10 Fascinating Masked 'Mystery' Wrestlers

No points for guessing who they were, but who did the gimmick best?

It may seem a tad niche and specific, but this gimmick really was a staple of wrestling in the territory days. It would invariably go something like this: someone would be suspended, or lose a "loser leaves town match", leaving his enemies to gloat but before too long a "new" wrestler would take up the fight in his stead - a new fighter with something suspiciously familiar about him... He'd look like the banished wrestler, except for his laughably cheap mask and some other on-the-nose clues. He walked the same way, spoke the same way (even down to verbal tics and catchphrases, brother) and even boasted a startlingly similar moveset. To the fans, it would be patently obvious that the two were one and the same, but the paper-thin disguise would always be enough to keep his enemies from proving he was violating his suspension. It happened all over the world across many decades, with these no-so-mystery men cropping up everywhere from 1970€™s Florida to modern day WWE. There were mystery men of all stripes and species, from vigilante cowboys and cowardly dogs to anthropomorphic flags and characters from folk songs. Sometimes the mystery man was a heroic babyface, bending the rules to get revenge on those who got him unfairly banned. Sometimes, it was a cowardly heel who'd adopt the new identity to try to get around a fair ruling by a babyface authority figure, in which case it was guaranteed to blow up in his face in a manner most comical. Whatever their alignment, this article looks at the best quote-unquote mysterious personages to pull this tried-and-tested con, while exploring the circumstances surrounding their mask-donning.

10. Calgary Kid (The Miz)

Deep in the dark ages of Raw€™s guest host era, The Miz was a rising young heel who was getting a good deal of mileage out of challenging John Cena to matches while Big Match John was out with an injury. Thanks to the ruling of Jeremy Piven, Miz was beaten by a returning Cena and banned from Raw. The next week, WWE moved on, hosting a contract-on-a-pole match between Eugene and the masked Calgary Kid, hoping to fill the Miz-shaped hole in their roster... Wearing a hockey jersey, and with maple leaves plastered on his knee pads and mask, one might assume the Kid was a Lance Storm student or even one of the less impressive Hart children. That is, until ol€™ CK dispatched Eugene with a Skull-Crushing Finale and removed his maple-amblazoned mask to reveal - gasp! - Miz. The reaction was great, but looking back and watching Miz with real upward career momentum is like watching Undertaker as €œMean€ Mark Callous. It just seems wrong, you know?

9. Very Mysterious Ice Cream (Claudio Castagnoli)

Mainstream WWE fans know Cesaro as the underutilized übermensch of the lower midcard, but for over a decade he wrestled on the indies under his real name. As Claudio Castagnoli, he often teamed with Chris Hero as the Kings of Wrestling, but it's his heated 2007 rivalry with his on-again, off-again partner that earned him a spot on this list. Hero defeated Castagnoli in a €œloser leaves Chikara€ match, but he and his allies were soon challenged by the heroic Los Ice Creams, and their new partner, Very Mysterious Ice Cream. Unlike Ice Cream, Jr. and El Hijo Del Ice Cream, Very Mysterious Ice Cream was also Very European. Instead of utilizing his lucha-inspired offense of his teammates, Very Mysterious was fond of dismantling his opponents with powerful uppercuts and hossing them around in cravate holds. He also wrestled in slacks, a sleeveless dress shirt, and a tie (because Claudio was Swiss and therefore working an IRS style gimmick by default, maybe?). He unmasked not long after his debut, but if a guy disguised as a frozen dairy treat shows up on Raw, you guys will know what's up.

8. Mr. NXT (Bo Dallas)

There's a lively debate among longtime NXT fans about who the developmental league€™s best champion was, and most of them have a legitimate claim. Seth Rollins was its first, and has been most successful on the main roster and Big E was the most dominant, while Adrian Neville was probably the fightingest. Bo Dallas, however, rarely gets a mention. Maybe it's because he rapidly became a joke following his call-up, or maybe it's because his own title record (longest reign) was subsequently broken by the Jumping Geordie. But rest assured, the Bolievers never gave up on their hero. Even after he lost the title to Neville, he campaigned for a rematch using a stack of letters from his worldwide fans as persuasion. Then he lost to Big E and got fired from NXT. His solution: show up like a week later, wearing a mask and literally yelling €œI'm not Bo Dallas!€. Bo€™s masked adventures were sadly brief: Mr. NXT only appeared on a single episode, which ended with him getting unmasked and chased around Full Sail by campus security like he was the Greased-Up Deaf Guy.

