10 Fresh WWE Feuds For A Returning Sheamus

Fresh meat and old blood.

In the six years Sheamus has been in WWE, he has seemingly done it all and collected accolades like it was nothing, from reigning as world champion on three separate occasions to winning the Royal Rumble match. Furthermore, he's feuded with almost all of the company's biggest names including John Cena, Randy Orton, and Triple H, begging the question of what is actually left for him to do in WWE upon his return to the ring. Despite his accolades and successes, not everything has gone smoothly for the Irishman recently. Even as United States champion, Sheamus floundered for the better part of 2014, engaging in forgettable feuds with Cesaro and The Miz. Originally scheduled to take part in the Team Cena vs. Team Authority match at Survivor Series, he was sidelined with an injury shortly before the event and hasn't been seen since, though recent vignettes have indicated his return to TV is imminent. With the roster filled with more fresh faces than ever before, there's a slew of Superstars Sheamus could feud with upon his in-ring return, especially if he was to come back as a heel. The Celtic Warrior did some of the best of his work as a villain in 2009/2010 and can add real depth to the heel side of the roster. And as the likes of Bray Wyatt, Seth Rollins and Dean Ambrose emerge as main event players, he will have no trouble finding a dance partner for WrestleMania 31 and beyond.


10. Erick Rowan

Of the three Wyatt Family members, Erick Rowan was surely the weakest when it came to his in-ring work and overall character development. However, that's not to say he was terrible in between the ropes; he could more than hold his own against John Cena, Chris Jericho and Daniel Bryan, showing signs of true potential in each of his matches. He'll never be contending for the WWE World Heavyweight Championship, of course, but he can be a solid undercard act if booked properly. And don't forget, Rowan did find himself in a prominent position last fall when he competed alongside Team Cena at Survivor Series, though he hasn't been featured on TV as regularly since. Following a failed feud against Big Show he has been mostly directionless and is in need of (another) rivalry with an established star that will actually make him out to look credible; Sheamus can be that opponent. The former WWE champion may not grace the main event scene immediately upon his return, but if he needs to spend some time in the midcard, a feud with Rowan could be beneficial for them both.

9. Luke Harper

Much like Erick Rowan, Harper has mostly been directionless since the breakup of The Wyatt Family last fall. Although he captured the Intercontinental Championship in November, his reign was short-lived, as he dropped the strap back to Dolph Ziggler the following month at the TLC pay-per-view. Having been a henchman of The Authority since then, he's competed against the likes of Rowan, Ziggler and Dean Ambrose, coming out on the losing end more often than not. Needless to say, the way WWE is currently using Harper (or failing to, more appropriately) is criminal; someone who is as talented as he is shouldn't be relegated to working WWE Superstars and Main Event each week. With the midcard as depleted as it is at the moment, it's mind boggling as to why they're not doing more with them, but a feud with Sheamus would be a step in the right direction. The two mixed it up in six-man tag team action last year, but never one-on-one. Their similar highly physical, hard-hitting styles would make for a brutal brawl and a refreshing feud. Despite his cartoonish character at times, Sheamus is a much better worker than some give him credit for; thus, an excellent match between them is essentially guaranteed, serving as a reminder to fans what great wrestlers both ruthless competitors are.

8. Ryback

Since coming back from injury last fall, Ryback has experienced a career resurgence that has seen him quickly become one of the most popular wrestlers on the roster. Reverting back to his "Feed Me More" shtick, he's returned to prominence in recent months and has fought his way back up the food chain, but has lacked a decent heel to work with. Alongside Dolph Ziggler and Erick Rowan, he has mostly been fixated on feuding with The Authority since the start of the year, though now has his sights set on winning the Andre the Giant Memorial Battle Royal. Post-WrestleMania, however, it's unknown what will be in store for Ryback, but a feud with Sheamus would a fine use of both brawlers for the spring season. Ryback and Sheamus have history dating back to their alliance against The Shield in early 2013, in addition to colliding in singles competition on a number of occasions just last year. Each time they clashed, they showed they can work well together, and with the roles switched this time around, the dynamic between them could be even better. They both belong near the top of the card and a feud pitting the two against each other would be an effective use of both of them coming out of The Show of Shows.

