10 Fascinating Facts About 2019's 5-Star Matches

There were a total of twenty-one 5-star matches last year. TWENTY. ONE.

Okada Ospreay G1
NJPW

Ask any wrestling fan who the most divisive figure in pro-wrestling is, and you're bound to get a lot of the same answers - Seth Rollins, Roman Reigns, John Cena, etc. But all of those answers would be wrong, because the correct answer is not even a professional wrestler.

No, the most divisive figure in wrestling is none other than the publisher and editor of the Wrestling Observer Newsletter, David Allan Meltzer.

Since 1980, Meltzer has been wrestling's most prominent journalist, providing insights and (mostly) reliable insider information that, still today, spreads like wildfire throughout the Internet Wrestling Community. He is considered a controversial figure not because he, like your local weatherman, is incorrect in his predictions, but because of his famed match rating system.

Inspired by a childhood friend and, interestingly, Jim Cornette, Meltzer adopted a system that rates pro-wrestling matches on a scale of 0 stars to 5-stars.... well, originally. Since then, he has gone below 0 stars and above 5 stars on several different occasions, hence much of the criticism from fans and performers alike. Nevertheless, it's still considered an honor when Meltzer rates a match so highly, considering he is perhaps the most knowledgeable human being on the subject of pro-wrestling.

As such, while most wrestling fans agree that Meltzer's ratings do not ultimately define how "good" a match is, it is inaccurate to say that his ratings are meaningless. With that said, let's take a look at some fascinating facts about last year's highest-rated matches.

10. Making It Rain

Kazuchika Okada
NJPW

For at least the last eight years, current IWGP Heavyweight Champion Kazuchika Okada has been firmly establishing himself as one of professional wrestling's most gifted and valuable performers.

At just 32 years old, he already boasts one of the most impressive resumes in the history of pro-wrestling, having won New Japan's top prize on five occasions, the G1 Climax and the New Japan Cup on two occasions each, and he is part of all four of Wrestling Observer Newsletter's four highest-rated wrestling matches of all time.

The now-pantsless Rainmaker's enjoyed an excellent 2019 as well, taking part in four 5-star bouts in that calendar year alone. While he was one 5-star match shy of the record he set last year, he still wrestled at least four such matches for the third consecutive year. That is an astonishing accolade for any wrestler, and considering he is still in his early-30s, he still has so many more years left in the tank.

And that, my friends, is exciting.


9. "The Best Bout Machine"... Or Is He?

Kenny Omega AEW
AEW

And now to talk about the *other* half of WON's four highest-rated pro-wrestling matches: Kenny Omega.

Omega holds the unique distinction of wrestling more 5-star matches in one calendar year than any other wrestler by far, with nine such matches in 2018. Yes, you read that correctly - of the twenty-one 5-star matches in 2018, Kenny Omega was part of NINE of them. This means that he wrestled in roughly 43% of that year's record-setting number of 5-star matches, which is absolutely insane.

Unfortunately, however, Omega's 2019 was nowhere near as successful as his 2018 was, as he only wrestled one 5-star match all year - a 5.75-star barn burner with Hiroshi Tanahashi at Wrestle Kingdom 13 in January. Since that final match in New Japan, AEW seems to have clipped Omega's one wing off, as he hasn't wrestled a single 5-star match in the promotion and has been on the losing end of the majority of his PPV bouts.

Thankfully, despite his shoddy booking thus far, AEW still has a lot of time to turn things around. Let's just hope that they do.


8. One "Buck" Away From Immortality

Young Bucks AEW
AEW

2019 featured yet another 5-star tag team classic from real-life brothers Matt and Nick Jackson, better known as The Young Bucks.

The colorful, superkick-savvy duo put on a banger of a ladder match with also-real-life-brothers Pentagon Jr. and Rey Fenix at AEW All Out, earning a scale-breaking 5.25-star rating from Davey Boy Meltzer. This was the Bucks' third 5-star match as a team, leaving them one match shy of tying the record set by legendary All Japan duo Akira Taue and Toshiaki Kawada in the '90s. Currently, they are tied with such iconic teams as Kobashi & Misawa, Akiyama & Misawa (damn, Misawa was great in tag teams as well), and The Golden Lovers, Kenny Omega & Kota Ibushi.