7. Giant Machine (André The Giant)

Though they're best-remembered today as the allies who tried to bring down Hulkamania at WrestleMania III, Bobby Heenan and André the Giant had a long history as bitter enemies. The Brain had spent much of the early 1980€™s attempting to force André out of wrestling via his proxies in the Heenan Family, with mixed results. Unable to best André in the ring, Heenan hit upon a more insidious strategy: airline sabotage. No, he didn't plant a bomb in Andr這s luggage or anything, but he did cancel one of his flights and the big guy got suspended for missing a show. Enter: Giant Machine. This titanic newcomer wrestled in a suspiciously familiar off-the-shoulder singlet and spoke with an impossibly thick French accent for a guy that supposedly hailed from Japan. Heenan became obsessed with proving that André and the Machine were one and the same, noting that there aren't too many 7 foot tall giants around. Gorilla Monsoon helpfully offered that it might be Giant Baba. Ultimately, Heenan dropped his case with WWE officials and André quietly returned, shortly before turning heel and joining the Heenan Family. Hmm...

6. Yellow Dog (Brian Pillman/Barry Windham)

Here we have a bizarre case of this trope being turned against a guy who'd used it himself. In 1984, Barry Windham disguised himself as the 'Yellow Dog' to escape the shame of being saddled and ridden around the ring by €œOutlaw€ Ron Bass. I don't know, guys, I guess someone on the booking committee was working through some stuff. Anyway, by 1991, Barry had left his white-meat babyface roots behind to join the Four Horsemen. When he and Arn Anderson chased Flyin€™ Brian out of WCW, they were soon confronted by a familiar figure in ochre. The Yellow Dog was back, this time with Pillman beneath the hood (though his partner Tom Zenk sometimes donned it to €œprove€ it wasn't The Loose Cannon). The masked man dogged (har har) the Horsemen until a kayfabe letter-writing campaign got Pillman reinstated, and Old Yeller Dog was taken behind the shed and killed off for good.

5. Mr. America (Hulk Hogan)

Do you know why the only part of Hulk Hogan€™s 2002-2003 WWE run they talk about is his match with The Rock? I mean, they don't talk about any of it anymore thanks to the, uh, unpleasantness, but it wasn't a great run to begin with. After the loss to Rocky, Hogan feuded with Vince McMahon in a red-hot CONTRACT DISPUTE program, with the boss eventually electing to simply have his foe sit out his remaining contract dates at home. He was foiled, however, when Stephanie McMahon hired the hot new prospect, Mr. America, sight unseen. The Mr. America angle had all the classic hallmarks of the trope: completely inadequate disguise, continued use of signature moves, and repeated outright denials of identity. What sets this iteration apart is that it totally didn't work. Mr. Americamania ran wild for about a month before Vince McMahon caught Hogan unmasking on camera and terminated his contract, and that was it. He didn't come back as Mr. America II or whatever, leaving the company for real. He wouldn't be back for back for two years. Vinny Mac don't play that way.

4. Los Conquistadores (Edge & Christian)

Edge and Christian were the best team of the Attitude Era, with apologies to the Hardyz, Dudleyz, and their fanz. That's why it totally reeked of unfairness, and, frankly, injustitude, when Mick Foley decided in the autumn of 2000 that E&C would have no more title shots while the Hardyz were champions. Forced into a corner by the power-drunk commissioner, the noble Torontonians were forced to engage in outright subterfuge, disguising themselves as (apparently resurgent) 1980€™s jobbers Uno and Dos, Los Conquistadores. Edge and Christian were more genre-savvy than most, though. They actually hired stand-ins to appear in backstage segments with them to €œprove€ that it couldn't be them under the golden hoods of Uno and Dos. The Conquistadores unseated the Hardyz, but before Edge and Christian could pin their dupes for the belts on Raw, the Hardyz stole the costumes and pinned THEM, meaning the titles simultaneously switched from E &C to the Hardyz and (officially) between TWO SETS of Conquistadores. The scheme ultimately paid off, however: both sets of Conquistadores were stricken from the record books, with credit for their reigns reverting to the Hardyz and Edge & Christian. And, of course, since the Hardyz€™ original reign did indisputably end, so did Foley€™s restriction on E&C€™s number one contendership. Break out the kazoos!

