10 Gems That Saved Rotten Wrestling PPVs
Thank God for these matches!
Every now and then a wrestling pay-per-view happens that has absolutely no redeeming qualities. Events like the WWF King Of The Ring 1995 should have been given away for free, instead of having the cheek to ask doting fans to fork out cash to see it.
Then, there are those events that have just one shining light, a match that saves the entire evening from coming across like a colossal waste of everyone's time.
Without these bouts, these shows would have been a complete disaster. Even with them, the pay-per-views that housed them aren't really spared from ignominy, but thank God this collection of matches happened!
Incredibly, the matches that did offer a glimmer of hope to such shows are even worth repeat viewings, very unlike the rest of the cards they helped rescue.
High-flying ladder wars, brutal brawls and even matches that caused one performer to rant at fans online afterwards are all included.
Let's look at hidden gems that pretty much saved otherwise utterly rotten wrestling pay-per-views...
10. Eddie Guerrero Vs. JBL (WWE Great American Bash 2004)
Those calling out for the return of the 'Brand Extension' should pay attention to 2004. Following a great start for the blue brand, SmackDown stopped delivering events like No Way Out in February and started producing tripe like the Great American Bash that June. Most of the card came across like a glorified house show.
Bouts such as Hardcore Holly vs. Mordecai, Kenzo Suzuki vs. Billy Gunn and Luther Reigns vs. Charlie Haas didn't really feel like they fit on a pay-per-view level show. Elsewhere, a truly dire main event had The Undertaker facing The Dudley Boyz in an awkward handicap situation, before Paul Bearer was apparently buried alive in concrete.
It wasn't exactly a stellar show, but a Texas Bullrope Match between JBL and Eddie Guerrero provided a beacon of hope. Following a better-than-expected main event just months prior at Judgment Day, Guerrero and Bradshaw delivered expertly with their gimmick bout at the Bash.
It's a good thing they had some drama to offer, otherwise fans may have been asking for their money back from WWE management.
9. John Cena Vs. Randy Orton (WWE SummerSlam 2007)
Heading into the pay-per-view, WWE made a lot of noise about the promised return of Triple H. Facing old foe Booker T (then under his 'King' Booker gimmick) on the card, 'The Game' was always going to receive a big reaction when he emerged for the match. The show didn't have much else to shout about.
Triple H's return was mired by a dull match against Booker, one that would have been better placed on Monday Night Raw than a show people were paying to see. Other clashes didn't really satisfy, with CM Punk vs. John Morrison, Kane vs. Finlay and Batista vs. The Great Khali falling short.
Rey Mysterio and Chavo Guerrero tried to provoke excitement, but it was actually John Cena vs. Randy Orton in the main event slot that saved the event. The match was the ideal length at around 15 minutes, never outstaying its welcome and justifying WWE's decision to put it in the headline position.
SummerSlam '07 wasn't befitting of the biggest pay-per-view of the Summer months title, but Cena vs. Orton felt relatively fresh at that point in time and was actually a pretty hot match.
8. Scott Steiner Vs. Goldberg (WCW Fall Brawl 2000)
World Championship Wrestling was in quite the mess by September, 2000. Those who were there don't need the history lesson, but those who weren't were saved from some truly awful shows that sapped the energy out of building after building. Fall Brawl 2000 was well on the way to doing just that before Scott Steiner and Goldberg hit the scene.
Constructing a hard-hitting brawl that felt like it carried a level of intensity everything else presented lacked, Steiner vs. Goldberg is one of the best matches from WCW's final year of existence. At times, it felt like the company didn't really know what they had on their hands with Steiner's intimidation gimmick, but he was on top form here.
Goldberg was damaged goods by late-2000, but he seemed reinvigorated by working alongside the trusty Steiner. Kevin Nash and Booker T later struggled to follow up on their co-main event with a 'Caged Heat' bout lacking real energy.
Energy wasn't an issue for Goldberg and Steiner, they really went at it with some great power-based brawling.
7. Daniel Bryan Vs. Bray Wyatt (WWE Royal Rumble 2014)
Who could ever forget the disaster that was the 2014 Royal Rumble pay-per-view? Going into the show, fans had almost demanded the chance to cheer on their hero Daniel Bryan in the 30-man over-the-top-rope main event. That titular match would be Bryan-less, the bearded warrior was nowhere to be found aside from a show-opener opposite Bray Wyatt.
Infamously, Batista made his return and won the Rumble, something that didn't appeal to the Pittsburgh audience. Booing mercilessly at 'The Animal', fans were disgusted that Bryan wasn't in the match. Even poor Rey Mysterio ended up incurring the wrath of angry spectators, his number 30 slot had people tearing their hair out in audible frustration.
A bloated John Cena vs. Randy Orton match (inferior to the SummerSlam 2007 gem) and Brock Lesnar vs. Big Show tussle that was more like an extended angle than a match were the other offerings. Neither thrilled like Bryan and Wyatt.
Looking like they had something to prove, Bray and Bryan went over 20 minutes. Nothing that followed could hope to surpass the match quality they produced.
6. Rob Van Dam Vs. Chris Jericho (WWF King Of The Ring 2002)
Taking to the internet and furious over fan response to the match, Chris Jericho tore into viewers who had lambasted his King Of The Ring Semi Final against Rob Van Dam. Jericho vs. Van Dam was the opening match of that year's King Of The Ring pay-per-view, and it would be all downhill from there.
Many of the complaints seemed to suggest that Y2J vs. RVD should have been better than it was, which seems like a farce when analysing the rest of the subpar show. Hulk Hogan and Kurt Angle tried, but their bout was more like a comedy match than anything serious.