Realistically, unless AEW and New Japan are able to work out some sort of agreement that would allow Omega and Ibushi to reunite, the Jacksons appear to be the only team with a chance at matching this once-untouchable record. And given that Meltzer is an unabashed Bucks fan (so much so that they named a move after him), it should be only a matter of time.


7. A "Golden" Year For Ibushi

Kota Ibushi G1 Climax
NJPW

There's no doubt about it - Kota Ibushi is in his prime right now.

While he has always been a top-rate talent, he has stepped things up considerably over the last two years, wrestling five 5-star matches in 2018 and three in 2019. What makes 2019 so remarkable for Ibushi, though, is the fact that he did not lose a single one of his 5-star bouts.

He beat Will Ospreay in a masterclass of fast-paced workrate at the G1 Climax in July, toppled IWGP Heavyweight Champion Kazuchika Okada in a "this couldn't-possibly-be-bad" match in August, and then bested Jay White just *two days later* to win the G1 Climax in a genuine Match of the Year candidate. Imagine that - going more than 25 minutes with arguably the best pro-wrestler in the world today, then having a higher-rated *and* longer match with one of wrestling's top heels just 48 hours later.

Not only is this a testament to Ibushi's athleticism, it also underlines his toughness, because nobody in the business takes riskier bumps than he does (seriously, just watch this horrific bump he took against Tetsuya Naito). Hopefully, his less-than-cautionary approach to wrestling does not shorten his career, as most of us would love to see him putting on more stellar performances for many more years to come.


6. New Records, Baybay!

Cole Gargano
WWE.com

NXT had arguably its two greatest matches of all time in 2019, and both of them were between the same two people.

Johnny Gargano and Adam Cole (baybay)'s saga for the NXT Championship was nothing short of fantastic, with the first two matches of their three-match series earning 5.5 and 5.25 stars, respectively. These impeccable performances set two records for WWE. Firstly, they are the first two WWE-produced matches to ever receive a rating higher than 5-stars. They may not be the only two, as WALTER and Tyler Bate wrestled an awe-inspiring 5.25-star match at NXT UK TakeOver: Cardiff this past August, but they are the first, and nobody can ever take that away from them.

Secondly, they are the only two WWE talents to ever wrestle two 5-star matches against one another, let alone in the same year. Gargano, himself, also set an individual record for the most 5-star matches in WWE history, with four such matches to his name thus far. While Cole also has four 5-star matches under his belt, one of them was not under the WWE banner, so he unfortunately lands himself in second place in this regard.

Nevertheless, fans are clamoring to see what Gargano and Cole have in store for us in 2020, whether it's against one another or not.


5. Scale Breakers

Shingo Takagi Tomohiro Ishii
NJPW

Wrestling fans are divided in their opinions regarding Dave Meltzer, especially when it comes to him breaking his own rating scale.

He infamously "first"* did so in January of 2017, awarding Kazuchika Okada and Kenny Omega 6 stars for their war at Wrestle Kingdom 11. He would later give their subsequent matches 6.25 stars, 6 stars again, and a record 7-stars for their final encounter at Dominion 2018. And those weren't even the only matches he tipped the scales for.

Needless to say, he has been a lot more flexible in this regard as of late, as he broke the record for most scale-breaking match ratings in one calendar year. While there were no 6-star matches in 2019, we were treated to nine matches over 5-stars in one year, thrashing last year's record of six. The highest-rated out of these nine matches were three matches that each earned themselves a 5.75-star rating - the first being Hiroshi Tanahashi vs. Kenny Omega at Wrestle Kingdom 13, the second being Will Ospreay vs. Shingo Takagi in the finals of the Best of the Super Juniors tournament, and the third being Kazuchika Okada vs. Ospreay in the G1 Climax.

If 2019 is any indication, look forward to a lot more scale breaking in 2020.

* Apparently, at the time of WK11, wrestling fans forgot about Mitsuharu Misawa vs. Toshiaki Kawada, which Meltzer rated 5+ stars in 1994, retrospectively tallying it at 6 stars.


4. August Burns It Down

Kazuchika Okada Kota Ibushi
NJPW1972.com

There's just something about summertime that makes people happier and more energetic. And why wouldn't we be? The sun is shining, the days are long, and the weather is warm.

Well, apparently, pro-wrestlers echo the same sentiments, as this August produced more 5-star matches in a single calendar month than any other month in pro-wrestling history.

