hence much of the criticism from fans and performers alike. Nevertheless, it's still considered an honor when Meltzer rates a match so highly, considering he is perhaps the most knowledgeable human being on the subject of pro-wrestling.
As such, while most wrestling fans agree that Meltzer's ratings do not ultimately define how "good" a match is, it is inaccurate to say that his ratings are meaningless. With that said, let's take a look at some fascinating facts about last year's highest-rated matches.