3. Charlie Brown From Outta Town (Jimmy Valiant)

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pJNp84BZaH0 Handsome Jimmy Valiant is among the most physically identifiable wrestlers to ever lace up a pair of boots, and therefore a perfect candidate for the old mystery masked man treatment. Sure, he started out as a relatively normal-looking dude alongside his kayfabe brother Johnny, but he gradually accumulated tattoos, facial hair and bizarre white guy dance moves until he was known as The Boogie Woogie Man. As BWM worked his way across the territories, he lost his share of €œloser leaves town€ matches, at which point his opponents would be forced to deal with Charlie Brown From Outta Town. Calling Mr. Brown a bare-bones disguise is pretty generous. He spoke and wrestled exactly like Boogie did, and he even used the same entrance music. His disguise was limited to a goony little half-mask that couldn't even extend past his nose because of his giant Charles Dickens beard. Seriously, brother looked like Son of Havoc€™s slovenly uncle, but it didn't matter. People loved Boogie, and they were going to love Charlie as well.

2. Stagger Lee (Junkyard Dog/Koko B. Ware)

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=40t8T2arIfQ Before he was a beloved WWE babyface/Hulk Hogan warmup act, the man known as the Junkyard Dog was a megastar in Bill Watts€™ Louisiana territory. Although JYD was supposed to be a lower-card comedy act, his personal charisma kind of got ahead of him and he started selling out the Sam Houston Coliseum as a top babyface. Whoops! He reigned as North American Heavyweight Champion until he lost both the title and his job thanks to the betrayal of his friend Butch Reed, who sided with upstart young heel Ted DiBiase. Reed and DiBiase were subsequently plagued by a masked stranger called Stagger Lee, named after an infamous American folk criminal. Stagger pursued them until JYD was brought back to challenge for his title again. Meanwhile, in Memphis, upstart babyface Koko Ware transformed into nefarious heel, Sweet Brown Sugar. Sugar began teaming with Bobby Eaton under the guidance of Jimmy Hart, until jealousy ripped the team apart and Sugar was forced out of Memphis. By this point, you know the drill: Stagger Lee showed up, repeatedly punked out Sugar€™s foes, and then excused himself when the loser leaves town stipulation expired. Well, not so much. In this case, Ware was so over as Stagger Lee that Eaton turned face to team with him again! When the mask finally came off, it was so Koko could do a goofy Michael Jackson gimmick with Norvell Austin.

1. Midnight Rider (Dusty Rhodes)

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jK-3ErNvZhQ There were three bad men, daddy. One of €˜em was John Wayne, and he's dead. There was the American Dream, Dusty Rhodes, but he was chased out of the NWA for 60 days after losing an unsanctioned €œlights out€ cage match to pint-sized satanist Kevin Sullivan. That left the mysterious Midnight Rider to carry the torch. Oddly enough, just like Dusty, the Rider€™s didn't look like the athlete of the day. His belly was just a little big, his hiney was just a little big, but he was bad and they knew he was bad. There was only one wrinkle: If it was proved that the Rider was really Dusty, his two month suspension would become a lifetime ban. The Midnight Rider was spectacularly successful, even defeating Ric Flair for the NWA Title. When the championship committee demanded that he unmask, the Rider was forced to choose between vacating the title or facing permanent suspension, and so he had to let the title go back to resting on Flair's less-ample waist. Around the same time, Kevin Sullivan also got himself suspended and was replaced by a masked pint-sized satanist called Lucifer. Lucifer and the Rider clashed in - what else? - a €œlights out€ cage match, with Sullivan being unmasked and expelled from the NWA. His work done, Midnight Rider rode off into the sunset, just in time for Dusty€™s suspension to expire.

Contributor

Long-time fan (scholar?) of professional wrestling, kaiju films and comparative mythology. Aspiring two-fisted adventurer.