August of 2019 featured not three, not four, but *seven* 5-star matches in just a 31-day span. To put this into perspective, this is the equivalent of having one 5-star match roughly every five days. That is, to phrase this lightly, f**king bananas.

Coincidentally, this past August also broke the record for most scale-breaking matches in one month, with a total of four matches rated over 5-stars, those being Shingo Takagi vs. Tomohiro Ishii in the G1, Kota Ibushi vs. Jay White in the G1 Finals, the Lucha Brothers vs. the Young Bucks at AEW All Out, and WALTER vs. Tyler Bate at NXT UK TakeOver: Cardiff. The latter two of those matches also made history, as they are the first two higher-than-5-star matches to have taken place on the same day (August 31).

Talk about one hell of a month to be a pro-wrestling fan.


3. A Classic G1 Climax

Dean Ambrose Jon Moxley
WWE/NJPW

The G1 Climax is always one of the best times of the year for wrestling fans, as all of New Japan's top talents take part in a massive, month-long round-robin tournament for the G1 trophy and a shot at the IWGP Heavyweight Championship at Wrestle Kingdom the following January. While there are often storyline aspects to the G1, most of the time it's just a way for fans to see two world-class athletes clash with one another in pursuit of glory.

This past year, we were treated to a total of eight 5-star matches in the G1, which is a new record for the tournament, breaking last year's admirable record of seven 5-star matches. It also tied with the previous year for most scale-breaking matches in a G1, with three total.

Some of the year's G1 highlights include Jon Moxley's first-ever 5-star match, which was a hard-hitting display of brawling acumen with Tomohiro Ishii. It also featured two of three 5-or-more-star matches on the year from Shingo Takagi, who prior to 2019 had never achieved such an honor. Strangely enough, one of those bouts was also against Ishii.

Perhaps this year's G1 can be renamed to "Tomohiro Ishii Makes New NJPW Talents Look Like 100-Million Yen". Yeah? No? Okay.


2. Two Days

Kota Ibushi Will Ospreay G1
NJPW

I mentioned in a previous entry that Kota Ibushi wrestled two 5-star matches just two days apart from one another this past August, but believe it or not, he is not the only wrestler to achieve such a feat that year.

In fact, he wasn't even the first wrestler to do so.

In July of 2019, Will Ospreay also wrestled two 5-star matches two days apart from one another - both were G1 Climax bouts with Ibushi and Kazuchika Okada, respectively. What's even more bonkers about all of this is that both Ibushi and Ospreay achieved higher ratings in their respective second matches. Ibushi went from a 5-star match with Okada to a 5.5-star match with Jay White, while the high-flying Ospreay flew even higher, going from a 5-star banger with Ibushi to a 5.75-star masterpiece with Okada.

Given the way these two lads wrestle, the impact that this must have had on their bodies is akin to that of a UFC fighter after two full, five-round fights with top-level talent in the same week. Good God, the muscle soreness and bone bruising must have been agonizing... tough sons of b****es, they.


1. Will Ospreay. Enough Said.

Will Ospreay
NJPW

26-year-old British high flyer Will Ospreay had a breakthrough year in 2019, proving that he is ready to bump elbows with the greats in the wrestling business.

The Aerial Assassin wrestled five 5-star matches in 2019, more than any other wrestler that year. While this isn't quite "2018 Kenny Omega" numbers, he is still tied with Kazuchika Okada, Kota Ibushi, and Hiroshi Tanahashi for second-most 5-star matches in a calendar year. What makes Ospreay's contributions this year so impressive is the fact that he was able to do this at just 26-years-old, while his contemporaries (including Omega) did so when they were older and more experienced.

With all being said, however, Ospreay has been widely criticized in the past for taking unnecessarily-brutal bumps and employing a high-risk offense, with Meltzer himself even going as far to say that Ospreay "will be the Dynamite Kid," so we should just "enjoy him while [we] can". We can only hope that these predictions are inaccurate, because nobody deserves to have their career cut short at such an early age. Especially somebody with as much talent and promise as Will Ospreay.


Contributor

He/him/his. Born in 1992. Lifetime native of Massachusetts. Part-time columnist. Aspiring actor/singer. Black Belt. Twitch Affiliate. Drinks iced coffee all year round. Loves pro-wrestling and MMA.