Meanwhile, a rookie Brock Lesnar raced through matches against Test and Van Dam to become 'King', and The Undertaker faced Triple H in a supremely slow main event. The opener had proven to be the best match on the card by far, not even Ric Flair vs. Eddie Guerrero (which under-performed) could come close to it.
It seems Mr. Jericho was somewhat justified, his match was the only essential one on an otherwise drab occasion.
5. Bret Hart Vs. Hakushi (WWF In Your House I)
Boldly taking the decision to turn their pay-per-view model into a monthly one, the WWF started a cheaper series of events under the 'In Your House' name in May, 1995. These 2-hour specials would be offered up at a reduced rate to bigger events like WrestleMania and SummerSlam, but they often fell short in terms of quality.
The very first one in the series didn't thrill as much as flash past in an instant. Admittedly, In Your House I is interesting for historical purposes, but what show featuring matches like Mabel vs. Adam Bomb and a plodding Diesel vs. Sycho Sid main event could really be accurately described as must-see?
Thankfully, Bret Hart was on hand to save the day, just as he was many times when Vince McMahon needed him. Later working a short bout against Jerry Lawler on the same pay-per-view, he faced the newcomer Hakushi in the opener.
Even McMahon on commentary seemed surprised and impressed by what both men delivered, an athletic showing that was almost worth the reduced price of admission alone.
4. Bret Hart Vs. The Undertaker Vs. Steve Austin Vs. Vader (WWF In Your House 13)
Around 2 full years on from first introducing In Your House as a concept, the WWF still hadn't been able to make each event indispensable to customers. That trend continued with In Your House 13: Final Four, a pay-per-view set to be headlined by a Fatal-4-Way Elimination Match for the vacant WWF Heavyweight Title.
After Shawn Michaels had "lost his smile" and vacated the gold, Bret Hart, Steve Austin, The Undertaker and Vader were pushed together with the purpose of finding a new champion. Amidst sadness over Shawn's apparent injury, the quartet produced a whirlwind effort that really had fans in Chattanooga, Tennessee rocking.
It was the only match that did so, everything else once again seemed like glorified house show fodder. Marc Mero vs. Leif Cassidy, The Nation Of Domination vs. Goldust, Bart Gunn and Flash Funk, and Rocky Maivia vs. Hunter Hearst Helmsley were all instantly forgettable.
Owen Hart and The British Bulldog vs. Doug Furnas and Phil LaFon was a match that tried, but it was only the blood and thunder of the 4-way main event that truly satisfied the watching audience that night.
3. Shawn Michaels Vs. Diesel (WWF WrestleMania XI)
There may never be another WrestleMania card headlined by a non-wrestling celebrity again, but that's exactly what happened in 1995. In fairness, Lawrence Taylor was a superb athlete, but it was nonetheless a brave decision by Vince McMahon to have his match with Bam Bam Bigelow headline the WWF's biggest show of the year.
Something didn't feel right with WrestleMania XI, everything felt muted compared to the pomp and circumstance of the previous year inside Madison Square Garden. The Hartford Civic Center lacked atmosphere, the event felt less like WrestleMania and more like just another pay-per-view.
That fact wasn't aided by lackluster matches like The Undertaker vs. King Kong Bundy or The Allied Powers vs. The Blu Brothers. After Bret Hart and Bob Backlund had also disappointed, it was up to Diesel and Shawn Michaels to rescue the entire show.
Knowing Taylor vs. Bigelow wouldn't be an in-ring classic, the WWF Title participants had quite the bout themselves. There was likely a chip on each man's shoulder, ousted from the headline slot by a celebrity, but they went about their business professionally and put together an under-rated cracker.
2. Syxx Vs. Eddie Guerrero (WCW/nWo Souled Out 1997)
Kevin Nash summed it up best to Kayfabe Commentaries by pointing out the poignant fact that Souled Out 1997 opened with the nWo riding garbage trucks. That could be used as a metaphor for this terribly botched experiment, one that left the renegade group looking more like bloated fools than the hippest act in the industry.
Souled Out was an nWo-branded event, everything about it was designed to flaunt the group's superiority over WCW. What resulted was a decidedly one-sided card of matches that did indeed leave the actual company (y'know, World Championship Wrestling) looking second rate compared to a mere heel faction.
There was little of real value on the event, aside from a Ladder Match between Eddie Guerrero and Sean 'Syxx' Waltman. Seemingly determined to put on a match the show could be proud of, Guerrero and Syxx went out and finally had fans jumping up out of their seats.
Guerrero scored a rare win for the WCW crew in the battle against the nWo. Even Eric Bischoff and Ted DiBiase on commentary temporarily forgot they were supposed to be New World Order cheerleaders at points.
1. Razor Ramon Vs. Shawn Michaels (WWF SummerSlam 1995)
During the intro to this article, the dreaded King Of The Ring 1995 show was mentioned. That was the lead-in to that year's SummerSlam, providing one half of what was supposed to be a colossal main event. Winning the tournament against everyone's wishes, Mabel would face Diesel for the WWF Heavyweight Title come SummerSlam.
The match was predictably woeful, and it was joined by much mediocrity on the undercard. Bouts like Hunter Hearst Helmsley vs. Bob Holly, Barry Horowitz vs. Skip and Bret Hart vs. Isaac Yankem D.D.S were hardly inspiring, but one match was on hand to give fans something to cheer about.
Back at WrestleMania X, Shawn Michaels and Razor Ramon put on a clinic in a Ladder Match. Seeking something a little faster-paced to help them top that effort, they used the ladder as more of a weapon at SummerSlam '95 than they had done previously.
It worked, the match was a stunner, arguably topping the 'Mania classic. That's up for debate, but it's inarguable that Michaels vs. Ramon was the only thing worth seeking out at SummerSlam.
What other matches can you think of that saved otherwise rotten pay-per-views? Let us know what you think down in the comments section below!