7. Rusev

Technically, we've seen these two feud in the past, but it was hardly a feud if it lasted all of two weeks; in fact, consider it a small preview of what be coming down the line. Rusev has been unstoppable since arriving in WWE the night after WrestleMania 30, dismantling every Superstar who has stepped foot in his path of destruction. From Kofi Kingston to Big Show, he has decimated them all, everyone with the exception of Sheamus up until November. After months of trash talking the United States, Rusev finally announced his intentions to take the U.S. Championship from Sheamus on the Halloween edition of SmackDown, and it was only days later on Raw that the two did battle with the belt up for grabs. In a shocking turn of events, Rusev emerged victorious against Sheamus to capture the star-spangled prize. They met in a championship rematch the following week on Raw, but it ended in a count-out win for Rusev following interference from The Authority. The Celtic Warrior was sidelined with an injury shortly thereafter, leaving the rivalry without a decisive conclusion. Rusev is currently tied up with John Cena at WrestleMania 31, but look for Sheamus to return with a vengeance and possibly take his title back in the process.

6. Roman Reigns

Since the breakup of The Shield last June, Roman Reigns has been on the fast track to super stardom. Outside of big wins over Randy Orton and Daniel Bryan and a tainted Royal Rumble victory, however, he hasn't done much to prove himself as a worthy contender to the WWE World Heavyweight Championship. While he has come a long way in a fairly short period of time, there are still legitimate claims against him that he simply isn't "ready" for the spotlight and needs more time to develop. What better way to build a future headlinder than by pairing them with an established Superstar such as Sheamus? Reigns and Sheamus have seldom crossed paths in the past, but there's the possibility that changes come after WrestleMania. It is all but confirmed at this point that Reigns is walking out of The Show of Shows as WWE World Heavyweight champion, and of course, he's going to need a handful of strong heels to work with coming out of the event. There's always Seth Rollins, but it remains to be seen how Bray Wyatt and Rusev will fare as top stars coming out of their respective matches with The Undertaker and John Cena. With rumors running rampant that Sheamus might be brought back to TV as a top heel, a feud between them over the prestigious prize is only inevitable.

5. Seth Rollins

Within a matter of months, Seth Rollins has solidified himself has the top heel in WWE with all the success he's had. In addition to his brilliant booking, he's also played his part to perfection by getting under the skin of members of the WWE Universe and portraying the slimy, vindictive heel that we all love to hate. With the Money in the Bank briefcase still in his possession, it's safe to say he'll be wearing championship gold before long, and he'll need a strong set of challengers to defend against. As noted, while it's heavily believed Sheamus will be back in WWE as a top heel, there is always the chance he returns as a face. In that case, Sheamus would be the ideal rival for Rollins going into the spring season. The Celtic Warrior hasn't been prominently featured in the championship picture for close to three years, so him in the title picture would feel fresh. Furthermore, given how great of workers both men are, their matches would be nothing short of excellent, and Sheamus could help put Rollins over in a big way, more over than he already is.

4. Dean Ambrose

Similar to most of the aforementioned names on this list, Dean Ambrose has made quite the name for himself in singles competition over the last year. He's lost a bit of steam since the fall when he lost his feud against Seth Rollins, but he still finds himself in a prominent position at WrestleMania 31 in the Intercontinental Championship Ladder match. At this juncture, he hasn't won a pay-per-view match since June's Payback event, and if he can't come out with a win at 'Mania, he'll be in desperate need of a feud with someone he can actually beat. Interestingly enough, it was around the time Sheamus took the United States Championship off Ambrose that the seeds were seemingly planted for a heel turn for The Celtic Warrior. He lastly eliminated Ambrose from a 20-man Battle Royal on the May 5 edition of Raw to win the gold, but other than a championship rematch that week on SmackDown, the storyline was dropped abruptly. Sheamus subsequently embarked on a forgettable run with the star-spangled prize, but who knows how different things would have been had he feuded with Ambrose instead. Regardless of whether they'd play off that old history or not, Sheamus and Ambrose could produce a solid series of matches that would see both Superstars receive the focus and direction they need right now.

3. Chris Jericho

While not technically under contract with WWE at the moment, Chris Jericho comes and goes so often that it's difficult to not consider him part of the roster. His most recent runs with the company have been hit or miss depending on who he's feuding with, but regardless of his rival, he is still very capable of producing a great match. He also has a track record for putting over younger talent, so there's no need to fear when he's placed in programs with rising up-and-comers that they will get "buried." Granted, Sheamus can hardly be considered a "young" talent having been on the main roster for nearly six years, but he's still a fresher face than Big Show or Kane.(who should be nowhere near the main event scene in 2015). Plus, he and Jericho have never engaged in a one-on-one rivalry. Any time they've done battle, they've always had excellent chemistry, meaning the matches they could have would be worth them feuding alone. Nevertheless, if they're looking to build Sheamus back up as a dominant heel, Jericho is an ideal babyface for him to engage a feud with. Y2J knows how to make his opponents look good in defeat, but when he puts them over, they score a win over a seasoned veteran and earn credibility in the process. It remains to be seen when we'll be seeing Jericho on WWE TV next, but a rivalry with Sheamus could exceed expectations.

2. Bray Wyatt

When Bray Wyatt first debuted in WWE back in the summer of 2013, there were fans who assumed he wasn't much more than a glorified gimmick. Although he was kept out of the ring for the first few months of his main roster run, he quickly proved the naysayers wrong when he started competing against the likes of Daniel Bryan, John Cena, Chris Jericho and others and tearing the house down. In showcasing his skills, he solidified himself as one of WWE's better in-ring workers, though he still searching for the perfect opponent. At WrestleMania 31, Wyatt will collide with The Undertaker, and as big of a matchup as that is for the third generation star, how well wrestled the match is going to be will remain a mystery until March 26. Also a mystery is who Wyatt will be feuding with following The Show of Shows as it's quite clear The Deadman won't be sticking around. Having already feuded with Cena and Dean Ambrose, that doesn't leave many top-tier names for him to work with, though Sheamus would be a plausible candidate. Sure, it might be seen as a downgrade for Wyatt coming off a match with Undertaker, but he isn't left with many other options. Meanwhile, it'd be an effective way of getting Sheamus back into the mix and in a program with a notable name such as Wyatt. The few times they faced off last year were fantastic, and I can only imagine how well they'd work together if they were given an ample amount of time on a pay-per-view.

1. Bad News Barrett

Sheamus and Bad News Barrett have had close to a million matches together over the years, but no matter how many times they face off, their matches never seem to get old. They have such a chemistry together that makes all of their matches must-see, but perhaps what's most startling is that they have never actually engaged in a one-on-one rivalry. Of all the matches they've contested against each other over the years, not one of them occurred on pay-per-view. Surely, this is something that must be changed soon. Barrett has gone on record in interviews by stating his dream match is to compete against Sheamus at WrestleMania. Sadly, that doesn't appear to be likely for this year's event, but it isn't out of the question for them to feud sometime later this year. The chances of Barrett leaving 'Mania with his title intact are slim to none, but by some miracle he does retain, he has a credible challenger lined up in The Celtic Warrior. Not only do they have an extensive history together, but the feud they could have over the Intercontinental title would help bring back some the belt's lost prestige. From their meetings on Main Event to tournament matches on Raw, their clashes have yet to disappoint, and you could only expect them to deliver a contest for the ages if they were to lock up once again upon Sheamus' in-ring return.

Contributor
Contributor

Since 2008, Graham has been a diehard pro wrestling fan and, in 2010, he combined his passions for WWE and writing when he joined Bleacher Report. Equipped with a master's in journalism, Graham has contributed to WhatCulture, FanSided's Daily DDT, Sports Betting Dime, and GateHouse Media. Along the way, he has conducted interviews with wrestling superstars like Chris Jericho, Edge, Goldberg, Christian, Diamond Dallas Page, Jim Ross, Adam Cole, Tessa Blanchard, Ryback, and Nick Aldis among others.